You know the 50's Hollywood version of Brooklyn you think of? Go to this place (and the whole surrounding area basically) and you get the real life version. Walking into D'Amicos is like walking into the past, a really charming past. If you LOVE coffee you'll love a lot about this place. You can smell the coffee a'roasting from at least a block away. The sandwiches are great. The older Italian guys who hang out in front are keepers. Love This Place! read more

This is the basicly not even worth thinking about. It is just the best place to buy coffee beans, hands down. The people are local and I think have each been working there since the begining of time. I have tried a few Colombian and Kenyan blends that were good, the carroll gardens blend that was a little to light for my perticular brand, the red hook blend which was good and little darker, and the house blend. I like the house blend for drip but my beau got it esspresso ground and WOOOO! So damn good. The pounds range from $8 to $14ish? So its not like you are spending more than you would at the grocery. Another great little specialty spot in Carroll Gardens! read more

The expectations are high. The competition for good espresso in this city is getting fierce and 'amanti di un buon espresso' (espresso lovers) rejoice! So is it the best? No Is it good. Yes, very good. Unfortunately we are in 2011 and sleek looking, with fully trained baristi, highly technical process, and freshly trucked in - perfectly roasted beans are not missing from the city. Where does this leave D'Amico? A little behind. You taste an espresso at Culture Espresso on 37th and its thick and fruity, yummy. This is America at its best. It takes something done forever and it improves it to make a better product by applying technique and carefully managed process. D'Amico is a quaint old establishment, full of dust and old jars, representative of a by-gone era where you can get still get an old school espresso, made from good fresh beans. Should they clean up, blow the dust off their shelf and off their espresso making process? Damn sure they should, and that would bring them to truly be the best espresso on the east coast, one where history and tradition marries modern espresso making techniques. The opportunity is there. read more

I love this place for the following reasons: - takes credit card - delicious sandwiches (uses boars head meats) - tiramisu flavored coffee - park slope blend coffee mmm - they have a coffee handbook that explains all their coffees in great detail - friendly and helpful staff read more

D'Amico may be one of my top five accidental finds in NY since moving here four years ago. Dat scent ya'll. I'd been brewing Stumptown or Blue Bottle at home for years and while they're a mighty fine family of gourmet coffees I started to resent paying almost fifteen bucks for a half pound of beans. I've found D'Amico to be just as good for half the price and also a way to support your local caffeine slinger. If you can't find what you're lookin for here then it don't exist my friend. The Gowanus blend pours like motor oil and backs a rich and bitter punch that will make you wince at your office's k-cup machine. Buy whole bean and get a grinder. Biiiiiiiiig difference and worth the extra minute of prep. read more

I was a little sad walking in recently to see that they've "hipsterized" the decor and layout, but thankfully the coffee is still great. I guess I can't get too sad: I'm a 20something transplant that buys whole bean coffee and writes Yelp reviews for heavens sake; they hipsterized for me. That being said, the coffee and the staff are still first rate. The shop smells like heaven, and they've got at least 20 different kinds of coffees to choose from. Whether you like something light and blonde or something dark and bitter, they have a range of both single bean and blends. And if you don't know what you want? The staff is more than willing to help. We stopped by at an off time (a weekday evening) and were able to chat with the employees for about 15 minutes, before walking away with two different kinds of coffee that have both been excellent. I can't wait to try every kind (except the light blends because those just aren't my style), and in the long run, I'd rather have a hipster D'Amico than none at all. read more

This little coffee shop is SO GOOD. They've been roasting their own coffee in the shop since sometime in the 1940's, and the coffee is BRILLIANT. It's not overly acidic, it's not super floral tasting like a lot of the bougie shops popping up around town... it's just great, dark, complex, coffee. And the breakfast sandwiches are pretty spot-on, too. Also, sometimes they'll give you a free small coffee with a breakfast sandwich. I mean.. what? Best deal in the city. read more

I love me some d'Amico. It's well-nigh impossible to pass by its ancient storefront without being seduced by the aroma of roasting coffee beans (a process which, by the way, makes the shop VERY cozy in the summer, AC notwithstanding.) And be seduced! Both by the ground-to-order beans (I like the dark-roasted Red Hook blend) and a cup from the self-service station in the back of the store. (NB: If you are getting iced coffee, ask for ice from the guy behind the little coffee counter.) The scene here is the real deal. Carroll Gardens old-timers while the day away at the back tables, winter and summer, joking with the owner and the highly competent and knowledgable Chris. In fact, when d'Amico goes on summer vacation, the guys still hang out on the benches out front! They make sandwiches here and have baked goods (some of them from nearby Margaret Palca) but personally I go for the coffee and the ambiance. Please note my impartiality. I still bestow a glowing review, even after failing to win the naming contest for a new, South American blend. "Mambo Italiano", people! The winning name can't have been as brilliant. read more

It aches my heart that someone will actually complain about the smell of coffee this place produces.. really people? really? This place roasted it's coffee the old fashion way and the beans are always fresh and smell amazing! In the warm heat of summer I was always going in and getting the hazelnut cold coffee with some cream, it tastes almost sweet so need for sugar. Never had a better cup of coffee read more

It's not often that I find myself in Brooklyn, but I recently got to know some of it's charms, and D'Amico is definitely one of them. It reminds me of my beloved Empire back in Hell's Kitchen as a shabby yet cozy place to get a cup or a pound of what you know is going to be amazing coffee. Stick with the beans as the pastries are pretty lackluster, as are the surroundings. But what it lacks in presentation it makes up for in charm and coffee roasting skills. This place has been around for 80 years, and I bet it'll be around 80 more. If I ever make the move to Brooklyn, I have a feeling this is where I'll get my grounds. read more

D'Amico Coffee - Coffee Roasteries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love this place: a slice of old Carroll Gardens. Great beans, freshly roasted, from all over the place. Also, great sandwiches. You can get fresh Italian [fill in meat of choice], w/ cheese and roasted peppers (!) on a roll for about $4. Just to correct a couple of misconceptions in other reviews: 1) they are now open Sundays, until around 3 PM, and 2) you can get a cappuccino or latte, in the back. read more

I brought in a bag of coffee beans from Blue Bottle once and shamelessly asked if they could grind them. Guy glanced at the bag (with Blue Bottle's logo imprinted on it), shrugged, and asked, "Espresso grind?" I offered to pay, but he waved me away. Later, I realized it had been kind of a dick move. So days later, I came back to actually buy something. You wouldn't think it from peering in, but the cappuccino is literally the best I've had in Carroll Gardens, which is saying a lot for a neighborhood peppered with good coffee places. It was delightfully creamy with a generous amount of tickly foam. The olive loaf (cured meat studded with green olive slices) on a roll tasted like Italy! It was all I could do to prevent myself from belting out "That's Amore!" Granted, the place is a bit dingy, but it's not unhygienic - just old. In fact, the homey space really grows on you. I couldn't help overhearing one of the owners lamenting about how to spruce up the interior. I wanted to tell her, "Don't! It's great the way it is." I do hope she sees this. read more

I was banking on the good reviews. Another let down. Come on, Brooklyn, really?!?! I tried the Red Hook blend, Hazelnut and White Christmas. None of them had any body or robustness whatsoever. This is the kind of coffee that needs cream and sugar to be drinkable. I guess if you're more of a mild, breakfast blend kind of person you would probably like D'Amico's coffee. I, on the other hand, will never return. read more

There is a feeling one gets when they've been hit by a brick reading the sentence ''Yeah, this was right under your nose the whole time... you schmuk.' I know this feeling intimately, especially after stepping into D'Amico's. I walked into D'Amico after using the last dregs of my Lavazza reserves (I know, I know...) as I haven't had time to pass by Stumptown. I had seen the reviews for D'Amico's and decided, why not? Thank god I was in a trying mood. After browsing the wall of amazing smelling beans the owner asked me some questions. I felt like I was at a beauty counter getting my personal fragrance. Then he told me 'Vienna' with absolutely no reservations. Vienna. Like I was being told the whole of my life's future in one word. I bought a bag and left with a quizzical grin. Immediately upon entering my kitchen I got my stovetop coffee-maker out and started a-brewing. I am now sitting, writing one sentence and taking one sip in turn as I cannot put it down. I don't know if this means I am easy to read or if the owners are just that good but, I can honestly say I don't give a damn. This is the best cup of coffee I have had this side of the Arno or Hudson. I love my Stumptown but, for the prices and the amazing service, D'Amico, you have a new addict to supply. read more

Go directly to D'amico's for coffee. Do not pass go. There is no better coffee with less hullaballoo than D'amico's. Anywhere. Walk in, pour your own from the selection of 5-6 blends in the back or iced coffee, and up to the register at the front you go. P.S. I like to think it's the guys who work at the 3 (three!) local funeral homes who are yakking in serious Brooklyn accents at the cafe tables in the back. Gives neighborhood newbies like me a small thrill. read more

Hours are not very reliable. I have come here before and the place was closed for a private party. Make sure to call before to confirm they are open. This issue aside, their Brazilian beans are fantastic. If you get the Groupon they offer, it is also an awesome deal. Enjoy! read more

Every single time I go back to my parents' house to visit, I have to smuggle this stuff across state lines. Their drug of choice? Hazelnut Cream- whole bean, not ground. I love doing them the favor- the place just IS Brooklyn. It smells like Brooklyn, it sounds like Brooklyn, and it sure as hell tastes like Brooklyn. My drug of choice is an Italian sub with peppers and fresh mozarella. It's huge and delicious and only $6 for the whole thing! People seriously still go to Subway and Dunkin's? I just don't understand... read more

What better time to say something about the folks at D'Amico than now, as I just sat down to a cup of fresh ground, fresh brewed coffee purchased from them. First thing that hits you when you enter is the roaster (I miss the old one) and the smell that comes from it. Any caffeine jones is you might be having could be satisfied by that alone, but taking the bag home is the treat. Prepared self-serve coffees in the back are always fresh (try the Red Hook blend if you like strong coffee), and in the summer they have a ice-coffee frozen slushy type drink that -while a bit on the sweet side for me- is perfect when you feel like having your caffeine but don't want to ingest anything warmer than body-temperature. Brewing tools and utensils are along the shelves, usually whatever you're looking for they've got. Behind the counter are Italian cold-cuts, a fresh roast of beef daily for sandwiches. I think bottom line with D'Amico is the very character of the place. They're not modeled after a corporate guideline or stringent rules of behavior, this is a family business with enough charm and character to develop a sitcom around. There's a certain comfort in seeing the same faces, always affable and welcoming, and knowing that they understand I am there for my two-pounds; Columbia-light House-dark blend, whole bean. Ready for my second cup! read more

I can't walk by D'Amico and not stop for coffee, as there is always the scent of freshly roasting beans that always draws me in! They are a neighborhood staple and serve the best coffee ! There is an abundance of different roasts/blends of beans so you are sure to find one you like! I also frequently bring a lb of beans home for holidays, etc and my family always looks forward to it! All of the staff are so nice and very helpful. As far as price, it is beyond reasonable for the quality of coffee! read more

I recently moved to the neighborhood and I have been trying to find a good coffee shop. As I walked by D'Amico I could smell pure caffeine emanating from the coffee roaster in the window and I heard an old man out front swearing in Italian... I decided to go inside. It was like stepping back in time one whole wall is filled with containers of coffee beans for sale, which I assume they roast themselves (see reference to roaster above) and across from that is a deli counter full of fantastic looking Italian meats. Oh yeah and you can buy a cup of coffee too, 16oz is only $1.75, it's sad how exciting that is. So far I've tried the House Light Blend which was a good everyday roast, the Copenhagen which is of a similar strength with a really interesting flavor to it, nothing over the top just really rich. Today, I had the Red Hook Blend which is their dark roast and is fantastic... It's still rich and tasty and doesn't have that charcoal taste that dark roasts sometimes get, but its got all the kick you could ever want. As soon as I unpack the coffee pot I will definitely be buying my beans there... their prices were fantastic and its such a satisfyingly old school place. read more

While I realize this quirky old place must be special for many people, I'm sorry: I must join the legions of people complaining about the roasting. Terrible cloud when they roast stinks up the block for years and years now. So sick of it. If you're going to roast coffee, fine: just don't stink up the block. It's like burnt toast and Lucky Strike cigs. EVERYWHERE. That, and the beans are mediocre crap. Sorry: admit it. read more

I miss this coffee! My parents bought their beans here and I continued to be a customer until I moved from the area. Maybe nostalgia prevents me from being more objective but all the coffee I've purchased anywhere since seems inferior by comparison. I am only commenting about the coffee here because I have no other fond memories of the place. The family was cranky and the then regulars always hanging around the place were obtuse, unpleasant, and unattractive. I am sympathetic to the complaints about the roasting smell permeating the neighborhood. To me it smelled like brewed coffee on the burner way too long. It gave me heartburn just the same. Luckily I lived in BH and the stink didn't reach that far. read more

I tried the hazelnut coffee, which was yummy with no sugar needed. I didn't purchase any whole beans coffee since my French press have been packed away back at my parents, but I must say as a first timer this place got the charms of being a good local spot where I can imagine regulars hanging out there all day. I came after work, and arrived half a hour before they close. I managed to get some work done, and even stayed there about 10 minutes over with no one bothering me or telling me anything. The staff is ...(thinking of the right words) most pleasing group of people that you can find in a coffee shop. They are mainly older age Italians which is adorable because even though the store got hipsterized the heart and soul of the shop still remains through the staff. I was greeted by a lady in the counter that told the other patron to wait a minute so she can serve me because I got there first. She also guided me through the condiment bar and brought out soy milk for me with no complaints. When asked what time the store closes (which is 20 minutes later), she assure me that I can stay until the closing time. (I actually ended up staying later since there were so many locals still in the sitting area while they started cleaning up.) Overall, this place is far from home but I am definitely glad I visited. read more

Surprised at the great reviews of this place. I visited 4 times and had a few complaints: Flimsy cups & supplies: this coffee shop has clearly not invested in presentation. The coffee lids are flimsy and see through, the straws are weak and bend/break, there are no stirrers provided, coffee is self-serve. Poor / sour taste: I was surprised because the roaster in the back suggests that the coffee ingredients here are fresh but the espresso was bitter all of the times that I tried it. I will say that the staff was very kind and attentive - no issues there. Also it looked like people were having a nice time relaxing and reading in the back. It does have more of a cheap breakfast place vibe than a fancy coffee shop. However, the prices were fair and I didn't feel like I was overpaying for a hipster vibe like I do at Blue Bottle and Birch sometimes. read more

Don't need to say more than I walked in here, stayed for a couple of hours doing some work and walked out smelling like heaven! Read the other reviews for more helpful stuff. (: read more

No need to repeat all reviews below. Everything said is perfect. Wonderful coffee. I've only tried the Red Hook blend, but will be spending the next 12 months exploring all the different verities. Love this neighborhood. read more

D'Amico Coffee - Coffee Roasteries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

D'Amico has a very interesting and eclectic mix of inexpensive drip coffees and other coffees by the pound to choose from. It's clearly a place with a history and not just a passing-by hip coffee place. The guy at the register was very nice, but the owner seemed angry and pissed for no reason. Also the music was way too loud for studying. I liked all the coffee flavors, hot chocolate options, etc - very cheap, too - but I felt kind of unwanted, so I wouldn't come back. read more

Very friendly staff, decent price for fresh and always yummy never burnt coffee. They have grinders there or you can get whole beans and bring them home. It's a hike but they have the best coffee I've had so it's always worth the trip. I've always paid cash but I believe they also take credit cards. read more

I really wanted to like this old-school coffee shop. I wandered over from my office, hoping to find something better than the drip joe available there. Sadly, the office brew was better than what D'Amico served -- by a long shot. The old-school charm of the ambience sadly meant old-school coffee methods. It's been awhile since I've had that abrasive gasoline-tinged brown water we used to accept as coffee. Given how much the game has been upped, this sad coffee shop seems stuck in the slow lane, falling further and further behind. They get points for nostalgia -- yes coffee did suck that bad back in the 80s! read more

For those seeking coffee: Go here for the drip coffee. Avoid if you are looking for a milk coffee. The cappuccino was not properly made, by a long shot. The service was friendly. read more

Legit coffee. They make a proper espresso and proper cappuccino. There's a reason why the old school Italians still hang there. They're always kind to my kids. Back in the day, they would shoo away my Husband when he was a kid because he liked to stop by often and smell the beans roasting. read more

I have to admit, D'Amico Coffee was definitely magnificent. Sooooo good and well priced. Every thing that we purchased was extra fresh and tasty. The servers are pretty welcoming and attentive. D'Amico Coffee is just awesome. read more

I don't think I've had better coffee... Their iced coffees are so rich in flavor and there's always great speculation that coffee is not meant to be served cold. D'Amico proves otherwise. read more

Easily the best coffee anywhere. I've travelled from Florida just to get a taste of this sweet brew. And their sandwiches are on point! Stop by if you're anywhere near D'Amico's. If I had a coffee shop Top 20, this would be #1! read more

Really good sandwiches. My wife got the Pastrami and I got the buffalo chicken. They were served on toasted fresh rolls and were really tasty. Well done! read more

As other reviewers have pointed out, this is a store that time forgot... Which means incredible quality of ingredients. The store is laid out in an amusingly inefficient way, and has a "we've done it this way for 80 years, so why would we change now?" vibe to it. Service can really slow, especially if you ask for sandwiches which are amazing. The first time I asked for a sandwich the woman left to the store to go buy more bread from the bakery down the street. Worth the wait! If your in a rush take your blackberry and bluetooth headset and head elsewhere :) read more

I haved tried several of their beans and so far the only one that stands out is the French Vanilla. Well balanced vanilla to coffee flavor with the coffee flavor the best of what I have tried. I will update with any other standouts I discover as I have a few more to go through. Be watchful when they fill the bean bags they tend to try and hide the scale with certain beans I suspect to cheat you somehow, minus 1 star for that. read more

Two words: fantastic coffee! I have been eyeing this place for awhile, and I finally went in today. I tried the Red Hook blend with a tiny bit of chocolate coffee on top, and it was amazing! The coffee was very strong and had a clean taste. We also had the chocolate chip banana cake, and it was moist and sweet- just as expected. Can't wait to go back and try the other flavors! read more

This will be my 25th year of House Blend Dark addiction; simply my favorite and only coffee I drink. As a matter of course at work I bring 1/2 lb bags to colleagues and customers around the country and Canada. It is always happily received and I always get thanked and told how amazing the coffee is. D'Amico's is the same homey neighborhood place as it's always been even after the renovation and it's always a home coming (every 2 weeks to feed my jones). Many of the low ratings on here have nothing to do with the coffee...can't find the sink outside the bathroom (the one you have to walk past to get to to get to the bathroom)?! Really? Paper thin meat? Those sandwiches are overloaded. Etc. Don't ever change D'Amico's! Your authenticity is refreshing and your coffee is the best (so sayeth countless American and Canadian cities and towns, Botswana, South Africa, and more). read more

The White Christmas Holiday Blend iced coffee may sound like an oxymoron, but once you have it, you don't care because it is on point! I hope they keep this blend as an iced option all summer. Christmas in July! read more