Homemade pasta- we had the Olivia with Chicken and the Bourbon Brown Butter pasta with steak. Very fresh and amazing flavor. Great service as well! read more

Cute little place with very friendly staff. I had a turkey cranberry sandwich. I am not a fan of hot turkey sandwiches, so would have preferred it cold, but didn't think to ask. It was still very good. The homemade chips were good, but a bit over seasoned. The hubs got the tuna salad on English muffins. He said the tuna was excellent, but the muffins should have been toasted. His onion rings were phenomenal. Highly recommend getting them! read more

The wife and I had a little date night for dessert at Dorsey's. The wife and I shared one of their holiday desserts and I think it was called the hot cocoa spice cake. It was delicious and it looks like a cup of hot cocoa with marshmallows and the cup was made out of cake. You can eat the cup! It was so cool! Dorsey's is always great with occasional live music and always excellent staff and service! We love coming here! If you have a chance to stop by you should! read more

Dorsey's Cafe - The hot cocoa spice cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

This place is ADORABLE! Had the fish fry and burger. A Service was A. Everyone was SO nice and welcoming! Cedarburg at its best! Ambiance is so cute. Like a market/cafe/bar Homemade desserts and the BEST fish fry I have had in a while!! read more

See all

Cute place. Scone was awesome - friend totally loved her sandwich. Mine was not very good. Kind of a mess. But that could be more my issue. Staff was nice. They have a big take out area with lots of meals ready to be picked up and made at home. read more

Dorsey's Cafe - Had a seat by the window! - Bakeries Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

Amazing lunch spot and exceptional customer service!! The chicken salad wrap and mushroom Swiss burger were amazing. Also loved the spicy/sweet watermelon appetizer. Cute cafe inside and optional outdoor seating. The ramp to go inside and the large bathrooms were accommodating for my mother who is walker-dependent. This also might be the only place in Cedarburg that allows dogs outside.....! Keep that in mind. read more

See all

If you have not had their spaghetti and meat balls - Polpetta Al Sugu - you need to! Absolutely delicious! The chef told us it's his grandmother's recipe. Too good to miss. read more

Their lunch and Friday fish fry are amazing! The soups are homemade and delicious each time I have come. Alison is always cheerful and helpful with menu selections! read more

Excellent lunch spot in beautiful downtown Cedarburg. We had the Apple Turkey and Sicilian Steak sandwiches and they were both incredible. Many great gluten free and dairy free options. The staff was very friendly and the restaurant was clean. Perfect for dine in or takeout. read more

The food here is amazing and the place is very clean. Love the freezer options for an easy dinner. The deserts and market items are also delicious read more

Cute place to grab some lunch. Laid back vibe, tasty sandwiches but my favorite were the fries and dirt cake.

So good, friendly staff and amazingly fresh. Not ostentatious from outside and only had walked past many times before. Big and bright inside and absolutely worth checking out - great menu with plenty of options for full meal. read more

The food was wonderful! Everything came out timely, hot, flavorful. Service was great, everyone very friendly. I'm glad I discovered this gem read more

Dorsey's Cafe - Cranberry Turkey and Lemon Chicken Soup - Bakeries Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

We received several of the prepared meals when our family was ill. They are easy to warm up and very tasty homestyle meals. It was such a thoughtful gift and now we will be stopping in to make sure we have several in the freezer from now on. read more

WOW!!!! The Food was magnificent and they had a lot of Gluten-free options for my wife. Best Chips I've ever had, definitely a lunch place worth stopping. read more

We love the weekly Friday fish dinners as well as the frozen soups and gluten free bakery items- it feels like home cooking away from home.

We had 3 separate options. Tuna Melt, Burger, chicken apple salad sandwiches. We had chips and chili as our sides. The portion of chili (cup) was tiny but tasty. read more

This is our go to place for fish fry. The breading is very unique and nothing like we've can find from any other restaurant. Their deserts are top notch too. I've never been disappointed. The owners and staff are always friendly and remember the regulars. read more

I think this place is having an identity crisis. It used to be local small joint, but has recently expanded into the neighboring space. It's kind of hard to figure out where to go, to get seated or if you want food to-go. We actually ended up having to ask how to order food, even though were were standing awkwardly looking around for 5 minutes. The food came out fast enough, that we didn't need to sit. It was what i would call a top grade homemade sandwich, not restaurant quality but very good. The bar, with out about 6 seats, is in the middle of the room now, which is kind of awkward. read more

Fantastic! We purchased a home in Cedarburg and went to visit the local businesses. This place is outstanding! I will be visiting all the time!!! read more

Really befuddled by some of these negative reviews. The service was exemplary. Incredibly friendly, sensitive to their customers' needs, and prompt. The fish fry is fantastic. Forget all the naysayers below and give this place a try. read more

The worst experience I have ever had. Incredibly rude and unaccommodating. I have Never had such an awe full experience. One would think they don't like customers. read more

Overpriced, marginal food (have to make your own sandwich) worst cappuccino I've ever had- tasted burnt, awful. I'm sure there are better spots in downtown Cedarburg read more

So I had fallen in love with the new fish place down on Mequon Road, but yesterday I was disheveled and needed food quickly. So I went back to Settlers Inn for my fish fry favorite - Cod. I'm sorry I cheated with that beer battered cod fried in oil at the new place. It was gooey inside and the batter kept pulling away from the fish, leaving me with shreds. Your cod fillets were golden brown, plump and coated with a light breading. Your tarter sauce and coleslaw are superior. The small roll? Divine. Next time I'll order a dozen. And the choice of side? Oh my! Better than french fried potatoes any time. I had the German Potato Salad. I often eat inside and took the time to restock my freezer with chicken pot pies. So good to know I don't have to dress up for a date when I can drop in on an old friend!!!!! read more

Thought it was an iffy place, but meeting husband's cousin. Fried fish was over cooked, dried up and inedible. Pasta salad was not good at all. I did not want to make a fuss with cousin there. After he left, I went to the register, told woman that it was inedible fish. She grabbed it, angrily shouted those people over there said it was the best they ever had. Then she huffily walked away. No apology given. No offer of refund. What a waste of money. Just sucking tourists in. Zero , that is o , stars. Horrible food, horrible people. No lights in hall to restrooms. Do not patronize this mess. read more

Quaint town, quaint building that settlers is in. However, that was about it. We should have taken the hint when hardly anyone was in there. We came around 10:00 am for breakfast. I got an over grilled egg bacon sandwich And my husband had an over grilled chorizo burrito, but hey- the orange garnish I was good, and they did make a killer white chocolate mocha. read more

We saw that this place had gluten-free options so we decided to try it despite seeing some negative reviews on Yelp. I have to say, the negative reviews on here are totally unfair, and I recommend disregarding them--they mostly have to do with people not liking the change when they remodeled. On the contrary, we found the atmosphere to be bright and pleasant, and the service to be friendly and helpful. We didn't find it confusing at all to figure out where or how to order. They have an area at the back with menus in wire baskets, and a counter that is clearly the place to order. Someone greeted us right away and let us know to let him know when we're ready. After ordering, we got a number and found a table (this is pretty standard for many restaurants). Our food came quickly after that. My husband and I shared a peppercorn beef sandwich on gluten-free bread with homemade potato chips. It was all delicious and a good portion. Really liked the chips! We were glad we came here for lunch and hope this place does well. We are from out of town but we would definitely return if we come back to Cedarburg. read more

This is one of the worst dining experiences in Cedarburg. First there are several other...... no countless other restaurants in Cedarburg that are all around better. Often dirty, bad service, food under or over cooked. Nothing to stand out. I have t A three strike rule about restaurants and on strike two I said never again. My burger could have been dropped at center ice for an ice dogs face off. read more

We have nothing but positive things to say about this homestyle restaurant. It's a gem here in Cedarburg. Their pies let me tell you are absolutely amazing. The Blackberry Sour Cream, Blueberry, Strawberry Rhubarb are the pies we have tried and have been pleased. We are excited to try more. As far as lunch goes we've had the cranberry turkey sandwich and the pastrami Ruben. Sooooo soooo good!! Our kids love the mini cupcake surprise that comes in their kids meals. Their frozen dinner section is amazing and makes those stressful busy days a little easier when you can go grab meatloaf or a pot pie and so much more to choose from that is ready to throw in the oven for your family. I'd highly recommend this as a must stop in Cedarburg. read more

Dorsey's Cafe - a sandwich and a cup of soup - Bakeries Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

See all

I picked up some frozen prepared meals from their self serve area. I was pleasantly surprised how good they were and my family also enjoyed. Anytime I've tried this from other places I've been disappointed. I feel the price is mostly justified when figuring the time saved. I will definitely continue to pick up their prepared meals, so glad I tried it. Highly recommend read more

We did take out in this Covid-19 world. Not cheap but food quality was high. Napkins and utensils would have been a plus. The owner's attitude though is a detraction. There is a reason why the Stilt House is always full/busy and Settlers Inn is always empty looking. Make it about your customer, not about you. we might try it again but unlikely and that is all because of the service experience. read more

Loved the pastrami Reuben - nice homemade foods and caring owners. Come for the tasty soups and excellent sandwiches! read more

Enthusiastic prices for a school cafeteria atmosphere. Food claimed homemade but bun on "chicken burger" would be beaten by any supermarket bakery. Why no chicken breast sandwich? Ground chicken? Ick. read more

It's not that we ignore the charm and the welcoming air of an establishment that has been around since before the turn of the century in the heart of middle America, Cedarburg, WI. Despite it's charm, our reason for the less-than-stellar review comes down to actually being welcomed. Aside from mediocre food, there was little attention paid to us and even less care given the menu. We're not trying to be harsh, but there is something to be said about not paying $10 for what we can make at home, sometimes better, for $8 worth of food. Okay, most of the time better. read more

I have been stopping at Settler's Inn for many years. I am surprised by the lack of reviews. It is surprising because a) it is NEVER empty; b) it has stood the test of time thanks to its food and influx of patrons. There is a lot of history (and conversations of ole) that haunt its confines. Those that enter its doors are stepping into a sarsaparilla time machine. The waitstaff can provide spotty service, depending on their mood ("Do not use the bathroom if you are not dining here." You may be told this upon entering by the manager/owner, even if you are there to eat.). My 4-stars are bestowed because of the food. I know my meal will be homey and warming. Everything tastes fresh and hearty. I enjoy a homecooked meal, and the walls of the Settler's Inn deliver that feel. They have homemade soups and pies to start and end your meal. Whether your starch of choice is a roll or their special house potato wedges, they prove the perfect match to your soup, salad, sandwich, burger, or panini. I often go with a wrap, but I went with my longing for a hot bowl of soup. Today was vegetable dumpling and crab bisque. I went with the dumpling dish and was pleased. The veggies stood up to the dense but pillowy texture of the dumplings. My fellow diners chose soup as well, another veg and the other a cup of bisque. The bisque also went with a monster salad (all of the salads come in size XL), the Southwest Chicken. Their salads consist of generous ingredients and healthy-looking greens. The only odd element with the SW salad was the dressing. It looked much like ketchup swirled in mayo, but was actually salsa in a ranch dressing. I tasted a bite of the dressing on a piece of romaine, and it tasted like it looked: unusual. That was the only minus. Otherwise, the meal and the service were superb. I make a plea to the many shoppers [and Yelp members] along the main drag to stop here--except Sunday & Monday, when they are closed AND before 2:00 p.m. on the other days. My real plea is to Yelp about it afterward. Share with the community, and let them know what they are missing. read more

Dorsey's Cafe - the bar of yesteryear, beautifully preserved - Bakeries Near Me - Cedarburg, Wisconsin

An amazing gluten free menu, that includes nearly all the items on the regular menu. Had the salmon BLT, and loved it. Casual, family atmosphere. I recommend sitting around the corner at the high tables if you're on a date or are alone, beautiful view of Cedarberg streets. read more

They ruined what was a nice little soup and sandwich place. They turned this into another over-priced fake "original" Cedarburg establishment that is far from original. There is no service as you have to stand at the front counter and wait to order. The food is incredibly bland and incredibly over-priced. read more

To be fair, I cannot comment on the food of this establishment, quite frankly, because before I ever had a chance to order, the poor, unfriendly and arrogant attitude of the woman behind the counter drove us to leave. However, the gentleman that works there was outgoing and friendly and greeted us with a cherry Hello and a smile. Seems like a very nice guy. I feel badly that he has work with such an arrogant woman. I feel even worse for him if it is his wife. Upon entering the restaurant, without even as much as a hello or a smile from the female staff, she simply said:"The menus are over there, if you want to make an order, come here by the counter and place your order" No smile, no cheerful greeting no hello how are you. Just arrogance. So we picked up the menus and the selections for breakfast looked decent. And since I choose to eat a low cholesterol diet, I asked her if she had Egg-Beaters or Egg-Substitute. The answer was an abrupt and unfriendly No. So I continued to go on and said further:"Can you make my eggs with egg whites?" After a strange look from the female, like what the hell are you talking about, she said NO, we cannot do that either. She went on to say all of our eggs are premixed. I went on to say:"So you're telling me that you are in the dining service and you're not willing and it is too much to expect of you to crack a few eggs open for a customer to accommodate them?" She stood there with no response what so ever with a dumbfounded look on her face and amazement. Almost as if though she were thinking in her mind "How dare you ask me to do such a thing!" All I could do is roll my eyes in disgust. I mean, "C' mon people. You're running a restaurant and you're a proprietor and your to frikkin lazy or don't know how to crack three or four eggs in half and do not know how to separate the egg white from the Yolk?" GIVE ME A BREAK In my opinion, not a place that will be around too long. Not only that, but 99% of all restaurants all over serve eggbeaters as an alternative or are willing to make egg white dishes for the customers. I give this place a complete thumbs down. My advice to the establishment; Learn how to accommodate your potential customers.No wonder the place was dead and nobody was in there. With service like this who would want to be. So we ended up someplace else with fabulous food and fabulous service. Do not go here. read more

Worst restaurant ever. The staff did not want to be there. They looked soooo miserable. It took forever to get our food and it really sucked. The fries were so greasy, we just left them. Atmosphere a real woofer. Place needs updated badly. The hours that this restaurant keeps are odd too. We'll never go back. read more

I was in Cedarburg last month and had breakfast at Settlers Inn. While there I bought a container of their frozen Sloppy Joe offering. Had it for dinner tonight, it was outstanding. I know that Sloppy Joes are not as popular as they once were, but this offering is as good as my mom's. Local Cedarburg residents, you have an outstanding frozen food offering available to you. Encourage you to stop by Settlers Inn and pick up a container of their Sloppy Joe offering. read more