I would say its my third time eating here but I 100% plan to go again today, so lets just call it the fourth. So far every time ive been i had the best waiter named jack and he provides an experience close to having a family gathering at a restaurant he makes sure you have the best setting rembers your names meals things you like dislikes places you like to sit its insane only something I could imagine coming from a close cousin or a sibling great at conversation and just makes sure every visit feels like an event 10/10 recommend this place to anyone who wants top tier food great laughs and a a vibe that will bring you back everytime read more

Cuisine: 7 Service: 7 Decor: 7 Value: 6 Overall: 7 Emmy has been around for a while now, but I have only been to this UES location once before. Upon my second visit, I still feel like this location is not as good as their other branch in Hell's Kitchen. However, it is still capable of a satisfying meal. Their claim to fame was the Detroit style square pizzas, which are quite delicious. However, I think their overpriced Le Big Matt Burger may be just as worth the visit. Another decent item is their Brussel Sprout Salad. Hopefully I'll be back to try more of the menu in the future. read more

See all

PRO = good pizza CON = Price This pizza place was next to my hotel so we popped in. I'm originally from NY and immediately knew this wasn't a "pizza place" It was a nice looking, but small, restaurant. And the pizza is Detroit style, not NY style We were greeted by 2 nice girls and ordered some sodas while we looked over the menu. We were only then2nd table on there and our waiter was slow to get to us. We only wanted a small pizza and added Gouda (do that and you won't be sorry) He couldn't seem to understand that's all we wanted. He asked if we just wanted the Gouda on half or if we wanted to create our own pizza...And we told him twice "no. We just wanted a regular pizza with Gouda added" The pizza was GREAT. Now for the one downside...your soda comes from a can and they ate $4 EACH. No one said anything about no free refills. $31 for 3 sodas and 1 pizza. It was good but I'll hit the small shop down the block next time. read more

Love this place! It is a cute, casual, and delicious restaurant nestled on third Avenue in the upper east side. vibes are always good and service is always good. For the food: Le Big Matt - the burger is really good. I think it lives up to the hype actually.... I've heard the one at Emily is just as good, so I gotta go try it as it is their sister restaurant I believe. While it is definitely on the pricey side, it doesn't feel significantly worse than a lot of other burgers in the city, given the quality and the size. as a bonus, it comes with great waffle fries. Pizza - while this is technically their main thing, I think a lot of people actually go for the burger. That being said, the pizza is great. This time, I got the "Founders", but I've tried a couple other ones and they are all fantastic. The trick is really to get their lunch special; it's a great deal. The pizza freezes and reheat really well if you have leftovers, but you might not as they are good and aren't actually that large, so you might just finish it all. Totally worth a visit if you're uptown or want a good thick crust pizza and burger without all the fuss! read more

See all

Was looking for a spot in the neighborhood for dinner after a concert in Central Park. I had heard from several people that Emmy Squared had great gluten-free pizza and it did not disappoint! Great cocktails also. Larger space than expected, plenty of seats inside. Friendly and helpfull staff. There were moments where they were very busy though so it took a little while to get someone's attention in those moments. read more

See all

Love the ambiance and service. I usually make a reservation ahead of time to get seated easily. They are accommodating with children and also have a baby changing table in the bathroom. I love their lemon pepper wings with one of their pizzas. All of their pizza options are tasty. Great spot! read more

See all

A group of us 4 Arrived at 4:30 to an empty restaurant. Hot honey pizza- meh not a fan of the honey but friends wanted it. Actually the burrata cheese was very good and balanced the taste fairly. VIP - recommended by waiter. When it came out he likened it to a Christmas tree because of the green and red sauces - Beautiful. And delicious. All 3 sauces are my favorite. The peppers made it the cherry on top. Can't believe I'm saying this for such expensive pizza but I would come back to try the others. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - VIP Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Delicious food! The detroit style pizza has a wonderfully crisp outside and nice bready inside. Definitely recommend the MVP!! The staff was incredibly lovely and helpful! read more

Fantastic every time. The founders pizza is delicious and they are great with the kids being around.

I mean.... aaammmaaazing! Redefines "Detroit" style pizza, totally NYC as one would expect but not just because! It's like if Detroit had a better looking, smarter sibling who left Michigan for NYC... they were just meant for more. That's what they did to Detroit style pizza. Lite, airy, crispy and velvety sauce. Beautiful interior and top notch staff make Emmy's a no brainier! read more

The pizza was SO good but the price for the size was a little pricey. Other than the that I think this place was really good.

We have been here many times. Ordered takeout many times. It seems to be going downhill. The chicken nuggets, which I raved about have not been good since that one time. The ones they served to us were likely sitting under a heat lamp for a while. It was more batter than chicken, and it seemed re-fried because they got cold. The chicken in the chicken parm sandwich was so dry, I would not eat that again. It was definitely not freshly cooked. The burger bun was way too small for the burger and fell apart. There was not much meat there. They compensate for this tiny burger by giving you half a try of cold fries. For the amount they charge on this food, it is really disappointing. Basically, this is fast food at dining in prices. I am not returning anymore. read more

See all

Pizza is alright but for price it's kind of hilarious. Got a salad for 12 dollars and probably feeds a 2 year old. Insane to price 7 pieces of lettuce for 12 bucks but go off. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - 12 dollar Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered from here one of the items was a Chopped Caesar salad with crispy chicken. It came I chopped in a little box with 10 pieces of shredded roaming, lettuce, dressing, cheese, and little plastic on top of the lettuce plastic containers. The hard chicken wasn't another little box sliced into five strips. It was rockhard I would not recommend ordering from here. Beware what they show you is not what it looks like when you get it. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - This is the $20 Caesar salad chopped with chicken - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We came here for dinner to meet up with our friends and I'm so glad we did. Everything we ordered was delicious - from the cheese sticks to the pizzas to our sangria! Our service was attentive and accommodating with allergies. Plus it was lively and warm here to help escape from the evening chill. read more

See all

I love Emmy Squared! Their portions are huge so plan to share. The food is simply delicious. I don't think I have ever ordered a bad dish. My fave is the MVP pizza. It's a casual laid back restaurant with good vibes. The staff is friendly and helpful. A neighborhood gem. read more

This is a nice little spot for a weekday lunch in the UES. We had made a reservation, but could have got a table easily as it wasn't busy late on a Friday lunchtime. The staff is super friendly and helpful, guiding us to the lunch menu with smaller portions and giving great advice. Would definitely return when it's a little more bustling. Bathrooms are down steep steps so patrons with accessibility needs may need to check before booking. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Pear cocktail - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The atmosphere seemed nice on a Friday night, but the food and service were not quite what we were expecting. For us, the dollops of ricotta were very heavy, and the small sprinkling of sausage crumbs was just not enough. If the ratios were adjusted, the pizza has the potential to be very good. The host squeezed us into a table for 2 even though we had reserved for 3, and told us there were no booth seats available even though it really seemed there were. The server told us a regular pie wouldn't be enough for us even though we discovered it would have been, and when we had a large amount of leftovers gave us a box very clearly too small for them, so we had to ask for two more boxes, and then gave us a bag too small for the boxes which ripped and we had to ask another staff member for a larger bag. We've never had this happen before so it was surprising. It's possible that we were unlucky, and maybe this just isn't the style of pizza for us. I generally love square pizza and other versions of Detroit pizza, but I guess each place has its own interpretation. read more

Pricey but great food! The pizza was small but filling and the pesto garlic cheese sticks are so delicious! read more

See all

Hey you can't expect a takeout burger and fries to look "wow". But the burger flavor was delicious. I ordered the Le Big Matt + Fries. I had a taste of the plain burger with nothing on it and one with sauce. Both were delicious - it's the grass fed beef. As for the fries it was just ok. So you get what you pay for in it's quality. read more

See all

What a pleasure it was to try Emmy Squared in person! I have gotten the pizza delivered and it's delicious, so I knew going in person would be a taste treat! My wife and I started off with the ceaser salad which could feed 4 and was everything you crave for a Caesar salad. We then split the Spicy Chicken sandwhich which was plentiful with taste if you could handle the burn of the heat after! I would only recommend notching the heat level down a smidge so it doesn't make me feel like I'm battling while enjoying it! We than got into their delicious vodka square which was just beautifully done perfect crisp all around accompanied by a delicious vodka sauce it's definitely a must try square slice! For dessert we had the skillet brownie with ice cream which was very nice. I must also compliment the service as the food came out with impeccable timing from when we finished each course. read more

See all

I've been to this location twice in the past year with two different friends, because that's how good it is! The first time I went, I got the vodka pizza and the cheesy garlic sticks- the cheesy garlic sticks are covered in a homemade pesto, and are so beyond delicious. The second time, my friend and I shared an MVP (their most popular pizza) and mozzarella sticks, which were honestly some of the best I'd ever had. The waitstaff is friendly and attentive, all in a cute atmosphere as well. Each pizza is the perfect size to be split between two, but more can be ordered if you're in a larger group. They are very accommodating towards everyone, and there's just overall a really warm and nice vibe. Will definitely be here again! read more

See all

Love this restaurant! Came here on a saturday with a party of 7. We were treated so well and given good recommendations from our server Cesar.he recommended the "emotional damage cocktail" , I really enjoyed it! and I definitely cant forget to mention the Founders Pizza!!! 10/10 read more

Updating my review! Went in and sat down and it was a much better experience! This was probably my fault for thinking of Emmy as a takeout place for me as this will be a great place to continue to go and sit down. The Brussels sprout salad is sooo good. I love the addition of the blue cheese. The MVP pizza came out super fresh within 15-20 minutes of us ordering and the crust is everything, so doughy and fresh! All of the servers were amazing and I will find myself back here. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - MVP - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Very good non-conventional pizza spot! They don't have your typical triangle pizza. This is more Sicilian style. They have several different types; burrata, pepperoni with hot honey, bacon and it is all delicious. The caesar salad and chicken wings are also very good. The staff is very friendly and the food comes out in a reasonable amount of time. read more

In The City for the day. Stopped at Emmy's for a late lunch. We had a choice of indoor or outdoor seating. We opted for indoors. We were seated right away. Ordered My Little Coconut cocktail. If you like a tropical drink, this was very good. We had the Asian pickled mushroom appetizers. Great flavor. The mushrooms were mixed in with cucumbers and red onion. For lunch, we ordered the Roni Supreme. It came out fairly quick. Crunchy crust. The right amount of sauce. Cheesey. Pepperoni was crisp. Rectangular pie. 6 slices. So yummy. Heard the burger is popular, too. Definitely will return. read more

See all

My family and I walked here for dinner after spending the day at the MET. We were tired from walking all day but it was definitely worth the extra walk over to get here. We wanted pizza but at a place that was more of a restaurant (not a walk in-by the slice pizza joint) but also not a high end Italian place. This fit the bill perfectly! The pizza was so delicious. And we ordered both the Caesar and the Brussels sprout salads and enjoyed both. We chose to sit outside which was a little noisy but as tourists we enjoyed the NY atmosphere. The servers were so nice and very attentive. Just take note that if you have any mobility issues, the bathroom is down some steep stairs. They had a nice drink selection but the beer selection was limited to bottles/cans and the wine is a bit overpriced. But overall we really enjoyed it here. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I love Emmy squared! I'm pretty sure I've been to most nyc locations, but the UES is my favorite. We came here after a family day at the Met with some friends. Our server was Caesar and he was so accommodating. He came out with paper and crayons for the kids. I love that they have a kid's menu at this location and are super family friendly! We ordered the fried mozzarella sticks, chicken bites(kids menu), le matt, classic, colony and the big ang. Everything was so good and their kids portion was huge! We ended the night with the skillet brownies which everyone loved. We'll definitely be back again! read more

I've been in a Detroit pizza streak for the past 10 days and Emmy definitely hit the spot tonight. It's crazy my neighbor was walking with the little box and I was like damn idk if that's gonna fill me up so I had to ball out and get the big boy definitely the better choice for value it's 4 dollars more especially if you're getting the original. It definitely filled my stomach. The service is good. I like the space kinda looks like Tribeca decor not your average woody upper east side business my only problem is that it says Detroit and Brooklyn on that box lol I know they are sister cities but it gives transplant vibes .. like if you gonna be Detroit just own Detroit or at least play like it ... I would come back for more but I'm not reading the box. read more

We ended up at Emmy Squared after a morning spent at Central Park and the Met. I made a reservation but it wasn't needed at all, the restaurant had plenty of seating! We were helped right away by Aisling (I'm so sorry if I got your name wrong!) who was super attentive and really went above and beyond in helping my partner (allergic to dairy) navigate the menu. We ordered the seasoned waffle fries and I got a side of the queso and both were super delicious, portion was huge and very easy to share with 2+ people. I ordered the vodka pizza (6 piece) and lovvvved the crust - it was perfectly crunchy and thick, my favorite. The vodka sauce was delicious and flavorful! Two pieces were more than enough for me so I found it to be a great value. My partner ordered the gluten free crust with vegan cheese, chicken and basil, and was also a fan of their pizza. Well definitely be visiting again! read more

See all

I ordered a Hawaiian pizza, boneless wings and mozzarella sticks from here this evening only to find all of the mozzarella sticks completely empty (no cheese). I called the restaurant who informed me that these come from a third party provider and apologized for the inconvenience... At Emmy's an order of mozzarella sticks costs $18 for 6 sticks. The largest 3rd party food provider I am aware of is Sysco and after a quick Google search I learned their bulk mozzarella sticks cost $0.70 per stick. So Emmy's is not just outsourcing the food prep they are effectively charging customers 4 - 5x mark up for low quality items. You would think an Italian restaurant that describes themselves as "founded on an unconditional love of well-made food" would bother to make the food themselves instead of buying pre-made from what is basically a grocery store for restaurants but I guess that speaks to how little they care about the actual cooking aspect of running a restaurant. After the whole mozzarella stick debacle we realized the boneless wings were also low quality Sysco fare so we won't be ordering from here again. It's a bummer because I've gone to Emmy Squared for several years now and always enjoyed it as a Detroit style pizza option. That said I had noticed a significant decline in quality the last few times eating there (although the pizza itself seems like it was made buy actual cooks not purchased pre-made from a grocer like all the sides). Unfortunately this last experience is a dealbreaker and I felt compelled to tell others to avoid eating here as there are plenty of other great pizza options nearby like Village Square read more

Legit one of the best pizza places I've come across. Would recommend to everybody. Top tier!

This is a comfort food place for my friends and I - my friends apartment literally burned down and out and our mental health dinner was to come here. The Miranda is our fav - so goood. Aileen is a great server, and was super attentive and made us feel at home! Thank you :) read more

What a really casual family friendly resturant on the upper east side. We meet some folks here while in NYC this week. Detroit style pizza is oe of those pizzas you love or say what's wrong with it Tholis place makes it to perfection. Small square pizza or large Square pies we went with the Angel and the Margarita with a side watermelon salad. Service was ok. suggestions is that most tables had small children, the wait staff be a little more attentive to signs of wanting to leave. Not the case at my table but thought they should notice this as such a full place with so many small kids. read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Angel pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've had Emmy saved for a while and I'm so happy I finally tried it. Service was great start to finish, our waitress Emili was so attentive without being intrusive - a perfect balance of service that is really hard to do. Arrived at 5:30 no resy and was seated right away. We ordered the cheesy garlic sticks and chicken crunchers to start. The cheesy garlic sticks are a bit pesto heavy but I enjoyed it. The chicken crunchers were delish! Tasted super fresh not like some pre frozen chicken they just deep fried. Main course we got burgers and they were awesome! One small critique I wish the pretzel bun had salt on top similar to a salty concession stand pretzel. Dessert was the brownie and that was amazing, tasted fresh baked and I love how the ice cream stayed frozen and didn't immediately melt all over it. read more

Emmy Squared is the "It Girl" of pizzas in NYC! You know there is an endless supply of pizza in this city and there are so many options at your street corner (literally)! But what makes ESP so different is the intentionality of their menu. Abundant yet limited in some ways (and unconventional in other ways - they got chicken sandwiches) - they offer a select range of unique pizzas with unique flavor and unique shape/size! You can order to share or order for yourself (which I did). Comparable to other popular/hype-based square-shaped Sicilian-style pizza in the city (iykyk), Emmy takes the cake (or should I say pie). I ordered their VIP which had a mix of topics I wanted - lots of flavor but with the traditional pepperoni like I like it! I also ordered their cheesy pesto garlic bread and it was really rich in flavor and gooey cheese. The pizza had a nice crisp crunch to it which I love love love! I did pick up which made things easy as I placed the order and quickly finished some errands near by! I would 10/10 recommend this place and to friends who visit! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - VIP - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I love this place and this pizza. I really like this location, it is spacious inside, it has never been packed when I've gone, and I like the furniture - the middle tables have wooden benches done tastefully. My boyfriend and I went a Sunday night, so it was pretty empty. Our waiter was hilarious and had great taste (he appreciated my Costco sweatshirt lol). We got the zia fries and the MVP. The fries are always a hit - super crispy and the toppings are placed perfectly that almost every fry at last has some cheese sauce. They also give you a massive portion of these french fries - we always end up taking them home. Now the pizza was cripsy on the edges, soft on the inside, and the toppings were great - I really like the combo of pesto with marinara sauce and vodka sauce - we had peperroni on it as well which gave a nice crunch on the top. You can't go wrong here. I've never had a pizza I didn't like. read more

Emmy Squared is okay, but I just don't get all the fuss. The pizza is fine--we ordered the one with mushrooms and ricotta. But, I defintiely wouldn't write home about it. In fact, it was a bit charred and had a super basic flavor profile. Oh, and then there's the highly-praised Le Big Matt Burger. I can honestly say, "Skip this burger." I mean, it's really no better than a Shake Shack burger, and it's priced at $26 (add $3 if you want bacon). I mean, WTF. Trust me, it's not worth that price! Despite my lackluster reviews of the pizza and burger, Emmy Squared did serve up a few enjoyable dishes. We tried three different salads--The Caesar, the Chopped Salad, and the Brussels Sprouts Salad--and all were pretty good. We also tried the Zia fries, which were waffle fries topped with bacon and cheese sauce. These were also tasty. Final thoughts: If you're going to check out Emmy Squared, go with a group and order a variety of dishes to share. You're bound to find something tasty, but it's not gonna blow your mind. read more

I think Emmy Squared made its way to my top pizza places in NYC! I've heard about them for a while and especially how they opened up a location in the UES. Finally got to check our their pizza and was surprised at how tasty it was! My favorite was the Angel! The caramelized onions offered a slight sweetness that balanced out the savoriness from the mushrooms and the pesto. The ratio of ingredients were appropriate, with more mushroom than expected! Their dough reminded me of focaccia bread, except it was airy as it was chewy. The crust was also pretty crunchy. The dough was still pretty good after my slice was sitting out for a while. Their regular pepperoni was good with the dough, but the red sauce was lacking a little flavor. Also big shout out of the delicious garlic bread!! It was covered with their tasty pesto sauce with lots of garlic flavors. It was chewy with a great cheese pull! I got takeout this time but definitely want to go back to check out other pizzas and apps! read more

I loved the pizza I had here, which, with all respect in the world, I was a bit surprised by because I believe I've had pizza at Emmy Squared before and I don't remember thinking much about it. But this was definitely my first sit down experience, so maybe that's the secret. I love pizzas that have a crunchy crust-- I know some people prefer chewy all the way through, but that's simply not me. And this was exactly what I was looking for. It was crispy all the way around the entire crust while also having a chewy and bready interior. Not quite deep dish, but I think veered more deep dish than a traditional NY pizza slice. The flavors were there, and I loved the basil leaves they included on top. My friend also recommended the mozzarella sticks. These were also delicious, with an amazing breading that held up even when it was super hot (I don't like a falling apart mozz stick, ya know). I'd absolutely come back!! read more

Emmy Squared Pizza - Vodka - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York