Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Creative Cakes by Carolyn

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Creative Cakes by Carolyn Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Creative Cakes by Carolyn

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Creative Cakes by Carolyn

    You might also consider

    Cramer Bakery

    Cramer Bakery

    3.6
    (140 reviews)
    5.3 km
    $$

    I used writing this review as an excuse to go. I grew up coming here and have always loved the…read moreElmo/Cookie Monster Cupcakes. They're so light and fluffy and have the perfect amount of icing. The sprinkles are soft and a wonderful addition to the cupcake (from an avid sprinkle hater). We also will purchase the Challah which is perfect for french toast. In all honesty I had to dock a star as their cakes always look good, but tasted mid at best. Another reason being it is quite an expensive place. Sometime there are great sales, other times, paying full price will put a dent in your wallet. The staff is always friendly and show their care despite typically being teenagers. I also must credit them for being open so late, given they're a bakery. Great memories and I plan to come many times in my future!

    Gender Reveal Ruined-- Followed By The Worst Customer Service I've Ever Experienced…read more I have never written a negative review in my life, but this experience was so upsetting and handled so poorly that I feel obligated to share it. I ordered a gender reveal cake and was extremely clear from the very beginning that this was for a gender reveal and that I needed blue on the inside and white on the outside. When I placed the order, I gave very specific directions: white on the outside, blue on the inside. I even provided a photo of exactly what I wanted. Later that same day, I called back to confirm again: white on the outside, blue on the inside. Then when I picked the cake up, I had a third confirmation point. They read the instructions back to me and again confirmed it was supposed to be white on the outside and blue on the inside. I even verbally confirmed one more time before leaving the store. So there were three separate touch points of communication confirming the exact same thing. This cake was for my first baby's gender reveal. This was a once-in-a-lifetime moment for my husband and our family. I spent time planning this, buying flowers, an outfit, and setting up something incredibly special for us. When we cut the cake during the reveal -- while filming -- the inside was completely white. No blue. Nothing. The entire moment was ruined. My husband found out we were having a boy in the most anticlimactic, confusing way possible. It was heartbreaking and honestly humiliating to have planned something so meaningful only for it to completely fall apart because of a mistake that was confirmed THREE separate times. What made this exponentially worse was the customer service afterward. When I called the next morning, I was met with rudeness and condescension. Later, when someone finally called me back, I was literally asked if I was "sure" there wasn't blue inside -- as if I didn't just cut into and dig through my own cake. I had to prove their mistake by sending photos. During that same call, I explained how rude the first person I spoke to had been. The response I got was essentially, "Yeah... she really shouldn't be answering the phone" and that she's not very good at customer service. That honestly left me speechless. If someone is not good at customer service, why are they the person answering customer calls? Especially when those calls are about major life events and serious issues? It was one of the strangest, most unprofessional interactions I have ever had with a business in my life. At no point initially did anyone apologize. I had to be visibly upset and crying before anyone even attempted to say sorry. Even the owner never called me directly -- he texted asking me to call him about a refund. When I did call, there was still no real apology, just discussion about money. Let me be very clear: This was never about the $50. This was about ruining one of the most meaningful milestones of my life and then treating me like I was an inconvenience when I called about it. People make mistakes. I understand that. But how you handle the mistake is what defines your business -- and this was handled terribly from start to finish. I have never been treated so badly by so many people from one business, especially over something tied to a major life event. I will never use this bakery again, and I will absolutely be sharing this experience with others so they can make an informed decision. If you are trusting them with an important life event, I strongly suggest reconsidering.

    Photos
    Give the place a try if you haven't been there before.
    Give the place a try if you haven't been there before.
    Hamantaschen (medium size) in poppy, raspberry, and lemon around Purim. Mini and jumbo sizes available as well.
    Hamantaschen (medium size) in poppy, raspberry, and lemon around Purim. Mini and jumbo sizes available as well.
    Cramer Bakery

    See all

    Dutch Country Bakery

    Dutch Country Bakery

    4.5
    (4 reviews)
    11.0 km
    $$

    Gad Zooks there are a lot of Zooks in the two Amish farmer's markets in my area. Jacob and Mary…read moreZook own and operate the Dutch Country Bakery. Everything is baked right on the premises and the aromas help to fill the air with sweets coming right out of the ovens. Mainly run by the Amish folks, they do hire help as I marveled at the gal with the Steeler's tee shirt on while she was making homemade cinnamon rolls, so I had to buy some of those. This area of the market is huge and I do mean filled to capacity with made from scratch whole of half cakes, cream, custard or fruit pies, breads, rolls, sticky buns, tarts, cobblers, whoopie pies, muffins, apple dumplings, cupcakes, cookies and of course shoofly pie. I know some of you who pay an arm and a leg for a cupcake, but here they are very reasonably priced and just as good and as fancy as the ones you pay top dollar for. I bought a half of a black forest cake, a half pumpkin cheesecake with a sour cream topping, both were so delicious, a few loaves of bread, two packages of freshly baked sandwich rolls, a few whoopie pies and a pumpkin roll, love pumpkin and this roll was filled to the brim with lots of cream cheese filling. I hate to bake, they love to bake and they do it so well. We have very few good bakeries nearby so it is a real pleasure knowing that I have the Dutch Country Bakery close enough for me to stock up the fridge, freezer, pantry and yes it will eventually be stored on our bodies. Oh well what a sweet way to do it.

    I have to say, this Bakery is the real reason I ever come out to this Amish market. Everything is…read morejust so so good. If I need baked goods and I don't have time to make it myself, I come here first. I always find something that I like and everyone is always happy with the product. I have never heard a complaint about something I bought from here. The breads, cookies, cakes, and especally the pies .. my mouth is watering. The price is on point too. I only wish they could be open every day!

    Photos
    Dutch Country Bakery
    Dutch Country Bakery
    Dutch Country Bakery

    See all

    Creative Cakes by Carolyn - customcakes - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...