Cute little place! Came inside to get a little warm…read more Ordered a hot apple chai and was the perfect sweetness. Lots of delicious looking pastries too! Great service!

The CUTEST little bakery and coffee shop, lined with photos from the turn of the 20th century. I…read morewas greeted kindly, served quickly and the prices were affordable! The Bishop's Hat tasted a bit like it had been in a freezer, and was soggy. Still edible but not what I expected from an otherwise lovely establishment. The espresso was deep and chocolatey, showing little to no signs of acidity, which I quite liked! Must come back again to give the pastry another shot!

Ordered this pizza for lunch, which was pretty pricey. Honestly, the food cost on this thing…read moremust've been like three dollars at best. It was a 12 inch type sized pizza with not much to it and I didn't think the taste was unbelievably different or special. Looked like they use sandwich pepperoni, which is just kind ok believe it. This is ordered as a double pepperoni pizza. Probably would never order this again.

I enjoyed one of the daily specials. It was a polenta and shrimp dish with a delicious spicy sauce…read more I also enjoyed a cocktail and the potstickers. The potstickers were ok, nothing special. What really sets this restaurant apart is the service. Kaitlin was our server and she was so gracious and helpful in selecting entrees. We also met her twin sister who works there as well. They are both sweet and kind. We enjoyed being able to communicate in ASL with them. The ambiance is a bit rustic meets artsy meets cabin. It's kind of loud so if you're looking for a quiet spot, this isn't it. But the food is very good. They serve food and drinks on creative tableware and glasses. But it was odd that the flatware was the cheapest kind you can get. All that said, this is a nice dining spot in Wooster if you're in town.

We stopped in to get the Egg Nog and ended up getting 4oz 4 flavor flight…read more What a great idea, ice cream flight. Farmhouse, waffely good, cheery cheese cake and mocha Carmel chip. We liked Farmhouse the best, but they are all very good ice cream. Staff is very nice, and we're so happy to get to visit the store, since we have only had their egg nog purchased at other retail outlets.

Was visiting Ohio and Amish country so on way back to Cleveland daughter recommend we stop here for…read moresome ice cream and milk! Place is great wish we lived here to keep enjoying that chocolate milk

Super yummy food. Super yummy food. Super yummy food. Super yummy food. Super yummy food. Servers…read morewere highly intelligent. Very pleasant establishment for getting a quick treat.

Was down getting fence for my cattle pastures and wanted a milk shake. Found this place on yelp of…read morecourse. Really good chocolate milk shake and my wife had a Sunday. Service was quick and friendly. If you are in the Wooster area give the place a try.

Hard cookies. Delicious elderberry pie which is hard to find elsewhere. Friendly employee. Lots of…read more donuts but they weren't too soft on the weekend I went.

Food and service are always the best.... Not to mention the prices! Easy to order and pull up to…read morethe window, pay and go. The best pies around!

We stopped in while walking by. If you're in the mood for a…read moresweet drink it's not a bad place but if you want an authentic coffee than this won't be your place. The woman was nice for the most part but acted like a sales person, some people might like that but it was kinda a ick for us. I got a frappe, the texture was great 9/10 The coffee taste wasnt great 4/10 And the sweetness was so strong and the flavor was overbearing.2/10 I'm not the type to leave bad reviews, I just love good authentic coffees and if that's what you're in the mood for I wouldn't recommend it. If you like sweet drinks and high caffeinated drinks than this is the perfect place for you, I have friends that would probably love it. The medium size coffee is also 13$, not complaining, just warning.

My wife and I stopped in on our way out of town with our two young daughters on the day after new…read moreyear. The owner was behind the counter working and was very helpful and explained all of our options to us, as we were unfamiliar with this kind of coffee. The iced coffees were very good and much different than anything we've had before. I would be curious to try this type of coffee hot next time, but the iced coffee was definitely good, and the serving sizes were huge. Our young daughters each had a lemonade (and I believe watermelon, but I can't remember for sure) ice pop which they both enjoyed as well. Would definitely stop by again if we're in town. Very unique product and it's good to know that small businesses are doing cool things even in small towns.

If you would like to go somewhere with amazing options for cones and 31 delicious flavors look…read morefurther. They had one bowl left, only normal cones and a small scoop on top of the cone, no ice cream inside, my ice cream almost fell straight off the cone. I've been to others and got much better service. The least I can say is the staff seemed nice.

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE. I want to start by saying this review is not about the food itself. The baked…read moregoods are delicious and if you're in Wooster you should give them a try. My issue is with the service and never actually receiving my order. I placed an order on December 8th, 2024. My order was confirmed and my money was taken yet I did not ever get my food. PLEASE SEE ATTACHED SCREENSHOTS. If you look on the bottom right corner you can see I am writing this on February, 27th 2025 and my order still says it is in transit on Butter & Fire's website, BUT according to USPS was never brought to the site to be shipped. I was extremely disappointed because this was the second time my household has tried ordering from them. The first time we were at an apartment so we figured that it is easy to get mixed up there, but this time we ordered to a house and it was never even sent! When my fiance reached out about both orders again and the legitimacy of our concerns were questioned. If we were lying or trying to pull one over on them we would have tried to get money- WE JUST WANTED THE SCONES!!!

I usually stop in here over the summer when I am watching my friend's boys! We love making a little…read morestop to get a package of cookies as a sweet treat before the park and with lunch! I love stopping in here to get goodies! I actually used their strawberry and banana cream pies for my bridal shower, and we didn't have any left! I love how convenient it is to stop and curb my sweet tooth!

Have always had excellent service any choice on menu is so good! Little more to savor next day…read moreand pastries...... Yum

Review applies to pizza only…read more I really wanted to like this place and read every single review on here. Counter to one review, I did not find the pizza too salty. It was cooked to perfection and adequately topped with all the items I ordered, except for one: SAUCE. Every piece had about a teaspoon of sauce, leaving the pizza essentially flavorless. It wasn't BAD per se, but every bite left something to be desired. If you're still curious, get extra sauce and it might save the pizza. But in all honesty, the "Hunt Brothers" pizza by the slice that you can find at many nearby gas stations is significantly better than this.

My wife and I stopped at this odd little building out in the middle of nowhere, because at the last…read moremoment she saw a small yard sign that said "Ice Cream". So we pulled off and found ourselves on a weedy gravel driveway in front of an old English cottage looking house. We went inside and found ourselves in a cramped entryway with signs, trinkets, and just stuff. Directly ahead of us was a freezer with the "Homemade" ice cream logo, and on the right at a 90 degree angle was another ice cream case with a small square counter between them to place finished pies. It was very difficult to find room to place an order or even take picture, but his small company must do a tremendous amount of business considering the amount of pizza they sold while we waited to order, it was nonstop! My wife got two hard scoops and I an apple pie soft serve. Both were served in large white Styrofoam cups and the cost $5 each. This may sound like a lot for a cup of ice cream but it's actually a bargain considering a "large" is nearly a quart! We did not sit on their patio, but in our car. The respite was delicious! If you are out tooling around and feel the urge for some great ice cream, (can't speak for the pizza) be sure to make Lionsgate your next destination.