Cute little place! Came inside to get a little warm…read more Ordered a hot apple chai and was the perfect sweetness. Lots of delicious looking pastries too! Great service!

The CUTEST little bakery and coffee shop, lined with photos from the turn of the 20th century. I…read morewas greeted kindly, served quickly and the prices were affordable! The Bishop's Hat tasted a bit like it had been in a freezer, and was soggy. Still edible but not what I expected from an otherwise lovely establishment. The espresso was deep and chocolatey, showing little to no signs of acidity, which I quite liked! Must come back again to give the pastry another shot!

Hard cookies. Delicious elderberry pie which is hard to find elsewhere. Friendly employee. Lots of…read more donuts but they weren't too soft on the weekend I went.

Food and service are always the best.... Not to mention the prices! Easy to order and pull up to…read morethe window, pay and go. The best pies around!

That counter help is friendly and knowledgeable. Shop is always clean and inviting. Pastries are…read morefresh and well prepared. There's a good selection. These pastries are more enjoyable to me since they are not overly sweet.

Great place the owners are amazing live to take grand daughter there she loves Amy's cookiesread more

Absolutely delicious and amazing service! We wanted a fun surprise for finding out our baby's…read moregender, and Chris helped us out in the form of a delicious and beautiful cheesecake. It was perfect! We were even able to pick up on short notice. We will definitely be back for future birthdays and celebrations. Thank you for giving us such a wonderful experience!

I ordered a cheesecake from this person that makes cakes out of his house. I had to order from the…read morewebsite. I ordered on Oct 22 for a cake delivery on Oct 27th. On the 27th I waited until the delivery time had passed and called the number on the website. He answered the phone and when I told him I was waiting for an order, he said he didn't have any orders and that he was on vacation. He said his site should not have accepted an order. I had already checked my credit card bill and had been billed for the cake. He was extremely rude and said "there's nothing I can do because I'm on vacation!". I told him I would want a refund, to which he replied "I can't do anything as I'M ON VACATION". He didn't bother to tell me when he might do a refund. I reached out to him through Instant Messenger several times with no response. On November 15th, he replied on Messenger that he had refunded me on November 7th. Today is November 22nd and I STILL don't have the promised refund! I'm having to dispute it with my credit card...

Ordered this pizza for lunch, which was pretty pricey. Honestly, the food cost on this thing…read moremust've been like three dollars at best. It was a 12 inch type sized pizza with not much to it and I didn't think the taste was unbelievably different or special. Looked like they use sandwich pepperoni, which is just kind ok believe it. This is ordered as a double pepperoni pizza. Probably would never order this again.

I enjoyed one of the daily specials. It was a polenta and shrimp dish with a delicious spicy sauce…read more I also enjoyed a cocktail and the potstickers. The potstickers were ok, nothing special. What really sets this restaurant apart is the service. Kaitlin was our server and she was so gracious and helpful in selecting entrees. We also met her twin sister who works there as well. They are both sweet and kind. We enjoyed being able to communicate in ASL with them. The ambiance is a bit rustic meets artsy meets cabin. It's kind of loud so if you're looking for a quiet spot, this isn't it. But the food is very good. They serve food and drinks on creative tableware and glasses. But it was odd that the flatware was the cheapest kind you can get. All that said, this is a nice dining spot in Wooster if you're in town.

Cool vibe but the pastries were stale/hard. The coffee tasted a little burnt. For $12 I would've…read moreexpected more. They also added cold foam on top of my drink which I didn't ask for and they didn't even mention at the POS. So I hope they weren't surprise charging more for it. I also overheard another customer asking for mayo saying that their breakfast item was dry and one of the employees said they could have a little bit of mayo but they would have to charge her an extra 80¢ which seems a little ridiculous if you serve food you should be able to give someone a little bit of mayo or ketchup for free.

Fantastic food and service. The vibes are very calm and great for getting work done. Favorite…read morecoffee shop to this day. I went to college in Wooster and miss it sm!!

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE. I want to start by saying this review is not about the food itself. The baked…read moregoods are delicious and if you're in Wooster you should give them a try. My issue is with the service and never actually receiving my order. I placed an order on December 8th, 2024. My order was confirmed and my money was taken yet I did not ever get my food. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED SCREENSHOTS. If you look on the bottom right corner you can see I am writing this on February, 27th 2025 and my order still says it is in transit on Butter & Fire's website, BUT according to USPS was never brought to the site to be shipped. I was extremely disappointed because this was the second time my household has tried ordering from them. The first time we were at an apartment so we figured that it is easy to get mixed up there, but this time we ordered to a house and it was never even sent! When my fiance reached out about both orders again and the legitimacy of our concerns were questioned. If we were lying or trying to pull one over on them we would have tried to get money- WE JUST WANTED THE SCONES!!!

I usually stop in here over the summer when I am watching my friend's boys! We love making a little…read morestop to get a package of cookies as a sweet treat before the park and with lunch! I love stopping in here to get goodies! I actually used their strawberry and banana cream pies for my bridal shower, and we didn't have any left! I love how convenient it is to stop and curb my sweet tooth!

Have always had excellent service any choice on menu is so good! Little more to savor next day…read moreand pastries...... Yum

It's a yes for me! Quiet, old home time feeling. Would revisit. I recommend…read more........ A favorite

This is s a great place to meet friends for lunch and a good but not gourmet…read more Lunch. I like their breakfast, burgers soups etc. Menu rarely changes so it's easy to decide. We like it after church and see friends

I have been buying cupcakes here since they originally opened downtown in the lower level of the…read moreCommons. The cupcakes aren't only beautifully decorated, they are delicious. They offer an impressive variety. The cookies are so good and equally delicious. Two top favorites are Wedding Cake and Curly Q. The young lady who works there (Rhonda) is super friendly, helpful and well informed. She is just the best! I highly recommend this sweet spot.

Another great Wooster spot! Their cake is always fabulous! I loved this particular cupcake in the…read morephoto! I believe it was almond with cherry! So good!