Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sicilia Pizzeria

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 10:30 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Sicilia Pizzeria Pizza Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Sicilia Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Alikat N.
    19
    68
    22

    2 years ago

    Fantastic food! Order through Slice app! Super fast!! They cooked the food just as we asked!!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Touch of Italy - Shrimp pancetta ravioli in pink cream sauce

    Touch of Italy

    4.2(24 reviews)
    5719.4 mi
    $$

    Nice local pizzeria…read more Was in the area and decided upon here for dinner. From the outside, it looks like a converted house - but most businesses in the area look the same. Inside was spacious enough to where they were having a birthday celebration in progress on one side, leaving all the tables for other patrons on the other side. The menu selection was decent, but I already had my mind set on garlic bread and the bacon chicken ranch pie - both since it has been a little while since I last had it and because I knew I'd be having the rest of it the next day for lunch. The pie was tasty - so tasty that I forgot to take the picture BEFORE I removed a slice. The garlic bread was okay - I've had better but I've also had worse. Garlic bread is often made differently at establishments and it's a taste and choice for preference. The rest of the pie I didn't finish taster just as good the next day when heated up. Really, if I ever go back I do plan to grab this one again. Staff was very nice. Waitress was friendly. I got to talking to one of the owners and it turns out they were from Brooklyn NY. So any doubt about the quality here should automatically be put to rest. Had I known about it previously, I'd have taken a regular slice too. Owners were friendly and welcoming. I've been in their old neighborhood, so we had a nice conversation about the general area. There is no lot, so parking is street. All in all a nice place and a good option for the area. Good for locals who want a more authentic choice for Italian food and of course pizza/ I'd easily return here if I'm in the general area again.

    We truly enjoyed every thing about this restaurant. The service was exceptional and the food was…read morefresh, homemade and absolutely delicious!! The ambiance was welcoming and relaxing. We would definitely recommended this restaurant. If you haven't been there or got food from there you should!!

    Photos
    Touch of Italy - Only fresh ingredients used!

    Only fresh ingredients used!

    Touch of Italy - Homemade dough made daily

    Homemade dough made daily

    Touch of Italy

    See all

    Trattoria Fratelli

    Trattoria Fratelli

    4.5(122 reviews)
    5711.4 mi
    $$$

    We found this fine restaurant on Yelp. Since my husband & I are both vegan I called to ask if they…read morecould accommodate us. We were assured they could and made our reservation. About 2 hours later I got a call from a staff member who asked more ?'s, and then actually called 2 more times for further clarification. First off the restaurant is lovely! The staff is professional & extremely welcoming. The restaurant is beautiful & charming. They even have a copper pizza oven!! The Chef's wife makes a fresh sourdough bread that is delicious even without the fresh olive oil they normally they serve with it! We started with salads which were delicious & very fresh & crisp!! The chef had prepared us a special meal of fresh vegetables with a light wine sauce with spaghetti. Truly outstanding! We shared a lovely coconut sorbet that was a perfect way to end this amazing dinner! Thank you so much for making my birthday dinner extra special. Should you find yourself in the area you should definitely call for a reservation.

    We trekked from Lancaster in the snow to come back here and we brought 3 friends with us. The food…read morewas fantastic as usual, my husband had the Cornish game hen and pork belly with red wine Demi glacé, I had the cast iron seared Arctic Char with blood orange Romesco on chestnut polenta, roast kale and cabbage. For dessert we had pumpkin cheesecake. The service was perfect, gave us enough time to chat and order. The ambiance was great, nice, quiet, and warm. We'll definitely be back.

    Photos
    Trattoria Fratelli - Restaurant sign

    Restaurant sign

    Trattoria Fratelli - The Turtle Cheesecake was my favorite, yummy!!!!!

    The Turtle Cheesecake was my favorite, yummy!!!!!

    Trattoria Fratelli - Double chocolate for double the fun!

    See all

    Double chocolate for double the fun!

    Amato’s Wood Fire Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Curly fries wit cheese

    Amato’s Wood Fire Pizza & Italian Restaurant

    3.5(33 reviews)
    5715.9 mi

    This was our first visit, and we were surprised by how busy the place was on a Thursday night. The…read moresignage refers to essentially 3 different kinds of restaurants: a dining room, a pizzeria, and a takeout counter. We were in more of a dining room mood but we weren't asked for our opinion and were taken to a high 2-person table in what we assumed was the pizzeria. I have a temperamental back, so these chairs were not going to work for me, so we asked to be relocated to a nicer table. We were shown to another table right away. Both the dining room and pizzeria were nearly full, and hopping with energy! Our expectations were high! Any restaurant that serves Guinness beer on tap earns a bonus star from me! Unfortunately, the flavor was a little off and I get the impression that not too many customers drink the Guinness. It struck me as beer that was a little past its expiration date. Thankfully our food was very good. Everything had a distinctive and agreeable flavor. Even the bread and olive oil had us cutting extra slices. I ordered the quattro formatti pizza and added bacon. It was as unique and tasty as it sounds. If you look closely at the picture you'll see that someone took a bite before I had a chance to photograph it. But apart from that, notice all the different colors and textures, which made for a nice, lively pizza. In the other photo you can see the chicken parmigiana, which they agreed to substitute Alfredo sauce instead of marinara. That was a delicious dish as well! We ended up way too full for dessert!! It's too bad because there were lots of interesting options to choose from. If we ever find ourselves in Mount Joy again we'll surely consider coming here again. The only thing that left a bad taste was the old-tasting beer.

    We were here this past weekend. We got there early, absolutely desolate. Absolutely nobody was in…read morethere that we could see. We ordered our drinks and our food. You would think a restaurant would bring the appetizers out first but no that's not what happened they brought the appetizers with the main meal. That was ridiculous and should never have happened. They were not busy whatsoever. Our waitress was also not very good, again no one in there at all that we saw. She seemed more annoyed with having to wait on us. Very disappointed. My sandwich was great. Calamari was just ok! Not horrible just ok. Boneless wings were not good at all, hard and lacked sauce. Cheese steak that my other half order was strange more like chopped burger than steak! Disappointing visit will be quite a while before we return!!!

    Photos
    Amato’s Wood Fire Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Cheeseburger

    Cheeseburger

    Amato’s Wood Fire Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Cheese Pizza with Marinara Sauce - thin crust

    Cheese Pizza with Marinara Sauce - thin crust

    Amato’s Wood Fire Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Crispy wings...best around

    See all

    Crispy wings...best around

    Marco's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Bad Pizza

    Marco's Restaurant & Pizzeria

    3.3(54 reviews)
    5717.9 mi
    $$

    Marco's is head and shoulders above an unusual glut of local pizza options in a small river town…read morelike Marietta, PA. Their pizza has a good crust -- thin enough to fold and eat, but with a good flavor as well. (Sicilian style also is available if you prefer a thicker crust.) Like all good pizza, you don't need to hide this under a pile of toppings. Just the pizza, maybe just add pepporoni or mushrooms or whatever your favorite is. When I was new to Marietta, I tried all the local places and Marco's is #1 for pizza, and also #1 for having a full menu. Marco's also has a meatball sub that would make your Italian grandma blush. Order it with a layer of mozzerella on top and it comes out all toasted and crispy and tasting like childhood in NYC. The menu has other Italian staples like pasta and garlic bread, but it doesn't stop there. If you want some turkey with mashed potatoes and gravy, Marco's has it. Or for lunch, go for the burger special. It's all good, and served with a smile every time!

    Not fancy by any means. If you are looking for ambiance, go elsewhere. The menu is varied, you can…read moreget sandwiches, pizza, Italian food and other choices. The prices are very fair and the bar prices are also affordable. Down home friendly service. Had zeppolis for dessert---$4.10 and 3 people couldn't finish them. My wife had veal parm and I had chicken cacciatore. Both dishes were very tasty. Again, not fancy, not gourmet, but very good for and wholesome. Great value.

    Photos
    Marco's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Grease, a soggy gross pile of grease.

    Grease, a soggy gross pile of grease.

    Marco's Restaurant & Pizzeria - Tell me you have no clue how to make and box a pizza, without telling me you have no clue how to make a pizza.

    Tell me you have no clue how to make and box a pizza, without telling me you have no clue how to make a pizza.

    Marco's Restaurant & Pizzeria - I was served a warm ass beer too. Lol!!

    See all

    I was served a warm ass beer too. Lol!!

    Garofalo's Calabria - Pumpkin Ravioli Homemade Roasted Squash Ravioli's dressed with sage butter sauce, and garnished lightly with Perocino Cheese

    Garofalo's Calabria

    5.0(1 review)
    5710.8 mi

    I stay at the Comfort Inn and Suites in Manheim Pa at 543 Champ Blvd a couple times a week. That's…read morewhere they are located for now. Finally trying the food tonight I am blown away and stuffed. I had the stuffed manicotti with bolognese sauce, the margherita pizza and the zuppa dessert. Everything was great, better than great. It was amazing and Ryan is an awesome person to talk with as well. Whether you are travelling along Hwy 283 or live in the area, make sure to stop by and give this place a shot. You won't regret it.

    From the owner: Italy has many influences and is not like any other Italian cuisine that you may have had before…read more By being a sustainable country in itself, a lot of the practices are reflected into our business. Whole utilizations of all food product, respect for the environment by which it is grown in, and the influences of conscious farm-to-table practices are very important to us. We source locally so we know exactly where our products come from and how they are grown. While supporting our local economy, we strive to make a positive impact in the Culinary Arts and the Food Trucking industry in hopes to boost said industries in a direction of healthy eating and more diverse food options. Respect for food goes beyond sourcing locally, it is to serve it as beautifully as possible, one ingredient at a time. Your food should be enjoy, not just eaten. Our exotic Calabrian foods will accentuate the palate of the consumer, while building long lasting relationships. We wish for you to follow us to Italy...

    Photos
    Garofalo's Calabria - I love margherita pizza!!

    I love margherita pizza!!

    Garofalo's Calabria - Join Us ALL day long on June 16, 2017! Terrific Old World Italian Cuisine Lots of fun and Give-a-ways

    Join Us ALL day long on June 16, 2017! Terrific Old World Italian Cuisine Lots of fun and Give-a-ways

    Garofalo's Calabria - Love the location. The grass is so green and soft.

    See all

    Love the location. The grass is so green and soft.

    Sicilia Pizzeria - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...