First time to this Rome original. Rather unassuming exterior and relatively standard bar interior. Plenty of space and seating areas, an outdoor patio awaits for the warmer months. Prompt greeting by restaurant staff, and fast service. Pretty impressive, as waitstaff aren't so plentiful in the new normal. The food - so, I went purely by my coworker's recommendations- and that's how we played it. Started with the peppers and cheese - hot Hungarian longs with an oil and chili paste from what I could taste, served with several slices of provolone and thin sliced Italian bread. This was spectacular! Word to the wise, the oil can squirt out of the peppers pretty hot! For the main event, I went for the "World Famous Burger". A 1/2 lb burger on a luscious sesame seed bun. The burger was grilled to perfection and perfectly medium rare - the only thing that I would note is that it could have had more seasoning to the burger itself. Served with Terrell's ridged chips - no deep fryer availability for fries apparently. read more

DeMatteo's - Burger - Burgers Near Me - Rome, New York

See all

Sunday June 9th I held a surprise 60th birthday party for my fiancé. This is the 2nd surprise party I've held there. Anthony Dematteo and his staff made this and the previous party remarkable. Dematteos is a very clean venue along with the bonus extension patio it was a hit. We had so much room. He stayed in contact to make sure no details were missed. Thank you for helping me make this party the success it was. Julie read more

See all

It's ok. People try to tell you it's l lm amazing, but it's just fine. It's a regular burger it's a decent one but nothing that stands out in anyway. read more

Best Burger in sooooʻ long. I've been all over the USA 2-3 times now. I will go back again to try more. I've been bragging about this place ever since i'm wet and I can't wait to go back. I wish I took pictures of my burger. They also have entertainment now.And then it's a great place to stop by and visit and eat. read more

Heard from multiple people about their burgers and they didn't disappoint. Cooked perfectly - medium rare!!! Other places you ask for medium rare, you get a hockey puck. I liked it came with chips and a pickle. Friendly staff, nice local vibes inside to watch football to. Go grab a burger and a beer. read more

We were hungry after visiting the Fort Stanwix so we decided to stop by here for lunch. This place is definitely full of mostly locals having drinks. We ordered their cheeseburger and grilled ham & cheese sandwich. They do not serve any fries here so our meals came with chips. The food were just decent. The buns on the burger were a bit hard. There was only one bartender who were taking all orders for both food and drinks. She was friendly and polite. read more

DeMatteo's - Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Rome, New York

See all

Great place to grab a beer for happy hour. I am also a huge fan of their burgers; definitely grab some mac salad on the side and you will not be disappointed. The bar are can get crowded, especially during nights with live music but there's a great patio area with a ton of space (and an extra bar). Be prepared to wait a little bit on live music nights, but I find it's worth the wait! read more

Mostly a bar but they also serve burgers and chicken sandwiches with rotating specials as well. The food is good. They don't serve fries, only potato chips, which is a miss as far as I'm concerned. If you want a good beer selection, then it's a great place. They have a solid selection of craft beers on tap and full bar service, too. Generally the service is good, but when they're busy it can sometimes be hard for them to keep up. They have an appetizer plate with local Italian bread, hot peppers and sliced provolone that's outstanding. The main part of the bar is old and hasn't been updated in a long time, but the addition is newer with a really nice outdoor patio that is the most recent update to the place. read more

My husband and I were driving through Rome and decided to stop for lunch. We have been to this restaurant in the past. We always thought they had a great burger. And they still do. In addition they have a great selection of beers on tap. But they have remodeled inside and added a beautiful patio. The ambiance is greatly improved. Just another reason to stop in the next time we are in Rome. read more

See all

Famous burgers with long hot peppers are absolutely delicious! The grill gives a char that can't be beat and they are served hot and fresh. This is a definite landmark in town and always a favorite stop. The beer choice is vast and wines are cold and refreshing. The staff are friendly and welcoming! The bartenders made some refreshing drinks too! We enjoy going every time we are in town! read more

Excellent place for food, beer and a great time. Bartenders, servers, cookers and owners are all friendly people.

Such a fun place! Awesome live music, happy vibes, yummy grub (long hots and provolone are the best ever)! Local crew is fun friendly welcoming... prices are reasonable .. just a blast!! 5 stars all day!! read more

Classic neighborhood burger joint/sports bar. No Italian food despite the name and location in Rome's alleged "Little Italy." My sausage patty sandwich was undersized and undercooked. Wife's burger was nothing special. Thirty bucks for two sandwiches, no drinks. Service was friendly. Bar area modern and convivial. We won't be returning. read more

Awesome burgers but the beef had a little too much char. Bun was a little oversized. There wasn't enough greens on the burger and it wasn't the most flavorful either. Overall, not bad for a burger. read more

I'm not sure how this place gets three stars. Maybe this is based on old reviews but then again I've been going to this place for years. The owner and staff are solid. This is a bar so you get a slight twist on Italian but it is bar food. You cannot go wrong with the burger. It's fresh ingredients and great every time. You also can't go wrong with the chipotle chicken or the cappi or roast beef. If you like very hot peppers you can add their long hots and sauce or have it as a side with fresh provolone. Their sides are always very good and it's a lively atmosphere. Entertainment every Friday night and they continue to expand the outside to accommodate more people. This is a place you go for a great burger or sandwich and service to match. read more

Burgers are awesome beers are cheap and the free peppers, onions and provolone wheel are to die for. Get there early for the peppers and cheese because they go quickly and are only served Monday -Friday. 2 for one drinks during Cuse games! Tell them Lori Edel sent ya:) read more

I ordered a burger there when i bit into it it was cold and bloody... Absolutely disgusting I went to the lady her name was Jamie. Instantly she told me no refunds before I even said anything I felt like i was in some low class chinese restaurant the way I was treated I just wanted my burger cooked. For some reason they claimed that was impossible. I ended up leaving my piece of half dead cow there mooing and bleeding on the counter as I walked out not even close to satisfied.. read more

This place has the best burgers along with everything else.Atmosphere inside and out are great.Great patio for people to get together.Music on some Friday nights.Awesome service and full bar. read more

Best burgers in town, well worth the money. Steady flow of people in and out. Be sure to try the free cheese and peppers in the back while you wait for your meal. Bring cash as they do not accept credit cards, there is an ATM on site if needed. read more

Visited one of our favorites places for a burger on December 31st about 12:30. The food is always exceptional along with the service but not on this occasion. Our waitress Hannah was without a doubt one of the rudeness individuals I've ever encountered. Upon arrival she simply tossed menus on our table and kept walking to the next table. After quite a wait she came back for drink orders. After ordering and receiving our food two out of the six orders were completely wrong. My father tried to get her attention and she simply kept walking. Her next trip into the back room he was able to alert her that he received an Eastside burger but ordered a bacon cheeseburger. Her response "yeah ok" and kept walking leaving the burger there on the table. At this point I got up to use the rest room only to see her standing at the bar texting on her phone. I couldn't even believe it. Her next time in the back room he again said something as she states "yeah I know." Well if you know why are you leaving the incorrect burger sitting there and not at least advising us that they are working on making the correct burger. Finally after all this my father receives the correct burger. My mother's burger arrived about 5 minutes after all ours did so we waited till hers arrived to eat. Her burger arrives and is incorrect! So rather than deal with everything my father had just dealt with, she just ate something she didn't order. I had never seen this waitress before but she had absolutely no personality at all and was extremely rude. Thinking she may have just been having a bad day I reached out to others that dine there frequently. All have had similar experiences with her. read more

Craft beer prices are very high comparable to other venues. Only one person tending bar, taking food orders and cooking while management sits at the bar doing nothing. Insanely poor service as a result, not her fault. Terribly run. Not coming back. read more

Amazing. Dive kinda feel, yet far from dingy or unfriendly. Good prices. Jennifer fucking rules. Can't recall a burger I've ever enjoyed as much. Found in the middle of a road trip and must go back. read more

DeMatteo's isn't as much a restaurant as it is a bar. They have some good bar burgers, but that's about it.

I went to this restaurant and 11/18/14. I was in Rome New York with a coworker and we ordered chili which is okay and two burgers I ordered the Southwest burger and my coworker ordered a regular burger . When we received our burgers bit into mine to discover it was raw / bright red on the inside , as my coworkers was as well. We sent the burgers back watch the bartender remove the burger's and place them back on the grill one of which I had bitten. After 2 min the burgers show back up and the bartender tells me our pitcher of beer will be removed from the bill. We inspect our burgers again and they are both bright red inside still. We both left . I recommend the Heath inspector pay a visit to this place. read more

We stopped in yesterday for lunch and had two really great sandwiches and cold drinks. My roast beef was rare (just like I like it!) and my girlfriend had grilled chicken with smoked ham was great also. It was very comfortable and the waitress was exceptional. The only thing that surprised us was the lack of any Italian items on the menu. After all: DeMatteos and in Rome!?! This is a place for tavern food and as such is at the top of its competition. Would we go here again? You bet we would ! Nice place, very clean ! read more

Stopped on our way back from Old Forge. GREAT burgers, cooked perfectly with the freshest roll! We were treated to fresh roasted peppers & spicy olives. Highly recommend! read more

burger was OK. a tad overcooked. Friendly service and cheap. The roll was a bit to tough to use as a hamburger roll.

Local Bar with grill. Hamburg was ok grilled Chicken not bad. I say go for the bar and not the food.

When I pass thru Rome this is the only place I'll stop for a sandwich . The food is very fresh , I usually get the chipotle chicken panini with roasted red peppers -Love it , they also have a nice back room with a fireplace and large tv. Very friendly people!! read more

We stopped here while passing through. Needed lunch & wanted something good . We both had the Eastside Cappy & it was excellent . The Cappy is sliced fresh for each sandwich & they lightly brush the ciabatta roll with butter before grilling it on the press. Out of this world! We shared a large potato salad which was just how my mother in law used to make it! The Mac salad looked great too! Burgers look good. The place is no frills & has no decor to speak of otherwise I would give it 5 stars. read more

The Eastside Burger was delicious. They also had complimentary bread and primo cheese. We had a party of about 10 so we called in our order in advance. The food was ready when we got there. Couple downsides. 1) Cash only 2) They said they couldn't do separate checks even though it's cash only???? read more

Traveling from out of town for work. On a Monday night myself and 5 coworkers went in at 8:45pm for dinner and drinks. The place was very clean and well lit. Approximately 10 people in the restaurant with 4 being served at the bar. We were met by a waitress, I asked if the kitchen was still open she replied "It opens at 9pm for burgers and chips only. You are welcome to wait for 15 minutes." The bartender then said "it's ok order what you want, except salads or cold cuts." We asked for the food and alcohol to be on separate checks. At that point we were told they only accept cash.(Which was ok, we just were unable to use the company credit card for our meals.) We decided to stay and they crew ordered a southwest burger (medium), 4 southwest chickens sandwiches and a chipotle chicken sandwich. We then ordered beers and they were out of glasses,(with only 16 people in the establishment) One of us was lucky got a chilled glass and the rest of us got solo cups. While cooking our meals, the hostess/cook/bartender informed us that she messed up the chipotle chicken and made it to be southwest. (The person who was receiving it said "that was fine and it wasn't a big deal and just finish it that way.") During the time we were waiting the owner and another bartender were very unpleasant, they stood in-front of us sitting at the bar, while sorting out a register problem. They were rude to the hostess/cook/bartender that was helping us, about not turning down the lights properly. Once we received our food... the burger was cooked medium well and instead of the southwest mayo there was a raspberry mayo on it. All the chicken sandwiches were cooked through but all had the same raspberry mayo. One also had two top buns and another two bottoms. At this point we didn't want to hang out for things to be recooked... (Other than the raspberry flavoring the food was good.) We decided that we would finish our beer and Pay our tab in cash. (Luckily there was an ATM in the bar..$3 sure charge.) We completely understand that places have "Off Nights" but we would all NOT recommend going there if this is a usual thing. We left and went to Applebee's to enjoy some more adult beverages and appetizers. They lost out on us sticking around and spending our out of town money in a local owned business. read more