Any way you slice it, this is absolutely the best pizza in at least Colorado! The atmosphere is…read morechill and inviting, the owner is super nice and ultra-passionate about their Pizza. They also have a homemade Hot honey that is out of this world. Anybody traveling on I 70 in the Rocky Mountains should make a pitstop off of Highway 40 in Winter Park. It's well worth it!

After a great day on the mountain pizza sounded perfect...we popped in and had a great pie!!!!…read more We also picked the perfect time at about 3 o'clock... Because it wasn't terribly busy so we got our pizza pretty quick... Service was incredible. The place smells awesome and it was overall a fantastic day. A great selection of cocktails to go with your pizza is available.

Stopped in for a late lunch because I saw they had subs. I didn't know what I wanted initially and…read morethe lady that helped me was very patient. I had the Alina's cheesesteak sub and oh my! It was sooooo good. A bit spicy but wow you won't leave hungry or disappointed. They don't have a ton of seating so I wouldn't take a big group but a family of 4 shouldn't have a problem.

Great pizza & great service!! Food hot & awesome tasting, I would come back at least once a monthread more

I've been coming to Firefly Pizza frequently and have been giving them 5 stars since day one. As a…read morelocal, it's honestly refreshing to have a place like this in Grand Lake. Everything is consistently great, and it's become one of those places you're always happy to come back to. Most of my reviews have focused on how great the pizza is, but this time I have to give some love to the Caprese sandwich. Wow. Everything was so fresh, and the bread was toasted absolutely perfectly. Simple, fresh ingredients done right, and I honestly can't wait to have it again. I'm actually kind of sad that Firefly is heading out for the holiday season, but I'll definitely be first in line next spring when they're back. Until then, I'll just have to dream about that pizza and Caprese sandwich.

We came to town from Nebraska and ate at Firefly on our last night in Grand Lake. The pizza was…read morefabulous and staff was super friendly. Highly recommend trying the Firefly. Would be great for take out too!

Greetings While visiting beautiful Grand Lake we ate at…read moreGrand Pizza twice because it was so good. We ordered the large Antipasto salad and it was so fresh and crunchy. This is a big salad be warned. We ordered a 14 inch pizza the first visit and a 12 the second, these pies are well dressed with the toppings of your choosing and baked perfectly. The manager Kelsey was very nice,cheerful, attentive to her customers. Our server was also wonderful. The atmosphere is typical of a pizza restaurant but, I was there to eat and not critique their ambience. If you're in Grand Lake and hungry stop on in and enjoy.

This is a tricky one to rate. Yes, the pizza was very good, but the price for pizza felt a little…read morehigh, even considering the location. As I took our pizzas to go, I have no opinion about the service itself. Ordering at the front desk was easy enough. No issues there! From looking at the place, it is a bit small. Nothing too fancy. Honestly, seems a bit dingy. I was happy with our decision to take it to go so we could enjoy being outside on a great Grand Lake day. We got a cheese pizza (14", $21) and the pesto chicken specialty pizza (16", $36.70). Both were very tasty and not overly greasy. The dough is very soft with the appropriate amount of chew--very dangerous as it was so yummy! They didn't skimp on the toppings, too. So, overall, it is a very good pizza. The value proposition here, though, is tough. There's a sliding scale of pizza value, and I think this ends a bit on the expensive side, even when making considerations for location. At the same time, I do think this is the best pizza you can get in the area. You just don't have many, quality options in this area, so the lack of competition might be keeping the prices higher here (not to mention it being a mountain town). I would come back here after trying other food in town.

In such a quaint little area it is nice to have a little Subway action. We went here mid June so we…read moredid have the misfortune of being stuck behind an entire little league team plus their parents all ordering but the staff did a great job with the chaos. It is quite clear that there are some very fresh and young artists employed here so give 'em a break! I did have to have my sandwich re-wrapped by a bit more experienced employee as my footlong almost met its demise on the floor alas all was well.

Arrived in Winter Park about noon for Labor Day weekend 2023. We had a referral to try a restaurant…read moreup the street. It didn't open till 3 pm so we decided to get a Subway for lunch and come back later.Parking was hard, nothing close, as all the street spots were taken so we just kept walking.It was a hot afternoon and there was a commercial fan directly in front of the doorway inhibiting access. That should have been the sign to leave. As we stood in the line and ordered there were 2 young men smiling and trying to help. I gave my order and asked to have it toasted. That's when the over bearing owner or manager came in and started humiliating both of the workers in front of the customers.I was so shocked he would berate them in front of the public I didn't say anything to their defense. I don't usually post negative reviews but in this case maybe the manager can learn that is not the way to teach new workers.The worker asked the manager, who was filling in the food containers, for more bacon to complete the order.This is when the manager proceeded to tell the young man he needed to think in advance to request refills on the sandwich condiments in a condescending manner and included he might not be working there if he couldn't put the sandwiches together. The manager then took over the sandwich order so I told him I wanted it toasted... he then said to me with a smart attitude, "I can't toast it before I get it set up." Really? I was trying to bring him up to speed on the order, since he took over. I was heartbroken for the workers and feel horrible I didn't say anything. I then ordered a soft drink and the manager proceeded to tell me they had "no ice but it comes out of the tank cold." I didn't want the drink without ice and he told me 2 more times it would be cold. I said "I just didn't want a drink." The store was too hot so we went outside to eat the sandwich. The picnic tables and seats are made out of trex decking materials and we're extremely hot. Find another place to eat!This was a very unpleasant experience and wish I hadn't spent the $27 and just left. Just saw 2 reviews in October 2022 and very limited customer input. Looks like management has an issue. Bring your coupons.

Delicious pizzas and great drinks! Kristen and Rachel both…read moreprovided stellar service, and the pizzas we had (the White Buffalo and the Stampede) were absolutely loaded with toppings and had some of the best crust I've eaten in a while. I know it can be tricky to do a good dough in high elevation, and they nailed it. The other specialty pizzas all looked good too, I will definitely be back to try more!

When you pay $47 for a pizza, you expect it to be at least somewhat decent. I should have read the…read moreother reviews first because my experience was almost identical to theirs. I was told 15 to 20 minutes and arrived right at the 20 minute mark, but it was obvious the pizza had been sitting there much longer. It was served up ice cold. Even the dollops of ricotta tasted like they were added after the pizza was made, straight from the refrigerator. I am not exaggerating when I say ice cold, despite parts of the pizza being burnt. The edges of the crust were burnt, not in a good wood fired way with flavor, but just hard, overcooked, and inedible. While the toppings were generous, the pizza itself was extremely dry, just like others have mentioned. As I waited, I could see into the kitchen and noticed they were using pre made crusts, basically the kind you would grab at a grocery store when you do not feel like making your own. Charging $47 for that? No thanks. I hate wasting food, but we could not even finish this pizza. It was that bad. That is on me for not checking reviews beforehand. We should have just stuck with our usual spot, Grand Pizza, which happened to be closed for mud season. The difference in quality is night and day. I just want to warn others before they make the same mistake and waste their money like I did. Definitely will not be back.

Right when we're got there the ambiance was cozy and nice, the people friendly, and the food on…read moretables around looked amazing. There was a lot in our group and the server and bartender, owner? I don't know, but everyone was so thoughtful and sweet even though we had a large group, very kind and genuine. The drinks were stellar, the food did not disappoint. Breadsticks, pizza, gluten-free and regular. Amazing quality. Some in our group had sandwiches or salads and everyone loved it.

Way over expectations! Incredible find in Granby. Might just be the best dining option in Granby!…read more Super cozy, friendly and very good food. We loved the pizza - homemade Detroit style - and the salad. Excellent beer selection - and full bar. Weird that you enter through Backdoor - but makes the find all that much better. Go here when in Granby.

After an afternoon hike my husband and I wanted to have pizza at Toss based on a recommendation…read morefrom his PT. We lived that it was 15 degrees cooler here than in Boulder and we could sit outside. I got a table outside while my husband ordered the "pizza of the month" which was a Palisade Peach pizza with lemon ricotta, applewood smoked bacon and a balsamic drizzle with a hot sauce for this pizza. AMAZING! There were no leftovers! Fresh, interesting and a flavor explosion. We lap had the Olathe wood fired sweet corn and it was exceptional! The crisp, sweet corn and creamy sauce with Parmesan was a perfect start to our meal. I had a red wine and my husband had an NA beer. It was the perfect ending to a beautiful hike. We will be back for the pepperoni for sure! The line moved and the servers were friendly. They were really hustling with so many pizzas and salads to get out with smiles on their faces. Fabulous!

Industrial big restaurant/bar with small parking lot…read more Bacon egg cheese pizza was just meh Prosciutto pesto pizza was ok Meatball app was small but tasty