(A True WNY Gem: Exceptional Food and Unmatched Hospitality)
We have had Dudley Catering Co. provide food for us numerous times, and we have always loved it. So, we decided to enjoy their dine-in space at Elk Lodge #234 in Niagara Falls.
I thought so highly of their dine-in service that I felt compelled to create a Yelp account to share this review.
If you are looking for a place that captures the true heart of Western New York dining, look no further than Dudley Catering Co. Operating out of the Elk Lodge, the space has the familiar, welcoming vibe of a cozy corner bar with a great dining space--something anyone from the Buffalo area will immediately appreciate. They offer a solid standard menu alongside weekly dinner specials, keeping things fresh and exciting.
We started our meal with a couple of appetizers. My wife ordered the soup flight, selecting the Steak in the Grass, Creamy Chicken & Broccoli, and the Butternut Squash Bisque. She enjoyed all of them, but the squash bisque was her absolute favorite. I decided to try their wings, and honestly, they hold up to the absolute best I've had in the area--perfectly crispy with a delicious sauce.
For our entrees, my wife had the Alfredo with beef tips, which she thoroughly enjoyed. I went with the beer-battered fish fry, served with fries and coleslaw. The fish fry was simply amazing! So many restaurants over-batter their fish, but Dudley gets the ratio just right. I also have to give a special shout-out to the slaw; it was such a standout that I genuinely wish I could make mine as good as theirs.
We finished off our night by taking home a slice of their homemade Dark Chocolate Oreo Pudding Pie to share. Like all of their desserts, it is made from scratch, and it was absolute dynamite!
However, what makes this place truly special--even beyond the excellent food--is the immense heart the owners put into it. I mentioned to April that I have SIBO, which makes my dietary choices quite restrictive. Within minutes, the chef, Johnathon, came out to our table to personally review ingredient lists for items we had initially selected, walk me through the menu, and even offer to make specific modifications to accommodate my needs. I have been to many restaurants where I've mentioned my SIBO, and this is the very first time a chef has taken the time and care to do so.
I highly recommend Dudley Catering Co. It is exactly the kind of hidden gem that makes the Buffalo and Niagara Falls area so incredibly special. read more