This place was SO good, everything on the menu sounded delicious, and everything that arrived was even more delicious. Portions are huge, so go hungry, or take it home for tons of leftovers. I really enjoyed the knish w/corned beef the most, everything paired so nicely down to the spicy mustard. Will definitely have to come back here to try more items off the menu, and to try the different seasonal items. Bar and restaurant is spacious and cozy, it's a great spot to come to watch sports as well. Windows surround the tables so you can also people watch down below of that's your thing. My parents also love this place and found the service to be exceptional, especially Liam and Jack. Will definitely be back! read more

A quick stop after catching a movie around the corner. I Googled restaurants that were still open and came across Crabtree. I didn't order too much -- just the honey wings, bread pudding, and a cocktail. The wings were a little too big for my liking. I've always had issues with oversized winglets, but the flavor was still really good despite the size. The drink was very good. I had something called the "Smash Bros," which has bourbon, grapefruit, orange, lemon, and mint, garnished with mint leaves and an orange slice. Very tasty! The banana bread pudding wasn't bad at all, but I have to say I didn't really taste the bananas -- I tasted the chocolate chips more than anything. It was definitely a different take on banana pudding by adding chocolate chips. It wasn't bad, but I personally prefer the traditional version. Overall, the service was great and the ambiance was nice. There were lots of windows, and the restaurant being on the top floor gave it a really nice view. I would definitely come back and try more dishes. read more

See all

The cheese board and wings were really good. The buratta salad was kinda soggy. I think if you do get it get the dressing on the side. I feel like there was way too much dressing. The vibes are great - you get to look over Huntington which is a great city already. Parking is a bit tough but have faith and do a few rounds. Overall I would come back. The espresso martini was really good and help fuel a fun night out. read more

See all

My wife and I had dinner here before a concert at The Paramount. She had the fried chicken sandwich and I had the Fish n Chips. They were both pretty good although mine was a bit greasy. As you might expect just be for a concert, it was a bit crowded but we were seated immediately and our server was excellent. read more

This long awaited review was from my visit in January. We live in the area but almost never eat in any of the restaurants, so I was excited to eat here before my concert at the Paramount. We climbed the stairs and were greeted immediately and taken to a table. The bar was hopping, so that was a good sign. But then we waited for a while. Even put our menus down when we decided. We still waited. FINALLY, our server came over. We saw him on the side, sitting and talking with friends. Hubby LOVES bread, so we had to get the bread service, but it was just a loaf of meh bread, it was the BUTTER that made the dish! The rest of our meal was nothing to write home about except for the REUBEN TATER TOTS!!! I could eat these everyday, for the rest of my life! Huge portion and so tasty. Go there now and get them! read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Reuben Tater Tots. OMG SO GOOD - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

The menu is all over the place, but in the best way because everything tastes amazing. They have some cool cocktails to try and really nice specials. The ahi tuna tacos were on the specials menu so I'm not sure how often they're available but they were absolutely delicious. Staff was very attentive and the atmosphere was fun, although a bit on the loud side. They have a cool steampunk theme and very pretty lighting. Though its a bit on the pricey side, this restaurant has a lot to offer and it's worth it. read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Ahi tuna tacos - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Great spot in Huntington high up on the second floor overlooking town. We enjoyed Cajun boiled peel and eat shrimp, a spicy cocktail and standard burger. The burger was a little dry but well presented and tasty. Took the salmon entree to go for my daughter, she said it was very good. Service was attentive and friendly. Definitely be back! read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Peel & Eat Shrimp Boil - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Beautiful bar beautiful view service is good. Food was OK. My wife loved her squash salad. English meatballs are not very good..Stick to what you know. Weren't many Chicken wigs for the money I think six . The rest of the people we were with said their food is good OK read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Squash salad - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

Love it here. By far my favorite cocktails in Huntington. Delicious dishes with friendly staff members. I love the food and atmosphere here really makes the restaurant/bar what it is. Only bar in town with this kind of view. read more

See all

This place seems very underrated. So cool and modern. It was packed after we got there. Service was great. The food was amazing. My favorite was the pretzel and cheese dip. So soft. It seems like a great hang out spot. Wish it wasn't so far from me. But will definitely come back if I'm in the area. The stairs to go up to the restaurant/bar were so cute. Wasn't too loud either. We were also seated by the window and was able to look down the street. read more

See all

I really enjoyed this place. It's on the second floor of a hair salon with a long staircase to walk up, so if you're disabled, just be aware that it's a climb. We were quoted 45 mins for a table, but it wound up being about 5 mins, glad we didn't leave. For appetizer we started off with the tuna, really good and tasted nice and fresh. We also had the wings, we got them dry, they were good but I think I prefer non breaded style. Drinks we both had the chai tea toddy- unique and was great. For my entree, I had the standard cheeseburger with bacon. I enjoyed it but it's served on an English muffin. I like English muffin burgers but I think the muffin should have been toasted or buttered for a better taste. It almost made the burger bland. For dessert we had the brownie sundae which was great. The server was nice and prompt. I definitely want to come back and try new dishes! read more

See all

We selected Crabtree based on the Google & Yelp reviews. The atmosphere was pleasant, and wait staff were helpful. Unfortunately, the dinner was almost inedible. We ordered the following: medium-rare cheeseburger with cheddar and a side of truffle fries, AND the English meatballs with noodles and peas. The burger was served well-done (dry and grey), and the meatballs were so overcooked that a fork couldn't pierce them. We sent the meatballs back for a do-over. The second batch came back as bad as the first batch. The noodles with peas and gravy weren't bad. We ordered margaritas with no ice. They were tasty, but tasted like a mix, not fresh limes. When the bill came, we saw we were charged EXTRA FOR NO ICE! Charging more for delivering less. So all-in-all, one of the worst meals we've ever had. Food: 1/5 | Service: 3/5 | Atmosphere: 3/5 read more

Went here while awaiting our dinner reservation. Very nice view over Huntington street near the window. Has a very industrial feel inside the restaurant. I ordered a delicious fruity spritz and there were a variety of beers on tap. Bartender was friendly and quick. Reasonably priced. Stairs getting in are decently steep. We didn't order any food but the fries and tater tots looked very yummy. read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

came here a few days ago with my boyfriend & we had an amazing time. the ambiance is really comforting and warm. we ordered 2 espresso martinis which were super good. afterwards we got the crabtree g&t which was also stellar!! the food is incredible, we got one of the specials which was general tso's chicken and the late night egg sandwich. the chicken was really nice and crisp. the egg sandwich was amazing, i would definitely order it again in a heartbeat. & it comes with tater tots which tasted super fresh and perfectly fried. all this to say, we are definitely coming back here & telling everyone about it! thank you so much read more

We hadn't been here in a long time and I'm so glad we returned! The food was great, wait staff was fun and funny, and the choices were super-seasonal! Awesome ambiance, too-cozy, quiet & sort of pre-end of the workday crowd. It really filled up as we were leaving around 7, but wasn't loud-totally civilized crowd of folks doing their own thing & enjoying the Ambon of this lovely, easy going place. The pecan crusted salmon with seasonal veggies was delicious, by the way! read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Happy autumn! - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

I was helped by a gentleman named Ant, a handsome and charming young man who was happy to make me and my wife espresso martinis SO delicious and perfect we just couldn't get enough. Ant was attentive, helpful, chatty and fun. We often go to wonderful spots like Crabtree's all across the country in our travels and always order the espresso martinis as a "gauge" of the bartenders. Ant nailed it and had funny joke after funny joke. I unfortunately spilled my drink on my pants and Ant was happy to give me his to wear to save me the embarrassment. He went above and beyond at every chance and will be back again and again for Ant's delicious Espresso Martinis and smile! read more

Crabtrees is the best spot in huntington for espresso martinis! And ask for Anthony to make it for you!! He enjoys making them too!

Best drinks in town and great bartenders. They have great food, we come here all the time for dinner and drinks. I only wish they had a better happy hour offer. read more

Great food, cocktails, and service! Their chicken sandwich was delicious. Very cool view of downtown Huntington.

Went to Crabtrees after a night of axe throwing and a stop at a couple local pubs. Locally, I stumbled upon Crabtrees after taking a stroll to find our next stop. Hauling in from Manhattan, I was looking for a quaint cocktail bar with a creamy Espresso to supplement my first Saturday of the New Year. I was more than happy at the sight and smell of my martini. Strong, creamy, and smooth. The foam was here to stay, which is a critical part of any espresso martini. I will say I have had many of espressos and martinis both at their separate occasions. The espresso martini is here to stay in Huntington New York. Thank you Crabtrees read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

Came in with party of 7 celebrating birthday ....food was spot on delicious and menu had n lots of vegan options for members of my group....best burger I had in a very long time....and the shrimp tacos were a big hit....special desserts were excellent and I can't wait to go back read more

See all

I came here for a quick dinner before going to a show at the paramount and had an odd experience. The menu is quite odd, i am not a picky eater but i struggled to find something that sounded appetizing. I ended up with the turkey burger that was placed on a large english muffin. It was kind of an awkward idea for a bun and got extremely soggy. The turkey itself was good but nothing special in my opinion, it looked lovely but tasted bland. The tap list was very small but there was a lot available in cans for beer. The cocktail menu looked great, if i lived in the area i would definitely come back just for drinks! I came on a saturday night at 6:30 and there was plenty of seating. The ambiance was great, we were seated at a lovely table by a large window overlooking the town which was nice. the decor is modern but still cozy. The service was not the best, we had several extremely odd and awkward interactions with the waitress that made the whole experience kind of odd. The price point was quite high for the quality of the food. I wouldn't come back for a sit down meal but it definitely seemed like a great place for drinks and appetizers! read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Goat Cheese Turkey Burger - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

First time there. Very nice. Kind of loud but not impossible. Good vibe with the exposed brick and the Edison lights. Limited menu but it covers all the bases. Decent drink selection. Service was efficient and we didn't feel rushed. Just a good experience and will go back. read more

Very nice place, view and staff. We will return I'm sure. Town parking is difficult though

Perfect night to sneak out to Huntington. Found parking on some strip and have been meaning to try this spot for a very long time! Tonight seems to be the right night!! Walked in and a table was there.. calling our names! We sat down, server told us to read the board for specials! Perfect ambiance. Not too bright and not too dark. perfectly lit setting! Ordered the reciprocal IPA. Thumbs up! Curious about the cauliflower vegan soup w Crispy garlic bc I'm cold as heck from walking 3 blocks up! It was a nice day but WTH happened... got cold all of a sudden! Wasn't properly dressed for the temp drop! Had to order up the Belgium pretzel sticks! That honey mustard! Yum just bc it's right with beer! I ordered the Salmon as my entree and told my other party to order the shrimp tacos on the menu bc that alfalfa topped over the 3 Large tacos you guys are dropping at every table around us looks very intriguing!!! Our other party ordered the Buttermilk fried chicken sandwich... I must mention, I stole the pickles off the dish and it was sweet & salty fresh, crisp delicious! My 2nd beer was called "somewhere out there" by sloop brewing co... the name caught my attention. I don't mind sipping this at all. I love the decor and vibe of this place. The bar was packed by the time we were ending our meals... I will be back for sure! Food tasted great and above pub food for sure! Server was very kind and attentive! Thank You Crabtrees and hope for long success! I also have to mentioned... something about going up those stairs to get to this spot just makes it even better. I can't explain but the anticipation to get up the stairs to land in a great looking spot makes it worth while! Try this spot out and let me know your thoughts! read more

See all

Fun spot! Food is okay - typical American/bar food. The ambience is fun and the drinks are usually great!

It was my first time going and I was excited to go I had heard the food was good and the happy hour as well which you don't find many happy hours on the weekends. The bar was not crowded at all and there were 3 bartenders. I was served by a bartender named Anthony and I have to say this was the worst experience I ever had at a bar. He had to be flagged down every time as he was too busy on his phone with his back to everyone. Did not offer me a food menu and when our glasses were empty he had to be called upon. When I placed my order for food it came and honestly was absolutely delish but he wouldn't know that as he never asked how everything was. But what really got me was how rude he was to me. There was Music in the background and he changed a song and said to him that was a good song why did you change it and he rudely said to me "just eat your French fries and don't worry about it". My husband heard him and said to him what did you say to my wife. My husband also mentioned he knew Jack the Manager and that he would hear about this and he began to say "Oh yea let's call him now". I asked for our check and said to him you are the rudest bartender and should not be in this industry. Mind you Ive been a bartender of over 20 plus years and would never treat a customer this way. I will never step one foot in this place again and that's unfortunate because Jack is nice person and a great manager and the food is actually good but someone made a really bad choice in hiring this guy. read more

I have to update a previous negative review. We've been to Crabtrees 3 times recently. I was concerned about returning due to our past experiences ? And fearful they might know I wrote a not too favorable review ? I must say ! We were very happy with the service ! Atmosphere ! And food !! We are "Born Again". Please disregard our/my previous review ! Crabtree is definitely worth the visit. All the best moving forward ! The restaurant business is very difficult and I just wanted to make sure Credit given to this establishment!! Godspeed Crabtrees !! read more

The smoked whitefish salad first & foremost is THE BOMB! I actually miss it when I leave to go back to the Midwest !!! But thankfully now that we have a hotel in town, I'm in Huntington quite often it's a MUST! ALSO don't underestimate an olive !!The Cerignola Olives& Egg sandwich what they do to those eggs WOW,that or I'm just that hungryhonestly the food is great! The staff is lovely! It's the first thing we get after check in and a long flight, they are open late! It's literally my fav place to get a late flight bite! And it's a really pretty place to top it off! See you next visit read more

Still the best place in Huntington Village to get creative cocktails. And a big, big plus for serving (great) food late. We got out of our movie at close to 11pm and were still seated and had lots of time to order, sip drinks, and eat some great food. Not enough restaurants stay open late in this town, which is odd considering there's concerts, bar events, movies etc. Go Crabtree's! read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Avery Island (gin, maraschino liqueur, egg white and Tabasco) and The "Better" Lavender & Lace - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

Why oh why? Are you letting customers vape and not saying anything? Food was good Parking ample Music good Waitstaff aware patrons are doing this! I saw it many times, and its disheartening It occurred to hanu too, and I never returned. Maybe post a sign like you do 4 specials for those who are doing this to go outside - Food was PHENOMENAL Bartender was terrrific bathrooms are clean, and most important was the live music. Absolutely great - and this place is good for all age groups very eclectic mix read more

Excellent Happy Hour and a recommended spot for a pre-Paramount show visit. Excellent conversation and service at the bar. Lucky to grab 2 stools at the far end of the bar ( convincing a patron to find accommodations for her pocketbook so I wouldn't have to stand to eat). Noticed a small but well curated local tap menu (yes - they have at least one DIPA). However, I went with a well made High Fashion (rye, amaro and cherry preserves) - a mere $8, served in a nice cut rocks glass. The $10 standard cheeseburger would have been perfect except for the doneness. Ordered the same, but Lisa E.'s came out spot on medium rare, mine medium. Fries crisp, salty and addictive. Debated reviewing - because this hidden spot a considerable stair climb above the street level shops should perhaps remain a little secret .. read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

I've been wanting to try Crabtree's for a while now. I always thought it was a great location overlooking the street with all those windows (I also like sitting in the Mezzanine sections at shows - what can I say? I like to look down on things.). It was cool watching the traffic go by on the busy Huntington downtown streets. I also really liked the decor of this place - a cool looking bar, a banquette of tables around the perimeter and cool music filling the place. The menu is fairly extensive, and we notice that happy hour is happening, but only at the bar (I always find it a bit strange that depending on WHERE you are in a place determines if you get a discount or not). I see Sand City has a beer in one of their taps so I get that, a hefeweizen - Sand City never disappoints. A peachy vodka mule type drink for my wife. We decide to do a pretty broad sampling of the menu.. here's how it goes: Stuffed Avocado - described as a Tuna Poke, but I find it a bit more salad like than a bowl. The dressing is tasty, avocado creamy, but the tuna is not the best quality with stringy tendons affecting the texture. American Made Burrata - I love when you slice open a burrata ball and it oozes cheese and liquid to mingle with the other ingredients - that did not happen here. The texture inside was more thick ricotta cheese like and I find that is a sign of inferior burrata. Figs, walnuts, lavender honey and crostini were all nice. Roasted Salmon - When you order the main you can get the protein paired with a salad instead of how it is listed on the menu (you still pay the entree price) - so the Iceberg Wedge was ordered. It was a decent wedge - really good dressing, and the marinated cherry tomatoes and onions were good, but no substitute for bacon that usually comes with a wedge. Salmon was overcooked though ordered medium. Standard Cheese Burger - is an accurate description - it's basic. A large thick burger comes more towards the rare side than the ordered medium, but it really had no flavor (no char, no flat top browning - just mushy meat). Topped with tomatoes, lettuce and mine with cheddar since you can't get American cheese - which, to me, is really the superior cheese for a burger. Not a fan of a big English muffin used as a bun either. Nice pickles with this - wish they gave more. Service was great from the single waitress since the place wasn't overly busy on this Sunday. I enjoyed the drinks and the vibe here, which is what I would come back to enjoy while probably avoiding the food. read more

See all

Anthony is legit the only bartender on LI that can make a tequila espresso martini- holy crap the MOST AMAZING drink I have ever had!!!! Come to this restaurant and request Anthony as your bartender! read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Came here last night for dinner and drinks with the girls. It is located above the cactus salon. The stairwell is a little dark so becareful. It should be a little better lit. The inside bar vibe reminded me of a speakeasy. Bartenders have all their potion bottles to whip you up fancy cocktails. I ordered the peach mule. It was delish! On friday and Saturdays they do offer happy hour specials but only if you sit at the bar area. Limited menu. But prices bary about $5. Good thing what i choose to order wasnt apart of it id be annoyed.. Since there was a few of us my fellow yelpers helped guide me to what i ended up choosing was the tater tots and corned beef concotion. Crispy tots gooey cheese and corned beef.! One of my friends ordered the mac and cheese with cheezits with beisket i tried that. But i am not a big fan of beisket but loved the mac and cheese with cheezits. Had homemade cheese sauce and lovely shells and generous portion! Tried the pretzel beead. Soft and came with 3 dipping sides I also ordered the sucker punch. I was a little disappointed i thought it wouldve been more sour based on the name and description. I did enjoy the fresh sage leaf on top I would def return and get here early. Bc they do not take reservations! read more

At first glance, this restaurant was warm and inviting. The decor was great, and you can't beat the location, 2nd floor overlooking the corner of Main Street and Route 110. Very nice! The food was pretty good and reasonably priced. I had the Chicken Wings, breaded and fried. They were fresh and tasty, much better than the frozen/fried version you get at some places. Our server was polite and professional, though not particularly friendly. Crabtree would have been our regular meeting place when in Huntington, and I would have given them 5 stars had it not been for the owner's attitude. We were meeting friends, but we got there before them. Since no one greeted us at the door, we grabbed a small table in the bar area. When the server came over, I mentioned that we were going to need a bigger table when the rest of our party arrived. She asked how many were going to be, and I said anywhere from 5-8 altogether. She said rather bluntly, "I'll speak with the owner." He came over and told us it's "first come, first serve" and told us we couldn't move. We hadn't even ordered our food yet. A few minutes later our friends arrived and were seated at a table for 4. Since there were only 3 of them, I asked if we could join them. There was plenty of room at their table and we didn't mind squeezing in; we would have been 5 people. Once again we were told, rather sternly this time, "No. I already told you, it's first come, first serve. You have to stay here". This made no sense since we weren't going to consume any additional seats, rather we would free up a two-top at the bar, which at that point was getting rather crowded. As we were leaving, I briefly sat at the table with my friends to say hello. I made eye contact with the owner and smiled at him, and he right came over. I explained to him, "This was all I was asking for, to join my friends at this table." He then told me that the server said I "threatened" to leave a review on Yelp, which is true. I stated to her that I was going to leave an "honest and accurate" review about our experience. But rather than trying to defuse the issue with a customer, the owner continued to argue with me and use the word "threaten". Finally, someone at the table said to him, "This is pointless, and we're all leaving. Because the food was good and the atmosphere was pleasant, even with the owner's bad attitude, I would have given Crabtree a 2 Star review. But then, I was taken aback when he stood about 10 feet away and took my picture! This creeped out everyone at the table. In several decades of going out to hundreds of restaurants of all different levels of cuisine and price, I've never met such an obtuse and abrasive owner. Bottom line is this; Crabtree is a pretty nice place with decent food, but the angry, creepy owner making guests feel uncomfortable makes it impossible to ever go back. There are dozens of bar/restaurants in Huntington who value your business and treat you with respect. read more

The English Meatball really hit it home for me. The beef meatballs had good flavor and sat on top of egg noodles tossed in delicious pub gravy. The dollop of sour cream added a touch of creaminess to the entire dish and made me almost finish the whole plate. What's best was that it came out piping hot! We also ordered the tater tot poutine and Mac and cheese. Both were good but not great. A white cheddar Mac and cheese topped with cheese-itz were good pretty good on their own, but tasted a bit odd together. When you call something "Cheez-it Mac and cheese", I imagine a google baked Mac and cheese, topped real cheddar and baked golden. Needless to say, having a cream white shelled mac and cheese topped with crackers was a bit underwhelming. The taters on the tater tot poutine was nice and crunchy. Plus, I'm a sucker for gravy.... BUT, it wasn't a poutine! There were no cheese curds. Instead, some sort of cheese was melted into the gravy, which made the dish really salty. Despite the salt, everything was tasty but again, t wasn't what you'd imagine given the name. The place itself is cute and has a nice vibe. I'd go back again if I was in the neighborhood! read more

Nice spot in Huntington. On 2nd floor with views of village below. Food is great & the ambiance was nice & cozy. Service was good too.

Cute cozy restaurant with a nice vibe. We came here a week ago on a Friday night. There were 7 of us & the wait was about a half hour. The hostess wasn't the friendliest, but maybe she was having a bad day. The decor was fun & trendy. Our waiter was attentive and helpful when we were deciding what to order. I got the Pomegranito which was meh. Way too much syrup in my opinion, so I wouldn't recommend. I ordered the cheeseburger well done w no bun & it came w fries. The burger was the way I like it but the fries were overdone with salt. Prices were typical for Huntington Village. The first Tuesday of ever month they have an open mic comedy night with no cover charge. I plan to check it out. Good place for groups & I would go back. This place was more of a 3.5 stars. It was a good time. read more

Crabtree's NY and Main - Chill vibe - New American Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

It was ok, had the cheez it mac n cheese app, not bad. Great drink selection, beautiful place, great service. The sandwich was good, I believe it was brisket read more