Corato II, has one of the best fried Calamari in the area. They have the BEST Connolis period! The pizza is very good classic New York style. The service is always efficient for small or large groups. Definitely recommend a visit, and try the connolis while here to test what I'm saying! PS. The flan is nice too. read more

I ordered two regular slices, chicken Parmesan with fettuccine pasta and baked clams. The baked clams were disgusting. The chicken Parmesan was mediocre and the two regular slices were average. The point of this review is that everyone that ate got food poisoning. We are never ordering from them again. I hope if anyone does order from them receives a better experience than us. Zero stars. read more

The food was good they were very nice sweet n patient but it wasn't the best food where I go back cuz it wasn't the best plus it was like 34 dollars which is a lot for pasta with meatballs cheesecake and flan read more

Ordered slices and they put them in the microwave NOT THE PIZZA OVEN. I've never seen something like this before! What kind of pizzeria MICROWAVES THEIR PIZZA!?!?!? for that give it to me cold and heat it up myself I'm damn oven at home. Wasted my time 20 minutes waiting for microwaved garbage. read more

This place only starts serving pizza at 12:00Pm. Most pizza places start at 11:00-11:30am Suggest going to John & Joes.

We received a decent pizza, and although it was delivered, it was still hot when it arrived. Overall, the flavors are there, but we find the crust a bit on the thinner side, maybe because they made it that way so each slice us easier to fold. Who knows. Anyway, pizza crust will always be a deal breaker for us, and this pizzeria almost delivered. read more

Corato Pizza II - Cheese Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ridgewood, New York

See all

THE BEST PIZZA DELIVERY IN RIDGEWOOD! I ordered 3 large pizzas on Halloween and they all arrived on time, piping hot. The upside-down Sicilian was the favorite, with a chewy crust and the cheese hiding under the sauce. We got the caprese pizza which has a thinner crust, just as good, and the napolitan pizza which was also just AMAZING! read more

Corato Pizza II - three pizzas in boxes - Pizza Near Me - Ridgewood, New York

I've been ordering from them for decades and the pizza just gets better and better. This last order was perfect. Crispy and full of flavor! They have one of the best slices in nyc. read more

I'm writing this review to report that Corato's has Italian ices! This might be one of the few pizzerias within a several block radius that has these. I got a small rainbow ice for one dollar and some change. They have about six flavors, including rainbow (my favorite) and cherry (my second favorite). If you're looking for an icy treat and just have some pocket change, Corato's has your back. read more

Sad to give this review. This is following my most recent order from Corato 2. I ordered through Grubhub for pickup and showed up within minutes of it being "ready". My family and I were so excited to dig in as this is usually our favorite pizzeria. We were shocked at the state of the pizza. The crust was limp and stale, the cheese was congealed and floppy and the pepperoni had pools of grease starting to settle. The state of the pizza was abysmal. The sort of shit that way have passed as OK in bumfuck Kansas. We called the pizzeria to address the fact that they gave us an old pizza that was clearly sitting around for a while. The woman who picked up the phone copped an attitude the moment she realized we were not calling with an order. After some unnecessary back and forth, eventually the guy who made the pizza got on the phone and was a rude, smug, condescending bull faced liar. Them being rude as fuck is nothing new. That's kind of their MO. It's something we let slide so long as their pizza is fresh and delicious. But y'all can't be douches and have shit pizza. Not gonna fly. read more

Writing this review mainly so that I can remember what I thought of the pizza! Overall, I wasn't a fan. I ordered the gluten free pizza and I found the crust to have an unpleasant taste. I've been gluten free for over 7 years now and have tasted a ton of pizzas...there are some great ones out there. This one tasted like it maybe had too much of a specific flour in it, or maybe was only made up of one specific flour (like just tapioca or something). The upsides to the pizza were that the crust had a nice crispness to it and the pepperoni was flavorful. The cheese for some reason, wasn't as great as I think it could have been, it definitely did not help make up for the flavor of of the crust. They need to work on their flour blend. It was edible but I will not be ordering from here again. My girlfriend ordered a regular pizza and she said it was okay, but was way overpriced. She rated her pizza at a 3/5. So based on the price, the disappointment of the gluten free pizza and the average-ness of the regular pizza, I'd say they get a 2 or 2.5 out of 5. read more

Pizza was sooo salty couldn't eat it. I need to remember not to call this place. The delivery took over an hour to get really cold pizza wasn't even in the heat package most places use now to keep it warm. Very disappointing. read more

So disappointed with the service and knowledge about them menu's. Ordering buy the phone And receive not exactly what I order plus the garlic bread should come with marinara sauce or any sauce. When I call back telling them that that's not my order the respond Was " Oh we don't have that" So my question is why you don't tell me that from the start. Poor service read more

Corato Pizza is the best pizza in town! The ingredients are fresh, generous portions and the location is clean!The customer service is always great and make you feel at home! We have placed orders for delivery, have dined in and placed a catering order for our engagement party! Everyone loved the food at our party. If you are hungry, want good food at a good price come to Corato's. #supportsmallbusiness read more

Great staff in my experience always accommodating. One of the guys always remembers my typical order. The pizza is sold classic Brooklyn/queens pizza. On par w what I grew up with in a very Italian neighborhood. I love their non pizza items also - specifically their simple pasta and broccoli dish- really hits the spot when so much in the area is a pile of fried grease. I hope this spot sticks around and snooty ppl moving further out from Williamsburg don't mess w it lol read more

Waste of money....food was bad!!! Lasagna burnt! Tried to eat it but sauce tasted like canned tomato paste mixed with meat...cheese only on top...very poor quality! I'd give 0 stars but I couldn't post without giving one...I had other items too but this was sad! read more

This was a wonderful experience! This pizza has the old school taste- incredible! Loved the fillet of fish, tuna, turkey, garlic puffs, chicken gyro- jalapeno poppers and the people running the place to boot! Will use again! read more

This is our normal pizza spot we get delivery from, and every time it is hot, delicious, and exactly what we ordered. Tonight is eggplant and ricotta pizza! Delicious! read more

Corato Pizza II - 3. Eggplant and Ricotta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ridgewood, New York

Slightly better than Corato I, but still mediocre. Expect inconsistency, and dry or burnt product. Open late, at least. read more

Amazing food. Great service. The Spinach stuffed slice is my favorite

An office I frequent ordered lunch from here. I had a regular slice and a slice with chicken & broccoli. The regular slice wasn't bad - it was fairly large and was decent by all local standards. The chicken & broccoli slice wasn't good at all. I'll rate this 3/5 on the strength of the regular slice, because ultimately, a regular slice is a solid measure for overall quality. read more

May I just say...VERY reasonable price for what you get. Generous with toppings and the pie sizes are much bigger than the norm. My boyfriend and I ordered a large because we were pretty hungry and are used to the smaller sized pies, like the ones you get at Roberta's. (Not hating.. luv u Roberta's!) I think less is more and this was way too much cheese for us. Thick crust and doughy but good sauce. Large for $17 and THIS PIE WAS HUGE. Good bang for your buck! read more

Corato Pizza II - HUGE large cheese pie. Added additional topping for $2 - Pizza Near Me - Ridgewood, New York

I ordered from Corato Pizza II for Father's Day and couldn't believe how delicious the food was. The portions were huge, the sauce was excellent, and the price was incredible for the amount of food I ordered. It was so good, my mom called them to thank them and let them know how much we enjoyed the food. We will definitely be ordering from them again!!! read more

I had a vegan cheese grandma pie delivered, this was probably one of the best pizzas I've ever had in my life! It was literally perfect. Amazing crust, the sauce was incredible, just enough cheese, and drizzled with some basil pesto. Highly highly recommend!! read more

Been eating here since I was a little girl. More frequently that I now live in the area. Be careful of the hidden fees. Delivery charge that's not on the menu. Menu changes and they don't tell you. Why do they get away with it? Cause their pizza is great read more

I ordered on Uber eats. The fettuccine Alfredo was okay. It was bland and I had to add seasonings but it was still good. It came with a roll which was really soft. read more

Corato Pizza II - Pizza Near Me - Ridgewood, New York

ABSOLUTELY THE WORST!!! First off, I have had Caesar salads and I have had amazing Caesar salads. I have never had a Caesar salad that was not only gross but tasted nothing like a Caesar salad... until now. Then I had a slice of Sicilian. They cut it into 12 pieces instead of 9. I thought it might be a large pie. Turns out it's a small pie, and each cheap-o slice is the size of a Stouffer's pizza bread slice (you know, the size of a slice of a baguette). Nonetheless, I should be happy as it tasted lame. The worst was the regular cheese pie. I have lived in L.A. since 1994 and had some of the worst pizza imaginable. This pie is as bad as the worst I've had in L.A. Maybe as bad as Domino's before they tried to re-hype their image. And that should be the greatest insult of all to a New York pizzeria. Fighting words. Unfortunately, it's the God's honest truth. Avoid at all costs. It's cheap, but you might as well wipe your bum with the money and set it on fire for all the good it's gonna do you ordering this inedible crap. read more

Corato Pizza 2 is a very clean restaurant, with a big seating area, and has a nice, warming atmosphere. At the back is the kitchen and the front cashier where you order your food. You can order from the menu, or point to what dish you want from the display case. I ordered a Cheese Calzone for $4.50, and my friend ordered a Stuffed Spinach Slice for around $3 and 6 powdered Zeppole for $1.65. We waited about 10 minutes for them to finish baking our orders and then sat down to eat. The Cheese Calzone was very large, and was gushing with cheesy goodness. My only complaint was that the crust was too thin to hold all the molten cheese, so it quickly broke. You definitely need to eat this dish with a knife and fork. The Stuffed Spinach Slice was as good. The ration between the spinach and cheese was perfect. There were equal amounts of spinach and cheese, and the crust was able to hold everything together. The Zeppole was delightful. It was covered with powdered sugar and was sweet. The texture of the Zeppole was soft, but still a bit crunchy. Good prices, adequate portions, clean space, and lots of seating. read more

See all

After 1 hour and 20 minutes I called to check the status of my order (MEATBALL SUB & FRIES) it hadn't left the shop yet, but would be shortly. Another 40 minutes passed, I called "it's been nearly 2 hours could you please expedite my order" his response "um, i don't know what that means.....it's coming" ** CLICK** food just arrived 2 hours and 35 minutes later - cold & soggy fries, the subs bread was like a wet diaper and what little sauce they used was cold. Fool me once..... read more

Food is good, but their customer service has gone downhill since la trattoria staff moved over. Some people should give it up if they hate the job or feel that entitled. Looking for another spot read more

My wife and I were regulars here for almost a year before we moved out of the neighborhood. The guys that work here are really friendly and there is literally nothing on the (large) menu that isn't worth trying. We would often order two slices of pizza (either sicilian, plain, or veggie) and two draft beers (cheaper than bottled) and wait for a larger item that we'd share (like pasta puttanesca, pasta with vodka sauce, or a garden salad with house dressing). It's also open late and they deliver (tip: you can read them your credit card on the phone if you're low on cash). Be patient, be nice, and enjoy being around good people and good italian food. Note: credit card minimum=$25, but they will be flexible if its around $20. EDIT: it's becoming obvious that most of the negative reviews here are confusing this location with the other (busier, similarly named) location. This is unfortunate considering how outstanding this place is. read more

Came to this spot the other day and was just so turned off by the fact they didn't have anything to eat really, and not even what I wanted was in stock. That really sucked and made the experience worse. I love the coratos on freshpond better they're way better!!!! read more

Once was enough. Corato Pizza II is better, but not by much. More like a last resort kind of place. The only advantage they have is that they're open late. read more

Restaurant accepted my order through seamless but never delivered. I get a call from Seamless 2 hours after I placed my order saying restaurant is closed. If closing why accept my order (I ordered at 7:15 and says restaurant is open til 10:30). The fact that no one called to cancel and let me starve is beyond unprofessional. This restaurant generally takes forever to deliver and now this unprofessionalism so this is my last time ordering from here. Food isn't worth it. read more

Great pizza. My son loves this place. The staff are always friendly and the prices are super reasonable. read more

See all

Get the grilled chicken salad! It comes with a homemade Italian dressing that is absolutely delicious. I eat it at least twice a week if not more. Pizza is better than most in the area, thought a tad bit more expensive, but overall, compared to whats around, its a safe bet to get it here. Chicken rolls are great as well. :) read more

Just paid over $6 for two slices of pizza which is bad enough but they were burnt to a crisp, both the top and bottom, and covered in grease. To make up for this, there was hardly any sauce, if there was any at all. Make sure you look at what they give you before you pay a dime for this slop. read more

If u want a good slice of pizza come here. Eat in and wait for the fresh pie. Always the way 2 go. read more

Corato Pizza II - Fresh pizza right out the oven. - Pizza Near Me - Ridgewood, New York

Ordered delivery. The pasta a la vodka is spectacular! We ordered through Eat24 and asked for rotelle but got fusilli, which worked super well with the sauce. The caprese salad and caprese hero are both very good, as is the Greek salad, though it does contain carrots. The caprese salad already has olive oil and is really good with the balsamic; caprese hero as is doesn't come with either oil or balsamic. Food arrived right when it said. Have ordered twice this week; first time I got the fusilli (aka rotelle) a la vodka, second time both my husband and I got the fusilli (aka rotelle) a la vodka :) read more

Best Pizza & best Penna alla Vodka ever. Prices are good and delivery is usually quick.