1. Elmo's Pizza and Subs

0

Fort Wayne, IN

Cancel

Open app

Search

Elmo's Pizza and Subs

3.7 (9 reviews)
InexpensivePizza, Sandwiches
Open • 5:30 am - 8:00 pm

Order Elmo's Pizza and Subs Takeout or Delivery

Elmo's Pizza and Subs Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Elmo's Pizza and Subs

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Stacy S.

Stacy S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lex B.
29
530
50

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Elmo's Pizza and Subs

You might also consider

Lake Avenue Halal Market - Pastrami sandwich and smoked turkey sandwich

Lake Avenue Halal Market

4.9(21 reviews)
3.8 mi

Friendly, great service, delicious sandwiches & the closest to a NY/Chicago deli we've been to in…read morethe Fort. Parking isn't the best, but we've never had any issues. More of a grab and go establishment, so don't expect dine-in seating! Hot tip: grab some sandwiches and head over to Lakeside park just down the road! Makes for a great afternoon.

We were recently craving Mediterranean food and didn't know where to go. Of course Instagram would…read moreshow us this place. When you first pull into the parking lot, you don't think much of it as the building next to the convenience store is abandoned. It does not have a beautiful façade but when you walk in, it's a mom and Pop small ethnic grocery store. You order your food at the counter. The menu is kind of limited however there is quite a bit of healthy options. We went with the lamb kebab over rice and the gyro sub. unfortunately, I did not realize that the prices go up if you pay with credit card, so remember to bring cash if you want to save money. After you place your order you can wander this very small aisles to look at a variety of different drink options, etc. The food did take a little bit longer than expected to prepare. The lamb kebab over rice was delicious and had the perfect balance of spice. The sub itself unfortunately was a little disappointing. Maybe I'm not familiar with New York style subs, but I found the bread to be underwhelming and the actual ingredients inside the sub to be slightly disappointing. I think it would be better to serve the euro in a pita. I don't know about the other sandwiches that other people rave about however, maybe I will try that the next time we come in with cash, of course.

Photos
Lake Avenue Halal Market - Menu 9.26.26.

Menu 9.26.26.

Lake Avenue Halal Market - Beef pastrami

Beef pastrami

Lake Avenue Halal Market - Menu August 2025

See all

Menu August 2025

McAlister's Deli

McAlister's Deli

3.4(76 reviews)
4.5 mi
•$$

McAlister's Deli Lima Road - I've never been a big fan of McAlister's. However, I've had them,…read morenow, three times in the last three months. Twice dine in and once for a catered lunch. I have come to appreciate the freshness of their sandwiches lately. My wife had the chicken Caesar wrap. She liked the moist chicken, light tasting dressing and soft wrap. The potato salad was fairly standard with most. It had a nice mustard-mayo taste and consistency. It might have been a little heavy on the mayo. The egg and celery were good touches. Very smooth! The McAlister Club sandwich was filed high with delicious turkey and ham. The Swiss and cheddar cheese...plus toppings made a nice sandwich. The white bread was nicely toasted without being overly crispy. Just enough mayo to blend the tastes. The 1/2 salad, on the 2 choice deal, is enough for a whole meal. It's a real club salad. All the fresh meats, cheeses and toppings. Lots of croutons. The honey mustard dressing is thick and spicy. All blended to an enjoyable taste. The Mac & cheese side was rather small. The noodles were a bit mushy and over cooked. The cheese sauce comes off a bit "institutional". Perhaps a flavor that you would find at school or a place who isn't focused on a designer Mac & cheese. It was very creamy and had a mild cheese flavor. I liked the tee shirts the staff was wearing to promote their tea. McAlister's special tea is like drinking a hug - per the shirt. The tea has a nice smooth/warm/soothing taste. It kind of reminds you of a southern style tea. However, it isn't over the top sugary. It also doesn't have a bold strong tea taste. It's good...and I almost felt the hug lol.

Visited this location on a recent visit to Fort Wayne to grab lunch before heading home to…read moreLouisville. McAlister's is usually a safe bet. Sunday around noon o'clock and it was pretty a pretty busy place. We reached the corner to place our order after a short wait and the gentleman behind the corner took our order. He spoke very quietly and I felt bad having to ask him to repeat nearly everything. After we gave him our order and he repeated it I questioned it if it was right. At the point another employee came back and asked us what it was. It turns out he was a new employee and still finding his way. No problem. No one starts out an expert at anything. The nice lady got it straightened out and we sat down to wait. A few minute later a manager came by and apologized and said he thought our order wasn't entered correctly. We told him that was the case originally, but it was corrected by another employee and it was good now. The food took about ten minutes and wasn't presented as the prettiest meal I've ever eaten. Both lids on my Jalapeño Turkey Crunch appeared to be sliding off the side and the pickled looked like it had been mushed in the hands of a toddle, barely resembling a pickle. It made it a VERY messy, high-napkin-utilization meal. While the tables were addressed quickly after diners leaving, the floors were another story. Yes, it was lunch rush, but at the same time it takes a micro-second to pick up an errant straw wrapper or napkin. This location has a nice outside seating area with several table and umbrellas. It was a bit too hot/humid for us to eat outside, but in better weather we'd have absolutely eaten outside.

Photos
McAlister's Deli
McAlister's Deli
McAlister's Deli

See all

Jersey Mike's Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.0(40 reviews)
6.2 mi
•$

I was pleasantly surprised. I see Jersey Mikeys every where and will now think of it for a…read moresatisfying sandwich

Shortly after 12:00 EST on September 18th I ordered a regular sized club sub on wheat bread. It is…read morecustomary for me to split this sandwich with my partner and she is not a fan of the turkey so when we visit Jersey Mikes we request they put all the turkey on one half and all the ham on the other half. This has never been an issue for us until yesterday when reaching checkout and paying for my sandwich I was confronted by the self proclaimed district manager of Jersey mikes requiring me to pay for two sandwiches. The store staff had incorrectly made my request into two regular sandwiches one being turkey and one being ham (neither being an actual club sub.) At the time of this confrontation I had already completed the purchase and was simply waiting for the sandwich. I reiterated to the district manager and other restaurant staff my order was for one sub with no additional meat - simply split the way I had requested. The manager became aggressive, again reiterating that now I had to pay for two sandwiches because they did not follow directions. Since this was not right I refused and I was told to leave the store and that I was now "banned from Jersey Mikes" according to the district manager. He proceeded to insult and mumble unprofessionally with zero tact as I stood waiting to be refunded for the sandwich I was no longer going to be allowed to receive. We left and immediately went to a competitor sandwich provider down the street. I have been a Jersey mikes customer for years and never received such a terrible experience inside one of the shops. Deeply disappointing.

Photos
Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs
Jersey Mike's Subs

See all

Bubba's 33 - Patriot Burger*

Bubba's 33

4.1(52 reviews)
1.6 mi
•$$

This is what all the other scratch kitchens were trying to be…read more Bubba's Smash Burger - Fantastic burger. Perfectly cooked. Bubba's burger sauce is great. 5/5 stars. Shotgun Shrimp Po'Boy - This is the best item on the menu, and it's a must get. The shrimp is lightly breaded, and their shotgun sauce is sweet, savory, and a little spicy. 5/5 stars. Bubba's Lasagna - Everything you wanted the lasagna to be. Not greasy, good flavor, and the focaccia bread is artisan quality. 5/5 stars. Salmon - Good portion size but overcooked and dry. The garden rice was delicious, and the side of broccoli is steamed with garlic. 2/5 stars, mostly for the good sides. Creamy Chipotle Pasta - Very spicy and delicious. It's almost perfect but there's just something missing. 4.5/5 stars. Side Salad - If you don't like salad, this one will change your mind. Just get a side salad, cause it's pretty big. I attempted to recreate this at home, but it didn't come close. 5/5 stars. Spicy Italian Pizza - This one was forgettable. I don't remember a whole lot about it. I'd skip pizzas here. There's much, much better food on the menu. 3/5 stars. Blackberry Lemonade - I've tried the blue lemonade and the mango lemonade, but they both suck compared to the blackberry flavor. Just get the blackberry, and you'll be happy. 5/5 stars. We've been here 3 times. Every time the service is great, and the place is a bit loud cause the place is usually packed. No weird dances like Texas Roadhouse, but you won't miss it. Plenty of TVs to try and find something decent to watch. Go here, you won't be disappointed. Highly recommend.

Despite being very busy we were seated immediately. We did break our party of eight into two 4's…read more But we were in booths back to back. Waites was prompt and fortunately we ordered immediately. That proved to be a good choice because the kitchen went down shortly after. Our order was process but the other booth was not. So, while we were finished our other booth had not seen their main course yet. Our food was delicious. Everything is very tasty and fresh. Even the spinach dip. My California chicken was delicious, with just the right amount of lime. My wife ordered a tenders plate. It was all great. The reason for four stars? The consistency of the service was very questionable. We had children with us and their meal came out even before our drinks came. Then our appetizer came out late, just a few minutes before the main course. Server was very friendly. Food was delicious, I will be back.

Photos
Bubba's 33 - Inside

Inside

Bubba's 33 - 33 Deluxe pizza

33 Deluxe pizza

Bubba's 33 - Exotic margaritas

See all

Exotic margaritas

Elmo's Pizza and Subs - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...