I have a business meeting in Montreal so my brother and I was driving up I-81 and picked this spot for lunch today. Morgan was our server, really friendly and helpful. Don't have to ask for refills or anything. I started with a water and Diet Coke. We decided to split the open face Reuben and Cheesesteak and have 1/2 of each. The kitchen was very accommodating. Good sized portions, the price was excellent and I was pleased. Both meals came with chips and homemade pickles. If I'm ever back and more hungry I'll try the Shepard's pie. Support small busi read more

We came back to Coleman's Corner for St Patty's day feast - corned beef and cabbage! We made the mistake of each ordering a meal, and ended up taking a whole meal home to enjoy another time. If there was a complaint, it would be that gave us Too Much Food! What an awful problem ... Yes, we enjoyed the meal again a day or so later - so good! We love the food and ambiance at Coleman's. We come back over and over! read more

GOOD PLACE FOR DINNER IN WATERTOWN, NY ======================================= My husband and I met my son and four of his co-workers at Coleman's Corner for dinner on Thursday, November 14, 2024. Our table shared some mozzarella sticks and Irish poutine. Those were good. Then my husband and I ordered the Shepherd's pie. It was ok. See my photo. The inside could have been thicker. No one ordered beer as it was a work night for the majority of them. read more

Coleman's Corner - Shepherd's Pie - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

Great local spot. This restaurant has been in business for many years and is a local favorite. I've had several dishes and have not been disappointed. Anything you order will be tasty. read more

Stopped for lunch on our way through town. Solid, wide selection of food that met all our needs -soup and salads, burgers, homemade dishes. Food was yummy. The French onion soup was especially good. Nice pub atmosphere, good service. Very busy on Tuesday at lunch so must be popular. read more

The atmosphere is really nice and authentic. But also cozy! Or waitress was friendly and on top of everything from refills to napkins ( big plus with kids) The food was really tasty and the menu had plenty of options. Overall very happy with our personal experiences. read more

I absolutely love the attention to detail that the owners took to build Coleman's Corner. It has a great location as well off of Coffeen next to the Fair Grounds as well. Plenty of Irish classic dishes and a great place to grab a pint as well. A local favorite for sure! read more

Coleman's Corner - Corned beef dinner with cabbage, potatoes and carrots. An Irish classic! - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

Makes the Irish lady in me, happy. The ambiance is unique, Celtic for sure. The food is abundant, prepared by an experienced chef (has to be, b/c it's delicious). Service is top notch too! COLEMAN's is the best place to eat in Watertown, New York in my opinion. read more

Slow food delivery, waitress non existent unless she requests orders, calamari was cold (old), clams were underwhelming, after about 30 minutes we decided to pay for our appetizers rather than waiting for the meal to come when getting up to leave another table stopped us and thanked us for saying something because they had a bad experience as well. Ive come in before and had good service, fridays are not for the weak of heart haha read more

First time eating at Coleman's Corner and it has all the qualities of the Fairground Inn next door with an Irish menu. Started with a Sam Adams Octoberfest, and we ordered a Reuben and the Limerick Spicy Chicken Ciabatta sandwich. Food was very good - prepared quickly , waitress checked in and was polite and prompt Definitely recommend to anyone in or passing through the area. read more

See all

Coleman's Corner presents your typical Irish pub atmosphere. The best part of the Coleman's experience is the delicious Irish food. The Shepherds Pie and Bangers & Mash are flavorful & filling. On a busy afternoon, the wait service was fast & responsive. We really enjoyed our meal at Coleman's Corner. read more

Coleman's Corner - Shepherds pie - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

See all

First off, the food and our waitress were amazing. I got the nachos and the Philly cheese steak. The sliced steak on the sandwich was incredibly juicy and flavorful. I was not expecting the sandwich to be that big. The drinks were always very well made, no complaints there. A couple things that deserve one less star is the fact that the service took quite awhile (claiming they were busy) but inside there were numerous open tables and the bar wasn't even half full. Not to mention the abundance of waitresses walking around. The hostess also stated that they couldn't put two of the outside tables together. Why not? No one else is sitting outside and we had 8 people. So our party was forced to sit separate from each other. Something I've never heard of at any other restaurant. read more

Amazing people Amazing food spent many meals there just great place to unwind with family and friends

Been here several times and it appears to have gone downhill. Sat down and ordered burgers and then waited and waited finally 30 minutes later the burgers arrived burned and past well done. We asked for medium. I asked to speak with the manager and was told there wasn't one and the owner would call me the next day. Still waiting for the call. So no surprise the service and quality has deterioated. read more

Good service and good food. Prices are alright. Location is generally busy. Best to arrive early if possible. read more

I've lived in the area for nearly two years and finally ate here. They have great options for my family's food allergies (nuts & dairy), so we gave it a shot. It's a small unassuming building, but inside is great Irish pub atmosphere. The service was friendly, but maybe a bit slow for being late afternoon. The food was amazing. I had the corned beef and cabbage that came with two large pieces of corned beef. They were super tender. The cabbage, carrots and potatoes were perfectly cooked. All my other family members loved their dishes. This is a place you must try. read more

I am a big fan of their fish n chips. Service is consistently good. I have never had a bad meal here.

Waitress was great and food was pretty good too two stars knocked because the hostess was very rude and stand offish- not a good vibe from her. Overall pretty good read more

Maddie the waitress is everything she gives great recommendations is enthusiastic about being there energetics and then there's the food! The fish and chips is to die for great portion great price there New England clam chowder was also delicious then the next day because I had to go back in I had the shepherds pie which I found good my daughter loved it so I will be back there this is a great place for Locals and if you like an Irish pub you better go! read more

See all

This is "corporate" Irish Pub in feel -- decor and menu and careful selection of posters on the wall -- and had much more of a Bennigan's vibe than an actual pub experience, with sports and lotto on large screens and families with babies making most of the noise. The food was pretty decent (the Guinness gravy poutine was quite nice). A list of beers on tap or in bottle would have been helpful. Our server was good. I would return, but I'd look for someplace more unique and interesting first. read more

I have had the pleasure of visiting a couple time, the service we received both times was so friendly and attentive. Food was delicious! Love the Irish Fries, French Onion soup was delish and hit the spot! The Buffalo wrap and the Guinness Glazed Chicken sandwich were so tasty and very large portions, 1/2 came home for later! We will most definitely be visiting again! read more

Coleman's Corner - Buffalo Chicken Wrap and Irish Fries with gravy - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

See all

Granted, it was a little late in the lunch hour on a Wednesday but there was still a good crowd. I sat at the bar and ordered a drink and a small order of fish n chips. The food was not great. The chips were soggy but I liked the fish breading even though it also got tough and soggy toward the end. But the place itself is just a very pleasant place to sit, drink, eat and hang out. I'll be back for another try. read more

Extensive menu, great food. Our server was very attentive. Irish music in the background created a fun atmosphere for our lunch.

Irish pub/restaurant that is super cozy vibes when you walk in the door. The food is always delicious and hearty and plenty of options to choose from. I always without a doubt get their shepards pie. I've also had their fish and chips as well and they do not disappoint. read more

Coleman's Corner - Shepards pie - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

I stopped here for lunch on a Wednesday. We were seated right away and a server met us immediately. I wanted to have a light lunch so I ordered a turkey club with their fries. Their fries are not traditional. They're little circles and they're delicious. They serve them with a small side of gravy, which is also very good. So much for having a late lunch the sandwich was huge and I am not complaining. The sandwich had a special mayo and bacon. They were both very good. The inside of this place is pretty cool. It has that old Irish pub vibe. The menu looks really good. There was some heavy stuff that I would like to try on another occasion prices are reasonable and service was great. read more

Very popular, local, good music, great food, Irish style pub, one of the best in town no doubt. I recommend the sweet chili burger. The poutine is absolutely perfect, plenty of gravy, cheese, and fries. Ask for the fries extra crispy, the burgers are all very good. 10-15 dollars a plate, good times all around. read more

Stopped in for the afternoon was hoping to get a breakfast shot it is an Irish bar I thought they would have them since it's with Jameson they do not make them was sad -minus the one star. Otherwise I was greeted right away sat at the bar had a beautiful spicy bloody Mary bartender made a good one nicely done and I had the calamari probably the best calamari I've ever had the Thai chili sauce on top was excellent!! I'll be back read more

Coleman's Corner - Calamari - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

See all

My first time here, late afternoon (3pm) on a Saturday, and it is pleasantly quiet. Lovely atmosphere- Traditional pub/bar feel; Waitress was conversational, and down-to-earth. We ordered the Irish Poutine for an app, my only complaint? I ate too much to enjoy my meal! So good. The Pub Burger was cooked to perfection & super tasty. Thankfully the waitress noted this didn't come with cheese, who wouldn't want cheese on their burger?! You have options to add American, Provolone, Swiss, Bleu, maybe one more? All in all, a great lunch date location. #SupportLocalBusinesses read more

Coleman's Corner - Blue Moon, Draft Beer Menu - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

See all

Food was great. Friendly staff. Appears to be a lot of locals which tells you it's good. Reasonably priced.

A little bit of a wait because they were packed but rightly so! Amazing food and prices! Loved the shepherds pie and had plenty to take home for the next day! Bravo!!! read more

Coleman's Corner - Shepherds pie - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

I will start this as I always do by saying that I don't give out five stars unless I am really blown away. This is my second visit and second time I was disappointed. Again it was partially my fault so I won't bash them. The atmosphere here is great. The decor is also great. The service has been top notch both times that I've stopped. Deborah was a very good waitress. Very attentive and friendly. I wanted to do a salad and maybe try some wings. I ordered the sweet chili wings and the Blarney Cobb. Food came out quick. First the wings sauce was good a little heat and a little sweet. They were not real meaty unfortunately. They were also over cooked so it seemed like thEy were even less meaty. If you like crunchy wings you in the right place. The salad came out as I finished the wings. It was as advertised bacon, avocado, egg and chicken over greens. I asked for blue cheese on the side. This is where I made a mistake. Always taste the dressing before putting it on the salad. The lemon vinaigrette was not something I would like on anything. I poured it on the whole salad ruining it completely. I tried to muscle through but the tart flavorless dressing was to much and overpowered even the bacon flavor. I will eat here again because the menu seems good and I feel like I have just been unlucky. I am hopeful that next time I will give a four star. read more

See all

Your average Irish pub! Always good food, and friendly servers. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, especially on the cold winter days here in the North Country. Their homemade fries are fantastic, and the gravy that goes with them is my constant favorite. Would like to see more traditional Irish fare options, but what they do offer is decent. read more

Coleman's Corner - Chips, gravy, and French onion soup (I said no cheese) - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

Most delicious corned beef and cabbage! Hubby got the trio and I stole a bite of each and my favorite was the corned beef. I'm not usually a big meat fan but this was so tender and flavorful. I ordered the Irish Cuban with Irish fries. We sat outside and loved the fresh air. The service was very friendly and attentive. We definitely plan to come back and try everything on their menu. read more

Welcoming atmosphere, good tunes but not overly loud as so many places are. Felt quite comfortable dining solo. Service was very pleasant and quick. Was there on a Thurs eve at dinner time, place was about 1/3 full. Decent prices and varied menu, nice salad choices. I had a paddy melt burger which was good (but not the best I've ever had). Ordered it med rare, arrived more pink than red (I prefer the reverse). I would definitely return. read more

My husband loves the steak and that they serve Guinness on draft. The staff is always friendly and it's nice that the bar is separated from the tables by a little partition. My only critique is that I wish they had better dessert options but overall this is one of our favorite places to go. read more

Great food and waitresses are so thoughtful!!! Patio dining adds a fun touch!!! Visit this place, you'll be glad you did!! read more

Atmosphere- very traditional Irish pub decor and setting however the music does not fit Irish pub at all our waitress was very nice and kind however her shorts were way too short I know it's summer time but that was way too short. Drinks- we ordered a raspberry iced tea it was very good it did not taste fake or over sweet it was the perfect blend of flavor sweetness in Tea which is very hard to do. Appetizer- we ordered the muscles as well as the lobster bisque the muscles were the showstopper for this time going to the Irish pub they were amazing with flavor depth of flavor something you would expect from a fine dining restaurant not an Irish pub so that was very unexpected and pleasurable how ever almost half of the muscles were not open there for I have to dock them because that is not except a bowl and the bread that was served was the consistency and texture of a over cooked hard old dumpling baguette would of been a way better option to serve with these muscles to dip the broth. The lobster bisque with some of the best bisque I've ever had the flavor was very full of lobster and you could see the small bits of lobster within the soup however the soup was served warm not as hot as I would like it with crackers I would rather had the best served either in a bread bowl or with a baguette to dip and crackers were a little off and cheap to me also would prefer to have large chunks of lobster within the bisque as well for the visual aspect of lobster in the lobster bisque but will definitely order those appetizers again Main courses - The Jamison burger was too sweet for my liking and canned out cooked more along the lines of medium medium well versus medium rare which I ordered there was no pink at all however was still juicy it was a severe lack of flavor and the red cabbage was very offputting it was very chunky versus the nice shredded red cabbage that I was expecting on my burger the sauce was good there just wasn't enough to make an impact on the burger it was missing something. The beef and cheddar would've been better if served with a cheese sauce versus sliced cheese in my opinion the beer and cheddar sandwich was missing something I either saw or another spice to elevate the dish . The chips that were served with the sandwiches were bled it is essential after frying potatoes you salt that this was not done which in turn made them taste very bland we ordered the Irish fries and gravy and we're given to small little things of the most generic bland tasting gravy you would expect which was very disheartening for the flavors of the appetizers in the charge was three dollars more per little cup of gravy which I think is absurd . overall not pleased with the main courses so far that we have tried . Overall will definitely be returning to order the muscles again because they were that good as well as enjoy the experience of this Irish pub would have given more star rating but have included why I have knocked them down on stars. The appetizers were five star the main courses were three star. read more

See all

I really wanted to give this place four start but I just couldn't. I really liked the Irish bar feel and the service was good. I did steal a bite of my husband's sandwich, I don't remember which on he got but it was really good. I got the fish and chips. The chips were really great a different. They were circular fries that came with some really good gravy. My only complaint was that the main part of my meal, the fish, was over cooked and dry. Based on the other reviews for this place it may have just been a one off. Despite that, I will be back. There were a number other things on the menu that I want to try and they have a deal on a full bottle of wine on Wednesday for $9. read more

Coleman's Corner - Fish and Chips - Pubs Near Me - Watertown, New York

Poor managerial skills made for a very bad experience! Hard plastic chunk found in Cobb Salad- not pleasant to bite down on that. Computers were down and nobody was told until after we had eaten and wanted to pay. They couldn't take credit cards, so the manager suggested we use the ATM next door, but didn't want to pay the fee. Who would ever suggest that when it was their problem with the computers??? We didn't get an itemized bill so we could check it. Instead, we got a hand written total on a piece of paper. That's unacceptable! read more

Just left Coleman's corner. Of course, it is a very busy day being St. Patrick's Day, and it was packed. The food was good and service was fairly quick especially for how many people were there. We ordered our food and got it quickly too. I ordered a second beer (while still eating), and shortly after, got a box to go. The server asked if we wanted our check right away with the box so we took it. I was finishing my beer and the hostess came up and rudely said "we have a policy that if you sit for 5 min after getting your check you need to go, so if you're just drinking you can go to the bar". I told her I ordered it as I was eating and was about to be done. I had one sip left of my beer and was trying to finish quickly and leave. She mentioned that she wasn't trying to be rude it's just her policy to tell people-that is the rudest comment I've received in a restaurant. We were there the standard amount of time (and other tables had been sitting there longer than me). The table behind me was only drinking and were there before I got there. I looked at the time and we were there a little over an hour. I understand there's a wait but clearly, I was finishing up and about to leave. Not to mention, when I first walked in, there were drunk older men hanging around the hostess stand flirting with the possibly underaged hostesses. They took a couple minutes to realize I was there waiting for a table (as the drunk guys were hanging around blocking the stand). Is there a policy for that? If you have a policy like that (esp. when it's busy) put it on the tables or tell people ahead of time. Also, your hostesses need training on customer service. Even if she did tell me there was a wait for the tables, she could have said it in a more professional, nicer way (it's not that hard). I was excited to finally try this place and that made me not want to come back. Would rather drive further to Syracuse or Canada for Irish food next time. read more