Wasn't sure what to expect from this place, but since Sideliners took it over, I thought it was worth checking out. It's typical grill food and even though they didn't have beer cheese, I tried the pretzel sticks, which were pretty good, but didn't really care for The processed cheese spread. The kids macaroni look like Kraft, but the tater tots stole the show. They seemed fresh and light and not greasy and everyone seem to enjoy them. The Philly cheesesteak and Italian beef seem like deli meat. It wasn't bad but it wasn't great. Staff was super friendly and attentive and that was a plus. The patron seem to be regulars and they're very friendly country folks. There's an outdoor patio when it's not too hot and plenty of parking. read more

See all

Nice local casual pub, a little off the beaten path Front of the business is really nice. Rustic comfort with plenty of seating and TVs to watch sports. Slots available to keep you amused! It can get very LOUD if the juke is turned up to sonic boom levels & TVs are on & the crowd is large. Don't plan on talking with whoever you are with! Very friendly staff! Came back to check on us a few times. Menu has a good selection of items - burgers, chicken, brats, pizza etc. Gluten free buns and pizza crusts available. Fish fry on Fridays of course. Fries are awesome as are the tots and fried dill pickles. Huge BLT sandwiches! Menu features specials. Generous portions! Orders come up fast. Front of the business is neat and clean. The kitchen seems to need some work based on 7 health department violations they received in 2025. Hope this gets remedied as this is not an insignificant issue read more

See all

Great food, drinks, and awesome service. Love the family atmosphere! The staff are always welcoming.

We love this local place. So yummy and great atmosphere! The food is great. Fish fry is yummy! read more

The service was amazing on a Saturday night. The Gouda macaroni bites were amazing! Also the wonton mozzarella sticks were delicious. Then the bartender recommended the pepper jack wontons and wow, she was not wrong! Nachos were huge definitely shareable. Everything was amazing, highly recommend. read more

Our bartender was Autumn, she is the best bartender in Waukesha county! She is very attentive and always remembers your drink of choice! She alone is worth the drive to Eagle! read more

Stuffed mushrooms were huge and very excellent tasting. Best ever and enough for four people. Boneless wings were worth ordering

Great drinks and wonderful food! New owners trying to get the word out Very good SERVICE!!! Stop by and leave a review. Let the manager, Taylor, know what a good job she's doing! read more

Terrible service. Obviously they pander to their regulars and won't even bother if they don't know you.

Fun place to catch a burger with any Badger or Packer game. I've been here 3 times and the staff has been fantastic even when it's busy. A "featured"cocktail is available and usually creative. read more

This was the worst experience we have had at a restaurant ever!! The cook and the bartender were full of drama. The food was cold, the service was at a snails pace! The bartender disappeared with her dramatic drunk friends for a long while. The experience was completely awful. And they charged us full price!! Yikes! I don't even want to rent a canoe from this hellhole, never again. And we live in Eagle, I know where to avoid. Stay away. read more

This place used to have the best friday night fish fry around, and then they switched owners. The fish is horrible now. Other food was still pretty decent for awhile, but service went way down hill and is extremely terrible now. I used to eat here every week, and my last time in there was almost 2 years ago. Very sad as this place used to be packed because of their well known fish fry. Wont return read more

fish fry was terrible , the batter was burnt . sides are inedible, very disappointing,

If you want sassy service with a smile, great food and a friendly atmosphere: This is the place for you! Hands down, the best Bacon Double Cheeseburger in the area. Nice char on the meat, crisp bacon, fresh bread and two cheeses make for an incredible end to the day. My fiancee ordered the all-you-can-eat cod fish fry and we were pleasantly surprised by the quality and preparation. Choice of fried or baked (if I remember right). He ordered the fried. Nice plump pieces, crispy and clearly made to order. A nice little find! We'll definitely come back for more food and fun! read more

Friendly, upbeat and welcoming. Best dog water on ice bucket in WI. You don't need to be a local to enjoy.

I'm a huge fan of the Eagle Springs Pub fish fry - their cod is dipped in a light batter that fries up crispy, not that heavy and thick beer batter that a lot of other restaurants use. Along with the cod, their fish fry includes rye bread, fried pita chips (yum), applesauce (for dipping the pita chips), coleslaw, and various potato options. The fish fry is served on paper plates (get baked fish for a high-class glass plate). Don't worry about using your fingers to grab another piece of fish from the serving plate (it's our guilty pleasure). I've been going there for years, and 99% of the time the food is excellent. Their service is always very friendly and almost always very quick, once you get seated. Wait times on a Friday night can be up to an hour, but you can sit at the bar and have drinks while waiting. The restaurant gets really loud when packed. Eagle Springs Pub also has fish fries on Wednesdays if you want to eat without a wait. read more

Worst food I have had in a long time. Baked fish was served luke warm and was dry. Fried fish was over cooked and tough. Potato pancakes were burned. Waitress only said she would tell the cook. The restaurant itself was cold inside making it uncomfortable to dine. The drink was a good pour but not made to order. Hadn't been there in years and have zero desire to go back. read more

A group of us really enjoy Eagle Springs Pub! Excellent fish fry, love the sides and great selection of beers!

On Friday a group of 7 adults went to Eagle Springs Pub between 6:00 and 6:30 PM. We were told that we needed a reservation. It's very unusual for a casual pub to require a reservation on Fri night. We asked how long of a wait? We had 3 different employees each tell us a different wait time from 45min to 2 hours. They settled for 1 hour. We decided to stay and wait on the deck with a drink. The host ( Hunter) was trying his best to accommodate us. He came out later and we told him we would be willing to sit at 2 different tables if that helped. After approx.an hour went by , he came on the deck and told us that another server gave our table away so it would be a longer wait. At that time, we were understandably disgusted and decided to leave. Eagle Springs Pub needs to stop taking reservations and have one person handle the wait list. The manager needs an attitude adjustment as well. read more

Been there a few times this past summer. Service and food has either been very good, or very bad. They need to be more consistent on the good. Staff is attentive, but seem to get overwhelmed when busy. I think they may be on a learning curve, I would recommend them, but hopefully they improve. Bloody Mary's are great, except when the old guy bartender makes them. He definitely needs some schooling. Don't even bother ordering one if he's working. read more

Tonight enjoyed a steak sandwich with some great tater tots. Delicious! We get the Joe & Susie pizza often. Consistent food quality from a great little place. read more

No lights in in the parking lot. We thought it was closed - wish it had been. Came here for a fish fry. The noise inside was terrible, waitress was nice but the very small paper plates were oft putting - paper? Really? For $3 dollars less we could have had great fish in a nice place (Fox and Hounds) with real dishes. Fish was TERRIBLE. Certainly didn't order seconds - what we couldn't eat we brought home for our dog, who sniffed it and walked away. Smart dog. Don't know what the other food might be like and will NEVER find out. read more

This place used to be awesome. It is no longer awesome. The burgers we had were very tasty, but the pub chips were terrible, and the fries tasted like they had been cooked in old oil. That is the good news. The bad news is that the bartender is also the waiter. This means people have to wait to get their drinks AND their food and not everyone gets the attention they deserve. We had 6 people in our group and the bill came with a 20% tip included. Honestly I would have never given our server a 20% tip on the service we got. They might as well just turn it into a pub only and not serve food. At least the bar patrons might not have to wait for their stuff. I am pretty sure I will not return. This is a real shame because we used to always bring out of towners here. NO MORE! read more

Friendly staff, delicious food and canoes for rent when you want to work off the delicious sweet potato fries!

My extended family went after the Fourth of July Parade for an early dinner. The food was very subpar. The sandwich buns were burnt on all the sandwiches and ingredients that were supposedly on the meals (tartar sauce and BBQ sauce) were not on the food. Very disappointed since we were there for fish fry months earlier and were happy about the food. read more

New management/ cook changed the menu and it is awful. We used to go here every other week but not any longer, food is very bland. There used to be a line out the door on Fridays, however, the first and last time we tried the fish under the new management we were seated immediately at 6pm on a Friday. The staff is friendly enough but nothing memorable. The new management does seem to want to expand their business and make it more of a bar setting. In which case, I believe they'd profit from decreasing their menu to more of a "bar" menu. read more

This place was awesome! Went here to rent a canoe but came back after to eat. Delicious food and timely service. I strongly recommend the California burger and onion shreds. read more

Completely disappointed. Brought my friend and his children ages 9 and 12 out to eat. Came about 830 and the place was pretty empty. Had Very rude waitress and when the kids went to shoot darts we were told they could not due to the inconvienence of the staff having to walk around the table. ALso were told that the darts were only for people over the age of 18 and not until after 10pm. Now this was not posted, and my friend and his children have been there once a week in prior weeks doing just this. I asked to speak to the owner, who was also rude and wouldn't make eye contact after I questioned these things and made the simple statement of the fact that my friend was just trying to enjoy an evening with his children after they had eaten. We will NOT ever walk in the place again, and I will continue to share this horrid service with other people that ask where a good place to eat it. This place is NOT it. read more

Very nice atmosphere. Had to wait to get a table about 30 minutes which is fine because this means the food is good and lots of people come in to enjoy. Our waitress was great! The only downfall was the fish was a bit bland for our taste, but we understand they produce for the masses and it was right for the price. read more

POOR... very VERY POOR! . I see it's under new ownership... at least the inside is clean. We're new faces to the new owners & they don't talk to you much = BAD! It's not like we're new customers, we've been there 1/2 dozen times in the past. Always had a fine time. . One thing "I HATE" the most is being overcharged. Menu states a basket of fries is $3.99, I was charged $6.00. One beer $6? One mixed drink, $6? YOU BEST DEEP 6 THIS PLACE. We will PASS THIS PLACE UP from now on. . BTW: IF you're going to gouge your customers, DO NOT expect to stay in business very long. . read more

What's not worth putting up with is being scolded by the server who brought our food (not the one who cheerfully took our order ) because we ordered a combo of sides instead of each of us selecting our own side. The server told us 'just so you know, we're letting you have it this time, but combo baskets are for groups because otherwise there is too much waste'. There were only two of us, you see. Mind you, they CHARGED us for the combo basket, even though had we been a party of 4 there would be no extra charge. So we got charged for a menu option that was supposed to be free and scolded about having ordered it. read more

Yummy family style all you can eat fish fry. The wait is usually long on Friday's but it is worth it. Staff has always been friendly.

Oh so sad, under new management and it's really gone downhill. Service was slow, the hostess there was the most clueless hostess I've ever encountered in my life, literally... and the food was nowhere near as good as it used to be. Very hard fries and burned burgers my children wouldn't eat much.. and the fish was chewy and bland. I knew something was up when there wasn't a packed house on a Friday night like there used to be. It's too bad. This used to be a gem. read more

After years, changed owners. Fish fry recipe changed. Fish was warm when served. Fries & shredded onions both soggy. Fried appetizer platter was awful. Was told is coming off menu. Owner removed appetizers from tab, apologized and gave us piece of éclair. Not going back. Save your $$ & go elsewhere. read more

It's a pub - but with limited selection of beers on tap. Food is served in plastic baskets. The salad had greens that weren't fresh. The service was pleasant, but the food left something to be desired. read more

The food is decent, especially the paninis which are friggin sweet. The variety of the food keeps you on your toes, but the best part is the super sexy cook in the back. Gotta love when handsome guys make your food! read more

Stopped in for lunch and everything was great. Service was awesome and made you feel at home. Very friendly and recommended some of the popular items and was spot on. Tons of choices and will have to stop back next time through. read more

I usually do not write reviews. However, I do not want others to be misled. I used to go there all the time before the new restoration was done. I cannot believe how poor the new fish fry is! Grease, grease, grease! I also watched other orders come from the kitchen. It did not matter if it was a hamburger, fries, onion rings, the place is a heart attack location! The worst thing is, I read positive reviews so a made the 45 minute drive! What a disappointment! read more