Custom Cookies by Jill

5.0 (9 reviews)

ModerateDesserts

Closed • 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Custom Cookies by Jill Photos

Custom Cookies by Jill - a variety of decorated cookies - Desserts Near Me

Custom Cookies by Jill - a variety of animal cookies - Desserts Near Me

+64

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Custom Cookies by Jill

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

I ordered a dozen cookies for my sister's bridal shower and they turned out absolutely gorgeous! From the details to the packaging, everything was done so beautifully. It was very easy to communicate with Jill and let her know my colors, styles, etc. These make such a thoughtful, unique gift--not to mention delicious--and I would definitely order from Jill again. I recommend her business for any event or special occasion!

I placed an order for custom cookies for a last minute birthday gift for a three-year-old cancer survivor. Jill responded quickly to my message and made the most beautiful and perfect cookies for the occasion. She was even able to create cookies with the logo of the nonprofit that I run as this was a gift from the organization. Everyone was very impressed with the cookies and even more impressed that Jill was able to create them on such short notice. I will definitely be ordering from Jill again in the future, and I highly recommend her.

See all

Adelia C.

1377

46

64

4 years ago

We are so thankful to have found custom cookies by Jill. Our cookie contact had an emergency and Jill came to the rescue. She not only helped us in a bind, but produced delicious quality cookies with our sponsors company logos printed on them in a short turnaround time. Everyone loved the cookies and it really was a hit! Thank you Jill for the amazing customer service, and quality product. read more

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Jennifer H.

12

11

4

3 years ago

Great service from start to finish! I was a little worried not having a phone number for direct contact, but Jill was very responsive via email and helpful with the design process. She offered different delivery options which was also great! The cookies were beautifully made, tasted delicious, and were hand delivered! I highly recommend Jill's services and will definitely be placing future orders with her! read more

Custom Cookies by Jill - Custom Cookies - Desserts Near Me

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

S S.

34

202

55

5 years ago

Jill is unbelievably talented. I asked for a very specific and detailed custom order and she made my cookies even more beautiful than I could have ever imagined. I try my best to support a lot of small business and I have failed miserably with other people who claim to make cookies but either do a sloppy job, or cannot make what I requested. But there is nothing Jill can't do! She does it all and it's all so beautiful! read more

Custom Cookies by Jill - Desserts Near Me

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Marcella S.

0

8

3

6 years ago

I ordered a dozen cookies for my sister's bridal shower and they turned out absolutely gorgeous! From the details to the packaging, everything was done so beautifully. It was very easy to communicate with Jill and let her know my colors, styles, etc. These make such a thoughtful, unique gift--not to mention delicious--and I would definitely order from Jill again. I recommend her business for any event or special occasion! read more

Custom Cookies by Jill - Custom bridal cookies - Desserts Near Me

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

H S.

0

5

1

6 years ago

I placed an order for custom cookies for a last minute birthday gift for a three-year-old cancer survivor. Jill responded quickly to my message and made the most beautiful and perfect cookies for the occasion. She was even able to create cookies with the logo of the nonprofit that I run as this was a gift from the organization. Everyone was very impressed with the cookies and even more impressed that Jill was able to create them on such short notice. I will definitely be ordering from Jill again in the future, and I highly recommend her. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Teresa N.

21

7

12

6 years ago

We absolutely loved the custom fire truck cookies for our son's 4th birthday. They were perfect and looked exactly like the picture. We could not have been happier. They were too beautiful to eat. I will always come to Jill for all future celebrations for my son. Thank you so much, Jill. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

mary z.

0

27

5

7 years ago

Beautiful cookies, worth the splurge and tasted great too. Jill was easy to work worth! Definitely would order from her without hesitation! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

K S.

0

50

3

7 years ago

Excellent Cookies. Purchased on-line and delivered just in time. Look very professional. Not a lot of frosting on the top of the cookie - like other vendors. Nicely presented and will definitely purchase again. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Delia D.

0

4

1

7 years ago

Every custom request on my order was perfect! Jill is great if you want to match a party theme or color scheme of a wedding. She responded promptly when I requested a quote. Each cookie came wrapped individually. Pickup was very easy, I was able to stop by on the day of pickup whenever was convenient for my schedule. The cookies tasted great! read more

Custom Cookies by Jill - Bridal shower custom cookies - Desserts Near Me

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Custom Cookies by Jill

Berwyn, IL 60402
Directions
(708) 906-8181
Call Now

Hours

What time does Custom Cookies by Jill open?

Custom Cookies by Jill opens at 10:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Custom Cookies by Jill close?

Custom Cookies by Jill closes at 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Custom Cookies by Jill take credit cards?

Yes, Custom Cookies by Jill takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Custom Cookies by Jill have catering options?

Yes, Custom Cookies by Jill does have catering options.

Does Custom Cookies by Jill have a drive thru?

No, Custom Cookies by Jill does not have a drive thru.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Custom Cookies by Jill have bike parking?

No, Custom Cookies by Jill does not have bike parking.

Does Custom Cookies by Jill have parking?

Yes, Custom Cookies by Jill has parking options. Street Parking

From the Business

Specialties

Handcrafted custom cookies for your special occasion

History

Established in 2011.

Custom Cookies by Jill started from the request to bring a dessert to a party. I found that I love decorating sugar cookies and enjoy challenging myself with custom designs. If you have an idea - let's make it a cookie!

Meet the Business Owner: Jill W.

Born and raised in the Chicagoland area, I can deliver or ship to anywhere in the US.

You might also consider

Hole in the Wall Custard Shoppe

Long lines but worth it!…read more I'm not sure I've ever seen this spot without a line! We visited recently and waited maybe 10 min to get in. We tried a sundae and cones and a number of items. Very delicious - creamy and not at all icy like some spots. Friendly people working there. And it's kind of nice to be the only group in there at a time. They didn't rush us even with the long line behind. Worth it - be prepared to wait but you will enjoy every bite of the delicious custard.

I've driven by this place probably 100 times and today was the first time I stopped in. Their menu…read morewas a little overwhelming because the inside is a little small and it's on their wall, but it's a really great spot and worth the wait. I loved that they had a few dairy free options too! Reasonably priced and worth the wait in line for sure.

Photos

Chocolate/vanilla swirl

Cherry small dole whip

See all

Twist (which they call a swirl). Good.

Turano Baking Company

My favorite grocery store bread! Here at the bakery, you'll find their restaurant "free range"…read morefresh baked bread mostly for under $5 a loaf. There isn't any where to sit, so expect to pickup. There are cookies, cakes, pizza bread and coffee cake. The sweets were just okay for me. Hummingbird and carrot cake had a weird after tasting I did not like. Napoleon, my favorite custard, is good. Prices are fair for the size you get, cakes $2.75/slice $19.99/whole, cheesecake $3.75. There is no parking lot, but street parking is easy enough to find.

Pasing by i stop in for a baguette , tomato focaccia ,and slice of carrot cake pretty good friendly…read morestaff

Photos

Huge croissant

See all

Old fashioned donut

Tastee Freeze

This was my first time visiting this location. There was a long line but it went by so quicklly. We…read moregot our ice cream within 5 minutes of ordering. I had a chocolate sundae and added banana. It was so delicious. We walked to the park across the street and ate our ice cream. The medium was a perfect serving. I want to come back to try the dirt and worms shake!

Fast service! High Quality items! I look forward to every Summer & asst. Ice Creams! I absolutely…read morelove their ice cream & look forward to their opening day every single year.

Photos

Brownie Sundae & Dirts with Worms Freeze

See all

Oak Park Bakery

Stopped in on a whim after a protest a few weeks ago to pick up some goodies. I got a few…read morepastries/donuts and slices of cheesecake. I'm super picky with my cheesecake but theirs was AMAZING! The strawberry one is 15/10 easily lol While in there I saw a few people pick up their cakes and they looked great! Will definitely be trying for our next birthday.

It's a real old school bakery with the best doughnuts. I would weigh 300 lbs if I lived nearby…read more Great counter help as well!

Photos

Take away box

See all

Avito Caffe

What a fantastic little coffee shop! Much more than coffee here, a local film maker. Local pasta…read moresauces also! Love the character displayed here. Nutella cold latte $6.25. They offer homemade bakery as well. Definitely stop in , worth it. Good service. Located on the South side of Route 66, Ogden Avenue. In a busy area with many restaurants, smoke shops, casino gaming rooms and more

We came here during the hot car show. It was a nice reprieve from the heat. The inside is decorated…read morewith images from the rat pack, etc. there is no seating. We had three different iced drinks. My latte with caramel was perfect.

Photos

Outside facing South

Order counter

See all

Outside with a latte and iced coffees

The Happy Apple Pie Shop

service was nice. $5+ for a mini slice is crazy tho can't lie. the ambiance is like 7th grade…read morepottery class im afraid lol.

Nothing new to add but still the same great service, same great pies, same great time. Keep it up…read moreguys. I'm trying my best to have 1 mini pie a day instead of all 4 today.

Photos

Cauliflower and kale galette

See all

Slice of apple pie

Old Fashioned Candies

If you like candy and chocolate this is your place. Been coming to Old Fashioned Candies for…read moresometime. My favorite is the dark chocolate. They also have a location in Indian head Park!

Was looking for something specific Googled candy cigarettes (a prop for a party) and found this…read morespot. Was greeted by a friendly young man who offered a sample of their yummy ice-cream, very good in such a hot day! Got a little more than the gum cigarettes (much better than the candy ones imo) and of course a scoop of ice cream. If I am ever in that area, will definitely stop again!

Photos

Chocolate s

Cotton candy

See all

Antique store items on display

Twisted Cookie

i ordered the cookie cupcakes, coconut, lemon coconut, key lime and caramel. They where all…read morefabulous, not to sweet, perfectly balanced creaminess of the filling/frosting and the specific flavor of the cookie. I will be back to try more and get at least a dozen more cookie cupcakes to share with family on father's day!

These precious cookies are Small little pies. Not as sweet and not as much filling. Much better…read morethan a traditional cookie , it's a small tart. Power packed flavors and very enjoyable. I cut my cookie into 4 pcs, to try several flavors. The pecan pie, apple pie & very berry . These are Perfect for Thanksgiving. Can't believe they were not sold out. Delicious. Must try and will return to try the chocolate flavors next time. Ty

Photos

Cupcake Cookie

See all

Chocolate vanilla twist

Spilt Milk

Nice cafe in bustling Oak Park! They have quite a bit of drink options but it seems that they sell…read moreout of food items very quickly. I anticipated having some lunch there at noon but they were sold out of savory items by them. Arrive early if you intend to do lunch!

Spilt Milk is a cute little neighborhood bakery that serves homemade pies and baked goods. You…read moreknow their food is homemade when you peer through the windows of the adjacent storefront where you can see them actually preparing and baking their scrumptious desserts. As much as the displayed baked goods look very tasty, I had their quiche of the day which was ham and guyere for lunch. It took about 12 minutes for the quiche, but I have to admit it was one of the better quiches that I have had. The quiche was filled with sliced ham which is different than most places that would use ham bits. The quiche was extra fluffy, almost omelet-like, with guyere cheese and was absolutely delicious. The crust was definitely homemade from the adjacent storefront and absolutely perfect. The only disappointment was that the quiche did not come with any side, be it a small salad or even one of their cookies. Split Milk is a wonderful neighborhood find. I will definitely come back to try some of their mouthwatering baked desserts.

See all

Paleteria Las Delicias de Michoacan

Clean nice ice cream shop , inside seating available. Located on the NorthWest corner of Ogden and…read moreOak Park Avenue. Sharing the parking lot with Little Cesar's Pizza, Smoke Shop, Insurance Provider & Lacey's Casino Gaming Room. In a very busy area along Route 66. Fun place to stop for a Paleta , Ice cream or fun snack.$4 fruit paleta,

One of the best local spots for ice cream and a quick snack. There is no other Paleteria in walking…read moredistance so I was pretty excited when this place opened up a few years ago. My dog was even more excited than I was! Any paleta de agua she absolutely loves, especially Sandía. I wish I could post all of the pictures of the delicious food I've had from here but I usually eat them too fast. The workers are nice & helpful & something to keep in mind is majority of them speak only Spanish but they will try their hardest to help out! Vibes are always good. If you have never visited this place, I highly recommend, especially if you like any of the other La Michoacana's in Chicago. Thank you Paleteria, I'll be back soon! Personal Review: 8.4/10

Photos

Outside

See all

Friendly Tap

My wife rented the coffee/art room side for my surprise 40th birthday party. It was an excellent…read morespace, and we felt supported in planning at all times. The organization is admittedly a little more laid-back than at other similar spots, but everyone we worked with was kind and supportive. Thank you, Friendly's Tap!

Great vibe they live up to their name from a fellow Californian thank you…read more Bar staff n the live band playing on 4/3 was fantastic.

Photos

Stage

French 75 and Old Fashioned

See all

Stick It Corndogs & Boba Tea

4.1

(18 reviews)

4.2 km

Really fun and creative corndog options! Everything is made to order and I liked the cozy…read moreatmosphere. The staff was super friendly! The flamin' corndog had a slight kick but wasn't overly spicy. Which was perfect for my low spice tolerance. The churro corndog truly surprised me with how tasty it was. Didn't think the flavors would blend together well but they did. I'll be back!

Super Cute Shop. Traditional yummy Boba Milk Tea. Love their design, the extra thought of the…read moresticker even. Orders a traditional 50% sugar. Definitely recommend it.

Photos

Inside

Ramen Stick -

See all

Churro Stick with condensed milk.

Avito Caffe

What a fantastic little coffee shop! Much more than coffee here, a local film maker. Local pasta…read moresauces also! Love the character displayed here. Nutella cold latte $6.25. They offer homemade bakery as well. Definitely stop in , worth it. Good service. Located on the South side of Route 66, Ogden Avenue. In a busy area with many restaurants, smoke shops, casino gaming rooms and more

We came here during the hot car show. It was a nice reprieve from the heat. The inside is decorated…read morewith images from the rat pack, etc. there is no seating. We had three different iced drinks. My latte with caramel was perfect.

Photos

Outside facing South

Order counter

See all

Outside with a latte and iced coffees

Friendly Coffee Lounge

4.8

(42 reviews)

4.2 km

Such a cool concept. There is coffee. There is a bar. You…read morecan see music there. You can play pool there you can take lessons there.

5 star for uniqueness in their own category! Wonderful little local bar/ coffee bar/ live music…read morelocal venue! How lucky was I to be able to See the local Blue Grass Band Practice.?! How authentic. It's fantastic to see it and keep music alive.! Cool decor and wonderful character in this place and all around it. Located in a great neighborhood with a lot to offer the community. Great people, as they represented at this establishment. Friendly service. Nice restaurants nearby. Great parks and many shopping places. Good community spot. To come relax and enjoy some great talent, peaceful. $6 for a large size cold brew. Ty

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Lizbeth K.

0

2

0

9 years ago

These cookies look as great as they taste! I messaged Custom Cookies by Jill on Facebook inquiring about a cookie order for my twin girls 16 birthday that was 4 short days away. I received a response within minutes letting me know they could fulfill my order of three dozen custom cookies. Payment was incredibly convenient as a link was sent to my email and the cookies were ready early for me to pick up. They turned out better than I could have imagined. Aside from the birthday girls the cookies were the biggest hit at the party. Each cookie was individually wrapped and delicious. I put some out for the party and gave the rest away as a party favors. I will definitely use Custom Cookies by Jill again in the near future. read more

Kate M.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Awesome cookies! Jill is super creative and talented. She has done cookies every year for my daughter's birthday and they are incredible! Paw Patrol, Rainbows, Butterflies....each year she's outdone herself. She will ship anywhere, so her cookies also make great thank-you, graduation, get well, and long distance birthday surprise gifts! Our friends are always impressed. Very professional. Check out her cookie designs on Instagram! Tip: Schedule well in advance because she does tend to book up quickly. read more

Nicalette T.

0

1

3

4 years ago

Amazing service! Reached out to Jill for custom cookies I needed for a work party at Porsche Downtown Chicago. She emailed me a proof of what the cookies would look like same day. She got the cookies done in perfect time and truly made it a seamless process & a great stress-free experience. I would recommend Custom Cookies by Jill to anyone looking for a reliable & trustworthy source for any custom cookie design. We l definitely be using her in the future for all our cookie needs. Thanks Jill! read more

Gracey L.

0

2

0

9 years ago

These cookies are amazing. I use them both for work and home and have never been disappointed. They are gorgeous and are so delicious. I have yet to ask for a type/theme of cookie that Jill could not do, whether it be My Little Pony cookies to "Thank You" for my daughter's teachers to corporate logos (CNN absolutely LOVED theirs!) And...she ships the day she completes the cookies, so they are always fresh. I highly recommend! read more

Maggie V.

0

1

3 years ago

I am so grateful to have come across Custom Cookies by Jill. I needed some custom cookies at somewhat of a quick deadline for a club on campus, and she was more than willing to work with me and get me the cookies by the date I requested. Don't let the email only turn you away! She's extremely responsive and understanding of your needs. The cookies turned out BEAUTIFUL and I could not have asked for a better experience. read more

Becky S.

0

8

1

8 years ago

These cookies were amazing. I ordered the bride dress with the football for our sons rehearsal dinner and they were perfection! They were shipped quite a distance and arrived exactly on time and in perfect condition, individually wrapped. Working with Jill was delightful as she responded immediately to correspondence. Thank you Jill for making our rehearsal dinner more special. read more

Kelly E.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Jill has been my go-to for custom cookies over the past few years. Whatever the event.... Whatever the theme.... she knocks it out of the park every time. Her attention to detail is unparalleled, and the cookies are often the talk of the event. Jill is professional, and responds quickly. She turns these tasty cookies into little works of art and I'm so happy I found her. read more

Jessica C.

0

3

1 year ago

I wanted to surprise my mom for Valentine's Day and help her feel better. She asked what she liked and made cookies of sudoku, her name and tv shows. My mom loved the taste of the cookies and loved the designs. They were beautiful cookies. Thanks so much Jill!!! I would 100% recommend her business. Please support her business. read more

Peggie O.

0

3

0

13 years ago

Custom Cookies by Jill are so beautiful you do not want to eat them! But after your first bite; you realize they taste as good as they look. When I needed a theme for the cookies I was going to order; Jill came up with great ideas. Ordering, delivery and price are right on. I give Custom Cookies by Jill a 15 out of 10 rating! read more

Adriana C.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Her cookies were absolutely amazing!! They not only looked beautiful, but they also tasted SO delicious. Jill made the entire process so easy, she was responding constantly and within minutes. I'm so happy I got cookies from her for my sister's bridal shower, every one was obsessed with them. I cannot recommend her enough read more

Christine D.

0

1

0

9 years ago

I am so happy with my order from Custom Cookies by Jill. Each cookie is truly a work of art! She was very responsive, gave me exactly what I wanted, arrived on time, and was packaged very carefully. We ordered them for a client meeting and these will make us look so good. Customer for life! read more

Louise K.

44

15

2

9 years ago

Jill's cookies are not only delicious but beautifully decorated. Jill has made cookies for me for several important celebrations, the designs matched my theme perfectly and contributed to a great event. Jill's cookies will continue to be part of all my important celebrations! read more

Joy G.

148

65

71

9 years ago

I ordered Jill's cookies for a work event. They are not only beautiful, but taste wonderful. Shhh... a couple of us shared a cookie before the event. The cookies are a work of art! Customer service is outstanding too. If I could I would give a 10 star! read more

Christine R.

0

13

14

4 years ago

Picked up the most beautiful cookies for my daughter's engagement party! A perfect addition to our garden soirée sweet table! Each cookie was perfectly styled in the colors requested and each one was flawless! A HUGE hit at the party! Thank you so much! read more

Carlos C.

113

1

8 years ago

The cookies were delivered on time and my daughter enjoyed them. "They taste as good as they look!"

Custom Cookies by Jill - desserts - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Custom Cookies by Jill also viewed

Coleys Cakepops

1 review

Lindy's Cookie Studio

19 reviews

Hyde Park

$

Granny's Cakes Luxury Cakes & Sweet Tables

4 reviews

Sweet Ali's Gluten Free Bakery

191 reviews

$$

Crumbles

1 review

$$

Cupcakes by Pink Katie

2 reviews

Hummingbird Cakery

4 reviews

Area 51 Cupcakery

336 reviews

$$

Kirschbaum's Bakery

144 reviews

$$

Sweet Soirees

2 reviews

Custom Cookies by Jill

Custom Cookies by Jill Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Custom Cookies by Jill

Reviews With Photos

More info about Custom Cookies by Jill

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Custom Cookies by Jill

You might also consider

Hole in the Wall Custard Shoppe

Turano Baking Company

Tastee Freeze

Oak Park Bakery

Avito Caffe

The Happy Apple Pie Shop

Old Fashioned Candies

Twisted Cookie

Spilt Milk

Paleteria Las Delicias de Michoacan

Friendly Tap

Stick It Corndogs & Boba Tea

Avito Caffe

Friendly Coffee Lounge

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

Custom Cookies by Jill - desserts - Updated August 2026

Best of Berwyn

People found Custom Cookies by Jill by searching for…

Trending Searches in Berwyn, IL

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Berwyn, IL

People who viewed Custom Cookies by Jill also viewed

Custom Cookies by Jill

Custom Cookies by Jill Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Custom Cookies by Jill

Reviews With Photos

More info about Custom Cookies by Jill

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Outdoor Amenities

Ask the Community - Custom Cookies by Jill

You might also consider

More businesses like Custom Cookies by Jill

Hole in the Wall Custard Shoppe

Turano Baking Company

Tastee Freeze

Oak Park Bakery

Avito Caffe

The Happy Apple Pie Shop

Old Fashioned Candies

Twisted Cookie

Spilt Milk

Paleteria Las Delicias de Michoacan

Trending businesses in Custom Cookies by Jill's area

Friendly Tap

Stick It Corndogs & Boba Tea

Avito Caffe

Friendly Coffee Lounge

15 Custom Cookies by Jill reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

Custom Cookies by Jill - desserts - Updated August 2026

Best of Berwyn

People found Custom Cookies by Jill by searching for…

Trending Searches in Berwyn, IL

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Berwyn, IL

People who viewed Custom Cookies by Jill also viewed