Miss Amy&#x27;s Bakery

Since the theme of the past week has been Eastern Europe cakes, it was imperative that I tried a…read moreDobos torte from Hungary to complete the trio (this past weekend I tried Austrian and Serbian cakes). I think Tulipan's take on the Dobos torte was probably the least authentic of the three, but it was not a bad cake. I've seen it with more layers and a caramel top. This one had four layers (still impressive and a pain in the arse to make I'm sure!) and no caramel. This bakery is very cute and the service is very friendly. My son also asked for some macarons, which he seemed to like, but he couldn't finish them because he said he was full. We were there around 12:30 PM and I think most of the items were fairly picked over in the bakery case by that time. There was an interesting raspberry thing that I wanted to try, but the person in line right before me bought the last one. The baklava looked temping too. I am pretty proud of myself for not buying too many sweets. I would return here if I were in the area and try some different items.

Cute little place! Came inside to get a little warm…read more Ordered a hot apple chai and was the perfect sweetness. Lots of delicious looking pastries too! Great service!

Hungarian tea cake, honey cakes, baklava, and mix of raspberry and apricot kifli

See all

Broken Rocks Cafe & Bakery

4.1(263 reviews)

I have been here a few times and have loved my food every time. Customer service is always…read morewonderful and the food is fresh and perfect. I love the portion sizes that aren't overwhelming-they're just right. I have enjoyed the cheese platter, the hummus plate, the chicken Marsala and the jambalaya. The desserts are lovely as well!

I want to start with our server, Natalie, was fantastic. Very sweet and attentive. The food is just…read morelacking. We started with the Pot Stickers. They were so tiny for $16. Hardly any filling. I got the Oriental Almond Chicken. It was very bland. The "sauce" was very soupy. Veggies were overcooked. And there were like three soggy almonds in the dish. Also a pretty small portion for the price. My fiancé got the Louisiana Shrimp Pasta. Again, small portions for the price. Shrimp was not great quality and way over cooked. The "sauce" was so runny with no flavor. Finally we hoped for redemption with dessert but were disappointed again. Bananas Foster is such a classic that shouldn't be hard to get right. Mushy bananas, cold and dry chocolate torte just did not mix well.

Welcome

See all

Hartzler Family Dairy

4.6(91 reviews)

0.6 mi

I love their flavored milk, its the best i have ever tasted..i am addicted,i am sad when ever the…read moregrocery store is sold out.

Hartzler does its job well. If you want good ice cream and milk, you're going to get good ice cream…read moreand milk. With a strong selection of flavors in both categories, you're bound to be satisfied. Tip: Don't be afraid to try the discounted milk. Though it's closer to expiration, you could not tell via smell or taste. You can get great value if you're looking to sample different flavors (ex: chocolate, strawberry) or if you're feeding a family of thirsty lactose tolerants

See all

Dari-Land Ice Cream

3.3(14 reviews)

Was down getting fence for my cattle pastures and wanted a milk shake. Found this place on yelp of…read morecourse. Really good chocolate milk shake and my wife had a Sunday. Service was quick and friendly. If you are in the Wooster area give the place a try.

Great place to pick up a quick dessert. The staff was helpful and friendly when we ordered. Liked…read morethe taste of the ice cream. Ordered a flurry and the ice cream to cookie dough ratio was great. I could taste both the ice cream and cookie dough. My friend ate a small chocolate hand dipped ice cream and said it was yummy.

Milkshake menu

Small Sundae

See all

Troyer's Home Pantry II

4.5(6 reviews)

4.0 mi

Hard cookies. Delicious elderberry pie which is hard to find elsewhere. Friendly employee. Lots of…read more donuts but they weren't too soft on the weekend I went.

Food and service are always the best.... Not to mention the prices! Easy to order and pull up to…read morethe window, pay and go. The best pies around!

Whippt Dalgona Coffee

4.0(21 reviews)

We stopped in while walking by. If you're in the mood for a…read moresweet drink it's not a bad place but if you want an authentic coffee than this won't be your place. The woman was nice for the most part but acted like a sales person, some people might like that but it was kinda a ick for us. I got a frappe, the texture was great 9/10 The coffee taste wasnt great 4/10 And the sweetness was so strong and the flavor was overbearing.2/10 I'm not the type to leave bad reviews, I just love good authentic coffees and if that's what you're in the mood for I wouldn't recommend it. If you like sweet drinks and high caffeinated drinks than this is the perfect place for you, I have friends that would probably love it. The medium size coffee is also 13$, not complaining, just warning.

Me wanting coffee, I decided to check out a place downtown Wooster we have never been to…read more Whippt (Dalgona South Korean Style Coffee) Smooth vegan real coffee concentrate that is prepared by whipping rather than brewing. You can create your own with the flavors and toppings she has and can get it iced or hot. Not knowing what to expect, I was impressed as it was fabulous and I will most definitely have to make my way downtown again

24 oz. Whippt Coffee (Cold Only)

Getting the best coffee drink in Wooster bar none

See all

Potion

Baskin Robbins

2.0(1 review)

2.5 mi

If you would like to go somewhere with amazing options for cones and 31 delicious flavors look…read morefurther. They had one bowl left, only normal cones and a small scoop on top of the cone, no ice cream inside, my ice cream almost fell straight off the cone. I've been to others and got much better service. The least I can say is the staff seemed nice.

Butter & Fire Bakery

1.0(1 review)

5.7 mi

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE. I want to start by saying this review is not about the food itself. The baked…read moregoods are delicious and if you're in Wooster you should give them a try. My issue is with the service and never actually receiving my order. I placed an order on December 8th, 2024. My order was confirmed and my money was taken yet I did not ever get my food. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED SCREENSHOTS. If you look on the bottom right corner you can see I am writing this on February, 27th 2025 and my order still says it is in transit on Butter & Fire's website, BUT according to USPS was never brought to the site to be shipped. I was extremely disappointed because this was the second time my household has tried ordering from them. The first time we were at an apartment so we figured that it is easy to get mixed up there, but this time we ordered to a house and it was never even sent! When my fiance reached out about both orders again and the legitimacy of our concerns were questioned. If we were lying or trying to pull one over on them we would have tried to get money- WE JUST WANTED THE SCONES!!!

See all

Troyer's Home Pantry

4.3(15 reviews)

8.4 mi

I usually stop in here over the summer when I am watching my friend's boys! We love making a little…read morestop to get a package of cookies as a sweet treat before the park and with lunch! I love stopping in here to get goodies! I actually used their strawberry and banana cream pies for my bridal shower, and we didn't have any left! I love how convenient it is to stop and curb my sweet tooth!

Have always had excellent service any choice on menu is so good! Little more to savor next day…read moreand pastries...... Yum

50% left of euphoria.

See all

Apple dumplings now available!

Lionsgate

4.3(8 reviews)

7.6 mi

Review applies to pizza only…read more I really wanted to like this place and read every single review on here. Counter to one review, I did not find the pizza too salty. It was cooked to perfection and adequately topped with all the items I ordered, except for one: SAUCE. Every piece had about a teaspoon of sauce, leaving the pizza essentially flavorless. It wasn't BAD per se, but every bite left something to be desired. If you're still curious, get extra sauce and it might save the pizza. But in all honesty, the "Hunt Brothers" pizza by the slice that you can find at many nearby gas stations is significantly better than this.

My wife and I stopped at this odd little building out in the middle of nowhere, because at the last…read moremoment she saw a small yard sign that said "Ice Cream". So we pulled off and found ourselves on a weedy gravel driveway in front of an old English cottage looking house. We went inside and found ourselves in a cramped entryway with signs, trinkets, and just stuff. Directly ahead of us was a freezer with the "Homemade" ice cream logo, and on the right at a 90 degree angle was another ice cream case with a small square counter between them to place finished pies. It was very difficult to find room to place an order or even take picture, but his small company must do a tremendous amount of business considering the amount of pizza they sold while we waited to order, it was nonstop! My wife got two hard scoops and I an apple pie soft serve. Both were served in large white Styrofoam cups and the cost $5 each. This may sound like a lot for a cup of ice cream but it's actually a bargain considering a "large" is nearly a quart! We did not sit on their patio, but in our car. The respite was delicious! If you are out tooling around and feel the urge for some great ice cream, (can't speak for the pizza) be sure to make Lionsgate your next destination.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Olivia N.

52

3

14

6 years ago

They've expanded their fresh bread and keto section! The honey butter rolls are to DIE for!

Mellissa F.

2

1

0

8 years ago

I like a amazing miss Amy's bakery is i will tell my family and friends about this place

Miss Amy's Bakery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Restaurants near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Desserts near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Things to Do near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Coffee near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Breakfast near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Shopping near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Ice Cream near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Lunch near Miss Amy's Bakery

BEST of Wooster, Ohio Thrift Stores near Miss Amy's Bakery

Best of Wooster

Things to do in Wooster

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Miss Amy's Bakery also viewed

Tiffany's Bakery

4.2

(70 reviews)

Called late in the week for a red velvet birthday cake for my husband that Wednesday and Tiffany's…read moreBakery was happy to take the order. Followed my instructions exactly and gave me a choice of half payment or full payment at the time of the order. Picking up was easy easy and I picked up a scoop of amaretto cherry ice cream (my favorite flavor ever) for my drive home. They have the same brand of ice cream as Rocky Mountain Chocolate!! They also sell slices of cake and lots of pastries which will require future visits!

My wedding cake was the talk of the night. This was the best cake I've ever had. The owner was very…read morehelpful. I will definitely order more cakes from here.

Troyer's Home Pantry II

4.5

(6 reviews)

Hard cookies. Delicious elderberry pie which is hard to find elsewhere. Friendly employee. Lots of…read more donuts but they weren't too soft on the weekend I went.

Food and service are always the best.... Not to mention the prices! Easy to order and pull up to…read morethe window, pay and go. The best pies around!

Cardinal Cakes & Coffee

4.7

(27 reviews)

Cardinal coffee and cakes has been on my list for a while now as I love trying out new cafes and…read morebakeshops. This place is ADORABLE. It has so much charm to it. The people are incredibly friendly, not only the workers but everyone who was there which shows the audience this cafe attracts. It was awesome to see the wide arrangement of drink options from hot to cold to energy infused drinks with Red Bull. They also had a TON of house baked goods. Scones, muffins, cinnamon rolls, strudels and more. They even have lots of various breads to choose from and cakes! They have inside and outside seating which is charming and simple. The food is great and the drinks are high quality and refreshing. The cinnamon rolls warmed up in the microwave were probably some of the best I've ever eaten.The cream cheese frosting is to die for as well as the strawberry rhubarb filling (I need a jar of it). Muffins are SO MOIST and great texture/flavors. I also really liked that by the cash register they had some pre wrapped baked goods that were slightly discounted meaning they were probably leftovers from the previous day or what not so I like that they do not waste! Overall, if you are in the area or a short drive away please stop in and you won't regret it!

This is one of our favorite spots to grab coffee and a treat. Cardinal Cakes has a wide variety of…read moredrink options to choose from, including a seasonal menu. My favorite drink is the maple cinnamon roll latte - a very unique flavor! The pastries can be difficult to choose from because everything looks good! Typically I stick with one of their scones. Lately I have been getting one for now and another for the next morning! They keep very well overnight and still taste fresh the next day. The ambiance is inviting and relaxing. Their breakfast sandwiches are very good! The only problem is they stop serving them around 11:00 or 12:00 depending on whether it's a weekday or a weekend. The last couple of times I stopped in, I left disappointed because I missed the cutoff for the sandwiches. Cardinal Cakes & Coffee is an excellent choice for any coffee enthusiasts or people in search of a quality breakfast.

Cookie Snob

5.0

(3 reviews)

Now under new ownership. We love the new owners. The cookies are fabulous! They make special order…read morecookies, cupcakes and cakes. Check their website out abs grab to go on Saturday mornings. Get there early they sell out quickly.

The cookie snob made these delicious sugar cookies, and the shape of a football. Of course the…read morefrosting was brown. What was a great surprise to me is that they tasted like fudge!

Hartzler Family Dairy

4.6

(91 reviews)

I love their flavored milk, its the best i have ever tasted..i am addicted,i am sad when ever the…read moregrocery store is sold out.

Hartzler does its job well. If you want good ice cream and milk, you're going to get good ice cream…read moreand milk. With a strong selection of flavors in both categories, you're bound to be satisfied. Tip: Don't be afraid to try the discounted milk. Though it's closer to expiration, you could not tell via smell or taste. You can get great value if you're looking to sample different flavors (ex: chocolate, strawberry) or if you're feeding a family of thirsty lactose tolerants

Breads of Fairlawn

4.7

(36 reviews)

Fantastic fresh bread made with wholesome ingredients. Very reasonable pricing too. Bring your…read morecash, Debit or checks they don't take credit.

Wow--this is a quick review to match the quickness of the service…read more I stopped by Breads of Fairlawn this morning, just two days before Christmas. Parking was easy, and the door was wide open when I arrived around 9:00 a.m. The line wasn't too long, which was impressive given the timing. As I waited, I noticed one of the many signs stating cash or check only--uh oh. I rummaged through my purse and managed to come up with $8.00. Whew! Just enough for what I was hoping for: a loaf of sourdough. I love sourdough. Mine was a complete failure back when everyone else mastered it during the COVID era. Since my husband is gluten-free, bread has mostly disappeared from our home, and when I do buy it, I usually choose small half-loaves for the freezer. But with Christmas here, I decided to treat myself to a full, good-tasting loaf--and I found exactly that. The sourdough loaf was $7.00, and they offered to slice it at no extra charge. I was also offered samples (which I happily accepted). I tried the Parmesan-crusted onion bread and immediately understood the hype. The crust was chewy, the cheese flavorful, and there was a subtle onion finish--perfect for snacking on the way home without dipping into my new loaf. Once home, I tried the sourdough. The end piece is always my favorite test bite, and it did not disappoint. The shop itself is cozy but efficient, easy to get in and out of, and conveniently located near Route 18. The aroma of fresh bread was divine, and the staff was fun, friendly, and incredibly helpful--even with the steady flow of customers picking up holiday goodies. I also learned they accept Venmo and Zelle, which is great to know for next time. They even offered me a calendar of their daily bread specials, and I noticed that sourdough is one of their regular daily offerings--very good to know. I'm really looking forward to going back.

Leach's Meats & Sweets

4.0

(47 reviews)

My family and I have been getting all of our cakes from here for years!! My wedding cake even came…read morefrom here back in 2011. For Easter, I requested two cakes and they were HUGE HITS! Vanilla and carrot. Thanks for always being awesome!!!! The decorating is so on point!

I have to admit, walking into the location gives me sensory confusion. On one hand, you smell…read moremeat. On the other hand, you smell sweets. It is what they say it is. It is just funny to experience it. The folks are always kind and efficient there and I've only ever gotten their donuts, so that is all I can speak for. I must say, they are pretty epic in the best way. I typically eat pretty clean, but about my treats, Leaches is always worth it. Strong recommend from me.

Cheesecakery Wooster

3.0

(2 reviews)

Absolutely delicious and amazing service! We wanted a fun surprise for finding out our baby's…read moregender, and Chris helped us out in the form of a delicious and beautiful cheesecake. It was perfect! We were even able to pick up on short notice. We will definitely be back for future birthdays and celebrations. Thank you for giving us such a wonderful experience!

I ordered a cheesecake from this person that makes cakes out of his house. I had to order from the…read morewebsite. I ordered on Oct 22 for a cake delivery on Oct 27th. On the 27th I waited until the delivery time had passed and called the number on the website. He answered the phone and when I told him I was waiting for an order, he said he didn't have any orders and that he was on vacation. He said his site should not have accepted an order. I had already checked my credit card bill and had been billed for the cake. He was extremely rude and said "there's nothing I can do because I'm on vacation!". I told him I would want a refund, to which he replied "I can't do anything as I'M ON VACATION". He didn't bother to tell me when he might do a refund. I reached out to him through Instant Messenger several times with no response. On November 15th, he replied on Messenger that he had refunded me on November 7th. Today is November 22nd and I STILL don't have the promised refund! I'm having to dispute it with my credit card...

OH-YO! Frozen Yogurt - Wooster

4.0

(7 reviews)

This is basically your run-of-the-mill froyo joint. I really dig their name's wordplay though! Lots…read moreof Ohio pride there and makes it unique. For what I know in the froyo world they have about all the same stuff as you can get at most others. There are 12 different flavors of frozen yogurt and there must be at least 50 different toppings. I thought it was impressive they had so many different flavors of popping boba. And yet they didn't have my favorite - strawberry - at the time I came in. The prices are also what you'd expect. Be careful, that cup fills up quick and you'll end up paying $5+ at the register. It's usually run by a couple of high school kids. This actually sounds like a good idea for a small business in terms of cost to payoff, the more I think about it. Seating is minimal and there's outdoor seating for those warmer days. Worth a try if you have a hankerin' for froyo.

The food was very delicious and the employees were very efficient and nice to everyone. The…read morerestaurant was cute and spacious as well.

Local Roots Market and Café

4.7

(55 reviews)