If you're going to charge $10 for a mediocre sandwich and $25 for a steak, I would prefer not to see fiberglass insulation hanging from the rafters. I would also expect to have a proper heating system instead of a dusty metal box blowing loudly. The food was not fresh, over priced and the atmosphere is nothing special unless you like breathing fiberglass. read more

Homer is a cute, quiet town just north of Cortland. Don't let that mislead you though. We needed to get out of Cortland for it was graduation weekend, and everywhere was going to be packed. Dasher's took care of us with reservations and even accommodating another 5 to our rather large party at last minute! As it turns out, Dasher's decided this was the same night, they would debut their new summer menu. So putting in our order took some time. The service was very friendly, and we loved their shirts, "Big taste in a small town." The starter bread was put over the top with the sweet butter. I'm one that doesn't usually indulge in bread and butter, but I couldn't get enough of it. The food came out surprisingly fast once the orders were put in. Everyone absolutely loved their food. It was full of flavorful and the menu had a great variety from chips and salsa to seafood to chicken sandwiches. My mother got a chicken and lobster pot pie which was surprisingly executed very well. I will definitely back here! read more

Nice little gastropub. Loved the old-fashioned cocktails. Appetizers were generous and food was good quality. Tasty French dip sandwich. Caprese salad was good but needs a little work on presentation--cheese should be sliced rather than presented in blobs. Burger was good, but would prefer fries rather than sad corn chips, which couldn't have been home made as advertised. Would definitely go back. read more

Bar food at "gourmet" prices. Decent burgers and salads but their mac and cheese was dry and definitely did NOT need truffle oil. Their appetizers look like something a teenager would throw together from their parents pantry and their steaks and seafood are wickedly overpriced. For being a "pub" too, their wings are AWFUL! Overcooked, greasy and tossed in Franks Red Hot or Sriracha. Seriously guys? No garlic parm? No real "Buffalo?" You didn't even include butter in the Franks... It's nice to have a place like this in Homer but they need to either reduce their prices to reflect the food they're serving or, simply put, make their food better. read more

Pretty subpar food. And extremely expensive. Salads were outrageously expensive and tasteless. Basically a pile of greens w tasteless oil. Lobster bisque was a broth without any lobster. Fish was micro waved from a frozen tough filet. read more

Tried this place for the first time on a Sunday evening. We had a party of seven and no reservations, but that wasn't a problem and we were seated in a c-shaped booth in the back of the bar. I ordered a Tom Collins and a put in an order for a Sizzling Potato Chip Platter for the table. The Tom Collins was well made and was tasty. We all looked over the menu and tried to decide what we wanted. We had to google what "lyonnaise potatoes" are because the steaks come with them and a vegetable (they're sliced pan-fried potatoes and thinly sliced onions, sautéed in butter with parsley). I ordered a Delmonico steak with sautéed mushrooms. The Sizzling Potato Chip Platter was served on a cast iron skillet. The chips were topped with blue cheese and bacon. I didn't actually expect the platter to be sizzling, but I guess I did expect the chips to be warm. Not only were the chips cold, but the cast iron skillet was cold as well, even though it had one of those protective sleeves on the handle and was on a wood block. Although the chips weren't hot, they were tasty. I think they would have been great if they had been served warm. It took about 45 minutes for the entrees to arrive at the table. This surprised me because the place wasn't that busy. I understand good food might take a while to prepare, so I wasn't upset. When the food arrived it looked great. The presentation was very nice. We all dug in with gusto. Four of us had ordered steaks and we all noticed that the toppings on the steaks weren't hot. Some were cold and some were warm at best. The steaks weren't hot either. They were warm. They were properly cooked and tasty, but not hot. In fact, everyone except one person said their food was only warm, not hot. This leads me to believe that the kitchen had a little trouble with one dish and that they either had to do it over, or it took much longer than they anticipated. Thus, the other dishes sat on the counter a while and lost some temperature. Maybe they don't have heat lamps. This would also explain why the food took so long. I do think the prices are a bit high, but not outrageous. Perhaps if the food was hot and we had been blown away by the quality and deliciousness of the food I would think otherwise. I will give this place another try. I think there's real potential here and I'm hoping they were just having an off night in the kitchen. read more

Food portion was so small it was disrespectful. Especially for the price charged. But it's a small town, I guess I expected more. Kind of trashy yet friendly staff. read more

The grilled cheese options and desserts are fantastic- love the profiteroles. They always kindly accommodate a larger group for family gatherings. I wouldn't recommend the Caesar salad- it was served as several whole large leaves of lettuce rather than a prepared salad. read more

This place is a very pleasant surprise and very close to Cortland. Since I rarely get to Homer I would like to give this a nice review as everyone was pleasant and the food was delicious. Sat at the bar with my wife and her friend and the owner came out of the kitchen and was very accommodating to my wife who wanted something simple to eat. I had the cioppino which is a seafood stew and it was delicious maybe could've used a little kick of spice and a couple of garlic bread points but still excellent. May I suggest you serve it with a spoon and I would have finished the last drop My wife's friend had a delicious steak and crab cake and she said it was awesome. If I ever make my way back through homer this is a must stop. Both bartenders were very nice and did a great job. Hope to see you all soon read more

The service was pleasant and a great atmosphere. The Caesar dressing was overpoweringly fishy, and the presentation was pretty but it was hard to consume. The calamari was bland and over priced for the amount given. The bun on the Napa burger was fluffy and buttery but over powered the flavor of the sauce. The beer was a standard price. read more

Went here a few times and the food was pretty good, although very expensive. But worth going back to. The last time we went we got a few steaks, which were the worst cooked steaks I have ever had. Our muscle appetizer seemed like it was left out and the muscles were bad. And the bill came to over $300. Emailed them to figure out why it was so bad the last time and never heard back. read more

I grew up living in both Cortland and Homer and moved away after college in '67. I have returned several times a year since because my Mother still lives here. Honestly, I have been sad because this area has lost so many of the jobs, businesses and the growth we had back then. For the last 50 years I have been a loyal customer of Homer Men and Boys because Frog knows how to run a business with great selections and fair prices. Now I am also VERY PLEASED to see there is another sign that Homer is rebounding - Dasher's. Great food, excellent selections, superb service and my wife and I loved dining outside on a lovely summer night. We travel many places in the world, especially now being retired and Dasher's measures up with many high quality facilities. Homer should be very happy with a restaurant like this. I read the comments about service, but ours was very good. Remember that the servers are people, not machines, and like you, have good and not so good days. Be thankful that you have this choice and support them. read more

Dasher's Corner Pub - American Near Me - Homer, New York

Dinner here tonight was amazing. Maple salmon and apple risotto was cooked perfectly. Waitress was very bubbly and attentive.

Excellent restaurant! They have many different variations of grilled cheese for lunch. I had the Brie, pear, and walnut grilled cheese and it was yummy. It was served with tomato bisque and chips and salsa. read more

I absolutely love this place. I am new to the area and I brought my mom and sister here for all of our first times at dashers. I really wanted to make a good impression for my family and I was terrified because I had no clue were to go. The patio is what caught our eye so we stopped in. We were all blown away, the atmosphere is inviting and comfortable but it's still upscale in a really interesting way. And the food was way more than I expected from a pub. My 11 year old sister doesn't usually eat much but she gobbled down her whole burger. My mother got steak and I got the lobster chicken pot pie. Everything was great. It's hard to find nice places in this area but Dashers Pub is the place to go if you want an interesting fun experience and splurge a little bit on amazing food. I can't put a price on quality and great service. read more

This place is great. The food is always really good. The steaks are by far the best around. The atmosphere is great and the staff is always super friendly. If you haven't tried this place yet then go try it tonight. read more

Had some good and not so good. This visit was on the good list. The tomato and mozzarella stack was huge and delicious. I will definitely be getting that again! Grilled cheese and tomato bisque always a great combination. I tried the Californian this visit, good flavor but would think the cheese should actually be melted on a grilled cheese. Love the avocado on it. read more

Dasher's Corner Pub - Tomato and mozzarella stack - American Near Me - Homer, New York

If you're in the mood for good food and fine service then this is a great place to come! We joined some friends for a nice Sunday meal and everything was great! We shared a veggie pizza to start followed by burgers, salads, fish & chips. The meal was topped off woth coffee and a shared apple crisp. The waitress was very attentive and eager to make a real perfect , she brought me plenty of extra lemon for my fish, catsup and whatever else we requested. I'll be back again soon. read more

We stopped here on our way from Aurora to route 81. Had the hamburger, The goat grilled cheese sandwich and the special which was a smoked trout sandwich. Everything was excellent. The service was very good as well. Will come back definitely. read more

Dasher's Corner Pub - Smoked trout sandwich....excellent - American Near Me - Homer, New York

See all

Def Top 3 places to eat in Homer/Cortland NY.. Food and service fantastic!! beers were cold,Prime Rib and Cornish Hen was rich with flavor but, the must have,BANANA CREAM PIE! OFF THE CHAIN!!! read more

Good food at high prices in nice atmosphere. $9 for a hamburger is a bit much even though it's a very good hamburger. For a small town like Homer, this place has some nice variety. I've only been there twice but I liked the food. I was there for lunch both times and doubt I'll go for dinner unless I'm willing to spring $30 for a steak (which I suspect would be quite good). Plenty of nearby parking, the service was good, and I liked the off-the-floor booths. LATER: I've now been there for dinner a couple of time and they are TERRIFIC. Their prime rib is just outstanding and the relatives I've taken there say their meals were great. Their lunch prices seems high to me but the dinner prices are easily worth what you get. LATER STILL: Gads ... just came back from Dashers where I had the absolute WORST prime rib I have every encountered. Looked great but was so chewy as to be inedible. Very surprising since that's probably the 10th prime rib I've had there over the years and previously the worse one was "only very good" instead of excellent read more

We go to Dasher's every time we are in Cortland NY. I love their beef wellington sandwich

Have gone here at least 4 times over the past three years. Cedar salmon and apple risotto is great. However as of late, I found the service has declined, the prices have risen significantly, and I find it disappointing that a $25+ entree doesn't come with bread or a side salad. I ordered a side salad, it was really small and cost $6.50 . Also my daughter ordered kids Mac and cheese. It cost $8, came with nothing and tasted awful. So, we won't be back, just not really worth it. read more

Great little, pub. The food was great and the price was pretty reasonable, especially considering the quality, which was what I would call something along the lines of upscale pub fair. The service was also exceptional, the waitresses were friendly and engaging. My only critique was that list of beer was nothing to write home about, but by no means bad. One of the better restaurants I have stumbled upon in some time. read more

Such a quant historical pub! Absolutely loved coming here and was pleasantly surprised at the quality and creativity of the food! Their seafood was unexpectedly fresh and delicious! The real hidden gem of this place though is the chocolate mousse! My mother has chocolate mousse at almost every restaurant we go to and let me tell you she and I agree this is one of the best we've ever had! This place is a must try. A hidden gem in a beautiful area of NY. read more

Dashers is a decent bar and restaurant with excellent beer selection. The food is good, though not extraordinary. At times the prices can seem high for the average-ness of the cuisine, but the atmosphere is lovely and cozy. read more

Dashers was an excellent choice. My girlfriend and I were driving down Main Street and we saw this place and immediately checked the reviews on Yelp. We decided to give it a try and I'm glad we did. It had a nice atmosphere inside. It is a bar/restaurant with friendly staff. Our waitress was very attentive and polite. We were greeted with fresh bread and sweet honey butter with a touch of sea salt. Everything on the menu sounded really good so it was difficult to choose. We started out with the fresh guacamole. It was prepared at the table by a staff member which was really cool. He showed us all of the ingredients and mixed them together. It was delicious. My girlfriend and I both craving a burger, went with the buffalo burger. It had buffalo wing sauce, bleu cheese, and carrots on top. It was really good. Overall, I would definitely recommend Dashers. I'm sure we will be going back. read more

I've lived in Homer, NY for over 25 years and have tried Dashers for dinner three times since they opened; most recently this month. Each time has been a disappointment. My last meal which was the Kentucky surf and turf was cold and when I sent it back to be heated, they brought me a new steak which was smaller than the first and just as cold. The steak was tasteless, the potatoes were old and the scallops were fair at best. The waitress was far from warm and friendly. I'm disappointed to say, I won't be going there for a meal again. It is waaaayyyy over priced and the food is far from fine food. read more

We had dinner there last night. The menu was varied, the staff was friendly and knowledgable. My dad was looking for an item not on the menu and the chef graciously accommodated the request. We will definitely be back- far better than the chains or any places we have tried in downtown Cortland. read more

Had the seafood pasta plate as recommended, but was sadly disappointing. Clams and mussels had sand all in them which ended up all over the entire under sauced dish. Server didn't know the menu or why to recommend either. Flies wouldn't leave me alone and I was inside. Sad... read more

Love this place. The salads are fabulous as are the appetizers. We've never actually made it to dessert. We travel from Dryden to eat here, it's that good. read more

We had the occasion to dine at Dashers on a Friday night. Seems to be the big night for them. We had Salmon and Scrod. Very tasty. A little over done but acceptible. The only thing that we were not real pleased with was the rush we felt. We had a beer, ordered and ate while the table next to us ordered when we were leaving and they were there when we came in. Three stars this time. Will try again for a re-rate. Tom C. Cortland read more

Called ahead to reserve a booth in the bar. I was told that the bar seating was first come first served. When we arrived we did get a booth in the bar. After a couple of drinks we had dinner. After dinner we were going to have a drink but we were told that we needed to leave because others had reserved the booth. Really?? I won't go back. read more

Amazing place! The Lobster Bisque was the best I've ever had by a long stretch. Great atmosphere, staff and menu. My wife and I tried several 'small plates' and loved them. The Lobster Newburgh was incredible and they are not stingy with the Lobster meat. They also had an impressive wine and craft beer list. Great experience in an improbable, beautiful small town! read more

Overly aggressive waitress selling way too hard to increase our check. Enough already! Menu was interesting but the actual results were disappointing. Over cooked meats and blah sides. $100 later and really no better than an dinner. Great local beer. Please make some changes b4 its too late!!! read more

Food is ok, nothing really impressive about it. Overpriced for what it really is, ok for a rare visit or change of venue when eating out.

Soggy chips, $10 burger with no taste, $7 house salad that is very small. Not worth the money

I felt compelled to write a review after eating at Dashers tonight and not only received below average good, but below average and rude service as well. Our server, Lyle was inept; No clue about what was on the menu items, didn't bring the water i requested, never cleared the plates we were done with. We ordered the half order of mild chicken wings which were horribly greasy and tasteless. We also ordered th "Utica Greens" which were essentially last night's kale sprinkled with dry bread crumbs and hot pepper flakes...oh, and 2 miniature cubes of prosciutto. They tasted fishy. I told the server that I didn't like them and could we please get another item. When the bill came, the $9 greens were still on the check. I have been eating at the establishments owned by these people for years. I have been gracious before when the food hasn't been good. I have spent hundreds on drinks and dinners and always leave good tips. I would think that the manager might remove a $9 item that I didn't eat, but instead the manager was rude, argued with me about what Utica greens are supposed to taste like, said "I'm sorry you didn't like them" and walked away. I have never been treated so rudely in a local establishment. Huge disappointment. read more

Had a very nice lunch here. Great range of grilled cheese and burger selections. Comfortable pub atmosphere and excellent service. A little off the beaten track unless you have a reason to drive through Homer, but actually worth a detour. Prices are at the high end, but the overall results make it worth it. read more

Great atmosphere, good variety in the menu, food has always been good. Have not had a bad experience yet. The lunch sandwiches are excellent and come with a tomato bisque that I wish they had on the regular menu - I would order it all the time! Vegetalian sandwich is one of my favorites - mozzarella, pesto and fried eggplant - excellent. Fred's chopped salad is also a favorite, as is the bruschetta dip assortment. They usually have seafood specials on the menu as well as a variety of seafood dishes. Decent selection of local draft beers as well. Will have to try the wine or beer flights one of these days. Wish I could get there more often. read more