Im basing this review on my first and only visit which happened to be during a weekday afternoon, for lunch. I sure do hope things get more lively in a few hours past my visit - for their benefit! I would really like to see this venue succeed and keep itself around! I happen to know, because I grew up close by, that anyone who touches the place seems to fail. Unfortunately so. The current restaurant, Emmas ale house, is just one of the other 3 or establishment names in about 15 years. So, we ended up eating in this quaint and relaxed establishment. I do also want to note that because of its location, I dont think there is any "passing traffic" by foot or car, to help spread the word. Itd almost be natural that locals of the surrounding neighborhood would be the ones to notice and observe the change. You see, unluckily, next door is located the famous, also awesome, "Sam's" restaurant. Going to Sam's is what brought Emma's ale into my mind in fact. They are neighbors, on Gedney Way, an uncommon street that is located as a turn off of Mamaroneck Avenue, right across the street is the large and very green Burke Rehavilitation Center. But the street is such a small one that unless you had a reason, youd probably never hear about the spot. It's very much a hidden gem in a generally residential neighborhood. It's just about where the neighborhood known as "the highlands" begins. Particularly now, with (sub)urban sprawl, it feels all the more unique to go to a restaurant that is in a charming and low key area.
Our server at the restaurant didnt take long to seat us. He was welcoming and wearing an adorable bow tie. From there, we ordered a variety of foods.. my partner & I did what we always do, which is get 2 entrees and share. We went with a simple burger & fries, as well as a salad. A highly appreciated but rare occurence took place - because they knew we were sharing, they took it upon themselves to split the food onto 2 separate plates! Loved that. So much better than just an extra "sharing plate." Oh, and rewinding quickly - To my most pleasant surprise, they provided a salted pretzel loaf to dip into mustard, free! How often do you find that gesture around anymorr? On principle, as opposed to the $1 they may spend, I love when places do that.
For drinks, I got a pumpkin spiced cappuccino and it was fantastic.. not too this or too that, flavor-wise...and now, a massive confession that i need to make is, I ate their krispy Kreme sundae!! Each bite, delicious, but dangerously so! Too big for one person! It has 2 krispy Kreme donuts, chocolate, whip, all you could expect but that youd never blend on your own! We also got a brilliantly delicious cakey creme brulee dessert, with iced cream.
This space feels more like a restaurant than any kind of simple sports bar but upon entry, you do have to choose one of 2 sections, depending on your purposes.. When you enter, you're in a slightly upscale fully loaded sports bar (i.e. TVs on, playing sports). But, that area accounts for less than half of the full space. If you want to sit in the dining room, you just hang a left and poof, sports bar be gone!
The menu overall was reasonable/normal in their pricing. It also had plenty of options so theres something for everyone.
It's not uncommon but do know that they dont serve "breakfast." They have a brunch offering although not on weekdays.
Go Gedney Way! Thnx Emma's :) Good luck! I'll come and see you again. read more