Supreme pizza 12 inch for two was more than plenty and it was really good. Ours came with sausage instead of pepperoni and this lovely establishment made it right but not only giving us the wrong pizza for free but boxing the correct one to go without charging us for anything extra basically we got a free pizza. Super polished and very Service oriented. My only small beef is there's no beer or wine strictly soda water in anything else nonalcoholic. I love me my beer or wine with my pie. Google says Online that they do serve beer and wine so there's a little bit of a disconnect. ;( You order the counter find a table and they bring it out to you. They do have crushed red pepper and crushed cheese no hot sauce. Overall, we were impressed in for our last night in town so thank you! read more

Crust 54 in downtown Holland is an absolute fabulous place to dine! Their pizza is awesome! So very fresh, fantastic, never without fail! You can tell they put real hard work into every pizza put real hard because they are very motivated. Deep dish pizzas take 45 minutes and that should great with any one who enjoys deep dish pizzas. We never ever found the crust very tough. People who do would be better off dining some ware else. We are never disappointed when we eat there! We can't wait to go back. We will be leaving to pick up 4 pizzas in one hour. read more

Crust 54 - The way you can proudly say all of these beautiful customers that you serve so very, everything. - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

See all

Great lunch special for the price and quality. Pretty greasy and no drink with the lunch special, which is a little bummer. Overall would totally come back. read more

Crust 54 - Thin slice and salad lunch special (2) - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

We wanted to grab a quick bite to go and ordered a deep dish pizza. Fortunately, the cashier told us that it would take 45 minutes so we got breadsticks instead. They were ready in about 10 minutes and were pretty tasty. I would return to get their pizza when I have more time. The night we went it was quiet and almost empty. read more

I read so many reviews about the gluten free crust that I was excited to try it. While I was happy to finally have a deep dish pizza I found the crust very tough. I had a hard time cutting through it. The cheese and sauce were great. The crust was just a little thin and tough. The non gf pizza looked great. I may try this place again and get the regular GF pizza and see if that is better. read more

Crust 54 - GF deep dish cheese pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

Pizza came out burnt. No indication of how long it takes for pizza to come out. Absolutely should forewarn customers that deep dish pizzas take 45 minutes. Told cashier to push first pizza out when complete. The back tried to time the pizzas so a thin pizza took 30 minutes to arrive. Enjoy deep dish from Lou Malnatis and Geno's a bit more. read more

Crust 54 - Downtown Holland Crust 54 in downtown Holland is an absolute gem. Their pizza is incredible -- fresh, flavorful, and consistently delicious every single time. You can tell they put real pride into every slice. The service is just as impressive. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and always on top of things, making every visit feel like a great experience. If you're in Holland and craving amazing pizza with equally amazing service, Crust 54 is the place to go. Highly recommend! read more

Crust 54 - Downtown Holland Crust 54 in downtown Holland is an absolute gem. Their pizza is incredible -- fresh, flavorful, and consistently delicious every single time. You can tell they put real pride into every slice. The service is just as impressive. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and always on top of things, making every visit feel like a great experience. If you're in Holland and craving amazing pizza with equally amazing service, Crust 54 is the place to go. Highly recommend! read more

The service was very slow. The cashier said it would be 20 minutes to get our pizza and it was 45. The deep dish crust was so tough it was very difficult to cut, was a weird shade of yellow and had an unusual flavor. We ate a bit of the crust and the toppings. We were very disappointed. But the worst part was within 15 minutes of leaving , we both were hit with extreme intestinal distress. If you want sub par pizza and service or need to prep for a colonoscopy, this is your place. read more

Great pizza. All of the ingredients seem to be of high quality, with the perfect amount of garlic to tie the flavors together. Chicago style of this quality is hard to come by in Michigan. Sad to see the location in Grandville gone, but will make the trip out to Holland to get my fix! read more

We ordered 6 pinwheels and we didn't get our food for 40 minutes while everyone else around us was served.

Went there over the weekend. Ordered food around 1:15pm, ordered small Chicago style pizza ( we knew it would take about 30 minutes to bake) and a two slice lunch special. My daughter went in about 15 minutes later and ordered cheesy bread. Around 2pm our cheesy bread arrived, another 20 minutes later our Chicago style pizza arrived. We asked about the two slices of cheese and they forgot we ordered that and said that the pizza they used for that was no longer good and would have to make more resulting in about another 20 minute wait time. We chose not to wait for it and asked for a refund of the two slices ( we didn't eat the Chicago pizza either) she apologized and said she refunded me the money. Two days later and still no refund! It was not a good experience. We were really looking forward to eating there. Frustrating. read more

I wasn't a fan of their thin crust pizza, but really enjoy the deep dish here. I typically get the Sawzall, and I really enjoy it. I feel like there is a good ratio of bread, sauce, toppings, and cheese. They can get pretty busy and the pizza takes longer to cook for the deep dish so be prepared to wait or order in advance. The staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable. read more

Crust 54 - Seating - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

See all

Amazing food! We were delighted with our 3 pizza varieties, they will do 1/2 and 1/2 pizzas as well. We had wood fired thin crusts and they were awesome. The staff was very friendly and helpful. We had a booth with a fun view of the downtown street so the kids were plenty entertained people watching. The restaurant is very clean, and has a nice casual modern feel. We highly recommend ! read more

I had the deep dish gluten free pizza, and it was really good! Quality ingredients and the crust was pretty darn good for gluten free! I would definitely go again. If you get the gluten free pizza, plan to share, as it is quite large. The young woman who took my order warned that it may take a while for the deep dish...I didn't mind. It was worth the wait. And while it cannot be compared to a fluffy gluten laden crust, I really appreciate that they even had this as an option. Side note: Epicurious has an incredible stuffed pizza recipe that can be made with a gluten free blend, and it is out of this world! Just sayin', if you really want a to die for gluten free pizza...well...there is just no comparison. But this restaurant does offer a good one. read more

This was not my favorite pizza place I have eaten at. It's conveniently located within downtown Holland. There's abundant parking for the downtown area. They put some tables out on the street in front for outdoor dining. That was nice! The food was okay. We got a basic Hawaiian pizza. It's our favorite. They did have onions listed as a basic ingredient for the pizza. I've never heard of Hawaiian pizza without onions so I opted to not have those. The wait was LONG for the pizza to come out. It was not prime dinner time either. We got there at 4pm. After waiting what felt like 30 mins, they brought out the wrong pizza. It had onions on it! So we began to wait another 30 mins for the correct pizza. Price was okay but the overall experience ruined it for me. I would just get hungry howies delivered!!! Pros: lots of parking, good location, nice staff Cons: wrong pizza, steep price ( would overlook that of everything else was good) , and long wait times. read more

Crust 54 - Hawaiian Stone Fired Thin Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

See all

We are from out of town and didn't realize they were going to close in half an hour. We asked if they had time to make a deep dish and a small regular pizza for my daughter. They said yes. We kept getting up asking for a refill, where were the appetizers, napkins, etc. The staff was cleaning up and forgot that we were there and were unprofessional. The amount of thick cut potatoes was a joke. The pizza was warm and not hot. The small sausage pizza that we asked several times about still hadn't come out. When it did the waitress said they forgot to make it and that's what took long and then there was a hair in it and my daughter didn't want it and don't blame her. No point to complain since they had comped her pizza since they forgot about. Nothing remarkable about the pizza and wings. Unpleasant experience read more

See all

After being blown away by the excellent pizza at Crust 54, we went back a week later. No changes, outstanding in every area. The real reason for this update is because of my disappointment in the picture of the pizza I posted in my original review. In no way does it even come close in capturing the majesty of what is created here. I took great care not to start eating before I took another picture. read more

Crust 54 - Deep dish pizza (from 2nd visit) - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

Stopped by Crust 54 this past weekend while visiting Holland, MI. I had read a lot prior to going and we ended up getting it to go. We drove to South Haven where we were staying. Oh My goodness so glad we order the Chicago Special. The sauce was amazing and the sausage was so savory and yummy. The crust was really good and we are so glad we tried it out. Good Job. read more

The Chicago deep dish was amazing. Rich in flavor and the toppings blended nicely with crust and sauce. The service was very friendly and accommodating, very helpful. The place was comfortable, noise level was at was a minimum and I loved they played Christian rock music. Lots of traffic for take out orders but was pleased to see many others enjoy the pizza. read more

Crust 54 - Chicago deep dish supreme. - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

Owner is a nice guy! Always makes it right. They sometimes have a hiccup but at the end of the meal he makes it right. 54 special is my go to. Thin crust. read more

Pizza had great flavor. We got the deep dish and crust was just ok. Sauce was on the sweet side but not too sweet. Service was great and they have a great selection of drinks. Had plenty of seating inside for the size and also had nice seating outside. read more

The place is big but the service is slow. I have ordered dip dish pizza for carry out. The server was helpful while placing an order. I got one vegan cheese and other regular cheese supreme vegetarian pizza. Vegan was really good. We also had garlic bread without cheese, which was on the dry side. The garlic bread was of pizza size so big. read more

Delicious! We ordered the deep dish carnivore. The sauce is the star... so so good! We will definitely be back! read more

Really delish pizza -very authentic Chicago style deep dish. Also a nice touch was Fustini's basil olive oil on the tables -it added a special touch and I love that they support local. My only complaint was that the pizza took forever too cook (prob bc we got the largest deep dish) which would've been okay if we were informed while ordering. I went up to check that we hadn't been forgotten about as soon as they were pulling it from the oven. So good! read more

I really like the dairy free pizza (be sure to order the vegan crust). The first time I ordered pizza it was cooked waaaay overdone so the vegan crust was hard as a rock and a bit burned. Now I just order it light to medium baked in my order instructions and it has come. Out fine ever since. Be ready to wait in the summer for typically an hour to an hour and a half to pick up your pizza. We have never sat inside because of the amount of time it takes to order, so I just order and take out. The first time we tried to order and sit it was an hour wait for the pizza so never tried that again. We get thin crust dairy free just cheese and I get veggies on my dairy free pizza. All super good. I do want to try the deep dish but I love the thin crust so haven't tried that yet. read more

Amazing pizza and service. Best Gluten free crust and toppings in area. Outdoor patio very nice. read more

Now that Giordano's has come and gone (that was fast!), Crust 54 is the only game in town for Chicago style deep dish pizza. (I understand Chicago die hards probably don't consider this legit, but I didn't come here to fight.) Tasty pies made local and fresh and served up with Holland charm. PRO TIP: Have your pie delivered to Our Brewing Co. so you can enjoy your 'za with some local craft brew. I keep Crust 54 in my Holland pizza rotation. Haven't been disappointed. read more

Not what I ordered, not cooked, person on phone couldn't tell me about their product because" I'm not a sales person" After reaching out to the manager they did refund my money read more

Heard some good things about this venue and we've had the best pizza Chicago has to offer. Went with the Godfather pizza, which is basically a supreme based pie. The ingredients were fresh and flavorful, however the crust was slightly dry. Overall, still a good pizza and a place I'd order from again. Best, Charlie read more

Delicious pizza, served in a reasonable amount of time, at a decent price. Friendly staff.

Poor service, we had to clean our own table to eat on, waited an hour for a pizza that came out so burnt that I ended up scrapping the toppings off and leaving the burnt crust. Won't go back. read more

I am really grateful that they offer a YUMMY gluten-free pizza! It's worth any wait -- you won't be disappointed.

Thin crust is most delicious. Chicago style is a must when you are hungry. Thank goodness we live close to the restaurant. So many choices in the area for Pizza. This is THE place ! read more

We hit this place up on 6/11/22 and it was awesomeness on a damn plate. I had the Deep Dish Carnivore and it was terrific. Thick gooey and filling. Awesome ham, sausage, and pepperoni. Everything you'd want and more of you were like me, just getting back with an excellent result from your latest stress test. Heart still good, let's load up those arteries at Crust 54 you won't be disappointed. read more

Crust 54 - Carnivore Deep Dish Good For The Heart. Get a stress test first like I did. - Pizza Near Me - Holland, Michigan

See all

My wife and I stopped into this restaurant during our day trip to Holland, MI on Valentines Day. Since we moved here from NJ and NY/NJ pizza is THE best pizza, we are usually disappointed in pizza. We were extremely and pleasantly surprised by the quality of the pizza made a Crust 54. The thin crust pepperoni pizza we ordered was tasty, crunchy, chewy and had a very generous portion of pepperoni on it. I HIGHLY recommend Crust 54. I just wish it was located closer to our home in Byron Center, MI so I could eat their pizza more often! Do yourself a favor and visit Crust 54 when in Holland, MI - you will not be disappointed! read more

I had my first deep dish from here. It was a carry out someone else ordered. Deep dish done right. Absolutely delicious. Would recommend to anyone who loves great deep dish. read more

Great pizza, very friendly staff. If you're in Holland MI, it's a great place to carb up as there is plenty of walking to do in town. We had both the stuffed and thin crust pizza, and enjoyed both in their own way. read more

Chicago Style or thin crust. Veggie or meats. Best in town. 2 locations 8th street or South Washington.

Delicious, hot, melts goodness in a unique deep-dish style crust. We ordered a pepperoni deep-dish, a stuffed spinach and the Doman (bbq and chicken). All were very good. I am from Texas so I had my doubts on the BBQ but it was very good. I would describe as more of a thick, sweeter sauce, not too vinegary with a good balance of smoke and acidity. The Stuffed Spinach was rich with cheeses and had plenty of whole leaf spinach. This is a solid vegetarian option. The pepperoni (basically a build your own with one topping) was loaded several layers deep with pepperoni and loads of cheese. The outer crust of each pizza is golden with a light crisp and had notes of sweet corn, maybe cornmeal with a pillowy center. The base of the crust is still relatively thin so you're not overloaded with bread, though these pizzas are very filling. The only less favorable aspect of the visit was standing at the counter for a good several minutes before being acknowledged. Additionally, be prepared to wait a bit for the pizzas - though I think it's worth the wait. read more