I'd be lying if I said I didn't drive 45 minutes to Nyack specifically to visit this cheese shop because of a video I saw on social media, but I absolutely did & it was a great decision. Scott & Joe is coined "the gayest cheese shop in America" & while I haven't surveyed all of the other cheese shops in America, I agree. It's a quaint little shop tucked amongst other small shops on Broadway. Scott is behind the fully stocked cheese case serving & SERVING with a smile. He was patient while we perused the case & asked questions. We sampled some cheeses to figure out what we like & what we didn't & ended up leaving with some yummy treats. Scott & Joe also have a little bit of a marketplace with delicious options of cured meats, crackers, jams, jellies, mustards & the like: perfect for any dinner party or snack plate. In my opinion, the best part is a not so secret little bistro section in the back where you can have a seat & be served some of the most delicious sandwiches, salads, & cheeseboards in the Hudson Valley. I got the Ciao Bella this time around, but it was hard to choose because I wanted them all! Everything was so fresh & delicious - I can't wait to return! Scott & Joe also hold various events regularly, so I recommend following them on Instagram to stay in the loop. read more

See all

I always order the southern Italy sandwich and it is sooooo good. This is a local business with very good food from all around the world. If you're ever in Nyack NY, I suggest you give it a try. The owners are very nice as well. The ambiance is very pleasant with cool decorations. Highly suggested. read more

Scott and Joe is a fantastic addition to downtown Nyack. My first visit was to pick out a cheese to bring to a party. Scott helped me pick something that was both unique but would be appealing to a large group. My other two visits was for lunch. Both times I had the delicious open faced prosciutto and Burrata sandwich. That sandwich is so good that it haunts my dreams. Scott is friendly and fun and really knows his cheese. Will absolutely be back. read more

Fantastic selection and very helpful. A bit of a drive for me, but worth the drive. Love it.

Delicious take out salad. A bit pricey -- Manhattan prices without Manhattan. Perhaps a positive for some, and a negative for others.

I stumbled upon Simard & Co. while exploring Nyack for the day with a few friends. It brought me right back to being in Paris, from the cheeses to the fresh artisan bread. The owners made us feel right at home. They were so knowledgeable and happy to give us samples. We ended up sitting down in the cozy dining area and had ourselves a lovely afternoon. As stuffed as I was I still bought cheeses, crackers and bread to take home. If you love cheese and charcuterie this little place is perfect for you! read more

See all

I wish I could give these guys 10 stars as my experience here was phenomenal. I came here with two of my friends after visiting Sleepy Hollow two weeks ago - not only did we have the most delicious meat and cheese board (American cheddar - epic, no joke, delicious and I'm from England), we had pate, and probably one of the nicest red wines I've had in awhile. I took half a pound of the cheddar home it was so good to share with my family. The best part though was the two guys at the shop - I'd go back just to chat with them. Truly the highlight of my weekend! read more

Scott & Joe - a platter of meat and cheese - Cheese Shops Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

Who could have imagined that Simard (the D is silent) and Co could get even more heavenly. Well, it did. As of 12.6.19, this Nyack gem now has a wonderful bistro of wine, cheese and charcuterie-the eclectic selection is well thought out, delicious and sublime. Cow, Sheep & Goat cheeses populate the blackboard menu. Interesting sides include, anchovies, olives, cornichon, and Macon's almonds. Special additions on this day were, wagyu beef, iberico jamon, and parmigiana stratavechio. The charcuterie menu which we didn't take part in featured: prosciutto Di parma, chorizo iberico, acorn fed mon serrano, dodge city salumi nudja and soppressata. Wine for every cheese at your enjoyment. A little bit of France can be found on S Broadway in Nyack on Hudson - Bon Appetit read more

Scott & Joe - Cheese Shops Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

Absolutely delicious food. Some of the best pate I've ever had. Owner Scott very pleasant too. Will definitely be back

If I could give this place more than 5 stars I would. If you're in the Nyack area I highly recommend stopping by Simard & Co. Both Joe & Scott are very knowledgeable about the items they sell but additionally are so kind, hospitable, and loads of fun. If you are ever with a group I highly recommend doing a custom tasting at the shop. You are able to pick cheese, meat, wine and more. Our girl group had a blast and cannot wait to go back! read more

Scott & Joe - a variety of cheeses and meats - Cheese Shops Near Me - Nyack, New York

awesome absolutely awesome place to eat! owner is great ! bread is out of this world! salad is fabulous! I'm drooling with delight! can't stop raving! I'm not done with my food but wanted to make sure I gave a stunning review!! I want to move in!! I will be back asap! read more

Scott & Joe - a sandwich and salad on a plate - Cheese Shops Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

We were very excited for a cheese store to open in the area. Our experience, however, was very poor. It took them a long time to recognize us after we walked into the store. They begrudgingly gave us a sample and asked who was paying. The moment someone older than us entered the store, the owner moved us to the side and attended them first. She told one of her employees to not give us any more samples unless we were buying. This was odd since we already had items set aside to purchase. We were discriminated against based on our age. I tell everyone I know to skip this cheese store unless they are middle-aged. We take our business elsewhere. read more

Delicious food, welcoming owners, great atmosphere. My husband and I came in for brunch last weekend. The sandwiches are out of this world, plus it is a nice relaxed atmosphere to enjoy a bite to eat. When given the option, always choose the truffle chips. read more

See all

I have a complaint. I am a cheese fan. I really really like the stuff. I eat it every day. On some days, I eat it for every meal. Some of my local go-to lunch spots were closed today because of snow, so I popped in to Simard and Co for a sandwich. Their sandwich menu is limited. They have one sandwich available. It is grilled cheese. Not surprising for a cheese shop, I know. I ordered the grilled cheese after first asking what the cheese choices were today and receiving this response: The sandwich is a mix of our cheddars with sliced tomato and a caramelized-onion jam. Now I know that once you add something other than butter and cheese, the sandwich is technically a "melt" not a "grilled cheese," but that is not my complaint. My complaint is this: I don't think I can order a grilled cheese sandwich anywhere else ever again. This was not only the best grilled cheese sandwich I ever ate, but I think it might have been the best sandwich I ever ate. read more

Simard & Co. is a MUST if you are in downtown Nyack. Not only is the charcuterie show stopping to the point you forget to drink the beautiful Sancerre they have to offer (at a steal of $38 for the bottle), but what will 100% be bringing me and my partner back is the service - Joe is not only very knowledgeable and attentive, he is more importantly so genuine and really cares at providing the best experience for his guests. We can not wait to be back! read more

What a gem! I brought my kids to Nyack to hit some stores and I stumbled across this place. Their selection is amazing. I can't say enough good things about this place. The staff was incredibly helpful. I'll be. Ack again and again. read more

Love this place. One of the best shops in nyack. Great menu, amazing and delicious cheese. Owner is great and knowledgeable of his product. Been here numerous times and planning on going more and more. Small place but nice. They have great wine and cheese classes if anyone is interested. read more

Ordered a wonderful charcuterie board for Christmas Eve. Everything was delicious and everyone enjoyed the cheeses, fruits, and wonderful slices of delicious ham. Would highly recommend anything from this wonderful store. read more

We came across this charming cheese and gourmet shop while strolling through Nyack. Incredible selection of fine cheeses, pastas, sauces, specialty and imported products. The owner and employees super knowledgeable and friendly. Reminds me of those small cheese shops in Paris. Definitely worth a visit. read more

A wonderful afternoon experience, warm and welcoming, fabulous cheese, wine, and the Ciao Bella sandwich was a mouth watering gem. Will definitely go back! read more

ExcelLent new idea for this established cheese shop! charcuterie, wines, salads and more. Quaint atmosphere, great service.... and cozy. Give it a try, relax to the soft background music and enjoy. read more

Wow, I cannot say enough good things about this place. The sandwiches and salads we had here are competitive with the best ones we've had in Napa Valley, NYC and Blue Hill Stone Barns. The wine selections were delicious too. Scott is a delightful proprietor and his pride in his craft really comes through. read more

Had a wonderful experience at this shop. Lisa is a hoot and shared the cheeses she likes so we could try them. Left with two wonderful cheeses -- one we have never had before -- and some delicious bacon marmalade. To top it off, we ordered grilled cheese sandwiches with tomato jam and it was seriously the BEST grilled cheese I have ever eaten. Can't wait to visit Nyack and "our cheese shop" again. Shops like this deserve our support. #shoplocal read more

Simard and Co has it all! Fabulous staff, warm inviting atmosphere and amazing charcuterie,cheese and wine selections. A hidden gem in Nyack. Can't wait to try their brunch that starts today. read more

Simard & co. created such a beautiful cheese board -- and walked it down the street at that, -- for our art exhibit opening tonight at the Edward Hopper House Museum in Nyack. It made for a very special, and delicious, table at our reception and was enjoyed by many. Thank you! read more

A MUST! This cheese shop is in the heart of Nyack and is a place you must visit. There's a variety of great cheeses/meats/charcuterie platters. Also lots of tastings and events! Very kind and knowledgeable owners. You won't regret it! read more

Today was our first time trying Simard & Co and we loved it. Super friendly people and just a great shop. They gave us generous sampling's of cheeses and meats to try - we bought every recommendation because they were all that delicious. Thank you for the great experience! We will definitely be back again soon. read more

Amazing selection of Cheese & Charcuterie. PLEASE do yourself a favor and stop in here. Staff is wonderfully knowledgable and friendly ! They will tantalize your tastebuds. read more

We are from Westchester and were looking for a nice Cheese and Charcuterie place around us. We have tried some around Westchester and have not been that impressed. So, we were happy to find a cheese shop over in Nyack. Long story short, we found the best cheese and charcuterie shop we have ever been in, and we have been in quite a few!! The staff was so helpful and knowledgeable. They allowed us to try a sample of everything that we wanted to buy and made good recommendations when we described what we like. They also have great baguettes which are hard to find. When we got home we had a wonderful meal that transported us to Europe!! All of the cheeses, sopprasetta, prosciutto were all the best we have had!! I cannot recommend this store enough!! It is a foodie's paradise! Make the trip to Nyack, it is well worth the trip!! read more

Love love love the place! It's great to have a local cheese shop to support! I hated having to go to the city for good cheese. I found the staff helpful and friendly. They seemed very willing to help us and leave us alone to look around at the same time. read more