Baked goods always good & it's a family run business for many years. Enjoy supporting this local business

The new owner is very friendly and accommodating, and his almond crescent cookies, eclairs [the real kind], cannoli, lemon bars, turnovers and PRICES are the best in the area. The place is a local treasure. read more

This is simply the BEST bakery I've been to in the US. They have a large selection of baked goods but also carry various meats and cheese and can do cakes and pizza to order. The best part about this place is the prices. $2 for a chocolate dipped almond horn (the best I've had since being Italy) is a STEAL! If you are jn town, you have to go. If your within an hr of this place, it's worth the drive! read more

See all

Hidden gem in Cortland . We loved it and highly recommend it! So much to choose from and everything we got was delicious!

Everything here is delicious. Can't go wrong with a sweet treat or pizza and wings. I recently tried the medium Stromboli it was the size of half the pizza box and was amazing! The owners are so sweet and kind. Just remember cash or check when you go here! read more

East Side Bakery - a pizza in a pizza box - Bakeries Near Me - Cortland, New York

The smoked pepperoni is excellent. The pastries and bread are also great. I can't comment on the pizza, but it looks good.

I was so excited by the yummy food and cheap prices I forgot to take pictures! Definitely a spot to go for a treat! Everything smelled so good. We got an eclair, an apple turnover, a lemon cookie and a half moon. It's been a challenge not to devour it all in one sitting. I look forward to coming back to try their homemade breakfast sausage! read more

Christine made the prettiest cupcakes for a co-worker who was retiring. She is so talented as well as everyone else who works there! Great small town family owned business. Highly recommend & everything they make is delicious :) Thanks again! read more

East Side Bakery - Chocolate cupcakes with traditional buttercream frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Cortland, New York

See all

Fresh sliced meats and cheese at crazy great prices? Wow!! Yes, yes and yes! I wanted to grab some fresh meat and cheese for sandwiches and my aunt suggested this place. I grabbed salami and provolone, freshly sliced on order. Then I grabbed a loaf of delicious italian bread and had them slice it for me also. It made for some great sandwhiches, small enough sized bread to not make full sandwiches but some great 4 or 5 bite sammies. Then we grabbed a few black and white cookies (at a great price also). Everything was delicious and they were the perfect solution to my hunger problem. read more

Best bakery in Central New York. Old school family owned Italian bakery...support local businesses! Slices are delicious and huge! Best Napoleon pastry I've ever had...always something new to try...I'm never disappointed and you won't be disappointed either. Friendly fast service. read more

My sister took me here and I went all the time once a week to get her favs on pay day. Almond crescent cookies shaped into a half moon. Half and half cookies were mine. All the treats and even different pastas to buy was great. Nice place variety. Even the pizza read more

One of the true Gems in Cortland NY. I cannot believe I am the first person to write a review about this fantastic bakery. They do pizza (order and pick up only) on Thursday and Friday nights, and it is fantastic. Sheet style, in either white garlic or regular. You can also get it by the slice some days for lunch, but hard to know when. Their desserts and bread are fantastic. My fiance is hooked on their macaroons. This is one of those places that once you go, you will wonder why you didn't know about it, and you'll think of reasons to go all the time. read more

I coordinated with the bakery to have a cake made for my gender reveal party. Christine was easy to communicate with and she made it very easy to arrange the cake, which was great because I live out of state and only made a trip to the area for the party. The cake turned out beautifully and was delicious. It was the center of my reveal party and I could not have asked for a better experience! Thank you! read more

East Side Bakery - Gender reveal cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cortland, New York

Christine's cookies, cupcakes and cakes are always delicious!! The bakery also sells homemade pasta and Italian meats and cheeses.

Two thumbs! We happened across this place a few years while visiting Cortland. We love it! Best bakery in central NY. The pastries are delicious. One of Cortland's finest institution. We stop every time we are in town and never disappointed. Can't say enough about them. read more

Whenever we are in Cortland from Binghamton we always stop to get your fresh bread. I also buy the pasta that you sell from the Utica Pasta Co. Alas, today being Sunday we had the spaghetti and didn't realize it until it was on the table that it was full of worms! Needless to sayeveryone lost their appetite, I just bought the pasta within a few weeks.You should contact the co, and let them know. I will continue to patronize your store. Ray & Joanne read more

Passing through Cortland after training and bought some treats for home. They not only have tempting baked goods but home made pasta and pepperoni. The chocolate dipped almond crescents and turnovers are great. I was not a fan of the apple square. The filling was a little thick read more

They Are The Very Best Bakery In Town And I Would Recommend Them Highly To All My Friends And Family Too

Excellent bakery! Wonderful family owned business. The owners are real hometown friendly people. They appreciate their customers andante them feel like family. The breads and baked goods are outstanding. Custom cakes for weddings birthdays or any occasion. They can do any design you can imagine and do it well!! Thursday and Friday from 4-7 they offer the most amazing pizza from fresh wholesome ingredients. Including their own homemade sausage. I am not a sausage fan and I love their sausage. On those nights they also offer antipasto and baked chicken wings with different flavorings. We love their hot buffalo wings with their homemade sauce. Great people great hometown bakery. read more

An outstanding family owned and run bakery. Pastries and bread are fresh daily and the prices are very very reasonable. Pizza and wing nights are outstanding, by far the best in Cortland. This tiny little bakery is a diamond in the rough read more

Visiting from Indiana and just happened upon this little delight. Ended up going back twice in our short stay. The Italian Bologna is absolutely wonderful. Even if you didn't like bologna you'd like this. Nothing like grocery store bologna. The smoothest texture and slices of WHOLE garlic cloves throughout! Pair this up with some Provolone and Pastrami on a round loaf of their Italian bread (fresh baked and only 3.00 a loaf! Unbelievable!) and you've got sandwiches so good you don't need condiments! While there check out their bakery sweets. No little brownies or danishes for these folks, they're as big as saucers!! And delicious! The prices are very reasonable which was a shock after eating elsewhere in New York. Friendly people and old world charm if I hadn't grown up in German town I would've wanted to grow up in little Italy just to shop here! Do you ship???? read more