Carly is quite simply and amazingly attentive and personable bar tender and server. She has a great memory too! After having been to Colina de Oro only once before, Carly knew what I was getting to drink. She also knew my business partner's drink order. The drinks are perfectly mixed. Both meals I've had were excellent tasting. Great portion sizes. The nachos grande are a friggin meal in and of themselves honestly. The fajatias were full of flavor. The veggies in the fajatias were perfectly cooked and retained the crispness I look for in a dish of this nature. The other staff and managers I have encountered were all very very helpful and professional. A couple of times I asked a question about a dish or about ingredients the the initial point of contact was uncertain of the answer; there was zero hesitation to find a staff member who was able to answer it! read more

Colina De Oro - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

See all

Unfortunately after a long day of moving and placing a 124$ dinner for a family of 5, three of the orders we're only al a cart carne asada tacos priced at 6.50 a piece which normally isn't an issue, attached is a photo, no cheese no sauce and the meat had no flavor. The older woman at the front was a bit unprofessional by explaining to us how expensive it was to eat out and how she was frustrated as she was training a bartender which apparently was not her job. All in all we were starving and ended up spending over 100$ and not eating any of it. I would not recommend. read more

Colina De Oro - We asked for meat and cheese on three of the tacos got just meat and tortilla and no cheese or sauce on anything - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

See all

I went to this restaurant one day with some friends. I ordered some chicken taquitos with a side of rice, no beans. I don't eat beans, ever. I got my taquitos and bit into them, and they were filled with beans. Not chicken, beans. When the waitress came back, I told her I ordered chicken taquitos, and these have beans in them. She went to ask the Kitchen and came back and said that is chicken. It just looks like that. I said there's no way this is chicken. They are clearly beans! She looked at them and agreed. She then offered to take them back and let me order something different. I opted for a chicken enchilada. Now that came back and it was chicken, all good. But the fact that they gave me chicken taquitos filled with beans and tried to convince me it was chicken floored me. read more

We drive through this area often on our way to Tahoe and have been on the hunt for a solid Mexican restaurant. This spot caught our eye so we decided to give it a try without checking reviews first. Walking in I wasn't sure what to expect. The front dining area was empty, and the staff were all gathered. It was early on a Monday, so I figured maybe it gets busier later... We were seated in another dining room, which actually had a few other diners. We ordered chicken enchiladas, mine were the verdes (Swiss-style) and my husband got the red sauce version. We also added a side of guacamole. Unfortunately, the food didn't live up to our hopes. The guacamole was missing something, maybe lime, cilantro, or seasoning, it just tasted flat. My enchiladas had a strong, almost sour aftertaste from the green sauce. The rice was overly seasoned, and the beans were just okay. The red enchiladas didn't stand out either. It all felt like it was quickly thrown together, hoping the cheese and sauce would do the heavy lifting. For the price we expected much better quality. It was overpriced for what felt like cafeteria style food. That said, the host and waitress were friendly, attentive, and welcoming. So while the service was great, the food just didn't do it for us. read more

See all

700TH REVIEW! Colina de Oro (Gold Hill) is an average run of the mill Mexican restaurant. For a Tuesday, it is the only place open to eat for many miles around, so in one regard it is good to have it here. As far as looks and ambiance, this place has seen its day and definitely needs a cleaning and fresh makeover. It looks very dated and a little ragged at the edges. The bar seemed quite active, and the rest of the place had a few patrons, but not many. Chips and salsa, plus water, was brought to the table right away. The salsa was good, chips mainstream. I also ordered a blended margarita, which was rather bland and lacked any punch or alcohol. It just tasted like lime punch. The menu is what one would expect and all the usual offerings. I decided to have the Chile Verde entree dinner, with rice, beans, and my choice of flour tortillas. The pork was OK, again nothing too special. All of it was middle-of-the-road Mexican fare. The service was friendly and cordial enough, yet seemingly bored. So, with that, if you're hungry on a Tuesday in this part of Amador County, this might be your only option. Just don't expect much other than ordinary. read more

See all

customer service fair food very basic didn't seem authentic salsa seemed from a jar very bland and not cheap

We stopped in for lunch after checking reviews which were positive. The service was inadequate - we had to get the waitress when we were ready to order . She wasn't with other customers as we were the only ones in there. She was standing at the counter on her phone! We both ordered taco salads and they were tasteless even after dumping salsa over the top! We told the server there was absolutely no Mexican flavor and she just shrugged and walked away! read more

I've been going to this restaurant off and on for several years. I always hoped the food would get better, like offering more American food choices (it's in a small town) and it would be nice if the owner wound acknowledge our patronage once in a while. Recently during our visit around 2pm we were nearly frozen, staff said they keep heat off during slow hours....thanks a lot!? But...The wait persons & bartenders are always courteous and friendly! read more

Went for dinner family got chicken, carnitas, and asada tacos. Each had no flavor and the meat was dry. I did a pick up order and I asked for salsa. I was told they just have one kind and it was already in the bag. That didn't have much flavor either. read more

Very disappointed with my dinner. Ordered Beef Taquitos, they were small flour tubes with what looked like mashed chicken, no flavor at all. My beans and rice were semi warm. Enjoyed the margarita but had a lot of ice. Our server never came back to check on us so when he brought the check I told him there was no beef in my taquitos. He made no explanation but said he'd take my meal off the check. He came back and it was off but he made no apology. My friends had no complaints so guess I ordered the wrong meal. Locals restaurant with bar. Maybe try next time in town as not many options. read more

See all

This place used to be good. They developed a steady clientele, but the manager has run off most of his loyal customers. The food isn't as good, yet prices are ridiculous for small portions. If I'm going to pay $18 for an a la carte burrito then they could at least turn on the heat. One loyal customer complained about the cold air flooding into the place and was told by the boss that that he could leave if he didn't like it. It's too bad because the staff is lovely. At least they finally fixed the bathroom (after years) so that awful smell is gone. As soon as another decent option is available this place will be done. read more

The people were super friendly and so was the server. But food didn't have much flavor and beans were terrible. And it's over priced for what you get. I took half my beef burrito to go and ate the rest today, while eating I found a piece of wire in my burrito. See pictures read more

Colina De Oro - Wire in my burrito - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

See all

This place immediately hits you with the dingey small-town-bar vibe when you walk in - not a lot of light and heaps of wood paneling. Staff are friendly enough for sure, but the food is way below average. Can't really see how any care is taken over any of it. No taste, no real effort. Needs a drastic remodel and reinvigoration. It's a shame because there's not many options in this little town. read more

When you food comes out 3 minutes after you place your order that tells you something about the dining experience you are about to enjoy. It's as if they tried to make the food taste and look unappetizing. read more

Party of 8 on a Thursday evening. The restaurant wasn't busy at all. It took at least 30 min for them to take our order. Notably, we had to get up and find the server and request they take our order. They just didn't seem to care. Food was just ok. Salsa tasted like Pace Picante and the enchilada sauce was most likely a can of Las Palmas. Food was overpriced and not worth it. Ambience was odd. Christmas lights from last year. My thought is like us people still come here because it's in the middle of nowhere and hungry. My advice ...keep driving . read more

Fabulous food and great service! I love this restaurant and I have been coming here for almost 20 years! Margaritas are tasty and I love their tacos, taco salad and nachos! read more

Numerous returns over the year and a much overdue upgrade on my original assessment: this is delicious American-Mexican food and an essential dining option in an area without much in offer - especially in turns of Mexican food. My latest visit was during COVID. I could go on about how most of Amador County has continued on as if COVID is a hoax, but I think I'll stick to reviewing the food as that is what will keep me coming back. All the dishes here are stick-to-your-ribs delicious. Lots of beans, rice and fried goodness. The chicken tacos I enjoyed, filled with generous portions of savory meat, hit the spot after a long day in the sun. Pair it with their addictive tortilla chips and salsa and a beer and you have everything a hungry guy would need. The service seems to have gotten better each time. I've never been in when more than a couple tables were filled so you always get some more personalized interactions with the staff. read more

Much prefer the Colina De Oro in Diamond Springs. We were in the area and decided to just stop here instead. The food was okay, the service was awful. And it's not a very inviting place. read more

First time here, ordered the veggie tacos. Loved it! Food, service and atmosphere is very nice. Recommend coming here, like an oasis in the desert. read more

See all

They said open until 9 we arrived at 8:15 and greeted with rude employees and said they are closed. Lazy and dirty setting.

Super friendly people and great Chili Reyeno. Stayed at Shenandoh Inn a few hundred yards away. Nice to have a good restaurant so close.

We were looking for a decent Mexican food place in this remote area and found this restaurant. We ordered a margarita and two taco dishes. The margarita was delicious and perfectly blended. The tacos were exactly as we expected. Nothing was good or bad about the food. Our three stars is because it was exactly what we were expecting. If you're looking for Mexican food in this area, this place is a decent option. read more

Colina De Oro - a plate of mexican food - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

See all

We have had family events here and have been devoted customers for years but the last few times the food has been utterly terrible. The last time it made my uncle sick and this time we decided to try once more and picked up the food to take home to my elderly grandpa who loves this place. All of the meat was either dry or chewy and the beef in my taco tasted like cleaning product. We threw away nearly everything besides some beans and the chips and salsa. That's three meals in the trash, two of which they got wrong. When I called to inform them, the manager said we'd have to bring back the trashed items to get any sort of refund. That is unreal. We will not be returning or ever having any other events here. Unless you want an upset stomach and wallet, do not eat here. read more

Super good food! Alejandra and Jackie were fun servers. Plymouth is such a cute town. Nice to have a yummy Mexican restaurant

Salsa is good. Service is wonderful. Mexican food is overpriced - bland and the carnitas was dry. The corn tortillas were in heated or grilled - just out of the package. read more

Colina De Oro - Pinto whole beans, rice and taco - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

We were camping at 49er RV park and decided to have a not cook night so we headed here. I actually called ahead to see if there was a wait, whicih is funny because they kind of laughed and said no. Sure enough just a few locals at the bar and we had a table of 6 in the dining room all to ourselves. Everyone ordered Mexican food and I decided to get crazy and ordered a burger. But kept it Mexican and ordered the Mexican burger. Lol. Which was just a burger with bacon and a sh!t ton of jalapeños on it. I was concerned when she Didnt ask me how I wanted it cooked. I told her medium. We ordered a ton of food. Fajitas, enchiladas, tacos, quesadilla and burritos. Enjoyed everything. Burger was bomb. Totally going back. read more

Overprice and bland food. Service was eh, I wouldn't recommend this place. Place looks dirty and poor. Probably the worst Mexican food I've had. read more

Best restaurant in town, fast service and great ambience. Every time I eat here I am impressed by the flavors imbued within the food. They don't skimp either, each burrito comes packed with meat. Chips and salsa are baller btw. Subsequent visits have not changed my opinion. Great customer service, always very welcoming. Good margaritas read more

Colina De Oro - Carne Asada Burrito - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

Service was great and friendly. Food was wonderful and delicious. Would recommend this fabulous restaurant!! read more

See all

Hands down, best Mexican restaurant I've ever been to! With such a remote location, I stumbled upon this gem on the way back from Daffodil Hill and what a fabulous way to end the day that was! We started with delicious homemade chips and salsa(complementary, as they should be) and great house margaritas. Their dinner plates are very generous. We had tender and juicy chili verde/ chili colorado and super fresh and crispy taquitos. I must add that their taco salad is the best I've ever had - it's made slightly differently than your fast food restaurant version, and so much better. Plus, our server Victoria was great! She had a calm and collected vibe as she seemed to manage the whole dining room! She was very kind and quick to bring us our drinks/food/ refills. Next time you're passing by, be sure to stop in and give them a try! You wont be disappointed! read more

See all

Over priced and generally bland food... service was fine and atmosphere was inviting. Definitely a let down.

Been here many times in the past, and it was good. Yesterday, awful. Ordered cheese enchilada and relleno. The enchilada had molded cheese! If I had a STD it would have been a cure, thankfully, I don't. No Bueno, for a Mexican restaurant. Obviously the enchiladas are rolled ahead of time and placed in the walk in. Prices way in outer space for drinks. 10.00 for a small margarita and 9.00 for a house glass of wine. Sorry, as a local, we won't revisit or reccomend. Hasta la Vista... baby... read more

It is dry, the tortillas do not feel good nor taste delightful. The service is good, they are nice. It is a cute restaurant and a nice environment, but to us the food did not match it. read more

Had fun here, not much open on a Sunday stopped in here for a quick bite to eat. Food was okay. The bartender Carly was super helpful. She was busting her butt. She had a full bar and waiting tables . She made the best drinks as we came back another day and was hoping to have her again. It's a spot to hangout read more

Food as always is good. Service in the past has been great and lately there is newer staff and it's a bit slower. I believe that it will pick up once they get to know their jobs. read more

Huge portions. Awesome food. Nice staff. We stopped here everyday for our Disneyland trip.

We come here often and really enjoy it. Carne Asada tacos have great flavor, we love the chips and salsa, and the margaritas are delicious. We've also had enchiladas, chimichangas, nachos, and all different kinds of fajitas without disappointment. Pro tip: if you prefer your side of beans and rice to come with refried beans just ask :) otherwise pinto beans are what is usually served. Service can be a bit slow at times which is the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars. It's worth the wait, though! read more

Colina De Oro - Asada tacos and combination plate with refried beans - Mexican Near Me - Plymouth, California

First time here, got the Adobado Burrito, probably the best burrito I've ever had!! Service was great and friendly, very original place, I'll be back as much as I can read more

After visiting 3 wineries we decided to stop here for dinner. When you walk in, you are thrown back in time to good times of the 50's of Dirty Dancing country club. The first thing you see is their full service bar. After drinking wine all day, you might want a drink. That time warp means the food is fresh and delicious. You know someone in that kitchen takes pride in their cooking. I had a southwest chicken without cheese or sour cream, add sautéed shrimp. The bell peppers were solid and crisps. The shrimp was fresh and juicy. The chicken was tender and juicy. The Mexican rice and beans perfect. Not a soggy item on my plate, like some Mexican places. All 8 of us just thought the food was amazing. We are in food comas... thank goodness I'm not driving home. Finally, our wIter was accommodating. We got separate checks. She took care of us like we were at her home. Even the owner of the restaurant came over to help with drinks etc. A great way to end the day with friends. read more

See all

Poor food quality-not authentic Mexican food. Get food at a gas station+ that's what it tastes like! Not even the burgers are worth it.. just go to Marleen and Glen's diner instead!! read more