Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    DJay's Fish Fry

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    DJay's Fish Fry Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - DJay's Fish Fry

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 523 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Brothers Fish & Chips - Fish tostada

    Brothers Fish & Chips

    4.3(238 reviews)
    24.5 mi
    •$$

    To say this restaurant's location and exterior is unassuming is very much an understatement…read more Inside, it is beautiful and has a wonderful ambiance. It was most unusual that our party of four all ordered the same. We started with a special app - Fried Shrimp & Calamari. Soo Delish! We followed with the signature dish, Cod Fish & Chips. I have had this entree in, I'd estimate, 50 restaurants, including several in England where I think it originated. NONE even come close to here! Oh My - the two big, thick pieces of lightly battered fresh cod fried to perfection! Flaky, moist and delectable. It just doesn't get any better! Wow! The fresh, hand-cut thick fries were again fried to perfection. Golden crispy on the outside, moist and tender on the inside. I don't know what their secret frying technique is or the type of oil they use but the flavor is light and delicious. Even their homemade coleslaw tastes like they just made it - so fresh with a little tang - Mmm! We ended with a very unique lemon flan, even though we all said we couldn't eat another thing. Overall, portions are generous (we took home some left overs!), service staff were friendly and attentive, and the Owner & Head Chef, Elmer came out to check on us and tell us some of his culinary encounters with blue fin tuna. Fascinating! A most enjoyable meal and experience. If you've never been, What the heck are you waiting for!

    Fifty Five dollars for two fish and chips and a drink, not an alcoholic beverage and iced tea. They…read moretook advantage that food trucks were running out of food unlike they are counterparts who just closed down and waited for reinforcements on their lack of food. They decided to serve one piece of fish that wasn't a full fillet or crumbles of fish or in like my case half a fish cut in half that was fried hole. and roll their eyes when someone told them what was going on, I decided against it cause I really don't want somebody rolling their eyes. That means they're gonna probably spit in my food. Next disgusting completely disgusting they should be ashamed of themselves. I counted not even 12 fries on that plate for 55 $55 for two fish and chips and a drink which is $25 per fish and chip. That was highway. Robbery. Don't bother to attend this business. They don't care about their consumers I went to their actual store and they were disgusting as well. I gave them two stars now I'm telling you not even that star is worth it the extra one I should say.

    Photos
    Brothers Fish & Chips - Tequilas

    Tequilas

    Brothers Fish & Chips
    Brothers Fish & Chips - Jackie & her colleague were great hosts and mixologists We had strawberry pisco sours which were next level

    See all

    Jackie & her colleague were great hosts and mixologists We had strawberry pisco sours which were next level

    The Thistle Fish And Chips - Thistle's Original Fish & Chips

    The Thistle Fish And Chips

    4.3(135 reviews)
    48.0 mi
    •$$

    Really excellent fish and chips…read more I ordered the food to go and was worried my 20+ min trip would make the crispiness of the fish and chips be lost but it didn't. The food was fresh, batter was perfectly seasoned and crisp and the fish was soft and tender. It was good and possibly better than any fish and chips I had in the UK. The chips were also nice and crisp on the outside and fluffy inside. Service was very nice. The food definitely leaves you wanting more. I wish I had ordered more so I could be eating it now. I'll definitely be back! (FYI: I ordered the lunch portion which comes with one piece of fish. Also there's a 3% credit card fee.)

    The Thistle Fish & Chips is a small restaurant in Lyndhurst, NJ. There is NO OFF street parking…read more Curbside only. I had to wait 25 minutes for a space to open up. As you enter there is a small waiting area and an ordering counter. Staff were very nice, cheerful, & accommodating while I waited for my order to be cooked and packaged. I didn't look into the dining room since this was a take out order. PROS: Cleanliness appears to be high on their agenda. My order consisted of Fried Oyster dinner, Fish & Chips dinner, and a Fried Shrimp & Scallops dinner. All came with French Fries and Cole Slaw. They also provided plenty of tartar and cocktail sauce. Additionally they have Malt Vinegar which is a must, at least for me when eating fish and chips. The oysters were cooked to perfection, as were the shrimp and scallops. CONS: The fish fillet was undercooked and the coating saturated with oil. I don't think the fryer was hot enough. French Fries were soggy because the steam from the closed containers. Easily solved by putting in a frying pan to crisp them up. Coleslaw was okay. As for Pricing, they are quite high for portion served. $30.00 for 2 shrimp, 2 scallops and a mound of french fries is outrageous. I can get a full seafood platter at any decent diner or restaurant for this kind of money. I think I'll look elsewhere when I get my next craving for this type of cuisine.

    Photos
    The Thistle Fish And Chips
    The Thistle Fish And Chips - Old Bay Fries (well done) & Coleslaw

    Old Bay Fries (well done) & Coleslaw

    The Thistle Fish And Chips - Fried Oysters

    See all

    Fried Oysters

    Blu Pointe

    Blu Pointe

    3.8(745 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    •$$$

    Blu Pointe is one of those restaurants we always come back to, whether it's during the week or on…read morethe weekend. Between the delicious food, outstanding service, and breathtaking views of the Hudson River and the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge, it's always a great experience. The staff is consistently friendly, welcoming, and accommodating. The servers know the menu well and are happy to make recommendations, making every visit feel relaxed and enjoyable. One of our favorite times to visit is for their weekend brunch buffet, which offers a great variety of options. During the week, their Happy Hour (4-7 PM) is another favorite, especially the $1 oysters. It gets busy, so I definitely recommend arriving early. Just keep in mind that Happy Hour is available only in the bar and lounge area. The restaurant is clean, has a spacious parking lot shared with the neighboring restaurant, and offers a beautiful outdoor patio overlooking the river during the warmer months. The patio closes for the winter, but it's one of the best places to dine when the weather is nice. They also have a kids' menu, although my 6-year-old usually orders from the regular menu because she has a very adventurous palate. If you're looking for great seafood, excellent service, gorgeous waterfront views, and one of the best dining experiences in Newburgh, Blu Pointe is an easy recommendation. It's one of our favorite restaurants, and we always look forward to coming back.

    We chose this restaurant for our anniversary lunch. I was a little concerned after seeing mixed…read morereviews, but I was drawn in by the seafood-forward menu and the beautiful river views. We went for a late lunch and were pleasantly surprised by how attentive the service was. The setting alone is quiet, scenic, and relaxing, adding to the experience feeling special. We're particular about cocktails, and the specialty drinks leaned a bit sweet and light for our taste, but switching to a Grey Goose martini solved that quickly. The standout of the meal was the special appetizer, the Lobster Escargot. Between the bread service and the rich, bisque-like sauce layered over the classic preparation, I could have happily ended the meal right there. We left no trace behind. I followed with the crab cake and wedge salad. The crab cake was generously sized, very fresh, and exactly what I hoped for. My husband ordered the branzino, which was absolute perfection, beautifully cooked and full of flavor. The sides, however, were less memorable; the smashed potatoes and green beans felt under-seasoned and a bit boring compared to the rest of the meal. Overall, it was a lovely anniversary lunch with memorable dishes and a beautiful view.

    Photos
    Blu Pointe - Seating area

    Seating area

    Blu Pointe
    Blu Pointe - Blu Point is one of our favorite restaurants. It is satisfying in every aspect: service, scenery, and, of course, the food is exceptional.

    See all

    Blu Point is one of our favorite restaurants. It is satisfying in every aspect: service, scenery, and, of course, the food is exceptional.

    DJay's Fish Fry - seafood - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...