On our way home from vacation we had one last dinner with the family. I ordered the corn dogs and the #4 pizza special individual size. The pizza came out steaming hot and great flavor. The only downside was the fact it had too many toppings on it. Which is something I would never say lol! But, truly the extra cheese on top made it a little difficult to eat. Suggestions- The Hawaiian pizza sounds delicious i should have got that one. Moose Out read more

Best pizza in Hayward by far. We have a cabin in cable so frequent trips to Hayward occur and coops is always a staple. If we come for dinner the go to is usually a pepperoni and mushroom pizza with their wings (which are huge!!). But if you go for lunch the buffet is awesome- includes pizza, salad bar, soup, and breadsticks. Their French onion soup is incredible. The staff has also always been above and beyond and we very much appreciate that! read more

Coop's Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom large pie - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

From Chicago. Really enjoy Coops pizza! Probably the best pizza outside of the city...my opinion. Also greatly enjoy the broasted chicken...very tasty. Service is good. Like any place, they can get busy in the summer and service is challenged, but I've never had an issue. I'm a Coop fan! read more

Saturday, July 5th at 5:25 pm we placed an order for 2 pizzas for pick up. I was told it would be ready in 30 minutes. When I arrived at coops at 6:00 pm I paid for the pizza and waited for an hour. No pizza was brought out to me. I asked what was going on and was told they didn't know. They asked for my cell number and said they would call when the pizza was ready. 30 minutes later I received a call that the pizza were ready. When I picked them up I asked if they would compensate me since I had to wait 2 hours for my pizza including leaving and coming back for it. A manager was called over and said there was nothing they would do as this happens in July. When my family finally got the pizza they said it was good, so no complaints there. I'm just really disappointed that I had to wait so long since they apparently lost my order. read more

used to love going there with the huge fishtank that is now gone ! Pizza buffet is peperoni and sausage maybey a mushroom but if you want vegetables on it youll have to get from the salad bar overall its okay for 12.00 read more

Had the best pizza today! Love your salad bar with such a huge selection. The Valentine pepperoni pizza was perfect for today! Your staff is excellent! Lora & Chaz are great & always welcoming when we come in. The pepperoni , sausage, black olive & fresh mushroom pizza is the bomb! Highly recommend! read more

Coop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

The food especially the broasted chicken was really good. Service was terrible. Server didn't bother pouring drinks, picking up extra plates, napkins after a spill. Even the other servers who asked about our meal didn't bother to help clean up table or offer assistance during a spill. I didn't realize we should say we needed help after a spill, I thought it was obvious. read more

Food was great, waitress was nice, atmosphere was perfect for our family with small kids. We really had a nice evening siting outside on their relaxing patio!! Will definitely go back again! read more

Finally tried Coop's. Nice restaurant, very friendly staff & atmosphere. Good onion rings to start. Tried the meat eaters pizza. Crust is very thin and doesn't support the toppings. Basic tomato sauce. Feels like the pizza should be baked longer. read more

We usually get a pizza on our way out of town to head back home from vacation. I recently developed an intolerance to gluten but was happy to see Coops had a gluten free pizza crust. They open at 11 am and I called about 10.45 and my pizza was Ready by 11:10 am. Service was fast and Friendly. I was just going to order the one 10 inch gluten free pizza but my husband talked me into ordering two. I got them both the same with black olives, onions, green pepper and sausage. The first one covered lunch and dinner on the way home and the second one the same for the next day. They were delicious and satisfied me greatly. I make cauliflower pizza crust and have tried the fat heads homemade keto crusts and ground chicken crusts but this gluten free crust was the closest I've had to the regular crusts. What a treat! read more

Coop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

We always come here as we vacation here and always have supported coops- This time we were so turned off as an employee kept bringing a dog to the kitchen- very unhealthy- We love dogs but they do not belong in the kitchen of a restaurant! read more

One of my favorite pizza places. Love the fresh mushrooms. Salad bar has room for improvement. Servers are great. read more

I have been visiting Coop's each year for the past 20+ years since I was a child, always a highlight of our travels with my parents among other tourist attractions. My family and I drove over 3 hours to take our kids to a relic of my childhood. What a disappointment to discover that they believe the pandemic doesn't apply to them. None of the servers, hostesses, anyone - was wearing so much as a face shield. In fact, over 90% of the patrons were wearing one, most seeing the staff situation and then requesting an outside table. How are they not getting the message here?? STAY AWAY if you want to stay healthy. read more

Had driven past Coop's 100 times. Had heard mixed reviews. Couldn't recall ever having tried it, so decided to try it. Mistake. Not good pizza. Not good service. There are far better options for good pizza in the area. The Dock on B has great pizza. So does Round Man in Spooner. Pass on Coop's. read more

Always good food - we ordered a torpedo and cheeseburger sub and lasagna to go food was hot and tasty and quick the new look is awesome great job but miss the fish tank read more

Bar style pizza but good, the cheese quality is top notch too. If you're looking for NY style or Chicago this isn't it, but if you like pizza you'll like this place. read more

Coop's Pizza - Meat lover - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

The best pizza in Hayward! I come here for pizza every time I come to visit my parents. Only downfall is...I wish I didn't live 350 miles away read more

Coop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

Excellent chicken. Good pizza, definitely not lacking in toppings. Fast friendly service. Clean, attentive staff, good atmosphere! Highly recommend read more

pizza is mediocre. very slapped together, not much in freshness, sauce is terrible. seafood pizza take off the menu. no love at all. but for bar pizza i'd rather get a frozen pizza from a store. lasagna not great. taste like its taken out of the pan it was made in three days ago. sauce no go. chicken actually good but not a science behind the cooking of that. salad bar and soup, ok but not on freshness or quality of items all canned and dumped. service ok. ambiance is good, couldn't hear the person sitting across from me because of the music. myfoodreview21@yahoo.com read more

The pizza was AMAZING! I had homemade Italian sausage and onions, and the sausage was one of the best I have ever had! My wife is Vegan so she had a veggie with no cheese. She said it was the best vegan pizza she has ever had... who would have thought it would be in Hayward WI that she would say that!! read more

Go on a week day!!! This buffet delivers a great culinary experience as well as deliver a old timey vibe as well. I'd recommend getting the egg rolls and the chicken strips. The barbecue sauce is also amazing. Overall, a really nice choice when riding around trying to find something to eat. read more

The plain cheese was at best a four out of ten. Very flour-y and cheesey, whereas I perfer a more buttery crust. Our waters also had a soda-y aftertaste, like the drink machine wasn't separating the two. My friends who got the buffalo chicken pizza gave it a seven, so maybe just avoid the plain cheese. Service was good, food was cheap. read more

I would like to compliment the chef "Nicholas Miller" on the food he cooked. The business is all around high quality... Staff is kind and gracious thank you all for the amazing food and hospitality read more

Nick Miller did an amazing job on the food quick fast and delicious and I would recommend to anyone

While my family and friends were vacationing in Hayward a few weeks ago, we decided to grab some dinner at Coop's Pizza one of the nights and it was a disaster. Everything started out okay, we walked in.....We had four adults and three children, so we needed a big table so we suggested their big table by the aquarium, (our kids love fish), and they gave me some comment about how 'we are going to get busy here soon so I don't know if we want to give that table away'. Are you kidding me? We are spending the same, if not more money than another family that will be sitting in the exact same table. That just pissed me off a bit from the get go. We all put our orders in and had to wait a long time, probably 20 minutes, to get just one of the food items delivered to our table. Then the other items trickled in for a little while after that. My friend cancelled his order because he ate his side of soup and everyone else was done eating before he got the appetizer he ordered. Ridiculous. I got the Italian sausage sandwich, which I thought was going to be Italian sausage links on a hoagie with cheese, peppers, and sauce. What I got was a ground Italian sausage sandwich, hamburger-style with a side of marinara sauce and some fries. Pathetic. Overall, this was a horrible experience and I won't be going back if I'm in the area again. read more

Not for us. The pizza has a thinner cracker crust but was kind of difficult to bit through sometimes. The pizza sauce was a little too much on the sweet side for my liking. We did the lunch buffet and it really is a good deal. Salad bar was well stocked and the pasta salad was great. Soup was included as well (French onion and clam chowder). Overall a pretty good value if you like that style of pizza. Great atmosphere we especially enjoy all the older beer signage! read more

Meat Eater Pizza. So good. Good service. Cool vibes. Been going here since I was a kid. read more

Coop's Pizza - Meat Eater Pizza. So good. Good service. Cool vibes. Been going here since I was a kid. - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

Casual Up North ambience with a cool fish tank, great 80's music. Nice clean large restaurant with tables and booths to choose from. Lots of choices on menu from pizza to fried chicken dinners to sandwiches. Good selection of appetizers and beer, wine and mixed drinks. The pizza had a really good amount of cheese, sauce was just right, not too spicy, and nice crisp medium crust. We ordered the #4 and asked for the mushrooms on only half of the pizza but they could not do that for us. ??So the pizzas are not freshly made?? Other than that, we enjoyed our night at Coop's and will probably return to try the chicken. read more

We went here twice on our 2 week stay in Hayward and both times we were tremendously let down. We all got different things on the menu and everything was very bland and dry and just not good in general. The 2nd time we came here the family next to us waited an hour and a half for there food and never got it. Our food came out about 15 minutes separate from each other. They weren't even busy either so I don't know what the delay was. Everything is very overpriced as well, 11.50 for cheese curds and 17 for a beef sandwich that was about 5 inches long. Not worth it at all. Plenty of better places to eat in Hayward like Riverstreet Family Restaurant or Anglers Bar and Grill. Will never be coming back here. read more

I'd like to tell you what we thought of the food but after 20 minutes we flagged down a waitress and she couldn't be bothered with us she had "a few other things to do" before she could take our order! Couldn't even bring us water. A shame, Coops used to be known for their service. we won't be back read more

Great pizza when you're up at the lake or staying in NW Wisconsin. Easy drive from Minong and Spooner and worth the extra miles. Full menu of burgers, sandwiches and lunch/dinner. Salad bar is small but adequate. Weekly buffet lunch specials. Pizza is above average with a great variety of toppings and a puffy yet not too yeasty crust. Definitely fork-and-knife pizza as the sauce is thin and very mild (the way I like it). And it's Wisconsin so lots of great cheese! Recommended. read more

Coop's Pizza - 10" salami, garlic, green olive and onion - around $13 - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, Wisconsin

Usually a great place to to eat in or for carryout. I was kept on hold for over 20 minutes waiting to order without even an explanation. Very poor customer service. read more

The pizza, to my liking was not edible. The dough tasted like a biscuit and was bland. Maybe the pizza didn't come out right because we have eaten there before and it was good. When we asked The hostess, if there was anything she could do, she got defensive. Also, I felt it was overpriced, feel bad paying $15 for a 10 inch pizza that was not cooked right. I felt the manager - hostess could have reacted better in making me another or offering me a discount. And it was not just me I was there with someone else who also was of the same opinion. read more

Best pizza ever. Any pizza I eat I compare to coops. Love the huge fish tank. Great staff

The best pizza I've ever had! Literally this place is a family owned business with 3 people working. They crank out the best pizza ever. It is comparable to the slices in NYC. The staff is also super friendly and do their best to accommodate. They are really busy so show up an hour before to order. It will be worth the wait. read more

Nice place, good food. It was great to walk into a restaurant and nobody jumped on you to wear a mask! They had a salad bar that you could actually get your own salad. No mask was amazing!!! Thank you!! read more

Curb appeal was great with the log structure, outside seating and located just off the main road. Inside atmosphere was perfect for a family with little kids ( music and fish tank entertainment). The service was great even during these hard to find employees times(thanks covid) and our waitress was very nice and very helpful. Pizza taste was great and was nice they had a salad bar if you wanted to snack while you wait. I will definitely visit this establishment again in the near future!! read more

My all time favorite pizza place! I had the garlic chicken pizza and it was so good and the service was super fast and everyone was so nice!! read more

We were debating between here and a place an hour away- I think we would have gotten our drinks faster at the other place (drive time included). Waited about 20 minutes for our server to notice us- told us she had to put someone else's order in before getting to us. Drinks took forever- watched the bartender pour himself a beer before he eventually got to our Bloody Mary's. If you want a pop refill- you're not gonna get one. The server clearly had no time for us. Lots of people standing around who could have helped... food was ok- pizza was salty. Honestly, not worth the wait for the so-so pizza. I've worked in the industry... lots of service training needed- let me know! read more

We were greeted and seated by the hostess, she said our waitress would be right with us. We sat there for 15 minutes without being acknowledged. I could maybe understand if they were busy but that wasn't the case. We ended up leaving after a few other customers were waited on that were seated after us. Extremely poor service!! read more