I wanted to like this but it wasn't that good imo. Something was missing. No flavor. Service was great and prices decent. Plenty of other pizza shops in the area that have better pizza. read more

Pizza By Alberto 10-17-24 It's been 3 years since we stopped by simply because we moved to another state. While we were back in town, we just had to stop by our favorite Pizza place to see if they still had the best pizza in this area. We arrived there about 1:20 pm on Thursday. They were not full and only had one other booth with someone in it. The place was neat, clean, and smelled great. In fact, I believe they were cleaning the kitchen as we walked in. From what I could see it was spotless. Our waitress came over introduced herself as Jace and took our drink orders. We ordered water, tea, and a beer. She then took our food order which was the Albertos Special. This Pizza has your choice of 8 toppings. We ordered the Peperoni, Ham, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Bacon, Extra Cheese, Black Olives. Every time we go there, we always ordered this Pizza special. We also ordered two side salads and an ordered of garlic bread. Our salads came out fast and were good as was the garlic bread and the beer was cold and tasted great. About the time we were done with our salads the Pizza came out. It looked very good and tons of toppings. When I bit into the Pizza it was very hot and the toppings were so good, and the crust was done perfect. I can't tell you how much I loved this, Pizza. I knew then I was giving it 5 stars. If you want to best pizza in this reviewer's opinion, go here and get one you will not be sorry. I give this Pizza 5 out of 5 stars. Follow me on FB for more reviews. Gulf Coast Terry read more

See all

The best !!! We love everything! The pizza and the subs, the salads are all the best. Support your local businesses !

I used to be there almost everyday. All my friends and my family went there. The Salvo family were friendly until Alberto's son Alfonso died and his grandson showed everyone how much he hated the place so most of their customers showed them how much they hated him. All they should do is start making their food the same way It was made at the beginning. The last time I got a steak sandwich there it was cold. The last time I got a pizza there it wasn't even baked! They made a severe mistake- mistreating their customers. It's not just them. Most restaurants are making the same mistake. It used to be my home but now my friends and I don't bother going there. read more

We love Alberto's and eat there often. The food is good, the staff is friendly and the prices are very reasonable ...better than most places! This family owned and operated business has been around for many years and the recipes and quality of the food are just as good as we remember from our younger years. If you haven't been here in a while, come back....and if you've never been, come see what you are missing! You won't be sorry! (and no, they're not paying me :-D ) read more

Price is low but the flavor is also. The pizza lacked a flavorful sauce and ingredients seems bland. More of a cardboard flavor.

Decent NY style thin crust pizza for a good price. Drive-thru is convenient. Friendly staff.

rude owner quality has diminished we have been a customer for over 20 years and will not be back there again. read more

The pizza here is very good. I really enjoy the feel of the place. The service was great and I only waited around 10 minutes.

Been going here since I was a kid one of our families favorite spots. Great service very good food.

Great tasting pizza and the price is great. Way better than the big chains and if you get wings they come out perfect crispy and nice size not mini wings. Plus they sell beer read more

Way too greasy, way too salty, taste "meh" at best. Went home and got sick. Had higher hopes for sure

030819 Stopped in for a quick bite during work. Best pizza I've had in a long time. Nice atmosphere and friendly service. Prices were good. Definitely would come back read more

Unfortunately this place has been slipping more steeply over the years. Quality of food as well as service is not the same as I got years ago. Unfortunate. read more

My experience with this restaurant was awful. I ordered two slices of pizza, twenty minutes later I get my slices and they are not even hot! They were barely lukewarm. I get the food and I have to ask for silverware and napkins...are you kidding me. The pizza tasted like the frozen pizza you buy in the grocery store. Don't waste your time or money at this place. read more

Normally, great place! Now HELL NO!! The lady was rude on the phone and inside. She threw my food at me on the counter and said her you go... have a good night. Then i walk out barely being able to open the door because they gave me a makeshift take out bag. The cup of soup was literally that. Like a dixie size wash your mouth out cup. They gave me Cesar dressing with a buffalo chicken salad. Ruined the entire thing! Had to throw it out.. Very disappointed! Will NOT be going back. Especially since the place is practicing any CDC guidelines!!! read more

I've been eating Albertos's food for 55 years now and have never had anything but delicious food and great service!! To me, they're the best in York county and beyond!! I love them!! read more

After another disappointment from yelper reviews I'm convinced that the people in this are have no idea what decent food and service really is or I'm spoiled by places with better food and service from where I grew up. In any event, our first, and likely last trip, began with waiting what felt like 5 minutes for a menu. We both decided to try a simple turkey sub and fries. It is a pizza shop after all. We waited and received a half basket of mediocre french fries about 10 minutes before our subs arrived. After our food was delivered we never saw our waitress again. I was never asked if the food was OK, if I wanted a refill, or even if I wanted our check (In the end, we were done and another waitress brought us the check.) During this time we observed just how filthy the Window area was. The food was 3 stars on a good day but I subtracted a star due to poor service and cleanliness. read more

Pizza by Alberto - This beverage at empty for 15 minutes. No waitress. No refill. Place had two waitresses and at most 6 tables. - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

There were two tables of people. We waited about 5 mins for menus. Waitress never came back for our drink orders. She was standing around talking to friends. We got up and left. We won't be back read more

It is the best pizza I have eaten since moving to Pennsylvania. Friendly service, great prices.. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone in the area looking for pizza. read more

This place is bad. They didn't care about how they cooked it and gave us cold pizza. I think that it is entirely possible that they microwaved the pizza. I would not recommend this place to anyone who wants a decent meal. This was an overall bad experience for me and my family. read more

Great pizza, salads, subs and dinners. Service is fantastic and friendly! Clean. Great prices on take out pizza, even a drive trough window to pick up. read more

Went yesterday with my two kids. Walked in, person making pizza yelled out, just so you know, your order will take about half an hour, it's our Prep time. No "hi, how are you, what would you like". After siting down to order, server took our cups to refill drinks... never brought them back. Was preoccupied taking care of her children. Food was not very good. Threw out half the pizza. read more

Rude management, arrogant not customer friendly at all. The customer comes last to him. Our group of 12 adults and 3 teenagers were told he couldn't accommodate us even though the restaurant was nearly empty. All of us left and went to another place to eat, the 15 of us in our group will never go back there again. read more

Never again! Waited 15 minutes at the drivethru to pick up my order because the car in front of us order wasn't ready! Never again!

Ok so I am back in the wonderful township of York, Pa. Watching yet another nut nudging sheepdog this one stands 32" high...how do I know? My inseam is 31" nuff said. And I remembered that pizza place that I wrote about earlier and decided to go back and try their subs...or grinders...or heroes....or whatever they call it in Pa. I ordered a meatball sub with a side of garlic bread extra garlic, I first did my due diligence and asked the cutie patootie (oh give it up they're no ugly women in this place and I'm a chunky guy, the sub would make me more excited) if the meatball subs were any good...she said yes (as expected) the sub was... well... it was decent, it was worth the trip the sub roll was crusty on the outside and soft and sauce absorbent on the inside which is how it should be, with melted cheese on top it was great... However... my only complaint is that it suffered from the same problem that every meatball sub maker in every pizzeria in America suffers from, and that is one less meatball...Can I get an amen from the back? Holla! Preach my brother! ...drives me nutz, hee hee hee get it nutz...meatballs? Yea I thought it was funnier in my head... It just seems that every meatball sub always needs one extra meatball so the last two bites are not just sauce sopped cheesy bread. Ah well, one strike for that, no biggie I did go back a few days later and had their Fettuccine Alfredo to describe it I would have to say that it was a religious experience...it was so freaking good I saw dead relatives and not the ones that you avoid during family gatherings I saw my dear departed Aunt Rosa who looked over my Fettuccine and said "Daaaaammmmmn that looks good" Seriously the Fettuccine Alfredo is that freaking good my only complaint and maybe just a bit misunderstood is that I ordered 4 meatballs to go with it and they packaged them in another container but in a red sauce...that my peeps is a cardinal sin, I should have told them to quarter the meatballs and add them to the Alfredo sauce.....I also added at home some pink sea salt for a little cohesiveness of the pasta, but that is just me ...so what have we learned? Order the meatball sub with an extra meatball and... If you want to meet my departed Aunt Rosa order the Fettuccine Alfredo...IT WILL NOT FAIL YOU. I'll be back next year! cm read more

This is a great little local spot. Very popular with sports teams and families. It's been a while since I've been there, but from what I recall everything has been tasty from the pasta, to the pizza, to the steak sandwiches. If you live nearby, stop in sometime! read more

Love Alberto's and great friendly staff! Good food and service! We are business neighbors and the smell of the food cooking is amazing and certainly sucks us in for lunch! read more

Cheeseburger sub with pickles. My favorite since I was 16. That was almost 40 years ago. Moved back to the area and it's still the same. Thank my lucky stars! read more

Dont go here, wouldn't let us in because we already had drinks, it was freezing cold out so i stopped to get my kids a hot chocolate, the waitress took a long time to come over to our table, when she finally came over she said, the owner does not allow drinks from other places, i never heard of turning business away like that, what happened to the customer is always right!!!!!, what a pos owner read more

We ordered over the weekend from Alberto's. Two subs and a pizza. Both subs were completely wrong and the "chopped steak" was a steak umm. Called them and they said they would give us a credit and that still hasn't happened. We used to love Alberto's, but their food has been going down hill and now the customer service is awful. We'll be taking our business elsewhere from now on. read more

Pizza was a little undercooked in middle, a good thin dough but could have probably stayed in oven for 30 seconds more. Sauce and toppings were fresh, hence the three stars. They have good subs as well as a decent selection of bottle beer for takeouts. read more

I have only visited this place once. I ordered two pizzas for an event while visiting relatives. Both were well executed, and the employees were friendly and accommodating. I am somewhat picky about pizza and have had some truly great pizzas, including some prepared by establishments known for offering prototypical pizzas of different styles. Alberto's pizza was not among my all-time favorites, but I was very pleased with it. read more

Favorite Pizza of York, hands down.. MY kids love it, I love it and my wife loves it... she also loves it because its in Dallastown and sees lots of people she knows... she seems to know everyone. The Subs are great as well but the PIZZA is just perfect. Add a beer and its better than amazing. read more

Loud, foul-mouthed young guy was regaling his co-workers with stories that were peppered with "F" bombs and other curse words that everyone in the dining room could hear. An older women was also shouting at the top of her lungs. Is everyone who works here deaf? The food was tasteless and mediocre at best. Ordered a sub that was on what seemed like a hotdog bun. Worst "sub" I've had in a long time. To top it off, our waitress could have cared less if we were there or not. All the way around a bad experience and we won't be back. Nothing special and lots of better choices. read more

I've been coming here for years. My favorite place around. Go for the Philly Cheese Steak or Chop Steak you won't be dissapointed. Solid Pizza but not the best. Great Mozz Sticks too! read more

Best $ Deal for Pizza in this area. Negatives: Crust is on the bland side and quality control could be improved (doesn't always quite taste the same from pizza to pizza) Positives: Generous with cheese/toppings and I like the herbs they put on the cheese. read more

Seriously , for the money , you can't beat this place. Service is great, bottle beer is cheap, and food is good. If you looking for an inexpensive dinner out, go here . read more

5 Stars because this is as good as it gets in York for Pizza. Usually take home a meal once a week for the family. Service is ok sometimes and very hospitable others. The seasoning they use for the sauce is great! They have super stromboli as well. The 2 pizzas for $13.95 was better at $12.99 but hey, it's good pizza!!! Hot and cold subs are very good. Much better than those chain sub shops !! read more

Don't go here if you have a family with food allergies!! They were completely rude and unprofessional by kicking out a friends family because they're youngest son had allergies and brought in food for him to eat while the others ate THEIR pizza. I don't care how good the food is.. I don't support establishments that don't bend the rules for a child with food allergies. ..and I have a child with food allergies. read more