I'm so glad this little pizzeria is still open and rocking! I ate here 2-3 times a week whilst I worked at Orr's Department store in the Hillcrest Mall late 1980s. Always got a pie when I would visit (back home). I havent lived in the area for over 30 years. But this last weekend I had a family reunion in the area. We had Nicolosi's p2 times. So glad it is still around as I remember it! read more

I moved to the dump commonwealth 2 years ago (pa) haven't found good pizza since I tried them all over the free bridge. I was told this place is good but never got around too going until today. Really good pizza I wish I would have came here 2 years ago. Thank you to the owner ? For bringing me a plate and checking up on me after I took pie to go. Thank you for being good ! read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Pie - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

There are many, many more in the area I need to try still...but Nicolosi's in Phillipsburg is absolutely at the top of my list for Sicilian slice now. They didn't have a pie made so I ordered a half. Good thing I did, no way I would have settled for only one slice anyway. Solid tasting sauce, they must be using Grande cheese, crispy crust with airy interior, the dough had good flavor ... just an overall Winner. This was closest to the Sicilian pies of my youth in Brooklyn than anywhere else I've tried out this way so far. Not saying that alone means it's better...just saying that is what I know and am used to so it hit a comfort spot for me for sure. Check them out if you haven't already. The half was in the ballpark of $16 for 6 slices. Certainly Didn't Suck! read more

See all

Back at the Hillcrest mall in Phillipsburg, NJ for that awesome, old style pizza. It's offers simple menu with Neapolitan and Sicilian as the choices, some common toppings plus some basic drinks. So when the recipe works for 60 years, no need to change it. We ordered a few slices of Sicilian and a whole cheese pizza pie for the perfect way to satisfy our hunger and it did it disappoint one bit. And the rockstar pizza maker who made the BEST Sicilian I've had in a long while, LOGAN, was on pointe with the depth of dough, the sauce and cheese balance. Anybody can make a pizza but using the best trifecta ingredients: dough, cheese and sauce reigns supreme here. The Grand cheese is unlike what's. or ally in pizzas we've eaten and notice the difference. Great stuff. Place is cash only, ATM on site. And extend our appreciation to the rest of the staff for having a hand in the business: Anthony, Aiden, Nick and the bald headed guy that looks like Rick from Pawn Stars. Ok, where in the world is Dave Portnoy when you need his taste buds? ‍ read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Because you can't taste it, you can see what you're missing - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

What happened to the best pizza in NW NJ? It was ALWAYS so cheesy. Now it's skimpy. It has been changed for a while now and IDK why. Someone else has been making the pizzas for quite some time. I've been going there for a half a century. Not the same. SO disappointing. read more

Disappointed I even bothered to order a pizza; even had to pay an atm fee. What a waste. read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Used to be the best in town has really gone down hill. Ordered a pie that was clearly a reheated premade pie. Such a shame. Not a one time thing last 3 out of 6 were the same. No more Nickolosis for us. read more

Great service, GF pizza is very good. Regular pizza is also very good. Comparable to NY pizza!

The best pizza in all the land. Over 50 years and still the best! People drive for miles to experience Italian pizza as it should be. read more

The pizza here was pretty good. I you want quick service and on an empty stomach this is a place to visit!

The best Sicilian pizza I've ever had. I drove 8 hours total from Massachusetts to come get a pie. Worth every minute of the drive

Stopped for a slice of pizza Only choice was plain or Sicilian plain. Had to put the pepperoni for the heat up. Hard to find in the St Luke's mall. Won't be back read more

Well I love pizza and finding a good pizza place or Chinese food place is so hard now a days. I recently moved which made this harder. Seeing as I had my local place where I use to live finding one just as good when I was have the crave for pizza was hard. But luckily I found two. I have not had there dinners but as far a pizza location they are really good. So good I can eat the pizza cold the next morning. read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

See all

All I can say is the best pizza around. As I am from Virginia, any time I visit family in Jersey this place is a MUST. Truly a hidden gem.

This is the real deal-quality NY pizza! When our family visits from the West Coast, we always make sure to pick up pizza from Nicolosi's! Our friends and family in the area agree and always order their pizza from here! Delicious sauce in just the right portion, with the perfect crust and plentiful cheese. FYI: They don't sell salads or other entrees. It's tucked in the back of a shopping and business complex. You can eat in or take out. But call them in person for orders. Last time I was there, they did not deliver or utilize delivery services. The inside is no frills, but clean and comfortable. The location in Easton PA is NOT owned by the same people. So don't expect the same quality there!! read more

Bloody awful, cheaply made pizza. I ordered an extra large pepperoni pie delivered. It had 4 pieces of pepperoni on it, overcooked and small. Don't waste your money. Bella Mia pizza far outshines this dump. read more

Pizza was great! Nicolosi Pizza has been a Phillipsburg's favorite place for a long time.

I love the pizza. It was delicious and the delivery driver was amazing very polite and nice and has a cool Jetta

Fantastic Pizza Fantastic Service! Friendly atmosphere. Very historical place. My family has been purchasing pizza from this establishment for over 40 years. read more

Their pizza is always fantastic. Some say a little too much cheese but I'm always happy with it.

ordered 5 slices for 3 of us and 3 Pepsi's! they reheated slices sitting there for who knows how long came out over baked, crust so hard barely edible! 3 sodas were piss warm! when I complained they said the ice machine is broken! we couldn't drink the sodas and they never apologized or offered to refund the money for the sodas! place is over rated, don't even have a restroom! read more

Stopped by to pick up a pie for lunch. Very small menu. I ordered a pizza and it was very good. Should not have ordered extra cheese. I'd order it again read more

The pizza is amazing. It's a combo of the dough, sauce that is flavorful, and the cheese is outstanding. When you walk into the pizzeria you can just tell it's going to be amazing. Love love love this place. read more

LOVED The pizza! The people who works there are very nice and the service was fantastic!

Pizza was ok. Service was terrible. No public restroom, kids that work there couldn't care less about the customer. We won't be back

Nicolosi's pizza seems to be a local favorite. There's a pleasant atmosphere with some impressive baseball memorabilia adorning the walls. I went with a standard plain slice, as there wasn't much selection at the time I decided to stop by. The slice was greasy but had a good cheese to sauce ratio, both of which were tasty. The base and crust were the right amounts of crispy. And while I prefer my slices come unseasoned so that I may add them myself if necessary, the slice came with a good ratio of spices that weren't too overpowering. read more

See all

I can speak from many years of experience. Nicolosi's Pizza is the best pizza in the nation! I travel back home to P'burg, NJ a few times a year and won't get pizza anywhere else. I live in Middlefield, OH and nothing comes close in Ohio. I've lived in 16 different cities and eight different states so I know what I'm talking about! NJ was my childhood home and it always will be home. Had the anchovy pizza- AWESOME! Thank you Angelo, you did us Well! Dan read more

Consistently delicious for the 30 years I've been going to Nicolosi's pizza - both the regular style and Sicilian. Even our out-of-town guests ask for it when they visit. I definitely suggest takeout - as you wouldn't go there for the ambiance - and remember to have cash handy. read more

This is my 2nd favorite pizzeria in the Lehigh Valley. Great for takeout. They do not skimp on the sauce and cheese. FYI, the accept Cash Only. read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Sicilian Pie with Sausage and Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

See all

Warren County's BEST pizza! It's the closest thing to New York pizza and this city girl feels like I'm right at home eating Nicolosi's! The decor is a blast from the past but the prices will bring you back to present day. It's a tiny bit pricey considering the size of the pizza and the place is CASH ONLY. But sometimes you gotta give a little to get a little. It's so worth it! read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Two regular. Two extra cheese. THE BEST in Warren County! - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Moved to the neighborhood about 4 months ago from NYC and was so weary to try any pizzeria in the area because I honestly didn't think anything could compare to the pizzerias back home... until we stopped by Nicolosi's. I read their reviews on Yelp and chose them over the others because they basically had the best reviews. What I found - this pizzeria is legit. Old school, classic pizza. Man feels like I'm back on Arthur Ave. Got a large cheese pizza - cheese has that perfect salty bite with a sauce that has just a bit of sweetness that compliments the savory flavor perfectly. Nice, thin crust... you can tell a good pizza by its fold. Trust me - Nicolosi's is real deal. Glad we stopped in. Not only is the pizza good but the customer service is nice. Guys at the counter were personable and threw in a Sicilian to welcome us to the neighborhood. Nice touch. Most definitely will be coming back. Mangia! read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - I couldn't wait to taste it so a slice is missing, but you get the picture. - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Easily the best pizza around. Simple, perfectly executed, and affordable. A little tricky to find in the plaza mall, but the delivery service is solid and fast. read more

The best pizza I've had in a while, and the best I've had in the Phillipsburg area. Good crust not too thin or thick cooked perfectly. The sauce was nice and a little sweet. Nice amount of toppings too. All they make is pizza here but they do it right. Bring cash, no credit cards here. They say they're the longest running pizzeria in NJ, and I can see why.. read more

Best damn pizza there is. Hands down. Tastes the same for the last 45 years I've been eating it. The people are great and delivery is quick. I recently went in for a slice and it hasn't changed much. Looks just like when I went there in high school. Still old school so have your cash ready. No cards here read more

Not sure why so many people claim this is the best pizza around town. Menu is pretty much non-existent and the pizza which they solely focus on is mediocre at best. We tried for the first time tonight and will not be returning. Best of luck! read more

The best pizza around. Been going there since I was a kid. I do wish they took cards but it's worth the atm fee for some great Jersey pizza.

My favorite pizza!!! I don't even live in NJ anymore, but I come out about once a year to visit family. Literally the first thing I do each time I visit, is get Nicolosi's for dinner. It is consistently delicious, and I've been known to put about 5 slices down in a night (hey, I have to make up for lost time!!) The only bad thing is they have ruined all other pizza for me. Nothing is quite the same. read more

Went here twice after reading great reviews. The pie is stellar! Our new go to place for pizza, as most here locally within a 30 minute radius SUCK! Mostly inconsistent...this place appears to be our savior- so glad we discovered it. It is truly a hidden gem as it is hidden between ST. Lukes medical offices in a strip mall off 22 west. Hard to find initially even with GPS but it is now implanted in my mind. read more

I started eating here in 1970 and although I have lived in Fl since 1987, no visit to my family is complete with a large pizza with extra cheese. I have had pizza in approx. 46 states but found none to be as good as here. read more

Nicolosi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

We were visiting family for the 4th and wanted to introduce my children to authentic NY pizza. These are the responses I got: - Best Pizza I've ever had. - 6 of the 9 kids - OMG can we have this delivered to TN? - 6-year-old - The only critique I can come up with is the crust is a little tough. - 17-year-old - I don't like pizza but this pizza is not bad -My Wife read more