What an amazing hidden gem in Farmingdale! There aren't any signs in front of the restaurant, so the only way to spot it is by looking for the big Italian flag. Once I stepped inside, I was surprised at how lively this restaurant was during lunch. They had live music playing and every table was packed with people eating and singing. I did not expect this vibe in Long Island! I ordered the Margherita personal-sized pizza since they don't serve pizza by the slice. The pie was so good! The pizza and atmosphere at Dom's Pizza made me feel like I was back in Italy. The restaurant is also attached to a grocery store that carries many items that you can only find in Italy and other parts of Europe. Very cool pizzeria! I'll definitely be back with my friends! read more

Dom's Pizza - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

What a great find hidden in Farmingdale. If you go down the road past the Target entrance, you can easily miss this gem. It location is an industrial building with other businesses and no sign. The only way to know where to go is an Italian flag you can see from the road. The parking isn't the best since when it's busy there may not be a spot with its limited parking. Once you enter the doors the grocery market is straight in, but Dom's Pizza & Pasta is just to the right. The spot can probably handle 30-40 people at a time. There are several tables at which the staff will seat you. Their menu consists of salads, pasta, heroes, pizzas and sides. We got two pizzas and a pasta to share between three adults and a toddler. The quality of their food really shows. You can watch as they make the pizzas in the back. I liked that the pizza crust was crisp, thin and had a nice chew. It also was sturdy enough to hold the toppings without the slice falling apart. We got the fungi and the pesto pizzas. The pesto was the big winner for all of us. It had a nice ratio of sauce to cheese in each bite. I would get that one again next time. The pasta was made fresh as well we got the orecchiette, sausage and broccoli rabe. For drinks they have an assortment in the fridges on the left which do include some Italian brands as well. Service was good and we had a pleasant experience dining here. The only thing to keep in mind is that they are only open during lunch hours and close by 5pm. We will definitely be back again soon. read more

See all

Really great Neapolitan style pizza! Stopped in for lunch with a coworker yesterday (Thursday) and the place was packed. Thankfully, we were able to get a table. Many pizzas to chose from, as well as some pasta/hero options. We both went with a pizza because it seemed to be the specialty. Pizza itself was decently sized, made to order, came out quickly, and overall delicious! They also have a decent soda/beer selection. I had the al prosciutto pizza and it came with a very generous portion of prosciutto. The location is a bit hidden in an industrial spot. You enter through a small Italian grocery store and the pizza place is to the right. The place itself was a bit chaotic/server was overwhelmed so service was abrupt. It's sit down/table service (no ordering at a counter), but we were told the drinks were self-serve from the coolers (odd). We were also asked to leave the moment we paid our check so they could turn the table over. Despite the chaotic atmosphere/service, still highly recommend and I would still come back for the pizza, especially because you're guaranteed to be in and out very quickly which could be useful if you're in a time crunch. read more

Dom's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

One of the best, you'll think you're in Naples Italy, most authentic Neapolitan wood fired pizza on Long Island... great pasta dishes, fried chicken cutlets, and the best meatballs you've ever tasted. Gets very crowded for lunch, live Italian music it seems almost every day. This is one of my top favorites, highly recommend. read more

See all

My wife went to Dom's Pizza with friends and loved it wanted to take me to try. It's a little hard to find, there is no store front whit their name, only an Italian Flag outside to let you where it is. But many know of Dom's Pizza. Upon entering there is an Italian Food market where many items are in Italian. Many authentic items to choose from. Over to the right is the dining room. Small and basic but they have all you need. We ordered Cesar Salad and a Brick Oven Al Prosciutto Pizza and couple of sodas. Maria was or server, she was awesome working all the tables quickly since it's small dining area and there is usually a wait for tables at lunch time. Our food came extremely fast. Both the salad and pizza were very good. We enjoyed our meal and then then did some shopping in the market. This is gem to check out. read more

Forgot to take pictures but wanted to share my thoughts on this great pizza. The place is a little hard to find. It is the door at the right end of the building. No sign, looks like an industrial park. Inside is a little market that makes really good looking breads, and the pizza place. We sat and ordered the vodka margarita and the cup and char pepperoni. Both were really good. Crispy, charred crust and tasty pizza. My friend thought the pepperoni cups tasted a bit odd but they were good. Great balance of dough, cheese, and sauce. We also got a couple of the meatballs which were really nice. Not too dense. Hear their home made pasta's are very good, will try next time. read more

A hidden gem. Great food, fun atmosphere and it feels like a secret place to meet since there is no sign, no advertising just word of mouth can't wait to go back. Only negative is there is only one person serving and she is overwhelmed. read more

See all

First of all, thank you Glenn K, for the recommendation on the best Margherita pizza on Long Island today! Per my son, it is 75% the way to the one he had in Rome last month. He was so thrilled that he would not put down the pizza box and he cheered all way to home from Farmingdale. The pizza dough was soft and chewy. The sauce and the cheese had perfect ration. The prosciutto provided a great combination. The huge spinach sausage roll was too oily to my son's taste. But my husband loved it. He said he would go there himself ( which normally means the place is good). The size was quite generous! The service was wonderful! The young man (owner's son?) was very warm and sweet. He definitely had a high EQ and good people skill. Extremely street smart type. Another man also was so sweet and helpful. He went to print out a paper menu just for me since they didn't have to-go menu. A very homey sit-down family restaurant was right attached to the grocery area. People were very kind and genuine, exactly like how those in Rome. We loved that! It teleported us to Rome instantly. There are many special pizzas on the menu. We will be definitely a frequent visitors. read more

See all

Lunch date with my daughter, we always agree on seeking out great pizza. Classic NY, Neopolitan, Roman, all styles but nothing pedestrian. We sought out this "hidden" gem based on social media accounts. We came, we saw, we ate! And ..... we are adding Dom's to our top ten overall pizza lists and top 5 of Neopolitan style. I also tried the San Pellegrino Chinotto - reminiscent of a Negroni without alcohol. it paired well with the meal. read more

See all

Self proclaimed pizza snob here. I seriously bumbled onto this place by mistake. It's in an Italian grocery store I've started going to occasionally and looked over and saw folks sitting at a table. I honestly had no idea it was there. The place is very small, only a couple of tables, and they seem to only do pizza and a few sandwiches (I later found they have a small menu with other dishes, which I will definitely try). Well, pizza was for me so, I got one. It's not a slice place as they only do small pies. They are authentic Italian pizza makers like you'd find in Italy. Definitely hand made with all fresh ingredients...honestly, one of the best , most honest pizzas I've ever had! Freshness in every bite! Had to eat the whole thing in one sitting! People were nice and service was polite! Cannot wait to get another! read more

The pizza was delicious and the entrees even better! As an Italian I never get meatballs out, but I was told they were good and I tried them and they were so good. The eggplant rollatini was also delicious. The service is also always awesome. This place is a MUST try! read more

Fabulous old world style pizza. Amazing ambiance Italian music, fresh cheeses and pasta. A wonderful experience

The best kept secret in Long Island! This Restaurant / Italian Grocery Store has the best pizza outside Naples Italy! However it's totally hidden from the public!!! One can only find it through word of mouth. It has no sign, only an Italian flag in the front. The groceries are limited to the best Italian brands and locally sourced cold cuts (salame, sopressata, etc. I ordered a "Quattro Stagioni" pizza and to my surprise it had imported capers, olives, artichoke hearts, and prosciutto from Parma. All the other restaurants outside Italy use cheaper versions of the ingredients, they don't! It's also comforting to know that they sell the real authentic Italian Nutella (in a glass jar). The restaurant has a small dining room with a few tables and some pictures on the wall obviously people don't go there for the ambiance but for the food! The service is excellent and the waitress is fluent in Italian and English. read more

See all

Tiny place with a market. The restaurant sits maybe 25-30. Small tables. Very welcoming, like walking into someone's kitchen. The waitress was so friendly and accommodating. Someone was singing, similar to a small hangout, reminiscent of a Little Italy pizzeria. The boys were looking for a Naples style pizza, mushy in the center. They found it with the bufalo pizza. Just like in Naples. The sauce was flavorful and had depth. The bolognese pappardelle was absolutely delicious. Reminded us of Rome. Fresh pasta, meaty sauce. The sauce adheres to the pasta and isn't watery. Some Italian imported sodas were a plus! Next to the restaurant is their mini mart where they sell some of their fresh ingredients. We also found some imported limoncello candies and limonata sodas! They had large rice balls and fresh mozzarella made right there. The building isn't labeled. The parking lot was full, that's one way of finding it on the weekends, no other lot is full in the area. Best Southern Italian place we've found so far on Long Island. read more

Dom's Pizza - Bufalo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Farmingdale, New York

See all

5th time here. Food, service, and people are amazing. Everything is made on premises. Then I went shopping at the attached market. Homemade and imported items you can't get anywhere else. read more

10/10. No notes. If you're thinking about going here, just do it - and don't pass on the meatballs.

This place is located inside the warehouse of an Italian food importer. They serve Naples style pizz. The mozzarella is made fresh and many of the ingredients from the warehouse are utilized. Live singer currently on Tuesdays and Saturdays. Recommended. read more

Top of the line! Well worth the trip Very authentic pasta. A hidden gem Has pasta carbonara was a good as Naples! read more

I was here for the first time with some friends today. The food was superb. The waitress was awesome (and over worked). I will be back again. Loved this place! read more

The food was authentic Italian and everything was delicious. Pizza Pasta Salad and meatballs. We ordered with our eyes so we all have leftovers. Thank you for your hospitality and cool vibe. I'll be back lol read more

See all

we ate it today. My wife had a Bolognese and we had a pizza that we brought home with olives, artichoke prosciutto, and arugula. Everything was delicious. read more

Absolutely phenomenal pizza! Felt like I was in a tiny little market in Italy. Italian being spoken all around me, smells of everything. Wow. I cannot wait to go back! read more

Pizza was very good and the waitress was very pleasant. There was a person who sang to the diners. It is a popular place situated in an industrial area. read more

This place is excellent and very much authentic. The fresh pasta bolognese was delicious the pizza was awesome. Will be back.

Excellent Pizza , Neopolitan for sure (had the Margherita) burnt ring burn bubbles etc...but also a wonderful charred bottom, making for a Margherita whose slices you could pick up and bite into..VG mozz and sauce Also BYOB, meaning better and Cheaper..Tight hours check ahead read more

The food is amazing!!!!!! And they are sooo nice. I love coming here on a quick lunch date with my hubby during a work day!

Ignore the hype - nothing great about this place unless you want a pizzamaker that doesn't know what toppings belong to each specific choice of pizza. He's confused (or just "stunard" in Italian), so busy fooling around can't concentrate on making a very simple pizza & had to ask an employee what to include. There's no slices despite Google saying there are, only overpriced whole pizzas with burnt black dough bubbles. You also have a nose-picking pizzamaker, nasty fresh owner who thinks she's scaring you, plus an overpriced on-premises grocery. Don't waste your gas. read more