Still great, continues to be a must visit, along with Mestizo Louisiana Mexican Restaurant on every pass through "Red Stick". As the saying goes, it takes an hour to get from Baton Rouge to Baton Rouge. And pie makes it better. Get the pie flight. Get the boudin melt. Waitstaff and ambiance were spot on. read more

See all

First time at Elsie's and I can definitely say it won't be the last! I've been hearing how good it is and they did not disappoint. We had about a 15 minute wait for a table for 2 on a Friday night. Our waitresses were so tentative and kind! We started with the boudin cakes! Really tasty with the avocado cream sauce. My husband kept wishing there were more than two! lol For entrees, I tried the crawfish hand pie and Brussel sprouts, along with a berry kick side salad! Everything was good. I particularly liked the fried jalapeños on the salad!! My husband ordered the Big Plate, includes fish, shrimp,and stuffed shrimp. The fish was fried so perfectly, just needed a few more shakes of seasoning! The remoulade sauce really shined and made the fish taste better. We finished with 2 desserts! The apple pie with ice cream and the turtle were both great! Overall, our experience was amazing! Our waitresses really anticipated our needs the entire night! We'll definitely be back for seconds! read more

See all

First dinner on our Acadiana road trip was a massive success! We walked in & they told us there would be a 45-55 min wait, but we were able to score two seats at the bar. The bar service was really attentive -- constantly refreshing water and asking if we needed anything. We ordered the seafood pie, the shrimp po boy with a side of fries, the s'mores pie, and the eye of the tiger pie. The seafood pie was a 5/5! I enjoyed the po boy, though my husband who has had more said it was a 4/5 in his opinion. The fries were decent -- nice spicing level but uneven bake. Some were super crispy and others were a little soft/limp. Both sweet pies were out of this world. The smores pie was literally like eating a s'mores. The eye of the tiger was perfectly creamy and an amazing balance of flavors. Would highly recommend!! read more

Just felt a bit underwhelmed. The savory pies (the chicken & beef/pork) were just a bit flavorless. The burger was just not very amazing either. The redeeming point was their apple pie with vanilla ice cream. So good and so fresh. read more

See all

This is a MUST go type place when in Baton Rouge! Such unique and oh soooo good dishes. Their pies are what they are known for and all that I get and you really cannot go wrong with any of them. They have dessert pies and lunch/dinner pies and their lunch/dinner pies take the cake for me (and I am a dessert guy). The place is not big, but they always seem to get people in/out quick so there is never much of a wait. The service is great and they always take great care of you!! The place is clean and cozy inside. It is small, but arranged so that you never feel crammed. read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - Crawfish Pies with Red Beans n Rice - Amazing! - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

We tried Elsie's Plate & Pie and it did not disappoint! I had the seafood pot pie and it was absolutely amazing, rich, flavorful, and packed with seafood in every bite. My husband ordered the honey chop and really enjoyed it as well. Everything was delicious, comforting, and full of flavor. We'll definitely be back! read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - seafood pot pie and honey chop - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

As always this meal was amazing! I tried the seafood bisque for the first time and I think I found a new favorite! I do wish the potatoes had gravy, but they are creamy and buttery and delicious without:) the fruity pebble pie was just okay, I prefer the Eye of the Tiger pie over this one read more

Easiest the best dinner I've had this year. Elsie's is living with cozy ambiance and warm service. The menu ranges from sweet to savory and features every pie I know of and a few more, look a little further down and you'll find a stellar selection of melts salads and sandwiches. Flip it over they've got such great mains my only complaint is I could hardly make up my mind on what to order. Thankfully our server Enola was happy to walk us through our decision making and lead us through a wonderful experience 10/10 no notes. read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - Crawfish queso and pork skins - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

See all

Named after "Ma" Elsie known for their history and Baton Rouge's best brunch! I dropped in for a sampling of dishes (faster seating at the bar where friends and service are front-row!) - the Cajun Crawfish Queso is a fan favorite and a tourist's wonder with pork rinds instead of traditional chips. If you didn't bring friends, you'll be sure to make some ordering this dish! Why not make it a double with the Louisiana Poulet Pot Pie - hot out of the oven with flaky crust, savory cream sauce, and pulled smoked chicken. I always close the sampler with dessert, and Eye of the Tiger (sweeter than it sounds, lemon ice-box pie topped with blueberry whip) delivers on all counts! First visit was a delight, looking forward to my return! read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - Eye of the Tiger - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

See all

I had never been to Elsie's, but it was an a similar location to a place that used to be called Toddle House that sold nothing but pies. It turns out that Elsie's is not related, but they do have great pies. My colleague had fried catfish with french fries, and I had stuffed shrimp with french fries. Both were really great, although they could've given us half as many fries and we would've been just as happy. We both ordered their eye of the tiger pie, which is a lemon icebox pie with a blueberry whipped cream topping, so it has LSU colors. The ambience was as good as it could be although we were confused about two semi private spaces that each had two tables that seat four. I would go back again over and over. read more

This place was amazing, we loved everything we had and could not stop talking about it. It is a small spot with a small parking lot but it is worth the wait. We would definitely go back if in the area again. read more

See all

I called ahead asking if they had gluten free items which they said they did. Turns out gluten free is just the regular menu items without the bun etc at the same price as the regular menu items. We ended up having to send the burger back because they left fried onions on there which had crumbled when we tried to take them off. When they brought out the new burger, they took all that toppings off besides the cheese. Burger was supposed to have mushrooms etc on there. My avocado sandwich was pretty good but missing flavor. The GF appetizer we shared was very good. The waiter was very nice and I know the problem with the burger was not his fault. I really had high hopes for this place seeing how many stars they got but I personally would not come back. read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - This appetizer was very good! - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

See all

Everything was perfect. How can that be? Well our server Alice nailed the recommendations and everything was stunningly good. Catfish. Red beans and rice. Seafood pot pie. Salads. Okra. Get here... It's awesome. read more

See all

From what I hear, Elsie's gets packed. That was not the case on a sunny Saturday mid-afternoon, but it was still decently busy. We were seated quickly, and skipped drinks. Elsie's, known for their pies, carries versions that are both savory and sweet in addition to a large menu of Southern-style comfort dishes with Cajun and Creole flavors. I got the seafood lafourche bisque and the blackened catfish sandwich. My friend got the honey chop, and we also shared the seafood pot pie. The seafood bisque: made with plenty of seafood bites is a super flavorful bisque broth - recommend! The honey chop: tender pork chop in their signature pepper jelly bbq - highly recommend! Seafood Pot Pie: I can see why they're known for pies! While on the heavier side, it was deliciousness in every bite - highly recommend. -- The blackened catfish sandwich: not worth it. Almost seemingly an afterthought on the menu... the blackened catfish itself was tasty but the simplicity of the lettuce, tomato and white bread (ok, sourdough) did not bring it together and was super bland and plain - do not recommend. It would have been better if they had a blackened catfish dish rather than this sandwich. -- Unfortunately service was also really slow. Our drinks (waters) and seafood bisque came out quick but we waited 35-40 minutes for the rest of our food. Our server informed us that the honey chop would be 20 minutes, which we were okay with, but after 35 minutes we were growing more and more impatient, especially given that it wasn't too busy at the time and our server never acknowledged the long delay. Inside, it's an industrial look and feel and on the trendier side. And even with setbacks, I'd definitely come back for their pies, and avoid the catfish sandwich. read more

See all

Cute place! Staff very nice! Been for breakfast and now dinner. I enjoyed dinner much more. Ordered: Smokey 3 Cheese Pimento: so good! Highly highly recommend Louisiana Poulet Pot Pie: very good! The top crust was nice and the rest was a little spicy but the flavors were amazing The Boudin Burger: falls apart in your hands. Nice flavor! Eye of the Tiger Pie: it was fine. I was hoping for more of a lemon flavor. And blueberry flavor in the whipped cream read more

See all

I was in Baton Rouge visiting family and since I'm always the one chosen to pick the place we eat at I chose this place of many pictures alone. It did not disappoint. We had the crawfish queso and cracklin as an appetizer. That was delicious. The cracklin was fried perfectly and the queso was flavorful. For entrees we had the seafood pot pie and the boudin melt. Both were amazing. The seafood pot pie crust was flaky and soft and butter and the filling was everything I wanted it too be. It was creamy with lots of flavor and just enough seafood. The boudin melt was unlike anything I've ever had but I'm so glad I got it because it was really good. The bread was soft, crunchy, and buttery. We also had the spicy watermelon margarita. Honestly I'm not sure what made me get this because I you l usually don't like spicy margaritas. This changed my mind. I love spicy margaritas now, at least the ones from Elsie's. I'm really upset that I ate so much that I didn't have room for dessert. read more

See all

If you don't try the pie nachos you have no clue what you are missing! Fried pie crust topped with a triple berry compote and vanilla ice cream! Will make a rabbit slap a bulldog! read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - Pie nachos! The best! - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

What an amazing find! DO NOT be fooled by the front of the building & the surrounding area!!! Haul yo a$$ around to the back (there's a parking lot off the 1 way street) and put your name on the list. We arrived about 1:00 on Labor Day and it was a 45 min wait, but we snagged a couple of bar seats. The special for the day was hot dogs. Hmmm... but wait!! These were NOT what you think, we ordered a Diablo Shrimp Melt and the hot dog with Pimento Cheese, Bacon, & house made Blueberry Pepper Jelly & Fried Pickles. Now I know how this sounds, but WOW!! Just WOW!! The melt was good, but sweet Baby Jeezus that dog was FANTASTICAL! We got a piece of Lemon Icebox Pie to enjoy tonight, so can't comment on that just yet, but I'm betting it will be da bomb. read more

First things first. Our server, Lily, was phenomenal. My husband and I are both fast drinkers and she had a refill ready every time. She was very pleasant to talk to and we had several conversations. She was so helpful and we loved her. I had never been here and was stumped between two dishes but ultimately got the Steak Frites. Tell me why the best steak I've ever had in my life was from a pie shop? It was PHENOMENAL and cooked to perfected. I prefer medium rare and few restaurants cook that preference well and Elsie's exceeded my expectations. The sweet pies were fantastic and very yummy. Their homemade pork rinds weren't overly crunchy and the perfect paring for the crawfish queso. The place itself is very cute and worth the extra minute to find the parking lot. I always saw the restaurant from government street but had no desire to try to find parking. It is SO WORTH IT! Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

I would have to say that this is the best restaurant in Baton Rouge. The food is delicious and the pie is super good! Everytime I go to Baton Rouge, I have to eat at Elsie's. I highly recommend Elsie's to anyone looking for some great Louisiana food and pie like Mamaw used to make! Yum!!! read more

Had a delicious meal at Elsie's! It was easy to come in and sit at the bar at lunch on the weekend and they have a good amount of other seating inside too. You're immediately greeted with all their sweet pies on display when you walk in. A very big temptation. For starters, I highly recommend the boudin cakes. The seafood pot pie was to die for, so rich and so delicious. The crawfish hand pie was also really good but the seafood pot pie was the stand out. Their entrees also come with a side salad and we tried their signature pepper jelly vinaigrette. It was pretty sweet but was still pretty good. Their melts and their crawfish queso with cracklins are also all so good. This is a great spot to come get some southern food that might put you down for a nap after! read more

See all

The pimento cheese app was fantastic! I would go again just for that. Ate dinner around 6 and there was a decent crowd. I would get there early for close parking. Fun and hip atmosphere. Service was good for how busy it became. Don't leave without trying a slice of homemade pie. read more

See all

Small cute find for lunch. Seems to always be a wait but worth it. First time there and will be back. Everything was delicious. Chicken pot pie, Natchitoches meat pies, and the biscuits with pepper jellies. read more

See all

Needed to pick a place to eat quick and the reviews for Elsie's didn't disappoint. They served our party of 4 quickly, even with a packed house on a Saturday at lunch. It's spacious, well decorated, clean, and seats many. We tried so many things, and I'm not kidding, it was all an absolute hit. The key lime pie and pecan pie were phenomenal. We all couldn't stop talking about the boudin ball appetizers and my friend ordered some to go to bring home to her boo. 12/10. I would drive the 1 hr and a half to eat here again. read more

See all

Inadequate parking We just kept on driving to Superior Grill with large free parking lot and excellent foodpp read more

In town for business and remembered seeing this place on DDD. Definitely worth the visit. I had the Fried Chicken Breast, Red Beans and Rice and Parmesan Mashed Potatoes. Everything was delicious! Great staff too! Oh had the hand pies too! read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - Hand Pies and Parmesan Mash Potatoes - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

See all

This place is off the beaten path and what I would refer to as a "hidden gem". The building is old and looks converted from something. There was about a 30 minute wait but you can get a drink while you wait. We were sat and the service was very good and then the food...WOW! Dish after dish was incredible and just when you can't take anymore, pie flight? Well yeah! And it is all incredible! Definitely go to Elsies! read more

See all

I can see why a lot of people like this restaurant. My colleague wasn't a big fan, maybe its too fru-fru for him but I enjoyed my experience. They have fun things on the menu like savory pies, crawfish queso with chicharones, boudain cakes and 7 different kinds of melts. I also loved how they have 3 different kinds of sauces and 4 different kinds of pepper jelly to compliment your entree. Not to mention 7 different kinds of cheeses to pick from or sub for. I tried the blackberry margarita and steak frites with brussel sprouts. We also ordered the crawfish queso as our app. My colleague ordered the seafood platter. The margarita is very small and really lasted just a few sips. It's served in a small rocks glass and decent, but geez, too small. Steak frites - this meal really hit the spot for me. The steak was thick, tender and cooked exactly how I requested. It was the priciest entree but well worth it. The butter on top of the steak helps elevate this dish. The brussel sprouts weren't crispy for the most part, as the menu indicated, but that's fine as they tasted pretty good regardless. My colleague, who is a native from Baton Rouge had never heard of this restaurant, so basically that means it wasn't on his "approved list" and he ate all his food, just didn't like the atmosphere. We both enjoyed the crawfish queso though. read more

See all

The food was superb and the atmosphere was nice and tranquil. The staff were able to give great suggestions and the service was prompt. My mom's red beans and rice had cooled while we were waiting to have all of our meal brought out and our server quickly replaced it with a fresh hot bowl. Maya was the absolute best! If you go there ask for her- she will take great care of you! The blueberry hand pie is a taste of heaven. Don't believe me just go! read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - Awesome menu with lots of options - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

See all

It had been awhile since eating at Elsie's. Our server, Hayley, was just fantastic. I tried the Arlington poorboy for the first time as well. It was a delight to all the senses and hit all notes on flavor. That touch of sweet spicy sauce for the shrimp was devine. The blackened catfish sandwich is a favorite as well. Just doesn't miss. The chosen sides were crispy brussel sprouts, pork rinds (also an order to go) that are light and crunchy and last the big better blue side salad. All so fantastic and gave another meal to bring home. No dessert this time but I'm doing dessert first next visit! read more

Elsie's Plate & Pie - American Near Me - Baton Rouge, Louisiana

Leaving a second review of Elsie's because it's that great. It was my last meal before I moved out of Baton Rouge and I still think about it everyday. Please do yourself a favor and get a side of red beans. I've never found any that compare read more

See all

Dropped in for restaurant week, which honestly is usually when I find myself here. We grabbed seats at the bar just as the crowd was picking up. We both ordered RW menu which was a great bang for our buck. $35 for 3 courses. I loved the way the price was broken down on my receipt. The bar was staff was attentive in the way they checked in on us, mainly the guy, the girl not so much. He noticed my expressions while digging into my second course and immediately asked if there was something wrong. I asked him if the sauce was intended to be cold. While the flavors were there the temperature wasn't. He admitted this was the first night serving the menu so he wasn't sure but if he had to guess he'd so no. He quickly grabbed my plate - whixh was also cold and said he'd have another dish made. Sure, my phone did eat first as usual but while the other second course was literally still steaming I knew this couldn't be right. When he returned it surely made a difference with a hot plate with a fresh hot dish. My only complaint about the staff is that the did not clean up our trash and discorded cups, glasses, dishes, napkins from the actual bar. I had the fish Michele and my companion had the gumbo pot pie. Course one she had the only none seafood option, cheese tartine which was very tasty just wished it was served with more toast crostinis. I went with the crawfish hush puppies. The crown bread was so delight sweet. Dessert we did one of each and the nachos are a classic hit I enjoy there but that Dubai hand pie was next level and I'm not even crazy about the Dubai chocolate trend. This was worth every $ spent. Congrats to them on being Michelin recognized! read more

See all

Absolutely outstanding food. The crust on everything, the crust! was pure perfection. Easily some of the best versions of each pie I've ever had. The entrées were perfectly seasoned and vanished from our plates before we even realized they were gone. High marks all around. It's hard to stand out in a region known for exceptional food, but Elsie's absolutely delivers. Great staff, excellent menu, and I'm already excited to come back and try more. Go here. Be happy. read more

See all

Delicious food, amazing atmosphere and service!!! We had a large group and everyone enjoyed the food!

Wow! Great meal for all 4 of our group, great service, highly recommend, key lime pie is the best ever!

Hands down one of my favorite Baton Rouge restaurants! It's family friendly, has great energy, and atmosphere. The food and drinks are excellent! Service is always great! I always order the blackberry raspberry margarita on the rocks. My favorite appetizers are the smoked wings and mouthwatering crawfish queso. Family favs are the chicken pot pie, crawfish bisque, and burgers. Seafood was a bit fresh and dissatisfactory at our last visit but still a good time! read more

See all

The service was super fast and friendly. We stayed well past closing but the waitress didn't rush us. I love the smoked wings!!! I had the boudin burger and it was okay. I wouldn't order it again. My friend had the chicken pot pie and it was super delicious. The atmosphere was pretty chill and laid back. The lemon pie was DELICIOUS. The other pies (blueberry, chocolate and smores) were okay just not my favorite. If i had to rate them in order from greatest to least it would be the lemon, blueberry, chocolate and then smores. The s'mores pie had a heavy Smokey flavor that I didn't like and the chocolate pie was too chocolatey (those that get it get it) lol. Overall though I do plan on going back. read more

See all

Excellent! I really enjoyed dining here. The seafood pot pie was exceptionally delicious! Service was very attentive and friendly, too.

We went for dinner with the family. The place was packed and we were lucky to have found a table fast. The servers were friendly and helpful. The inside is nice and clean. There are also small boots inside. How lovely. We ordered the crawfish bisque, Duck BLT sandwich, shrimp and fried green tomatoes, the big plate and fried okra. The dishes came out fresh and hot. They were also very tasty .We enjoyed all the dishes. Will definitely come back when we're in Louisiana. read more

See all

Great lively ambiance for dinner on a week night. Place was packed but my friend and I found 2 seats at the bar. Made my drink perfectly. Got the "nakadish" meat pies which were outstanding, the best I've ever had. I even ate the salad, which I never do. I'm dreaming about those meat pies. I can't wait to go back. read more