It was Y U M at first sight!Our server Tommy was a treasure and brought the heat with service, professionalism, personality! Tommy took the time to explain our options and was patient with us ( two drinks in when we sat down!) We'll be back. With a bigger krewe! With a larger drink order! !! Bring it on Tommy and Emmy Squared! read more

I was visiting GA for the weekend and this spot was one of the recommended places to eat at. I'm definitely glad I made that decision! We came on a Friday afternoon and the restaurant was completely empty, so we were greeted right away. Our server was personable and friendly. However I was disappointed by the fact that there were crumbs on our table and when one of our plates was dirty. Our server mentioned the night staff did not do a great job of cleaning, and that doesn't usually happen. The food was great! I wished there was more pesto on the cheesy sticks. The red sauce that it's paired with (which is essentially the same sauce as the pizza sauce) is delicious! I could eat a bowl of that on its own. You could def taste the freshness. The pizza was very tasty, the edges had the perfect crunch. I also paired it with their miso ranch and that sauce is a MUST! I washed it down with one of my favorites, ginger beer, we added a lime to it & that took it to the next level. I look forward to trying their other pizzas when I do visit ATL again. read more

See all

This place is clean, all of the staff were personable. Pizza came out of the oven hot and so fresh. The food is delicious. Perfect place for a date night. read more

See all

Visited Emmy Squared Pizza and enjoyed the whole experience! The pizzas have that deep-dish pan crispy crust on all the edges with flavor stacked on flavor. There are so many great options that you will want to go with friends and have a pizza tasting gathering. The Midtown location is great to stop in, grab a drink, order a pizza, and unwind. They have an awesome bar space and table seating that can accommodate any party size. The service staff was spectacular and offered recommendations for drinks and their favorite pizza choices. read more

See all

This honestly was the best pizza I have ever had! Doss was an amazing waiter very attentive. It was a perfect evening on the patio. Will definitely come again. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Easily in the top three delicious pizzas I've ever had in my life. The crust is soft and just melts in your mouth. The service was really friendly as well, and great location in the heart of midtown. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Partially eaten, margherita pizza with added jalapeno and caramelized onion, large. - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

We ordered a shareable caesar salad and got what it barely a serving for one. Also all of our hot food was dead cold when it arrived

I've had Emmy Squared bookmarked for a while now. I finally got a chance to check them out for lunch. I was very surprised to see the restaurant practically empty on Saturday for lunch. I wasn't sure if that was a good thing or bad thing. We started with a shareable cesaer salad ($12) add chicken for an additional $5. The salad was just okay, and was a little bit on the drier side so we requested more dressing. For pizza we ordered a regular size pineapple delight and regular pepperoni pizza. The pineapple pizza was pretty good. I enjoyed the crunchiness of the crust. The restaurant itself is nice, I like the open air of it, however the bathrooms could use some attention. I went into multiple bathrooms that had no soap in it. That makes me question the cleanliness. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Pineapple Delight regular - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This is my favorite pizza place! The crust is always to crispy but pillowy soft! Service is always pleasant and fast. Each location I've been to has been clean and inviting. I love the variety of toppings they have to choose from. It's like having pizza on a delicious focaccia! I recommend this spot to all of my friends and out of town guests. An elevated pizza experience! read more

See all

The food and service was excellent! The founder pizza is the best pizza I've ever had. Everyone should check it out

Emmy Squared is always a win! We tried the MVP and Margherita pizzas, and both were incredible -- the MVP was loaded with flavor and the Margherita had that perfect balance of fresh sauce, melty cheese, and a crisp crust. The Zia Fries were next-level with their seasoning and toppings (definitely not your average fries), and the cheesy garlic sticks were the ultimate comfort bite -- gooey, garlicky, and so satisfying. The vibe here is always fun, and the food is made for sharing (though it's hard not to keep it all to yourself ). Can't wait to come back and work through more of the menu! read more

See all

We made our way through a stormy Atlanta night to Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown Atlanta (1009 Marietta Street NW). We had a good experience at our local Durham, NC Emmy Squared - so when we saw another one was around the corner from our hotel, we jumped on it. We started sharing a Caesar salad (chopped romaine, creamy anchovy dressing, crunchy sprizolina on top). For mains, I ordered the "Top Dawg," their meat lover's pie (layered with Italian sausage, ezzo pepperoni, a rich cheese blend, and pecorino) . It arrived with a side of house-made green ranch, something I'd never paired with pizza before, and it surprised me. The heat of the meats balanced and cooled with the ranch. Super tasty! Our server, Adam, made sure we had everything we needed without ever hovering. His attention, friendliness, and professionalism was top notch. The evening was really nice, and definitely worth us stepping out and bracing the weather for. read more

See all

If it weren't for Tommy, I probably wouldn't have discovered Emmy Squared in West Midtown and I'm glad I did. Tommy has built a strong reputation for taking care of his guests, and wherever he goes, people follow. He's attentive, welcoming, and makes sure everyone feels looked after. I make it a point to stop in whenever I'm in Atlanta and see him working. Emmy Squared offers a great variety of food and drinks. My personal favorites are the wedge bacon salad and their pizza, and the drink selection never disappoints. The atmosphere is relaxed the kind of place where you can walk in, unwind, meet people, and genuinely enjoy yourself. For context, I don't even live in Atlanta anymore, but Emmy Squared has become a regular stop whenever I'm back in town. That says a lot. Highly recommend checking it out especially if Tommy's behind the bar. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

So, I like to give credit where it's due and the first time we stopped in, service was great, food..."Yep it was amazing. My wife who always has issues with gluten crusts found what she said was the best she had tasted in our five years here. We went back last night, and here is our experience. We waited for our booth table to be wiped down. The table top was clean but the painted wooden seats were sticky and sprinkled with Parmesan and pizza crust crumbs. We silently wiped them a little with one of our napkins. The taller guy who served us did his best and could improve on cleaning tables. Then a young server by the name of Doss took our drink and food order as we knew what we wanted. We ordered mozzarella sticks and wings, she got a pizza with green pesto sauce drizzled on it, ( she understood it to be a dipping sauce) I ordered a good Pauline add red sauce...it looked like they may have been at the. End of a rush because there were quite a few tables. We spoke to another tall gentleman as we had recognized him for a few moments and then my cheese sticks and my wife's pizza came to the table. Since there was only one pizza it didn't make sense to have it sitting up on a race. My wife waited for a few minutes but decided it's better to eat it while it's still hot. We let Doss know we hadn't received our second Pizza or the wings. He then said he would go back and check an older gentleman wearing an apron and a ball cap came out and kind of looked around the dining room, and I remembered him from when we walked in we were waiting to be seated and he had asked us if someone had helped and we said yes meanwhile we were still waiting for a pizza and wings. No one came back for a little while, and my wife has started eating her pizza and she commented that it looked like there was only a tablespoon full of crumbled sausage sprinkled on her pizza far underwhelming than what it was described to be in the menu maybe about 20 or so minutes later and that's about waiting 20 minutes first for my wife's pizza to come my pizza came and the wings came. The wings were steaming hot in a pan that was bone dry there was no sauce in the pan no extra sauce on the wings. They were just steaming hot my pizza meat wise was the same. It seemed like there was just crumbled. Sausage sprinkled on the pizza with a few pepperonis here and there, I had a few chunks of sausage but not what I expected based on my last experience which again that Pizza was amazing our drinks were fine and there was no mention of dessert. There was no follow up. It was really just you know let me grab those to go boxes for you and you dropped them off in any left and he was handling other customers and I get it. You know Bizzy is busy but attention to detail matters and to go from such a great experience to such a really bad experience. It's kind of disappointing another note a couple of days after maybe one I heated my pizza up and my wife he hers up and we both noticed that the dough was really thick and it seemed like it wasn't fully done. It was almost very oily like some like poured olive oil on the dough and then did what they were supposed to do. I've enclosed photos and you could see them and you can see the condition of the Pizza as well. We may come back we're still deciding. read more

See all

Best Detroit style pizza I've had here in Atlanta. A lot of great pizzas on the menu to choose from. The Brussels salad was great too! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - The Founders Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I can only give this Emmy Squared Pizza location in West Midtown three stars. The food and service weren't as good as what we experienced at two other Emmy Squared locations. I hate it because this is our neighborhood Emmy Squared and it was noticeably worse. To give you an idea, I rated both of the other locations five stars. Maybe we went to this one on a bad night. Emmy Squared is a national chain that specializes in Detroit-style pizza. To me, it doesn't feel like a chain, though, because the locations we've been to are in vintage, repurposed spaces - not in cookie-cutter strip malls - and each location's vibe feels hip and independent. Currently, there are two locations in Georgia. This location opened in January 2022 in the old Octane / Revelator Coffee space in West Midtown (Marietta Street Artery / Bellwood). Octane lasted almost 17 years in this spot (original location) and closed in September 2020. Emmy Squared's first Atlanta location opened on April 22, 2021 in the old Shed at Glenwood space in Glenwood Park. I love what the designers did to the old Octane space. The dining room is quite spacious. It's divided into halves with a bar on each side. Business was slow last night, so half the space was closed off. Outside, they have a string-lit patio out front and a small rooftop patio with a perch. There are retractable doors on the storefront side. One of them was pulled up last night, allowing for bar-height seating that faced both into the restaurant and out towards the neighborhood. Cool. Free parking is available in the surface lot out front, but there are only 10 spots. We lucked out and found open spots around 6:30pm. However, when we left around 9:10pm, the lot was full. As we left, I saw three cars waiting on spots to open. This was on an ordinary Tuesday night. If the lot is full, there are two paid parking options nearby: (1) the surface lot at 1040 Marietta St NW, which is part of the Brickworks development across the street and (2) the Brady apartment garage at 701 8th St NW. You can book reservations for Emmy Squared on OpenTable. When I booked, both this location and the Glenwood Park location did not offer points. Boo. Along with Detroit-style pizza, Emmy Squared serves a small variety of apps, salads, burgers, sandwiches, cocktails, beer, and wine. When ordering pizza, I recommend ordering large for $5 more each. You won't regret it. The regular pizzas are 8x10 inches and cut into six slices. The large pizzas are 10x14 inches and cut into 10 slices. They are rectangular in shape and deep dish. The menu says the large-size pizzas are "75% larger" than the regular-size pizzas. Here's what our party of four ordered: Cocktails * The Prime Cut Martini ($15) - New Amsterdam Vodka, dry vermouth, olive brine, and blue cheese-stuffed olives Seasonal Cocktails * Emotional Damage ($15) - Lunazul Tequila Blanco, fresh lime juice, in-house tropical passionfruit syrup Sweet Auburn ($15) - Old Forester 100 bourbon, New Amsterdam Vodka, real peach puree, and fresh lemonade; shaken Mocktails * Lavender 75 ($11) - take on the French 75; lavender syrup, fresh lemon juice, and club soda Shareable Plates and Salads * Jumbo Wings ($18) - 10 house-brined jumbo chicken wings with Sriracha "crystal" glaze with peanuts and cilantro * Brussels Sprout Salad x2 ($14 each) - shaved Brussels sprouts, house-pickled red onions, cashews, blue cheese, sweet dried cherries, and miso dressing Detroit-style Pizza * Colony (large, $25) - signature cheese blend, housemade red sauce, hand-sliced and house-pickled jalapenos, Ezzo pepperoni, honey; added Italian sausage $3 extra * VIP (regular, $24) - signature cheese blend, three housemade sauces (vodka, red, and parsley pesto), Ezzo pepperoni, Calabrian chilies, sesame seed crust * Good Paulie (large, $24) - signature cheese blend, caramelized onions, Italian sausage, freshly-shredded smoked Gouda When our pizzas came out, our server noticed our Colony looked wrong. He immediately took it back to the kitchen and had a new one made for us. My wife and I had all three of these same pizzas - Colony, VIP, Good Paulie - at a different Emmy Squared less than a year ago and, it pains me to say it, all three tasted worse here. Our server admitted the proof (rise) was off and our crusts were too thin. This was most apparent with our VIP which, in hindsight, I think we should've had remade or not be charged for. Not only was the dough undercooked, but the VIP was especially greasy and not cut properly. Also unfortunate -- the wings were unremarkable. Not bad, just not memorable. On the bright side, my wife really liked the Brussels Sprout Salad. We ordered two of them. The drinks were tasty as well and our server was nice, though perhaps stretched thin. The restaurant seemed kind of dead, which is the opposite of our past Emmy Squared experiences (nice and busy). Admittedly, those visits were on weekends. In summary, not all Emmy Squareds are created equal. read more

See all

Excellent pizza!! Unos fan and loved it! Easy parking and great location!! Nice place for a group to meet for social gathering. read more

Nice large place, food was wonderful and staff was spot on. The Detroit style pizza crust was perfect! Will be back. read more

See all

Some of the best pizza I've had in a while! They have their own parking lot as well which is a huge plus! Our server was very sweet & friendly. They have a lot of great sounding items so I'll definitely be back to try other things! Super yummy & flavorful! I never eat the crust of my pizza but this one was too good to pass up! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

I've heard about Emmys for years, before moving back to Atl. Of all days, we stop to finally try the pizza & told as we walk in from someone there is currently no more dough- then the hostess confirmed & let us know it would be a while for any pizza orders...we still sat to read the menu. Tommy came over & let's just say he is worth his weight and definitely saved our 1st time experience. Thanks Tommy for the suggestions & such great service. Pizza (Good Paulie) was great. read more

This place is hit or miss. But when it hits, I keep coming back after a miss or two to get the next hit. Obviously I'm writing this after a hit. The pizza crust was the perfect balance between crunchy and chewey, and Tommy the bartender was mixing my Negronis srtrong and keeping the vibe in the room energetic. I was craving this for weeks, and of course I'll be back, even if next time it doesn't hit. Because the next time after that... read more

I came here (group of 3) on a random Tuesday for Lunch. It was a good experience. Service was friendly/attentive. We all ordered some variation of pizza with a Caesar Salad to share. Overall it was a good experience and the food was yummy. Def had enough of the Regular sized pizza left over for later. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Regular Pizza (Pepperoni and Mushrooms). - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Tommy once again created the best vibe for me and my friend. The cocktails were excellent, and I highly recommend this lovely spot to anyone looking for a relaxed place with amazing drinks. I will be returning. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Dirty martini - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Hands-down, the absolute best pizza spot -- especially if you're looking for a gluten-free crust and vegan cheese. I've tried gluten-free pizza all over the city and even in other cities, and it almost never fully hits. This place nailed it. The gluten-free crust was deep-dish style, soft on the inside with the perfect crunch on the outside -- not dry, not flat, not cardboard-like, just really well done. They didn't skimp on the tomato sauce either, which made a huge difference. I ordered the Rino Supreme with pepperoni and Calabrian peppers, and it was excellent -- flavorful, balanced, and genuinely satisfying in a way gluten-free pizza rarely is. On top of that, the service was top-tier. Friendly, attentive, and welcoming from start to finish. This is officially my new go-to pizza spot. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Rino Supreme - gluten free crust, vegan cheese, pepperoni, calabrini peppers - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

This place is not far from my daughter's apartment and she said she loved the pizza and we should go. So when we arrived the place was a decent size and cute. Our server Adam was very polite and attentive. The food arrived in no time. We had the Top Dog pizza which was delicious. Also the Zia fries which were delicious waffle fries with a flavorful sauce with pimento cheese bacon and ranch . Can't go wrong with that combo. We had a huge Caesar salad which was great. Soo much food we definitely had a to go box . Overall food and service were great! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Seasoned Waffle Fries - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Great space. The brussels sprouts salad is delish. My mescal margarita was on point. My friend enjoyed her vegan pizza. Good service. Will be back to try more of the menu. Parking on site is limited. read more

Pizza and fries were amazing and the gluten free crust was also surprisingly above average. Service was a little off but nothing too bad. The bathrooms were disgusting and that was definitely the main detractor. We came on a Saturday night at 7pm and there were only 2 other people in the restaurant which was really weird. If I were back in town I'd definitely come back, the food was so good read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Vodka Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

I went on a Sunday night, last minute decision and wanted something good. Plus I've been here numerous times and it's worth the drive. Upon arriving it was no one at the hostesses stand I noticed that the host would also be our server and it was the only server. I decided at this point to get my food to go. A few cons is the bathrooms were pretty dirty I'm not sure if it's because it's the end of the day. They also don't have paper towels instead of a hand drier which I'm not a fan of. As for the drinks they don't serve sweet tea and they have glass bottle non alcoholic drinks. read more

Tommy is my personal goat, fantastic recommendations and service. If you're looking for a good slice and some good vibes, check this spot out read more

From the greeting to the service to the pizza and drinks -- simply YES!! 10/10 will recommend!! They have a small private lot - arriving a little before 4 I was able to snag a spot. I walked in and loved the contemporary vibes of the decor. I opted to sit at the high top overlooking outdoors -- doubles as a great people watching spot & a space to get fresh air directly lol! I've been wanting to try Emmy Squared for years - I passed by locations often but would be on the way to an event I had about 45 mins to spare before my next gig and let me tell you -- nothing was getting in the way of me and E2 lol Due to the time crunch I only ordered a drink and pizza. Once Tommy, my waiter, mentioned the drink special - spicy margarita - I was sold. You had me at spicy. I enjoyed the refreshing drink and water while my deep dish pizza was being baked to perfection. I opted for the Colony Deep Dish pizza which had red sauce, ezzo pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, & honey. Take my word for it - top contender for sure and I love pizza of all varieties! The crust was fluffy yet had the perfect crunch and the toppings meshed together so well. I added red pepper flakes to mine cause I longed for a little heat and it did the trick. I will definitely be back very soon! Such a great experience. PS. They are now open for lunch daily!!! read more

See all

Elmy square has some of the greatest Pizza and cheesesteaks. The food was piping, hot and the service was immaculate. I have really enjoyed my experience at Emmy. I love the relaxing ambiance. It was the restrooms were very clean. Had no odors. read more

See all

The pizzas were delicious. I bought the Meatsiah, Vodka and Quinn. Thankfully I ordered them through Doordash and was able to grab them and go because it didn't seem like they had any staff working there. No one greeted me or ever came to the hostess stand. read more

Ordered take out: pizza and a burger. Pizza is good, there was burnt cheese on the crust (yum) but not worth the money. It's too small for what they charge and honestly I can make a better pan pizza. $18 for a personal pizza, no meat. Nah. We got le big matt burger and it was just okay. It was soggy by the time we got it home and it was ready before the pizza so it was probably already soggy when they gave it to us. There was nothing amazing about the way it tasted. It was kinda just greasy meat and bread. Fries are an extra $7 so when asked if we "want fries with that" we quickly declined. (I wonder how many people think it's included) I'm sure it's a nice spot to happen on while out with friends. The decor is nice. Given our to-go order for two of $37 wasn't enough for dinner, I doubt I'll be returning. If they don't want to reduce prices, they should increase portions or add a small side or something. This is too expensive for pizza read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The restaurant had a really pretty interior and our waiter constantly checked up on us. My friend and I shared the Miranda pizza (four cheese, bacon, hot honey) and it was delicious! I loved the crust, it was perfect fluffy and crispy. The hot honey added a sweet kick and tasted great with the cheese and bacon. Would love to come back and try the other pizzas! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - West Midtown - Miranda Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

We ordered a pizza it was 25 for 6 slices ok........the dough was way under cooked. Called for a replacement only not a refund and the Manager ; black girl heavy set) said call door dash for the refund!!!! lol door dash didn't make the MF Emmy's did! I will NEVER buy from them again and it wasn't even good PLEASE! read more

I had a long day at work and the manager (Amanda) and bartender (Jason) made me feel safe, at home, and not rushed. I only came to have a drink. I don't know anyone else that is best fit for this job and role but (Amanda) . They are truly amazing. read more

Excellent service and great food and drinks. The place is clean and the staff is on target.

Jason was a great server. He took care of our party! Great food and great service! Definitely some of the best food in west midtown!

Sadly our experience this time was a huge disappointment. We asked to switch a topping and were charged $3.50 for the change. The pizza wasn't hot. Our second pizza had sausage instead of pepperoni. we had to wait for another pizza to be made while half of our party got to eat. Nothing was offered for the inconvenience. We had to ask for ice in our water. Honestly it seemed like we were inconveniencing our waitress. We visited Emmys squared 1.5 years ago when our daughter was visiting GSU. We couldn't wait to come back and after today's experience we won't ever be back. read more

Wings, vegan pizza, clean restrooms, and good service Full time vegans, cover your eyes. I got you on the vegan pizza. There wings are worth it. I could do without the tip, but it was proof it was from a chicken. Those wings were HUGE!!! They bake them first then fry to order. They are phenomenal! And did I say there HUGE. Now, the vegan pizza. I was hesitant because of the large garlic bulbs. But it was so creamy and flavorful. It gave the wings a run for its money. Service was nice and laid back decor. I'll be back. read more

See all