Dicola&#x27;s Pizza

334

405

3 years ago

Very, very average. The regular pizza had some very serious flop - almost doubled-over. The grandma's was much breadier than I am used to. Way to bready. Having said that, the flavor on both was very good. The sauce was just a hint sweet and the cheese had a nice flavor to it. If they just got the crust right, they would have something there. Good enough if you lived around the corner but wouldn't drive a long way to get there. read more

Dicola's Pizza - Bottom was well-baked but still floppy. - Pizza Near Me - Washington, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Natalya R.

2 years ago

Best tasting pizza in Washington NJ. The service is fast and staff are really friendly. I would recommend this place. It's small place but the pizza is the best. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Charles T.

445

1625

5 years ago

Wanted to update to add some photos and say i've been back twice since and it was excellent both times. read more

Dicola's Pizza - Sausage Slice - Pizza Near Me - Washington, New Jersey

Dicola's Pizza - Plain Pie - Pizza Near Me - Washington, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Veronica S.

106

4 years ago

Love the food from here. Especially their cheesesteaks!! Never a bad meal when you order from here and the staff are always terrific.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carrie D.

4 years ago

You feel like you've discovered a hidden gem every time you pick up a pie from them. Great crust, great sauce, beautiful melty cheesy deliciousness. I've heard others complain about the interaction on the phone. I'm not looking for an intimate relationship, I just want to enjoy their excellent pizza. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nancy G.

2 years ago

I really like this place. Friendly workers and the food is very good. My husband and I came from the east coast where pizzas are fantastic. When we tried their pizza it was like home. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Judith W.

2 years ago

Service was goodand people were friendly and very nice Cheesesteak was wonderful. The best I've had in years

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Thomas C.

190

5 years ago

Amazing pizza!!! Great food period that's what these reviews should be about. Shouldn't they? You care about a worthless mask THEN ORDER TAKEOUT YOU LOSERS AKA the schmucks ruining a good businesses reputation because you're sheep. Look now masks don't matter and you're worthless as of today 5-28-2021 just like the mask you want other people to wear. I live out of state and go out of my way to come here and hope to not see anyone wearing face diapers. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Evan L.

3 years ago

Was my go-to place growing up and have recently gotten back there when visiting my parents.... Great Cheeseteaks!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cindy H.

3 years ago

Went there for lunch today, closed?? No sign. Hours are that they open at 11am? We arrived close To noon?? read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Denise A.

3 years ago

Best pizza ever !!! cheese steak pizza is to die for!! Arrived fast and super hot. I can't wait to order again

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jacklyn K.

5 years ago

Not one single employee was wearing a mask. There were about 8 people behind the counter and it was very disappointing !!!

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tara R.

4 years ago

Fucking cheese is BIOdegradable lol never seen cheese that takes an eternity to chew!! For Jersey pizza it's more Koffin Slops Hopefully their business will go out soon!! Enzo's is right behind them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elizabeth N.

196

471

767

8 years ago

This is by far our favorite spot to grab pizza for our family. Located in the heart of Washington, DiColas is the hot spot in town that boasts amazing pizzas and area know cheesesteaks. This family owned an operated business offers free smells but don't hesitate to get your order in as everyone LOVES DiCola's! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Diana A.

212

158

12 years ago

Dicola's Pizza - Picking up my takeout! - Pizza Near Me - Washington, New Jersey

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Chip G.

3 years ago

The cheese steaks and meatball parm subs are phenomenal. All the food I've ever gotten was delicious. I would definitely recommend trying dinner here.Great quality and huge portions for the price. You'll be glad you did read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Greg H.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

203

363

1499

12 years ago

Try the cheesesteak! Everything here is excellent. Cheesesteak pizza is the best thing. This is the only pizza place I order from. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. read more

Dicola's Pizza - Cheesesteak Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Washington, New Jersey

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Rossaly G.

8 years ago

Awesome pizza came here for lunch and the pizza was amazing. Friendly staff & fast service! Great job guys. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Joseph M.

4 years ago

The toppings for their pies are just weird. The Buffalo was okay, but my tummy wasn't afterwards. Tread lightly.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jack Z.

5 years ago

I ordered the Margarita pizza and it was good. The pizza had a nice balance between the sauce, cheese, and basil. Other places don't have that balance, either the pizza had too much sauce and not enough cheese and vice versa. The service was really good. Like what other reviewers said, however, the staff didn't wear masks. Although it is concerning they didn't wear masks, I don't think it was frightening that they didn't wear them. I'm sure if they had COVID, they would not have worked there. Overall, I recommend this place and will come back. Next time, I'll order some subs. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

James F.

7 years ago

We loveeeeeeee the dinners and sandwiches but not a big fan of the plain round or square pies. So glad we found this place

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Mike S.

6 years ago

Love their roast beef sandwich, bread is excellent. Oddly enough I haven't tried the pizza.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steven S.

7 years ago

Great food here and prices, the pizza and the hot dishes are awesome also there are from my old school town Brooklyn

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Alyse R.

9 years ago

I've eaten here twice. The cheesesteak is amazing. And so is the cheesesteak pizza! I don't know how they do it. Its thick and delicious and cheesey but the crust stays nice and crispy. I can't believe it doesn't fold from the weight. Very good. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Charlie H.

4 years ago

Thank You so much for are lunch today. Are cheese steaks and fries were phenomenal. Such fast service also and customer service was excellent. thank you once again for such great service and i highly recommend Dicola's in Washington. thank you Lovevena read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Megan N.

5 years ago

Use to get food from here often. Went in there once Covid started and no one was wearing a mask. Not only were they not wearing it but making fun of people who do. I don't care if you don't want to wear a mask outside of the job, I don't agree but that's your choice, but when you are working in a cramped kitchen with food it's is absolutely disgusting to not wear a mask. If they do decide to wear mask while making food I would definitely get food from here again but until then it's a no for me. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Barbara J.

4 years ago

This is hands down the pest place in town!! I've lived here 27 years and they never disappoint. They have the BEST cheesesteaks and pizza I've ever had. Every single thing I've ever ordered has been absolutely delicious!! The owner and staff are so friendly. 10 out of 10 recommend!!! I can't say enough good things about them. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C. M.

6 years ago

Like the last few reviews said,... VERY off putting when you walk inside to get your food and 5 or more people cramped behind the counter don't have masks on. Pizza is good, but I'll be waiting until 2022 to go back. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alina B.

9 years ago

I love their honey mustard pie! The crust is delicious.. Only down side is that they aren't open Sunday's.. Other then that place is delicious & busy. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Chris B.

131

7 years ago

One of the best cheesesteaks I've ever heard. Pizza is damn good too. Love it. I've driven an hour to get it. With the trip.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Taste B.

4 years ago

Their chicken cheesesteak with onions and mushrooms is my favorite. The bread is fresh, not too greasy, flavorful and filling. I never finish a small. The family is polite and accommodating. Give yourself ample time when ordering Friday and Saturday. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Abby G.

159

6 years ago

*EMPLOYEES DONT WEAR MASKS* This place was recommended by a local since I'm new to the area. I genuinely like the pizza and I'm sure the other food is great as well. The service has never been a problem. However, since the pandemic started I've been very off-put by the lack of mask wearing by all staff. I mean really? You're in close quarters in a kitchen breathing on people's food, how have you gotten away with this for months now? All they have is a safety shield up at the register. I won't be going back until all of this is over or they actually follow the state mask mandate. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Michael D.

Elite 17

264

270

15 years ago

Pizza is good, lots of speciality pies, but seriously screw that. Buy a cheesesteak and get a free cheesegasm. Basically all i have to say is CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK, CHEESESTEAK PS - CHEESESTEAK read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Katherine L.

16 years ago

The ONLY decent pizza in the area! I don't know why it took us five years living here to try it. I more than recommend it, I insist that you get some (they deliver, too!) read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Wayne L.

5 years ago

This is by far the best pizza in the local area. Not only the best pizza but dinner meals, their garlic knots and sauce are the absolute best. I have never been disappointed with anything from DiCola's. Highly recommended!!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brian R.

7 years ago

This is a great option for pizza in the area. They have a delicious philly steak pizza!! The people there are very nice, as well.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ed I.

6 years ago

Food handlers behind the counter and delivery people do not where masks. This is the second and last time I eat anything from there for a while. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Tommy H.

13 years ago

Not just the best pizza within 20 miles.. But the best cheesesteak as well. Better than any cheesesteak you will find in philly. Try the honey mustard chicken pizza or the chicken bacon Ranch read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 3

See more reviews

More info about Dicola's Pizza

50 State Rt 31 N
Washington, NJ 07882
Directions
(908) 689-0250
Call Now

Full menu

Hours

What time does Dicola's Pizza open?

Dicola's Pizza opens at 11:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Dicola's Pizza close?

Dicola's Pizza is closed on Monday and Sunday.Dicola's Pizza closes at 9:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

Mon, Sun ClosedTue-Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Dicola's Pizza take credit cards?

Yes, Dicola's Pizza takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Dicola's Pizza have catering options?

Yes, Dicola's Pizza does have catering options.

Does Dicola's Pizza serve alcohol?

No, Dicola's Pizza does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Dicola's Pizza have TVs?

Yes, Dicola's Pizza has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Dicola's Pizza have bike parking?

Yes, Dicola's Pizza has bike parking.

Does Dicola's Pizza have outdoor seating?

Yes, Dicola's Pizza has outdoor seating options.

Does Dicola's Pizza have parking?

Yes, Dicola's Pizza has parking options. Private Lot Parking, Validated Parking

Other Amenities

Does Dicola's Pizza have free WiFi?

No, Dicola's Pizza does not have free WiFi.

Ask the Community - Dicola's Pizza

Review Highlights - Dicola's Pizza

“If your looking for pizza that's comparable to NYC and a cheesesteak that's comparable to Philly, you'll want this place.”

Mentioned in 17 reviews

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 2,463 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Mamma Maria

3.9(21 reviews)

2.6 mi

Food wasn't that good. The pepperoni was "bangin" but the rest was sub-par. The drunken Nona just…read morekept falling apart and lacked flavor. The mushroom was alright and the cheese was just too plain. The service was fine and the restaurant was nice on the inside though.

Staff is so kind to us, always. The atmosphere is calming & comforting. Our server is always so…read morenice and attentive whenever we go. My mother, her husband, and I have been coming here for years and are never left dissatisfied. Food tasted amazing! All of our entrees came with bread & salad (i love love loveee the bread here!)

Penne vodka (i drowned it in parmesan & red pepper lol)

Menu as of 12/28/2020

See all

Crave-worthy pizza!!!

Brother’s Restaurant Bar and Pizza

4.2(6 reviews)

1.1 mi

Beautiful restaurant with wonderful outdoor space. We opted to eat in the latter. The menu was…read moreextensive as was the wine list. The prices are on par with other local restaurants. The service was great except for one snafu with our server. The food was just ok. My onion rings were great but on the opposite end, the calamari left a lot to be desired. The special piña colada sangria was fun with the pineapple chunks & coconut but was it weak. Everyone else was satisfied with their meal so I hope this place has a good run.

Certain dishes are very good. The pizza is delicious. The servers are nice and it's enjoyable to…read moreeat inside. The chicken roll I cannot recommend. It was the most disappointing roll I've had- the equivalent of 1 chicken finger with 2 pounds of mozzarella. Based on the other dishes I've eaten here I had higher hopes for this one.

Patio out back. Really just a beautiful space.

Scallops Florentine with Mixed Vegetables

See all

The Smashed Olive

4.1(72 reviews)

1.4 mi

Went for an late lunch early dinner. Took my wife. It was festively decorated…read more We sat in a mostly uncrowded main dinner room, with a nicely adorned fireplace wall. Rich wood cladded horseshoe shaped soffit on the ceiling bringing the focus back to that sitting area. They started off with a complementary olive tapenade with pita bread. The bar staff took our order for drinks and also provided water. My wife had a chicken Saltumbucco dish & I had a seared salmon fillet in a bed of steamed spinach and lemons wine reduction bed of rice. Afterwards, I had a cappuccino. My wife abstained. The food was great. Very flavorful. The cappuccino was one of the better ones I have had. Thick foam with a hint of cinnamon and a flavorful espresso and milk. Will be going back here when next in town.

Always a good meal! The service was excellent. Every time we eat at the Smashed Olive we have food…read moreto take home, the portions are huge.

See all

Whipped Ricotta

Desiderio’s Pizza & Pasta

2.5(8 reviews)

1.5 mi

Really bad, expensive ! Flippant attitude from girl talking my order and money ! I will not be…read morereturning to this place

We've gotten takeout here a few times... tonight we were disgustingly disappointed. We've been…read moretrying to support local small businesses during the pandemic and I can promise we will never be customers here again. I called to complain that our garlic bread was burnt & practically inedible & our order of chicken fingers was pretty pathetic, not to mention our pizza was missing a topping. Didn't get an appropriate response form their staff at all. Got offered a store credit.... if my food is this disappointing and cold at delivery I'd rather just have a refund. Truly disappointing.

"Cheesy garlic bread"

Chicken fingers with fries.

See all

Gluten Free Margarita Pizza!!

Enzo's Pasta Grill

2.9(72 reviews)

1.2 mi

Good food and great service. I enjoy the creamy sausage and chicken dish. My family like the nachos.read more

Great Italian restaurant and bar. I like everything on the menu. Sit down bar, great serviceread more

Chicken from my pasta dish

Linguini with White Clam Sauce $14. Sauce was good but they could've added chopped clams in addition to clams in shell.

See all

Bar top is original.

Mario Pizza

5.0(1 review)

0.8 mi

By far the best chicken wings I've ever had. Not sure about the rest of the menu but I'll probably…read moregive it a shot one of these days.

Leo's Pizza Italian Restaraunt

2.4(63 reviews)

1.5 mi

Sunday, the family elected pizza for dinner, so we gave Leo's Pizza a call. We ordered a medium…read moreMargarita. The pizza was good, but it was the crust that made the pizza very good. We will reorder from Leo's again.

One of the best pizza joints in the area! Only reason for the none-5 stars is because they forgot…read moreone of the pies we ordered ahead of time so we had to wait an additional 20 minutes for it to get done and we didn't get any apology etc for the inconvenience. They should work on their customer service because the slices are great, but not sure if it's worth it if you have to deal with the staff. Besides that I really recommend the grandmas pie if you do end up coming here!

Pizza!

Chicken Parm Sub

See all

Grandmas pizza

Little Italy Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe

3.2(33 reviews)

2.8 mi

Great brick oven pizza place. Loved their fried calamari. Crispy and delicious. Service is far…read moreabove and seniors get 10% off everyday. Family centered pizza restaurant . Busy with delivery orders specifically on weekends. Ambiance is relaxing. Clean place and tidy. First time customer definitely will be back.

The shrimp cocktail was absolutely delicious. Big fresh shrimp with a delicious creamy cocktail…read moresauce.The zeppolies, on the other hand were a little bit hard and small.I like the old school pillowy zeppolies with a lot of powdered sugar.

Zeppolies

See all

Sal's Pizza

2.8(35 reviews)

0.3 mi

I tried Sal's Pizza once when I was in Washington. I tried a Sicilian Plain slice. I thought it was…read moreokay. It's an okay pizza place and it's fine if you want pizza in a pinch.

If I could give this place a 0 I would. I orders a plain slice of pizza to go opened the bag in the…read morecar took the slice out and the strong gross smell that came out of this pizza was crazy. I still decided to try it and I wish I didn't I spit it out couldn't get it out fast enough it was disgusting! The place inside is extremely outdated but I've been in places like this that can still put out good food unfortunately this was not one of those place I would never eat here again. I do not recommend as a matter of fact stay far far away! It's a shame they call this a pizzeria what a disgrace to the food. And it was so oily

Entrance

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

19 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Brittneh M.

273

7 years ago

Dicolas I'm twenty six and I remember meeting the family mom and Pa row funny Anthony and I was only like three years I met them when I was even younger when I was first born my dad was friends with them best friends and now obviously I know them very well but they are good people they made the best food ever and I wouldn't go to I don't I have gone to other pizza places but I have a like that but yeah definitely tried to call was if you haven't read more

Bonnie B.

12 years ago

We are new to the area. During our unpacking phase, my son searched for a place that delivered. We tried Dicola's. We've tried the cheesesteak, pizza, pasta dishes & grilled chicken over ceasar salad. All were excellent, delivery was prompt & the food arrived hot. The cheese steak is outrageous! Best ever! Prices are reasonable. Don't pass up this great restaurant! Bonnie Washington, NJ read more

Rodney F.

6 months ago

My roommate(who is from Washington originally) brought me a large pepperoni and mushroom all the way to Tennessee when coming back from visiting family there. Only because she knows how much I LOVE their pies! A huge thumbs up and highly recommended. BTW,2nd time she has done this...lol. read more

John T.

11 years ago

I will join the chorus here. The cheese steaks are crazy good. Ton of cheese. I recommend getting it without onions. (leave space for more steak!) Its a small store, tucked away on a side street off of 31. Worth hunting it out. read more

Mitch T.

13 years ago

Thanks to Dicola's for donating lunch for the firemen who participated in the fire prevention programs at the local schools today. Brass Castle School Good Sheppard It was greatly appreciated!!!!!! Assistant Chief Tobin read more

Matthew R.

1 year ago

The owner of this establishment told me that he denies God to my face. The owner also establishes discriminatory payment and lending practices between whites and blacks. read more

Meghan M.

13 years ago

the only place ill eat pizza anyone who writes a bad review about this place would be crazy or brain dead. the best bbq chicken pizza in the state!!!! read more

Patricia H.

12 years ago

These food is good but they are too busy for their location. On the weekends it could take over an hour to get a pizza. Cheesesteaks are the best read more

Dee W.

6 years ago

The cook is a PREDATOR!!! He assaulted me and another worker in the bathroom of the restaurant. Please do not support a child predator!

Connie Y.

102

4 years ago

Best pizza and sauce around lived in the area for almost 20 years cannot find anything better! Staff is amazing

Carol H.

13 years ago

Fanstastic! Small place but great pizza, cheesesteaks, & calzones...my family's three favorite things!

Destiny I.

10 years ago

The only place we go to for our pizza and cheese steaks! I highly recommend the buffalo steak pizza!

Chris J.

2 years ago

This is great pizza, especially the margarita pies, authentic Italian food, you cant go wrong!

Kassi G.

116

8 years ago

I have never been disappointed! My favorite is cheesesteak pizza! Would highly reccomend!

Jennifer C.

7 years ago

The phone girl is rude but the food is always pretty good. Pizza is the best around

Steve M.

11 years ago

Good people and great pizza!! its a Friday night tradition keep up the good work!

Eric C.

11 years ago

By far the best pizza in town!! It's the only place we go!

Cash D.

11 years ago

Excellent pizza, love this place! I am very impressed!

Bobby F.

13 years ago

Best Pizza Ever!!!

Dicola's Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Dicola's Pizza also viewed

Roma Pizza

4.1

(10 reviews)

Pizza and wings are good. Haven't tried too much other foods. Staff is friendly. Prices are fair.read more

Just giving a more up to date review- best pizza, wings, burgers and wraps around. Super clean,…read moregreat price and the staff is very kind and polite. A true gem spot to rely on.

Carini's Pizza, Pasta & More

3.9

(22 reviews)

I love the food there and The guy that works there is really nice. I always go there to relax and…read moreeat pizza.Its pretty calm too.

Cheesesteaks, cheesesteaks, cheesesteaks!!!!!! Yum, chicken or steak your choice on fresh in-house…read morebaked bread. Luv mine with onions, hot peppers and mushrooms. Fantastic!! Get yours the way you like it. The weekend is here. Get them hot and ready to take home or enjoy in our newly renovated dining room. Ready set go!!!!

Galasso's Cucina Italiana

3.9

(157 reviews)

Brooklyn pie pickup. Still one of the best pizzas. Seems to be the same even after the rumored…read morechange of ownership.

We haven't been here in a while. Stopped for a fast slice and sat inside at a table to eat. We…read moreboth had a margarita slice. The dough was so light and crispy. The taste of the sauce was excellent and it had the right amount of cheese on it. The staff at the counter were friendly. We will be returning to try something else.

Frank's Pizza and Italian Restaurant

4.3

(4 reviews)

Prices are fair, staff is nice, and overall the best pizza in town. Great place to grab slices or…read moresit down for a bit with family & friends.

Burnt pizza served. See pic. Yuck. I ordered a BBQ Chicken slice. The guy at the counter seemed to…read morebe on his phone and distracted. This burnt pizza is the result. They didn't offer to heat up another slice instead. THIS is what they served. Really?

Nicolosi's Pizza

3.9

(120 reviews)

I moved to the dump commonwealth 2 years ago (pa) haven't found good pizza since I tried them all…read moreover the free bridge. I was told this place is good but never got around too going until today. Really good pizza I wish I would have came here 2 years ago. Thank you to the owner ? For bringing me a plate and checking up on me after I took pie to go. Thank you for being good !

There are many, many more in the area I need to try still...but Nicolosi's in Phillipsburg is…read moreabsolutely at the top of my list for Sicilian slice now. They didn't have a pie made so I ordered a half. Good thing I did, no way I would have settled for only one slice anyway. Solid tasting sauce, they must be using Grande cheese, crispy crust with airy interior, the dough had good flavor ... just an overall Winner. This was closest to the Sicilian pies of my youth in Brooklyn than anywhere else I've tried out this way so far. Not saying that alone means it's better...just saying that is what I know and am used to so it hit a comfort spot for me for sure. Check them out if you haven't already. The half was in the ballpark of $16 for 6 slices. Certainly Didn't Suck!

Roman Pizza

4.3

(3 reviews)

Pizza is just OK, nothing special. Cheaper, greasy cheese, not enough sauce. Crust needed a…read morelittle bit of a crunch. First time here, so maybe it wasn't their best day. Might try another place before coming back. Plenty of street parking. Place looked clean. Four tables inside and a few outside on the porch area.

Used to visit them at their original location in Hackettstown until they closed due to rent…read moreincrease. Heard about the new location and yeah found him. Got myself a favorite pizza spot again. Had a fresh pie made. Great crust thin, like a cross between NY style and cracker wafer thin, no flop, airy firm. The sauce is just as it was, not as acidic like others in the area which is what we like. Quality cheese. Price is better than others in the Hackettstown, Washington area too. Our old go-to is back closer again!

Old Log Cabin Inn

3.2

(116 reviews)

Came back for pizza. It didn't disappoint. We ordered a white pizza with mushrooms, spinach and…read moreblack olives. It was delicious. We also ordered the fried mushrooms, they were disappointing, overcooked so it was basically just breading and small mushrooms. The place is kind of dark inside and choose your table wisely. We went to sit in the back corner but everything was sloped so we moved. Staff are super friendly and service was pretty quick.

Great pizza, cold beer, good wings. Love the antipasto with the diced pickles & pepperoni.read more

Cryan's Tavern

3.5

(212 reviews)

A throwback to the old days where Buffalo Wings , Beers and Football rule the day…read more Great wind selection and rated tops in Hunterdon County. The friendly service with a smile and the old bar ambiance make this a perfect place for Sunday football.

Whoo, boy. What an experience we had at Cryan's. I thought it would be okay to gather a group and…read morehead over for happy hour and dinner. Wasn't sure how many people we'd be, but the place looked big enough. It wasn't. Not for the crowds of people stuffing Cryan's on Saturday night, drinking at the bar, eating at the tables. Clinton doesn't have as many people as Cryan's did that night. Incredible. So we put our party down to a 40-minute wait. Time went on, a few people left, a few drinks happened, and finally the rest of us got a table together. Minus for service - the waitstaff was not very friendly to our group; granted, we were forced to stand due to lack of seating, but they didn't give us any helpful tips or any sympathy. Drinks were just "are you ready?" and then handed out. Food experience went a little bit better. The food itself was fine, mostly because none of us ordered pizza. It's bar pies here - super-thin crust, comes out crispy, which may be your thing but it's not mine. The onion rings look fantastic - huge, but with a lot of breading, and I didn't have enough of an appetite to down that by myself. I ended up on the Baslick Burger, ordered rare, and it actually came out pleasantly close to rare. Other people's came out to their order as well (medium and well, one with a subbed side). Nothing spectacular, but nothing bad. Same for the fries. All in all? It was an experience. But not one to walk into blind. Maybe if I was local I'd go on a low-volume night, otherwise I'll stick to some less crowded vibes.

Pronto's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.6

(29 reviews)

The service was good and the price of the food was great. The food (sub sandwiches) really lacked…read moreflavor. I would give the food a two.

This place is located in a Shop Rite shopping center so they get a lot of foot traffic. I've…read moreenjoyed salads and pizza from here in the past and most recently a chicken parm hero. It was very good with lots of cheese. I've never gotten entree's but I would definitely check it out sometime! The inside is a little dreary but hey, I wasn't expecting anything fancy anyway!

Joe's Pizza & Restaurant

4.5

(109 reviews)