Absolutely delicious! We ordered a custom pizza with caramelized onion, sausage, and mushroom, and it was a total standout. The flavors were perfectly balanced--the sweetness of the onions, the savory sausage, and the earthy mushrooms all came together beautifully. Classic New York-style crust, cooked just right, with that perfect fold and bite. A true hidden gem that delivers big on flavor. We'll definitely be back! read more

Nino's Pizza - Custom pizza with caramelized onion, sausage, and mushroom. - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

We haven't gotten to Ninos in awhile. Their Staff took great care of our large party . They made sure we had everything we needed. The Large Regular Stromboli was delicious and was enough to feed 4 adults. You must be sure to get the Marinara Sauce. The Fresh Cut Fries were crispy and a great side. For Dessert, The Tiramisu was the star of the show. This restaurant was very clean , and if you want New York Style Pizza, this is the place. -Tim and Judy read more

This is our 'go- to' pizza place. When I call in an order I usually ask for what I want and add the adjective 'delicious' to my order. Yesterday DH ordered and guess what, our pizza was delicious even without the reminder! Quality cheese, tasty Italian sausage and great sauce on top of a well baked dough which has a very slight sweetness and a great crumb, just as it should. We try other pizzas but we keep coming back to Nino's. You should too! read more

This is my third visit to Nino's. On my first I ordered a Tuscan chicken panini which was good. Then we ordered a cheese pie but it didn't have a crispy crust nor was the cheese melted into the sauce; you could still make out the grated cheese. Their sauce was too sweet for my taste. Now this third time, I'm not sure if it's under new management but the sign has been updated. I ordered jalapeño poppers. I really wanted a chicken Stromboli but it's too big for me to finish so poppers it was. They were crispy not too spicy but again didn't like the sauce to dip. There is ample tables to sit and booths. There's a big tv screen and great a/c. read more

See all

I ordered for delivery tonight and it took 2 hours for my food to be delivered, I tried calling to see if they received my order since I ordered online however each time I got a busy tone. They probably were very busy however, when the food finally did arrive, it was cold to the point I needed to reheat the food! I was disappointed. The delivery lady was nice, and they are short staffed on the website so be aware of that. I want others to see my review and understand it probably is better to do a pick up than delivery. read more

My bestie and I come here for lunch every time we go on our Pennsylvania shopping sprees. We love the veggie pizza. It is delicious and cheesy. The only downfall to this place is when you only want a slice or two you have to choose what's left over behind the counter case or you have to order a whole pizza. read more

See all

They have terrible service, this place discriminates against customers. The following thing happened to me, I was with two children and the owner scared me with terrible attention, he is a racist! I bought a pasta at pizza hut and took it to the place and bought 4 pieces of pizza and soda there and the owner told me not to eat it there and I told him it was fine but then he continued to be very undesirable and discriminating, my children got quite scared. read more

I ordered a large pizza on 7/9/23 and was told it would be ready for pickup in 15-20 minutes. I arrived 35 minutes later fearing that the pizza would probably be cold because I got delayed in leaving the house to go pick it up. I paid for the pizza and was standing there patiently waiting because I was told it would be a few minutes, which seemed odd. I asked the gentleman at the counter how much longer and he said we're gonna make it now! This is 40 minutes after I placed my order. What irritates me is that they could have informed me before I paid that the pizza isn't made yet, they're running behind, whatever. No, they made sure they got their money first, then decided to make the pizza. There was only one table with customers. It's not like they were busy. Never again. read more

I tried other pizza places with higher ratings on grubhub in York and bleh. The pizza here at Nino's is pretty good. Still not like east pa pizza but compared to the other places in York this pizza, so far, out of Marinos and Parma, this is the best. Parma, no idea where this pizza came from. Belgium? Germany? It's not Italian. Got like cinnamon in the dough? Weird. Marinos is pretty good but not quite like NY style. It's more like cheesy bread. Very little sauce. Ninos is the best if the three. Still not like marios near lansdale but it's decent. The dough needs something. It seems to be under done? But even if I reheat it the crust doesn't get that crispy doughy balance of the NY dough. The sub is good, cheese gets a bit slimy but I mean that's minor. The wings are primo, check out the wings. Overall parma is a joke, Marinos is a 5 and Ninos is a 7. Not sure if it's because York is in the middle south but we're still PA and equidistant from Philly, Harrisburg and Baltimore, I mean come on people. We should be a foody paradise up in here. read more

We placed an order online for delivery and ETA was 25-30 minutes. Waited an hour before calling to check on status and the man wouldn't let me husband finish a sentence and yelled at him that he was not his only customer and that it would on it's way shortly. Waited another 15 minutes and then I went to pick it up. Yes the computer system mistakenly marked my order carryout, but the customer service and rudeness of the owner/manager was just not how I want to be treated. I respectfully asked for my 20% tip I added to be returned and it was after repeating the request 3 times. My husband really liked his spaghetti, but I deserve kindness. I'm Sicilian and grew up with many family members who owned pizza restaurants. Also there was 1 customer in the restaurant and your cook was pacing around with nothing to do, so we weren't your only customer but 2 is not a rush. Remember to be kind. read more

Never have issues with my subs but the last 2-3 weeks idk if it's someone new or WHAT! I order an Italian sub and Everytime now comes with mayo and no dressing with the Italian sub meat y'all need to teach someone how to make a fucking Italian $80 order y'all falling apart read more

After discovering Woodfire, I never go here anymore. The white slice could draw me back in eventually, but the rest is inconsistent. Got a cheesesteak one night that was only OK. Got a couple cheese slices another night that was thoroughly meh. Still not a BAD place, but Woodfire is worth the extra 15min drive. read more

Very friendly staff. Excellent COVID precautions. Witnessed frequent hand washing while waiting for my order, from every employee, and correct mask usage. read more

We had their pizza delivered to my work on memory lane the food was outstanding very good and very high quality of ingredients I will definitely be going back or rather getting more pizza delivered in the future read more

My stromboli was outstanding, the small was very generous, and the marinara on the side was so good I wanted to drink it! My husband got a hoagie , loved it, perfect bread! The employees couldn't have been nicer - will definitely come back on our way through town next time. read more

There are plenty of great pizza places around here that respect their customers and make serving high quality items a top priority. Nino's is NOT that. We have been ordering from Nino's for years & have seen the quality slowly drop. We blamed COVID. We stayed loyal. But 2 days ago we placed an $80 order! It was our last. One of the items, a California cheesesteak, which was always a favorite, ended up in the trash. Unfortunately, the 1st bite I took had a LARGE piece of hard gristle/cartilage in it. Next bite, the same. Dug through it & found more! It so grossed me out I pitched the whole thing. (restaurant was closed). I called the next day to speak with the manager or the owner. I got the owner. When I explained to him what happened, his response was to make excuses as to why there was gristle. Like that was okay. No apologies. No "thank you for being a loyal customer". No "let me send you a gift certificate". Just a lengthy diatribe filled with arrogant excuses that I guess I was supposed to say, "Well, that's okay then!" Apparently one is supposed to expect such thing when "high quality beef" is used. Moral of the story, pick a different pizza place. read more

OK, I have to review this. I did a search for "pizza" in York and this was ranked number 20. Ummm...not on my watch! A friend recommended me to this place when I raved about NY style pizza and how after Genova's, Touch of Italy, and Marcello's there's not really a lot of decent pizza arond here. I am happy to report that about 6 months ago I found this place and would vote this as the BEST pizza in York. I've only been there a few times but will continue to go back. Great fries as well. I had both the sicilian and neopolitan and both were really good. Haven't had subs there. read more

This place is a gem. The pizza is fantastic- even my two picky kids both kept saying how good it was. Crust is perfect. I had a salad, which was also very fresh, filling and tasted great. The people working there are warm, generous and very thoughtful. HIGHLY recommend! read more

Okay so three stars because we didn't hate it and services was friendly. Pizza we got was Mediterranean and the regular stromboli. Neither where horrid but not the best pizza in York. Service was friendly. But over all what we got was lacking in flavor we didn't hate it but won't be back soon. read more

Nino's Pizza - Regular stromboli...large - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

Talk about disappointment. I ordered a California CHEESESTEAK.. I got ground meat, GROUND MEAT!! On top of that they were so stingy with it, the meat didn't even cover the whole bread! I Also ordered breaded bbq boneless wings... they gave us CHICKEN STRIPS dipped in bbq sauce! REALLY?! Spent $36 on a slice of pizza, fries, a "California cheesesteak" "breaded boneless wings" NEVER AGAIN! read more

Nino's Pizza - Our "boneless breaded wings" that are actually chicken strips! - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

One of the few actual places in the area that offers REAL NEW YORK STYLE pizza! Thin and tasty the way it should be. Service is ok. read more

BEST PIZZA, EVER! I have never got bad service or food from Nino's. I highly recommend it! read more

We ordered the Bruschetta Pizza. It could have used more basil for sure, but it wasn't too greasy and was quite tasty. Plenty of tomatoes and onions, but we added basil from our own garden. We walked in at noon on Sunday and they whipped it up in about 10 minutes. The chef was very nice and stopped out to give us the pizza read more

Typical local pizza shop. Good food, great prices. Friendly and attentive owner usually onsite.

I ordered the linguine with meatballs in red sauce with chicken noodle and garlic bread. Chicken noodle was lukewarm, extremely bland and carrots were undercooked. Chicken was also green and tasted over cooked. I had to add salt and lots of pepper and it still couldn't save it. Garlic bread was meh. Linguine and meatballs was cooked ok but the sauce was REALLY watery and didn't stick to the noodles. My GF had a slice of pizza and fries. Fries were ok. Came out fresh (like literally the first thing before anything else came out) but not salted at all. The pizza I thought looked good but my GF said there wasn't enough cheese. Service was mediocre. read more

Nino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

I got cheese pizza and I don't know if I got a bad batch, but it was some of the worst pizza I have ever eaten. The crust hurt my gums it was so hard. I don't think I'll return or recommend the pizza. I don't know about the rest. read more

Have to agree with with Nathan f. Really good New York style pizza. Nice place but tucked out of the way. Is in gabrielle brothers plaza. Will give 5 stars once I see how their cheese steaks are. Genovas and mammas pizza is best so far in York. read more

Great quality pizza! The owner uses quality cheese and sauce. The chicken pesto panini is also great. One caution, if ordering food for pick-up or delivery, don't order fries. They're soggy by the time you get them. That's not a reflection of their timing, just that they put them in the box hot and the condensation from the heat makes them soggy. read more

Best pizza I have found in york so far. Haven't found any that isn't delicious and the staff is awesome.

Just had dinner there and it was awesome. Best French fries- hot and crisp. Hamboat was fresh with gooey melted cheese, fresh veggies and best bread ever. Service was excellent and friendly. We have gone to Nino's for many years- both eat in and carry out pizza- and never had a bad experience. Highly recommend. read more

Our family ordered $45 worth of food today and although the food itself was good the customer service was horrible. Ordered a chicken steak NO cheese. After we picked up the food and got home we realized they put cheese on the chicken steak. I called back in and told them about the mistake. I know it's a common one. I politely said only steak and bread NO cheese. I sent my husband back only to find out they messed up yet again. I called back in again and explained they had messed up again. After a minute the owner got on the line and was extremely rude and said so you're trying to tell me we messed twice. I responded, well yes you did. He then says we have professionals working here. He was basically accusing me of lying that the steak did not actually have cheese on it. So living close by I decided to go in there and show him. I decided to go in myself this time and honestly I wasn't very pleasant especially considering $45 and 3 trips later this is how I was treated. He was extremely rude to me and said well do you just want a refund? I said yes. His exact words were give her the damn $7 so she can get the hell out of here. I actually felt bad for the kid working at the register ,you could tell it was awkward for him. After he gave me the $7 I said to the owner are you serious, this is really how you treat your customers? He screamed at me and said take your money and get the hell out. Who would spend $45 and go back 3 different times just to get a free sub? They definitely won't get my business again! read more

Used to be the best pizza around. They changed something, cheaper cheese, I'm not sure. I liked getting a pie from my childhood with all the oil dripping off. read more

IF I COULD GIVE IT NO STARS I WOULD! I came on my lunch and had limited time to get something and hustle back to work. I ordered chicken noodle soup and it was Campbells chicken noodle soup strait out the can! He charged me $4.25 for can soup! I also waited over 15 minutes for it. I took it back inside and said if I wanted can soup I would have went to the grocery outlet. He started laughing in my face. I said this is terrible, he proceeded to laugh and said I'll give you your money back. I said yea you will. I said you just waisted my lunch on this crap! He was so very ignorant and arrogant. I will never go there again. This place is a total joke. read more

If you're looking for true New York style pizza, don't go here. Pizza is very bland and not much sauce. Probably a slight step above something like Domino's. Wings are average at best. read more