Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Cold Spring Cheese Shop

    4.4 (41 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 6:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Cold Spring Cheese Shop Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Cold Spring Cheese Shop

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Fig, Arugula, Mozz Sandwich
    Pratima M.

    The Fig Jam, Arugula, Mozzarella sandwich I had here was one of my favorite sandwiches in recent memory -- this shop is so cute and has a wide selection of cheeses, jams, spreads, etc. They have an outdoor patio which tends to get busy, but there's also plenty of benches on the street to sit and eat. I'm obsessed with it, totally worth the stop in Cold Spring!

    Bonnie G.

    I cannot get over how incredible their soppresatta is! The greatest I've ever had. Thin and silky and fresh and divine. Paired with their camembert brie-style creamy cheese and their womanchego... oh my gosh. Heavenly. We ate almost our whole plate in a sitting outside. Would drive an hour to Cold Spring just to go to this place. Can't wait to come back! 5 stars!!!!

    Mozzarella fig jam sandwich
    Avery D.

    I got the mozzarella fig jam sandwich. It also had arugula on it. The jam was very good and so sweet! Overall a good sandwich. $12 for the whole thing and it filled me up. Sat outside and had a nice view of the fall Main Street.

    tables and chairs outside
    Rafael V.

    We stopped here for lunch after hiking at the West Point Foundry Preserve in Cold Spring. We got the fig with mozzarella sandwich and the smoked ham with cheese. The sandwiches tasted good. My son ordered the Mac & cheese and it was a generous serving. I'll definitely come back to this shop.

    a hand holding a sandwich
    Grace L.

    Got here on a busy Saturday morning, maybe around 11 am. It's a quaint shop with a small sandwich menu, but lots of meat and cheese selections. They seem to pre-make all of the sandwiches so it's pretty fast to checkout as they just grab it from a basket. They were about to close the store temporarily after us though so they could make more sandwiches. Proscuitto & Brie ($12) - solid sandwich on a baguette. The bread was a little tough but could still chew through it. Simple, but all the flavors worked well together. Saw the charcuterie boards as well, but they looked underwhelming. No bathroom.

    Cheese

    See all

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Cold Spring Cheese Shop

    Review Highlights - Cold Spring Cheese Shop

    Tim the owner is a delight to work with - responsive, thoughtful, and helpful.

    Mentioned in 3 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Second Mouse Cheese Shop

    Second Mouse Cheese Shop

    4.7(40 reviews)
    21.4 mi

    A most delightful cheese shoppe with a variety of unique and delicious cheeses and their various…read moreaccoutrements, be it - wine, whisky, chocolate, biscuits, bread, jams, fruit, or thou. Second Mouse also offers many tastings for one to reserve a spot at a cost. Join your fellow cheese fans for fromage tastings with the many wondrous lovely accompaniments to the Art of the Enjoyment Of Cheese! Bon Appétit! Enjoy! Thank you for reading

    This place is absolutely fantastic! The staff is very knowledgable and friendly-they even have a…read morelunch menu with homemade soups and different types of sandwiches that feature their cheese which is awesome. They also do really nice catering plates--I got one of the mini cheese and chucutterie plates and brought it to a party-everyone absolutely loved it. The plate was put together so nicely with little flags on the cheese so you knew which one it was and the meats were very tasty. They pretty much have any type of cheese you could imagine, and it is hard to walk out of the store without buying something. This is the type of place you feel SO good shopping at and supporting a local shop. Things there are pricey-but you are paying for excellent quality and service. I always look forward to going back to try yet another cheese that I have yet to have--I love how the cheese also rotates based on the time of year and what is available. They also have various cheese tasting events either at the shop or at another local establishment. I went to one of their events at the local brewery-I believe it was a beer and cheese tasting which was a ton of fun. I really want to go to another one of their events.

    Photos
    Second Mouse Cheese Shop - Lovely cheese varieties - 10/15/2025

    Lovely cheese varieties - 10/15/2025

    Second Mouse Cheese Shop - Lovely gift of Jams for cheese - 10/15/2025

    Lovely gift of Jams for cheese - 10/15/2025

    Second Mouse Cheese Shop

    See all

    Scott & Joe

    Scott & Joe

    4.8(30 reviews)
    22.7 mi

    I'd be lying if I said I didn't drive 45 minutes to Nyack specifically to visit this cheese shop…read morebecause of a video I saw on social media, but I absolutely did & it was a great decision. Scott & Joe is coined "the gayest cheese shop in America" & while I haven't surveyed all of the other cheese shops in America, I agree. It's a quaint little shop tucked amongst other small shops on Broadway. Scott is behind the fully stocked cheese case serving & SERVING with a smile. He was patient while we perused the case & asked questions. We sampled some cheeses to figure out what we like & what we didn't & ended up leaving with some yummy treats. Scott & Joe also have a little bit of a marketplace with delicious options of cured meats, crackers, jams, jellies, mustards & the like: perfect for any dinner party or snack plate. In my opinion, the best part is a not so secret little bistro section in the back where you can have a seat & be served some of the most delicious sandwiches, salads, & cheeseboards in the Hudson Valley. I got the Ciao Bella this time around, but it was hard to choose because I wanted them all! Everything was so fresh & delicious - I can't wait to return! Scott & Joe also hold various events regularly, so I recommend following them on Instagram to stay in the loop.

    I always order the southern Italy sandwich and it is sooooo good. This is a local business with…read morevery good food from all around the world. If you're ever in Nyack NY, I suggest you give it a try. The owners are very nice as well. The ambiance is very pleasant with cool decorations. Highly suggested.

    Photos
    Scott & Joe
    Scott & Joe
    Scott & Joe

    See all

    Cold Spring Cheese Shop - cheese - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...