Beautiful restaurant with wonderful outdoor space. We opted to eat in the latter. The menu was…read moreextensive as was the wine list. The prices are on par with other local restaurants. The service was great except for one snafu with our server. The food was just ok. My onion rings were great but on the opposite end, the calamari left a lot to be desired. The special piña colada sangria was fun with the pineapple chunks & coconut but was it weak. Everyone else was satisfied with their meal so I hope this place has a good run.

Certain dishes are very good. The pizza is delicious. The servers are nice and it's enjoyable to…read moreeat inside. The chicken roll I cannot recommend. It was the most disappointing roll I've had- the equivalent of 1 chicken finger with 2 pounds of mozzarella. Based on the other dishes I've eaten here I had higher hopes for this one.

When we first moved to Warren County, after being born and raised out East, finding authentic…read moredelicious Italian food was almost an impossible task but when we found Mama's our search was over. The food is delicious and the selections plenty with the ambiance to match. The waitresses are always pleasant and friendly with the attention to service that fine restaurants offer. My only suggestion would be that guests absolutely enjoy being asked as to the their dinning experiences and meal quality but not repeatedly within the reservation. That aside, I can say only the highest praises of Mama's Cafe Baci and I highly recommend anyone yearning for authentic Italian cuisine to experience it themselves.

Can't recommend this place enough for any kind of diet!! If you are gluten-free, dairy-free, vegan…read moreor vegetarian...they really take care of you and have 19 separate fryers to make sure you can eat safely. And the food is scrumptious!! They have soft guitar music...perfect background music and not loud at all. The owner could not have been nicer. If you are in the area...or want a delicious dining experience...go to Mama's.

Amazing spot for lunch, the food and prices were very reasonable and the service was great. This is…read morethe perfect spot to relax in the middle of a work day and have a "dinner like vibe" during a break. Highly recommend trying the salads, they were so fresh!

By far one of the best spots in Hackettstown. An absolute gem when it comes to delicious, homemade,…read moreauthentic Italian food. Their bread is absolutely delicious too! The staff is phenomenal and so unbelievably kind and funny. I love coming here with my dad and family friends. It's a small place so make sure you make your reservations!

Pino's truly checks all the boxes! The staff is warm and welcoming, and the owner never forgets a…read morecustomer--it's that kind of place. They serve the best penne vodka and chicken francese around, but my personal favorites are the Filet Mignon Ravioli and the Chicken Pino--absolutely delicious. It's BYOB and conveniently located right next to a liquor store (perfect if you need a quick refill!). Plus, the outdoor patio is perfect now that the weather's warming up. Do yourself a favor and go to Pino's immediately. You won't regret it!

This is our go to place either for dine in or take out. Food is always fresh, well prepared and hot…read morewhen served. Staff is very accommodating. Sandwiches and pizzas are top notch.

Really bad, expensive ! Flippant attitude from girl talking my order and money ! I will not be…read morereturning to this place

We've gotten takeout here a few times... tonight we were disgustingly disappointed. We've been…read moretrying to support local small businesses during the pandemic and I can promise we will never be customers here again. I called to complain that our garlic bread was burnt & practically inedible & our order of chicken fingers was pretty pathetic, not to mention our pizza was missing a topping. Didn't get an appropriate response form their staff at all. Got offered a store credit.... if my food is this disappointing and cold at delivery I'd rather just have a refund. Truly disappointing.

What a wonderful surprise! My husband and I stopped in for…read morelunch and immediately knew we had found a hidden gem. The moment you walk in, you are welcomed by a warm and intimate atmosphere that feels genuinely Italian, more like being invited into someone's home than visiting a restaurant. The food is exceptional, fresh, full of flavor, and made to order with obvious care. The husband and wife team prepares everything with such personal attention, and her homemade desserts are truly something special. Do not leave without trying one. This charming little spot has definitely earned a place on our list of places to return to. If you are looking for delicious Italian food served with heart, this is absolutely the place to go.

Had a reservation. Arrived on time and were seated. Took a while to get menus, 45 minutes to get…read morebread. No water served and were required to purchase bottled water if we wanted water. Food took an hour to be served. Only 1 person cooking and 1 person serving and handling all the take out orders. Everything was served in plastic takeout containers and cheap paper plates. Our bill was around $240 plus tip for 4 people for appetizers and dinner. It's BYOB. For this price point we should not be eating on plastic and buying bottled water. Arancini balls were good. Herb crusted salmon was plain in a pool of something. Pizza was not good. They really need to have china and glasses and more help on service. Service was disorganized and food was disappointing.

BYOB! The inside is elegant and cozy. The staff is friendly and professional. Incredible location…read moreand view. Came here for Valentine's Day date night. We came in before the kitchen closed, so we were able to order. We knew what we wanted right away. I got the meatballs for appetizers and my wife got beet salad. I got the lasagna. Food was perfect and delicious! I picked the lasagna because the sauce sounded delicious. The BEST lasagna is here! I'm getting the lasagna again! It's my new favorite dish, only here. The sauce is meaty with a perfect balance with tomato sauce. The pasta didn't overwhelm the dish. The cheese was great. INCREDIBLE!!!

Walked by on a beautiful day and decided to dine here. The food was excellent. There are many…read morecomplaints about the staff. I did not find that at all. Our meal was basic (shrimp wrap and penne w/vodka) and would certainly come again. One note: tidy up that restroom.

Service was great. Ambience is very nice, prices are not too high. But the pizza is just okay.read more

We went for dinner here after friends told us it was really good. I looked for their website to…read morecheckout the menu, but there was none. So I went to Yelp and Google to find a menu. After finding them, made the decision to take the family. Well, what a surprise! The Lasagna on the Yelp menu was $18. The restaurant was now charging $30. Chicken parm was $18, now $28. Holy smokes! The food was good but really overpriced for Italian food. The service was fine but the inside was pretty cold. White tiled floors with black table clothes didn't lend to a warm atmosphere. Sorry, can't recommend Gambino's, not worth the money.

I stopped going before the place was sold. The food was really good but they were very unorganized…read moreand not overly friendly. The food is the same ... It looks like the staff is the same. They are organized and friendly now

Remarkable. Simply remarkable. When I moved to arse-end-of-nowhere Hunterdon County I thought I'd…read morehave to drive 45 minutes to get good pizza. Well, let me tell you; you should be driving 45 minutes to get out here for this pizza. Just incredible. I have now been to 57 pizza places in greater NJ (including 26 in NYC) in search of the best pizza in the world (let's face it, if it's the best in NJ it is obviously the best in the world) and this place cracks the top 10. Easily. With room to spare. I got the Brooklyn which, by my definition, is actually a Grandma's. Crust isn't nearly as thick as what I'd expect from a Brooklyn. Regardless, it is mind-blowingly delicious. The crust is super crispy and has a hint of salt. It holds up well without being tough. And that's good because it has a generous amount of excellent cheese which is then topped with an abundance of spectacular sauce. It is thick but not chunky. It has an amazing tomato flavor and is not bogged down with overwhelming amounts of herbs, which most places overload to pretend to bring the flavor. It was served piping hot so I had to wait a while to enjoy, which was difficult. They cut the pieces big but trust me, you won't complain. It's hard to stop eating. So I don't care if they call it Brooklyn. If it tastes like this they can call it whatever they want. I'm am so amazed and grateful to have found such a spectacular pizza place way out in the hinterlands. Just perfection. I am hard to please and this place took my breath away. I sound like I'm getting carried away but it is just that good.