Tuesday special 8/11/2026: shrimp tacos W/mango salsa with a side of my choosing potato salad. Absolute BANGER. I've been living in Carrollton for about a year and a half and haven't had the chance to try deli on the square. IT IS the best restaurant in town hands down. Everything tastes so fresh and just so good! And the owner is so nice!! 10/10 hands down!! :) read more

Deli on the Square - Special Shrimp tacos, with mango salsa and potato salad. - Delis Near Me - Carrollton, Ohio

Super welcoming owner with fantastic food. Turned a simple Sloppy joe into an amazing sandwich- huge! Homemade bun and pickles. Plus banana peppers, cheese and chips. With a side of delicious homemade potato salad! read more

Deli on the Square - The giant sloppy Joe sandwich!!! - Delis Near Me - Carrollton, Ohio

We're camping at Atwood Lake and tooled around Carrollton looking for. Place to eat. Saw the reviews and had to try it. This will now become a regular stop every time we are here. It's very nice, inviting and clean inside. Very welcoming. The owner herself took our order...very friendly, kind, and explained the menu. We love that it's a local shop with all made to order food. With that being said, our food was served pretty quickly...just a short wait. I had the daily special which was a French dip with potato salad. It was to die for. My husband had the Italian sub with pasta salad. He said it was probably the best sub he'd ever eaten. It truly was delicious. If you're in the area, be sure to stop in. I can't wait to try more food from here. read more

Deli on the Square - French Dip and potato salad. - Delis Near Me - Carrollton, Ohio

See all

My husband and I have been excited to try Deli on the Square and we were finally in Carrollton on a Friday for the meatloaf sandwich special. This little downtown deli is a must try if you were in the area. Even if you are not in the area and have the time to drive down and try the meatloaf special along with any of their other sandwich options, we highly recommend. Any of their sandwiches can be made into a wrap. Hence you will see the Italian on a wrap on my plate. We also tried the broccoli salad, which was amazing as well as a vegetable soup, which was great with depth of flavor. Service was great and everyone was friendly. If you're looking for a spot to relax for a few minutes and enjoy the vibes of downtown Carrollton, this is where to do it . Enjoy! read more

Deli on the Square - Meatloaf Sandwich and Broccoli Salad - Delis Near Me - Carrollton, Ohio

See all

Food was exceptional! I had the veggie sub which comes with a side; I had the broccoli salad. Most places this is pretty standard fare but my first bite of the sandwich was anything but. The veggies were sliced thin, some were pickled and plentiful. The mayo was delightfully tangy but not overpowering, and smoked Gouda cheese, all packed into a fresh, house made sub bun. The broccoli salad was also very tasty and pleasant to eat since the vegetables were sliced in manageable pieces. The house made dressing complemented the broccoli nicely. Portions are generous and the coffee was fresh and delicious too. I had not been back to the deli since it changed hands, only because my schedule did not coincide with the hours, but now that I have I will definitely make it back to try another enticing offering. read more

Passed through Carrollton today and stopped in with my two kids. All three of us are were impressed and we'll be back - we live 2 hours away but will go out of the way to return when we have the chance. I was told everything is scratch made and I believe it after our visit. They make their own bread?! Are you kidding me? That's the easiest thing to phone in but they take pride in their food and rightfully so. My kingdom for those homemade pickles! PS: and the potato salad And the pasta salad And the pepper mayo omg read more

What a cute Mom & Pop place! The owner is so friendly and so helpful, and the food was so very delicious. I had 1/2 of a Turkey and Smoked Gouda sub with potato cheese soup. Everything is homemade here, the sub bread was fresh and perfect for the sandwich. The potato cheese soup had big chunks of potato and the cheese wasn't overpowering. My husband had the Meatball Sub and some coleslaw, and both were delicious. He said it was the best meatball sub he has ever had! And the coleslaw was light and so tasty. Since you walk up to order, we didn't have a waitress, but all the staff was so friendly and accommodating. If you are in the area, make sure you stop by and try this place, you can't go wrong! read more

See all

Out and about in the local area and thought we'd give it a try. Glad we did! Great little soup and sandwich shop right on the historic square facing the 1885 courthouse. Order at the counter and sit where you like. Small place with a homey feel, booths and tables. Counter help was friendly and information. We had potato salad, broccoli cauliflower salad, an Italian sub, a meatball sub, and peanut butter cookies. Everything was delicious. Laura, the owner, chatted with us for a few minutes. She's only been open since February, but says things are going well. She bakes her own breads for the sandwiches and you can tell. Takes them to another level. If you're ever near Carrollton, Ohio around lunch time you can't go wrong at the Deli on the Square. read more

What a nice place to eat lunch! Took the wife for some anniversary lunchings. The special was steak salad and bread pudding. It was good salads, feta- wife's favorite, but the bread pudding was artisan and delicious. Would recommend to stop if your in Carrollton around lunchtime read more

I'm new to the area and was just walking around exploring the center of town. I stopped into the Deli on the Square just to see what it was like. It is an attractive and very wellcoming little space. The interior reminded me of a restaurant out of the the 50s and the people inside were as nice as can be. I only ordered a cup of coffee and sat down at a table to drink it. It was good coffee. I was made to feel most welcomed by the waitresses who were most attentive. Judging by my eyes, the food looked marvelous, but I wasn't really hungry at the time. When I am hungry, I will definitely return to get some of the attractive food that I saw and my daily dose of kindness. Thank you. read more

What a lovely find. The food was so fresh and the staff friendly and helpful. We had a chef salad and a turkey wrap. Generous portions and delish. We ordered some pickles to go. Yummy! We will definitely be back! read more

The homemade soups & salad dressings are very good. We had an amazing Reuben with potato cheddar soup. Everything was as good as it gets! If your in Carrollton stop in between 10:30 & 2:30 M-F You won't be disappointed. read more

Deli on the Square - You can tell they care about their product. Donna is a gracious host. - Delis Near Me - Carrollton, Ohio

Dear Donna's Deli, Thanks for making us strangers from California feel so welcome in your establishment. The peanut butterscotch cookie, homemade chocolate sheet cake, the Reuben and hot pot of coffee was delicious... HOWEVER, the Bloody Mary mix was THE BEST we have ever tasted and I wish I could buy it in batches. Thanks for sharing your special Bloody Mary blend for us to enjoy. Order the Bloody Mary if you go here. read more

I travel Northeast Ohio for work and whenever I'm in Carrolton I always make it a point to stop at Donna's Deli which is in their downtown area. Everything is homemade, the food is phenomenal, and Donna is almost always working the front counter eager to let you know what the day's special is. I always get whatever the special is, and am always blown away by the unique flavors and how fresh everything is. If this place was located in a large metro I'm convinced there would be a line around the block for their food. But since you're in Carrolton, you can get served right away and a hearty lunch will run you $8-9$. Phenomenal. Only open for lunch hours M-F. read more

I finally had lunch @ Donna's Deli, on the square in Carrollton, OH. I had heard that they had terrific food, but limited hours (10:30 - 2:30, M-F). We arrived @ 2:10 and had, perhaps, the best lunch I've had in the past 20 years. My wife had the Reuben w/potato salad. I had the French Dip w/Turkey Noodle soup. While my wife raved about the Reuben, with its thinly silce corned beef & homemade sauce, I had the best French Dip I've ever had (& I order this out...a lot...). Both sandwiches were generously sized, great ingredients, and simply delicious. The sides were homemade, fresh, & perfectly sized. This place is a gem...simple decor, great service by people who seem to love their jobs, and tremendous food...all at a very reasonable price. This will be our "go to" place for lunch in Carrollton. Although there are many nice little places around, none can compare to the food & service @ Donna's Deli. read more

great sandwhich and realey good soup. had the daily club panini i was told everything was locally sourced and grown. the staff was very friendly and attentive to covid protocols cool place read more

As always, so good!! Donna herself greets customers and ensures every dish is made to your satisfaction. Everything is fresh and today's special, blueberry cheesecake is amazing. read more

What a great lunch spot! Everything is made fresh to order and source all local breads, fruits, vegetables when possible. Friendly and great atmosphere. I really like it. My new favorite lunch spot when I'm in town. read more

Donna and Paul have embraced and honed a great formula for success... a simple menu of delicious food, prepared quickly and efficiently in a clean environment. read more

Donna's is amazing! Carrollton is lucky to have a deli like this! Donna makes everything from scratch. The daily specials are creative and delicious! Sometimes the tomatoes and other veggies are right from donnas garden. The macaroni salad is the best I've ever had. The servings are very generous. All of the sandwiches come with a homemade side dish of either potato salad, macaroni salad, pea salad or a cup on their homemade soup of the day. All of their salad dressings are made from scratch! We love this place - the food is delicious and the atmosphere and service are excellent! read more

Looking for something different, I stopped for lunch in the Carrollton square. This place does a steady business, and deservedly so. The chili special was very good, and sufficiently flavored, a rarety in this part of the country. The dining area was clean, and the service was friendly. They also sell a few cheeses abs cold cuts at the deli counter, for reasonable prices. I'll definitely return here. read more

Small town diner with big flavor, fast service, and good food. A great place to go for lunch. Everything is fresh.

Great homemade food and service, if you are passing through or visiting Carrollton this is a must stop place for lunch

The food here is AMAZING!!! You can tell it's always homemade. The deserts are even better. If you want a really nice lunch and don't want to spend and arm and a leg come to this place. The owner is really nice and personable. read more

Excellent little lunch spot in the heart of Carrollton! Roast beef sandwich with horseradish was excellent. Service is friendly and attentive. read more

In Carrollton for business coming from Chicago. BEST sandwich I've had at a deli. Got the turkey jalapeño special, and it was delicious. Great prices for very generous portions! read more

Awesome Reuben sandwich and chicken noodle soup. I will be back next time I'm in town.