A favorite of ours since it opened and continues to deliver at a high level. The culinary flavors are fantastic and the food is just full of flavors. In addition the service is always five stars and the ambiance is excellent.. Don't miss out on going to Cutthroat and enjoy all they offer. read more

Cutthroat Club - Brisket dinner - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

See all

75$ bloody (ordered medium well) steak sent back to kitchen for 20 minutes while I watched my wife eat her filthy fries (fitting name) which made her sick all night. Over 150$ for bad food!! Got me 3 times in a year... save yourself the bathroom trips and your hard earned money! Only good experience was the bartender after getting the wrong beer (charged full price for mistakes?) read more

Cutthroat Club - 75$ New York jerky - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

See all

Wonderful historic building with a very attentive and delightful staff. The dishes are beautifully plated and the crème Brulé Alone is worth the drive from sun valley to Bellview ! read more

See all

Bad services for everyone over prism and duty bathroom food was cold and no taste b very expensive

Went for our anniversary ordered Chicken Milanese . It was rubbery and flavorless over zucchini slices and gnocchi. Sauce tasted like Ragu. Chicken tasted like it was thawed in the microwave and baked with cheese and breadcrumbs. It looked nice but tasted like tough abalone. Had mushroom appetizer tasted like mushrooms boiled in beef broth. Salmon cake was okay but had a fishy taste. My husband had perch was crispy fried potatoes tasted undercooked potatoes or stale tasting. Paid $200. Wine was very average tasting. Won't recommend and won't return. Waitress was friendly but lacked professional edge. read more

Was on a road trip and stopped in to the Cutthroat Club for a quick dinner. The restaurant is housed in a beautiful old building and the decor suits it perfectly with an upgraded modern western feel. The staff is efficient and friendly and make great suggestions for food and drink. The food is absolutely amazing! Chef Rodney is a genius! One of our group is plant based and he created a beautiful dish for her to enjoy. If you're in the area, this is a 5 star stop! read more

See all

The food is so so good here. Even the happy hour food is amazing. We will be back 100% read more

This was the best meal we have had here in Idaho. The ambiance is amazing, the service was superb! The food was incredible. I am so glad we came! I had the organic chicken and it melted in my mouth the sides were awesome. My friend had the prime rib cooked perfectly. We also had an amazing appetizer! Perfect a must try restaurant. read more

Cutthroat Club - Crustini - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

See all

Love this food and atmosphere the food is some of the best I've ever had! 10/10 recommend

WOW. This place is incredible. 1) the food is terrific and 2) the portions are HUGE. Definitely worth a visit if in area (even if visiting Ketchum and need to drive a bit). The brisket was very tender and covered in a delicious au jus sauce. Other plates were equally as good. Our waitress Hailey was incredibly kind and the owner even stopped by to check in on us. Restaurant is very cute inside. 10/10 read more

See all

Thus is an excellent restaurant. The menu selections are creative and well prepared. The bar and eine lists are excellent. One of the best in the Big Wood Valley. Service was impeccable. read more

We went here to celebrate a special occasion and were very disappointed. We ordered the brisket and the walleye. We went midweek when they opened so there were only two tables in the dining room. The food came out very quickly, which we were pleased with until we started eating. Everything on the brisket plate was lukewarm at most. The meat was so extremely fatty that it was inedible. If our server had come to check on us after, we would have sent it back. If I could do it over, I would have gotten up and found someone remedy the situation. There's no good reason that a plate of food should come out so quickly after ordering it and not be at least warm, if not hot. It made us feel like we were getting old food and tainted the entire experience. The one positive was that the perch light and crispy. It's very unfortunate sounded good but not enough to return to find out. We took one of the two slabs of brisket home thinking we could "fix" it by rendering off some of the fat in a pan but it turned out to be irredeemably fatty. That's $38 down the drain. read more

Cutthroat Club - Extremely FATTY brisket. - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

We've been waiting a long time to go to this restaurant. Went for our anniversary and did a brunch. THE GOOD: the ambiance in the dining area is nice, the server and the bus staff were all friendly. THE BAD: We had the mussels / Basque sausage appetizer. Flavors were there, but you could tell it had been sitting under the heat lamp for too long. Butter sauce in the dish had coagulated and mussels were rubbery. I had the bay shrimp omelette (a brunch special) and I'm not kidding it was THE WORST omelette I've EVER had. Dry, flavorless, sad. I choked down half of it. My fiancé ordered the NY strip steak, asked for it medium and it came ruby red raw inside. Had to send it back. By then, we both lost our mojo for the brunch. SERVICE WAS TERRIBLE: Everyone seemed out of sync, not refilling our drinks, took forever to get our bill run, my fiancé took our bill to the bar himself. The server was frazzled and we literally had to keep flagging people down throughout the meal. We wanted to like this place, but sadly can't. For the prices, service, meat cooking, appetizer temperatures and a basic omelette should be flawless. All were pretty bad. We won't be back. read more

Once again amazing flavors, presentation and variety. The staff is incredible. the special could probably use their own menu.... So many amazing options to pick from, Ciara did an awesome job explaining all of those delectable entrees. The Ahi special, WOW! So well plated with a smattering of all the flavors in each bite. read more

Cutthroat Club - Ahi special - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

We tried this restaurant for the second time last night after a very disappointing first visit a year ago. Once again it was a very mixed experience. The salads were fantastic but the entrees were not. Two of us ordered the pork special - when I ordered it I told the server to ask the chef not to over-cook the pork and her response was "there is only one way to cook pork". Hmmm. Then it came out so touch I had to saw away with the steak knife so I sent it back. The other person at our table kept their's but said it was only because he was quite hungry. The third diner had the lasagne which he said was okay (served with cornbread, an odd pairing with lasagne). The fourth had fish that also was over-cooked. The server was not very well-trained plus was chewing gum and must have said, "Perfect!" countless times. We won't return. There are so many VERY good restaurants in the valley and this is not one of them. We don't understand all the great reviews! read more

Excellent food, great service, cool historic vibe. On the menu we tried the Caesar salad (delicious fresh croutons), ribeye bison (mouthwatering), muscles/sausage (huge muscles), Japanese style beef over rice. A wide variety of non-alcoholic bevies rounded us out nicely. IPA and lime tini. Desert looks amazing but we are so full. Will be taking home the bourbon bread pudding - yummo! read more

Service, food extraordinary, Owner Jay, worked the room, made everyone feel special. What a treat!!!!

Wonderful food and service. I had the halibut special and my husband had the beef. Both especially tasty and generous portion.

The best crab cake special for dinner last night!!! Also a drink special peach margaritas! For a southern girl both were amazing.

Fabulous spot a must in the Valley Great staff, food is a 10 Bring your appetite Fun atmosphere read more

The mussel and sausage appetizer dish was awesome. I can't wait to go back. We share two deserts. The bread pudding and the cheesecake. They were awesome as well. We are going back on Tuesday. read more

Hands down the best food in the Wood River Valley, and the best service, in the prettiest food. The portions are HUGE, so come hungry and bring a friend. read more

We all loved dinner at The Cutthroat Club. The duck was a big hit as was the Walleye and the beef tenderloin and the beet salad. There was one slight fail to my taste, the New Zealand Mussels. Huge and a bit tough. We also liked the bar menu! Service perfect, chatted with the chef- good story how he came to Hailey. Ambiance nice. Will probably be very noisy when busy. Go early? read more

Unreal food and amazing people, love this spot in Bellevue! Chef Jay is next level! Service is great along with the ambiance! (Love my Hulett sisters!) read more

Cutthroat Club - Pork Chop - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

See all

Great service and food that is creative and farm to table quality. Appetizers should be shared if you want any room left for entree. Would love it more if they had a full service bar. Atmosphere is pleasant and noisy. read more

Definitely worth visiting. The service is great. The food is amazing. Very tasty and huge portions. To top it off the prices are very reasonable. read more

Wow - thank goodness a great restaurant south of Hailey!! Place is amazing and the food is on point. The bar has great service with awesome beers and wines. Best Lamb I've ever had. read more

This is the place to go! The food is amazing and the staff were very friendly. Do not skip dessert; the butterscotch bread pudding was to die for. The restaurant is in an old bank and it's fun to look around at all the old details. read more

Cutthroat Club - Bison and butternut squash stew was one of the specials. It was wonderful! - Bars Near Me - Bellevue, Idaho

Website stated they were open until 3 p.m. on weekends. I called at noon to verify this and the girl who answered confirmed "yes, we are open until 3 p.m." With this confirmation, my wife and I made the decision to relax, take our time and get ready to go there at 2 p.m. We arrived just before 2 and were told they had closed because they were slow..... SERIOUSLY?!!! THIS IS HOW YOU TREAT YOUR CUSTOMERS?!!! "I'm very sorry....blah blah blah..." GO STUFF YOUR APOLOGIES!!!!! I WILL STAY HOME AND MAKE MY OWN, AND PROBABLY MUCH BETTER MEAL, IN THE FUTURE!!! read more

6 of us ate there last night and our food was cooked to perfection! The room was large but comfortable and inviting. Our service gal, Hailey, couldn't have been nicer. Friendly, fun and knowledgeable about all the food on the menu! All of us agreed we can't wait to go back again! read more

Finding great service and great food under the same roof is t easy these days .... until Now!!! The food was fantastic and large portions. Best waitress I have had in YEARS! Very relaxing atmosphere. This is the best restaurant in the valley and if you don't believe it give them a try! read more

Best restaurant in the valley. The menu is unique and the food is delicious. The staff are great and the whole restaurant has a nice ambiance. Would highly recommend for all locals and visitors! read more

Our food was exceptional and the service was top notch. We inadvertently arrived close to closing time. The staff was so accomodating and freindly that we didnt realize our error until all the other patrons left shortly after we placed our order. We received our order promptly. I had the cauliflower steak, the other 2 guests had the walleye and the brisket. The portions were generous enough that we were fully satisfied that evening and had enough for lunch the next day. I will definitely return to the Cutthroat Club next time I visit the area. read more

Cutthroat Club's food is top notch, French inspired but prepared in a simple and fresh manner! The servers are warm and attentive! The ambiance is the perfect blend of country chic where everyone feels welcome! A plus plus plus! read more

Worst service I've had, the beertender couldn't even truly greet us. We waited at least 5 minutes to be greeted while we were sitting at the bar. We ordered the pork belly, which came highly recommended by the beertender. It was so chewy it was barely edible. It was hard for my girlfriend and I to even decide if we wanted to try their primerib. We asked for it medium rare and it came out medium well, the flavor wasn't bad but at the price we should get the primerib cooked to the temperature we requested. We asked to talk to the chef and even he said it was medium, which is not what we ordered. We told Jay this isn't what we expected, he told us "get the fuck out of my restaurant or will we call the police". He then threatened me and said he would "beat the shit or of me outside". In all my years I've never experienced this from a pompous chef, but Jay takes the cake! Ambiance is great but for Ketchum prices it's a huge pass. read more

CC is continuing a long line of excellent restaurants at that location. Meal ( lamb), appetizers, and service were excellent and this was opening nite where bloopers are usually rampant. well done! read more