After our exciting trip to the turkey hill experience, we needed something quick to eat before we hit the road back home. I adore small pizza shops, the pizza was perfect and the fries were nice and crispy. Prices are reasonable and the owners was very sweet read more

Columbia Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

See all

We were in a rush to get to the turkey hill experience and needed a quick place to grab lunch. This little pizza place knocked my socks off! Being a Brooklyn girl at heart I absolutely loved this pizza! I usually go for something with veggies on top but felt like having plain and boy was I happy about that! The crust was super crispy and the cheese to sauce ratio was perfect! I highly recommend this place for a quality slice! Ill be back the next time I'm in the area! read more

Columbia Pizza Restaurant - Front - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

It's your friendly neighborhood pizza place that actually has good pizza. I wouldn't want to eat there or choose this place for a date night, but if you are looking for something to pick up to take back for a Netflix and chill, this place is perfect. read more

Good food! Great price! Pretty quick most the time! But if it's on the weekend I'd give them 45mins- 1 hour (for pickup) so they don't feel rushed since they're crazy busy on weekends. Pretty nice people and I appreciate these prices in this crazy economy. Also the biggest extra large pizza I ever seen in my life. And it was the best tasting too. Good stuff around here read more

HIGHLY RECOMMEND COMING HERE! It doesn't look like much, but looks can be deceiving! It's your local family run business, and they treat each and every customer great! The pizza is the BEST PIZZA I have had in my life!!!! Knowing it has fresh ingredients and homemade dough and sauce really makes me feel great knowing that I'm eating safe non-processed foods! And not frozen (unlike many food chains)! I'm glad I didn't look at any of the other reviews and just went right in, best decision I made! The place is small, but I feel like it really adds to the charm of the restaurant! Oh... and I don't know how many of you like desserts but their cannolis are TO DIE FOR! read more

I ordered from Columbia Pizza, but the girl that took my order couldn't even take my credit card information right. I gave it to her twice. And couldn't even take my phone number correctly. read more

My children and myself love to eat here. The pizza is great to me...a little greasy but I love it. Their wings are awesome too just make sure they put it in the foam container. If you are ordering for pick up make sure to arrive 5 minutes before your estimated time .. they tend to finish before the time quoted. They have costume jewelry to look at and purchase as u wait ... I fall for it every time. Also they always have a bin of candy to take a few for free! the staff are nice just not talkative. They get u in and out. But overall I choose this place before any other local spot for pizza and wings! read more

I'm glad we disregarded the lukewarm reviews that talked about appearance, no AC etc. This place easily has the best pizza in the Columbia-Wrightsville-Mountville area, and the prices are also the best around. Very friendly service, also. If you give this place a try, you will NOT be disappointed. read more

Walk in and the bottom of the screen door is missing and the door was wide open for bugs to come in. There was no ac just a stand fan. Lights where not working. Tiles stained and place looks like they let things stay broken as they break. Place looks run down and dingy but the food was amazing! We got the special 12 wings, 24 inch pizza and a liter of soda for $24.99. Wings where cooked to perfection and had good taste. Not over cooked and the perfect amount of sauce. When the pizza came out on a large piece of cardboard wrapped in tin foil we where surprised with how large the pizza was. Pizza was cooked to perfection perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Lady working the counter was friendly and joked around with us. The place might look like a hole-in-the-wall but never judge a book by its cover because Columbia Pizza is worth visiting! read more

Columbia Pizza Restaurant - a large cheese pizza on aluminum foil - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Pennsylvania

See all

Good average pizza. I did like their cheese and sausage. Took home the rest from vacation.

Pizza is delicious... Wings are good! Would like to order more items but I've never received a menu (though requested) and there's no actual website or menu posted online. Don't let the roadblocks stop you from ordering pizza or wings, but I can't speak to anything else because I have no idea what they offer nor have I tried it. I'd venture a guess it's good?? read more

First of all the pizza was ice cold! The meatball sub was all bread with half meatballs!..the delivery driver was too busy on his phone to remember the two liter bottle of soda we paid for but never recived! read more

Very small for dining in, but their pizza is great. Thin, chewy crust, that real pizza taste you only get with an independent pizza shop. It beats the chain store pizzas. read more

This place used to be awesome. If you want to order appetizers, do it before 2 hours to close or they won't have it. The pizza is still good, but after trying three times to order takeout within 1.5 hours of close and not getting my whole order, it is not stellar. The pizza remains worthwhile. read more

it's pretty good for what it is--a neighborhood pizza spot. not the cleanest place on earth; but it's tasty, cheap and quick. if you're the type of person who goes into a pizza shop with a white glove looking for dirt, avoid this place. the straight up cheese pizza is the best, and you gotta eat it hot. it's not good if you let it set and reach room temperature. i've also never had their sides, and i'm not eager to try it. read more

great slice lots of cheese no taste plain jane worker there has a problem like he doesn"t want to be there....No A/C too hot to eat and enjoy your self read more