Dante's Pizza has been serving Columbus since 1973, and after this visit it's easy to see why they've been around for more than 50 years. Our group sampled four different pizzas: Pepperoni & Sausage, Mushroom & Black Olive, Pepperoni with Green Pepper & Onion, and the All the Way. We also tried the gluten-free pepperoni pizza. Every one of them was outstanding. When it comes to pepperoni and sausage pizza, Dante's has long been my personal favorite. The crust is right in the middle, not thick and doughy, and not cracker thin. The sauce is lightly applied with a nice balance of sweetness and tanginess that lets the toppings shine. What really sets Dante's apart is their sausage. It's a traditional Italian fennel-based sausage made from founder Joe's original recipe. We learned that Wieland's Market, just a few doors away, still makes that custom sausage exclusively for Dante's. It has a distinctive flavor you simply don't find on most pizzas, and it's the reason I keep coming back. Our server, Gavin, was outstanding, and it was a pleasure meeting Pat, who has been making pizzas there for decades. Great food, great people, and a classic Columbus pizza tradition. One tip before you visit: Dante's does not accept credit cards. They do accept cash, checks, Venmo, and Zelle. Highly recommended. read more

See all

lots of room for improvement let me tell you what tastes like something i'd get from a bar at 2 am! put it in the fridge for tomorrow, and then it ... tastes like cardboard! what can dante do to improve his pizza folks? read more

Family dinners include a tasty salad and are great for a family of 4. We also loved the pepperoni pizza and the sausage with peppers.

So we were at a yelp event at Winston's across the street and decided to try this pizza spot because we didn't feel like cooking and wanted to try a new pizza place for us! Well I'm so glad we did! THEY DONT TAKE APPLE PAY OR ANY CARD PAYMENTS!!! cash, Zelle and Cash App only! Baby they was packed and busy! So we got the 12in 3 topping pizza and it was $17.70! Everyone was really nice and did tell us their sauce is garlic forward and huni he wasn't lying! NORE DO THEY SKIMP ON THE TOPPING THANK YOU BTW! We got pep, sausage and ham with extra sauce and they put the extra sauce on top OMG!!! IT WAS DELICIOUS!!! The sausage was perfectly cooked and the ham was crispy! There is an area to sit down and dine with some decor on the walls and it was very cute! Now they do have take out options also because baby they was pumping them take out orders out like hot cakes! So glad we found them because we definitely will be back! My crust was a little too hard for me but that's ok! Everything else was still delicious! And customer service was amazing! read more

See all

Great pizza. Everyone is very friendly who work there. Definitely stopping by again next time I'm in the area.

Since we were in the area we always want to stop in at Dante's Pizzeria. We had a great experience during our last visit so we wanted to patron this establishment again. It did not disappoint. We ordered the 14" pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. The atmosphere is amazing and I loved the rotating Budweiser Clydesdale horse and carriage light fixture. Christina the owner is the best. So friendly and attentive to everyone. Love this local mom and pop shop. Will definitely visit again. read more

See all

A Clintonville institution who still takes cash, checks, and Venmo. I realized it had been quite a while since I'd stopped in so on Pizza Night I called in my order, and showed up 20 minutes later to pay for it and pick it up. They use the crispy pepperoni and make the sausage in-house. It's got a little black pepper kick or another spice that makes it zingy but not enough to burn off your taste buds. Still a solid choice after all these years. read more

Small pizzeria with a big heart feel, you can watch them prepare your pizza upon entering the restaurant. Food; Started with Salad, which was very very good loaded with fresh ingredients. Pizza, ordered a pep, sausage and mushroom was delicious, the meats were all tasty. One of my top places so far. The beer was cold, and hit the spot. Service, everyone was great. read more

See all

Great old school Columbus Pizza, one of the best in the whole area, great ingredients and the people running the place you can tell li what they do in making fantastic pizza read more

Walk in, take a deep breath, and boom--you're hit with the scent of molten cheese and decades of pizza glory. The waiting area is roughly the size of a coat closet on a budget airline, but somehow five locals and a delivery guy are packed in, swapping life stories and sauce recommendations. The staff knows everyone's name, favorite topping, and probably their cholesterol levels. It's like a secret pizza society, and we got a taste of the initiation. We grabbed a large pepperoni and sausage, and it was perfect. The kind of pizza that makes you suspicious of all other pizzas. Crispy, cheesy, greasy in that glorious "I'm-living-my-best-life" kind of way. If you're looking for sleek modern vibes and kale on the menu--keep walking. If you want pizza made with love, served in a spot where the 1970s never left, and nobody wants them to--welcome home. I took some extra "action shots" while I waited for my pie - they all looked very good read more

See all

Old time traditional-high quality-excellent pizza. The aromas, the flavors, the appearance...reminds me of what really good pizza used to be....and here it is at Dante's....well....who knew?! I'll be back. (I ordered carryout...but I'll dine-in also soon and leave another review later.) read more

For years I've been hearing that I need to try place. So last Saturday was the day. I was in the area wasn't really hungry but I did want to try. I ordered a pep, sausage, Ohio, garlic and banana pepper. As I was waiting on my order the incredible smell got to me. So once I got to the car I couldn't wait to try. Of course I burnt all the skin off the top of my mouth but still so good. Let me tell you that one peace wasn't going to do it so as I was driving I took another and another piece of like I said I was driving and this thing incredible crust held up. Not one topping ended up in my lap or on my shirt must of had 5 or 6 pieces on my way home (pic of what was left when I got home) The balm e of flavors was near perfect, maybe a bit more garlic would have been nice for my liking would have been nice but like I said near perfect. It wasn't lacking in any other topping and cheese. The staff was extremely friendly My only regret was not trying this place sooner. Will definitely return. Also I will just add I purposefully didn't eat it all cause I wanted to see how good it was the next day. Loved it out of the fridge also micro waived a few pieces turned out very good but air frying was perfect. Can't go wrong with this place. read more

Dante's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The best! Jeff and Christina treat their guests like family. Great pizza, homemade soups, cocktails. A great neighborhood institution, where community and hospitality are every bit as important as delicious, quality food. read more

This mom and pap pizzeria couldn't get any better. The pizza is one of a kind. The sauce is delicious and it's the perfect ratio of toppings and cheese. They used to be cash only but now accept Venmo. My only wish is that I had discovered them sooner! read more

Dante's Pizza - three slices of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We tried Dante's for the first time this week. I'd rate it a solid middle of the road option - we got Ezzo pep as our topping because it's one of my favorites. We also got a quart of salad, which came pre-dressed in their oily dressing but lacked flavor. Overall, it isn't terrible but it wouldn't ever be my first choice. It was just a bit greasy and soggy for me. As with most of my pizza reviews, I like to mention how it tastes day-old cold from the fridge. The outside crusty pieces were best, albeit a bit chewy. Overall, it was fine but not great. The best thing was the ezzo pepperoni. Also, they have the flimsiest boxes I've ever seen. Like a donut box. Better than the Bexley pizza joint that wraps it in paper, but barely. read more

Dante's Pizza - Ezzo pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This is the first time I tried Dantes! I got 14 Pepperoni and cheese with extra pepperoni and cheese. Wow it was fantastic! I loved everything about it! The flavor was so good. I will be back soon. There was a number family and I could tell they all was regulars and getting hugs. It a small dinning area but very clean and comfortable. The time my husband and I will eat there. It smelled so good there and all the way home. I did not know they was only cash, Zelle, Vermont that was not issue I work for Huntington and I sent money thru Zelle. I am going to add sausage and I looking for to trying sausage sub. I was so impressed and Dantes will be one of my favorites! Darlene Lewis read more

This place makes top 3 pizza restaurants list in the city. Christina and Jeff are extremely welcoming. Wish you guys nothing but the best. I will be a regular. read more

First time visitors this evening. So very good! The staff was fantastic from the moment you step in the door all the way through your dinner experience and out the door. Service is key to me and everyone was fantastic. Very authentic and it was very refreshing. Beer and wine only. Glasses of wine are $6 a piece and they have red and whites. We split an Italian sub and a 10" veggie which was SO VERY GOOD. There are about 12 tables total in the small dining room and it's a casual environment. When you go in simply take a seat and you'll be waited on - we didn't know we stood to wait to be seated - not necessary. Small enough dining room. Dante's takes cash/check or VENMO - no credit cards. Kind of unique but super smart on their part. We paid with cash and what I love about Dante's is observing the locals :). With every take out order that was placed, everyone was super casual and chill and they all know the routine. I loved this place. So long as they have beer/wine options I'm golden. That light crust was amazing. I'm almost sorry we only split a 10" pizza. I def could have done more! read more

Always amazing pizza, salad and subs! Love their homemade sausage! I craved it with my first born(26 years ago). It still taste the same. Their cauliflower crust is amazing as well. read more

Every time I pass Dantes, I say I'm going to order so I finally got myself a Friday night pizza. Right now, they're pick up only. It took about 20 minutes for 1 pizza, which was pretty awesome. I grabbed a couple of groceries from Weilands, and my pizza was ready. Good cheese to sauce ratio. Plenty of topping. I really liked the crust, thin but still a little chewy. I like something between paper thin and doughy, and Dantes nailed it. I think I found a new spot! read more

Dante's Pizza - Med cheese and onion pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We just picked up a pizza from Dante's, our favorite pizza place. They accidentally gave me the wrong pizza (there were two of us with the same name). I called to tell them about the mix up. Ten minutes later someone showed up at our front door with the right pizza. Now that's service! Good people. read more

This restaurant has been a part of my life for as long as I can remember, and it's still just as welcoming as it was when I was a kid. The pizza is absolutely amazing--comforting, consistent, and made with care. It's a true family-owned, small business, and you can feel that warmth the moment you walk in. A local gem that deserves all the support it can get. read more

Omg!, we ordered a large supreme pizza to pick up and it was the best pizza we have ever eaten! I am so glad we finally took everyone's advice and tried this perfect gem located in Clintonville!! read more

Review update. Great job with the remodeling! Looks great with homage paid to their history. Still great food. Just wish they took debit cards but we go prepared. read more

See all

This was the first time I had ever had Dante's. Just the smell from inside in the parking lot was a good indicator that this was going to be some bomb pizza. As soon as I walked into the shop, a smiling greeted me and checked me out. I did have to wait a little bit for the large Everything Pizza to be done, but it was delicious. It's definitely worth the wait. This hole in the wall is definitely going to be a go-to. The little seating area was also a plus; quiet and intimate. read more

Hidden gem! Amazing food. Great and friendly staff. Love the sausage for pizza. One of the best italian subs in Columbus. Their soups are incredible too. read more

A few things before the pizza & other food options...The updated dining room is fantastic. Nothing fancy, just a cozy clean local pizza joint. The staff was also A+. We were welcomed upon arriving and our server/owner was friendly and attentive. The food...The pizza.... Wish I lived closer. Maybe the owners could be persuaded into a 2nd location in Lewis Center??? I'd would have it on a minimum of once a week dinner rotation. I enjoy a well cooked crispy crust. Dante's nails this. Sauce and cheese were quality and happy to see they offered a Columbus staple Ezzo pepperoni. We are typically simple pepperoni pizza lover but based on reviews I've read we opted to add sausage. Never again will I get a Dante's pizza without it. Phenomenal. Has to be made in house or something. We had a side salad and the soup special as well and were completely satisfied. I almost ordered soup to go. Bonus they have beer, wine and a decent little bourbon selection too. Yes please. Anytime we are near by and sometimes not, Dantes will be getting a repeat customer. Worth the extra drive from home. read more

We enjoyed stopping by the remodeled spot. As it has only been reopened for about a week, lots of locals are coming back in to see the updates and check back in with old friends, which was really wonderful to see. We both ordered pepperoni pizza and it was good, nice and cheesy, thinner crust / very little crust area. Still only going cash or check, so be prepared! We will happily come back again. read more

OG excellent Columbus style pizzeria takeout in Clintonville! Very nice local owners.FYI it's cash only.

Dante's what can I say? The crust, the sauce, the fresh toppings, EVERYTHING about their pizza hits the mark. I have to say Dante's ranks in my top 5 pizza spots of Columbus. If you're looking for a good pie in Clintonville, look no further. Bring cash or a check, leave with a pizza, and enjoy the heavenly bliss that is Dante's. They also have tasty pasta which you can get in a family meal, it's a good bang for your buck and their meat balls are amazing. read more

I drive by this place five nights a week and see people working their butts off and think, "damn, are they that busy? Is this pizza that good"? And I finally got to try it. It's a small shop hidden in a corner of a larger plaza on Indianola. I'd never have noticed it if I wasn't going to the gym next door. I ordered two large pizzas and had a $2 coupon. After tax it was $30. The price was very fair and it was worth it. You'll see from the pictures, they are loaded with toppings. Their homemade sausage and pepperoni is simply delicious. The pizza is thin crust and cooked perfectly with a nice crunch. And not greasy. They know what they're doing here. Will definitely go back again. Plenty of parking and pickup only. Was made in 20 minutes. read more

See all

Outstanding. Consistently delicious pizza & salad with house Italian dressing. Been going there since I was a child! LB read more

Pepperoni is amazing. Good service, friendly and fast. I love this pizza. It's consistent and delicious. The salad and garlic bread you can pass on, nothing special, but don't miss out on a meatball! read more

Dante's is the quintessential local pizza parlor. It may look terrible inside and out, and the staff is crusty and terrifying. They don't take credit cards, or deliver right around the corner. It makes up for it all with their Midwest pie. They also have beer so kick ass. I ordered a large vegetable. It was ready in about 20 minutes. The large is about $10 to $12. It's not the cheapest but the quality is much better than most of the competitors. The pizza was thin cut into squares. It's not my way of cutting pizza but otherwise it was good. They also have other menu items like subs. It also serves beer if you're eating inside. The dining room is really tiny with few tables unfortunately so it would be hard to do so. I want authenticity and Dante's certainly has some. It's what neighborhood pizza should be. This place is small inside so you should order takeout. read more

Dante's Pizza - Vegetable Sub - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

One of my favorite pizzas I've ever had, the quality of the meat and the care into the bake of the pie is incredible. Columbus has some serious eats! Dantes has my loyalty! Mich Ultra to swig. Boom! read more

Last night I bought my 2nd Pizza from Dante's, and, as I imagined it would be, it was delicious. Made the way I wanted and hoped for, which is more than a scant amount of the add-ons I requested. With the previous owner the pizza was good but I couldn't always count on generosity. Made ready at the time specified by them. My only hope for them, is that they continue in their present mode, and for which, I expect they will. read more

Love this little gem in Clintonville. The business is old school- only accepting checks or cash. Food was excellent and prompt. All the employees were helpful and kind, and it's always a good sign when there's lots of regulars when you go inside! There is also a space to sit and eat. read more

This pizza is good, and it's local, a huge plus. I just wanted to point out that a lot of people are saying they only take cash or check. A true millennial, I never have any of these things, but take heart! VENMO IS A PAYMENT OPTION! Thanks for serving those of us who have eliminated wallets from our lives, but still want fresh, local 'za. read more

The owners and staff at Dante's are so warm and friendly, and are slinging the best pizza in Columbus. Crisp, chewy crust, flavorful toppings and the perfect balance of cheese and sauce. My go-to topping combos are tomato & onion and sausage & green pepper. The sausage is homemade and steals the show. I feel so fortunate to have Dante's in my neighborhood - they stand above the rest when it comes to Columbus-style thin crust pizza. read more

Dante's has been my favorite pizza in Columbus for more than fifteen years. The interior recently received a facelift under new ownership, which has only improved the experience in the restaurant. This is a must-have every time I visit Columbus! read more