Always great Bbq! The service has always been great, staff is so helpful and friendly! We try to go as often as we can. In summer I will definately order the gyro again, absolutely phenomenal! We order pulled pork sandwiches, pulled pork 1/2 lb., ribs, coleslaw, fries and the peanut butter pie regularly and we love the sauce too. Never disappointed! At Cockeye Creamery the ice cream is so good! Blueberry cheesecake, pumpkin cheesecake ice cream for fall are excellent! So delighted that they have vegan ice cream options. The absolute best vegan ice cream we can get! My husband just loves it! We can't find better Bbq in our area! read more

I have eaten at Cockeye BBQ several times and I'm always pleased. The service is prompt and friendly. The food is delicious and there is a sauce for everyone. I would definitely recommend. read more

I remembered my dad saying we haven't had barbecue in a while so I told my brother that was the plan! My dad saw this spot on New Day Cleveland years ago and we keep coming back. When we got to the counter to order, the two ladies there both greeted us, although one was taking someone else's order. When my mom and I said we were gluten free, she had every answer we needed. Sauces, putting hush puppies on the side, no bread. Excellent job! We would have sat outside, but all of those tables were filled. We did get a table inside for the four of us. Packed inside too. They brought our food out to us when it was ready. With it being packed for Father's Day, 20-25 minutes wasn't that bad. The two sandwich eaters devoured their sandwiches and sides. The two meat platter had just the right amount of proteins and sides. Pulled pork is often my go to, but the brisket was divine on Sunday! I didn't know there were at least four kinds of beans available in the side but yum! The Green beans were solid, cooked in/with butter. Upon finishing our delicious lunch we went across the parking lot to the creamery. They had vegan options so I got one vanilla and one chocolate. The cookies and cream wasn't gluten free so I am unable to comment on that vegan option. Very smooth. An awesome finish to an excellent Father's Day lunch. Great atmosphere. Great staff. Great food. One of my favorite barbecue spots! read more

See all

So friendly as you are cheerfully greeted upon entering. Also wished my hubby Happy Father's. What a nice touch. Their BBQ is amazing. I split the two meat platter with my son. The brisket literally melted in your mouth. We had the original bbq sauce. Great choice. Along with the platter we selected green beans and baked beans. Definitely worth the trip out to Warren. read more

Cockeye Bbq - Two meat platter - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

Food was delicious and wait staff attentive. I can't wait to return. Even though it was busy waiting time was minimal Deanna . read more

Food was great. Especially the sides. Variety of sauces to choose from, don't miss out on the blueberry bbq sauce. Staff was very nice. If you're going between Cleveland and Pittsburgh as we were, a nice detour. If it's nice out, recommend sitting outside. For road trippers, there's a gas station just down the street. read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

Excellent barbecue. However make sure you save room for ice cream. Some of the best BBQ and ice cream you will find. read more

Great food. Best I had since being in St Louis. Definitely will eat there again. Service was very good too!!

Excellent food! Great ribs and brisket! Wish they were open on Mondays and Tuesdays. Simple restaurant with simple and extremely great barbeque! read more

We were here yesterday. I asked for a 5 gallon bucket of Colardgreens to go... But they wouldn't give em to me . They did however let me go home with a quart. Well worth the price . I luv this place. read more

Really friendly counter staff and so many choices! I got a pulled pork sandwich and fries and my date got the mess plate. We enjoyed everything. There is a condiment station where you can add sauces if you like. Give it a try! read more

See all

Great staff and fantastic owners! The ice cream was definitely a fantastic addition to their menu. The online ordering works great! Some of the best side dishes around. read more

We had the smoked gyro, chili, and mac & cheese and all was delicious. Couldn't eat more because it was just lunch and we had to save room for ice cream! read more

Best BBQ I have ever had. All the sides were delicious. Service was friendly and speedy.

Food is always great and the staff is friendly. I enjoy all their BBQ offerings and ice cream

Best BBQ in town. Friendly staff. Everything I've tried on the menu is amazing. Highly recommend

The food is amazing, especially the Cajun Catfish! All the ladies that work there are incredibly nice. Great place to eat.

Worst service ever again last two times they put my food in the warmer without calling my name those time I was 4.ft from warmer they never called 14 minutes in I checked my phone said 13 minutes ago my food was ready. Taco Bell has smarter people And better service never again read more

Dry bbq, dry ribs, dry crumbled brisket, dry sausage, dry pulled pork. No smoke flavor, zero seasoning. 60$ for leftover microwave bbq. The staff was friendly and the place was clean. read more

So we went to the Ambrosia concert in Warren, OH. We decided to leave early to grab a bite to eat along the way. We stumbled upon this place. OH-EM-GEE!!! Hands down THEE BEST bbq. The picture speaks for itself. It's not a big spot, but the service is great. It's a tiny bbq joint, and it can be a bit crowded inside, but they do have outdoor tables. They also have a creamery, right next door. We didn't get to try it because we were so full. I ordered the "Mess Plate" for $9.99 It comes with pulled pork, Mac n Cheese, sprinkled shredded cheese and two onion rings. I couldn't finish it. If you're in the area, definitely check them out! read more

Cockeye Bbq - MESS PLATE - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Excellent BBQ and I'm not big on BBQ. Brisket is amazing. Many sauces to try. Dessert? Homemade ice cream that is to die for.

So many choices so little room in my stomach to eat it all.... But I tried. Pork rinds. I love them. Especially when they are fresh. These came in a pretty big paper bag and were suuuuper tasty. Brisket.... Just right. I think I got a little of each sauce and had fun dipping little pieces of it to try them all. The sauces were all great. But I liked the mustard one best. The burnt ends were my favorite. The sausage was spiiiicy! But so, so tasty! Collard greens were some of the best I've had. I couldn't eat it all and ended up eating the rest for lunch the next day. You definitely get your moneys worth. The kids got burgers and were very happy with them. The gal at the counter was super helpful and patient with the indecisive teens. It's probably a good idea I don't live nearby or I'd be here on the regular. read more

Cockeye Bbq - Brisket, sausage, collage greens, and slaw. Yum! - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

See all

You know the moment you walk into this joint that there's a legit pitmaster somewhere on the premises. I have traveled all over the country and have been to some of the best bbq joints in KC and Texas. This place is hands down some of the best bbq I have ever eaten. The flavor profiles in the shkrimps n cheddar jalapeño grits and in the greens are rich and well balanced. The ribs were perfectly seasoned and tender. The mac n cheese is creamy and delicious. I'm a dry rub bbq fan. I did not try any of the multiple flavors of bbq sauce. I was so stunned by how delicious the bbq was, I had to go next door to the creamery and experience the hype. I tried the Cookie Monster and the Blueberry Cheesecake, highly recommend. The staff and service were also top notch. Big ups to the owners. This is a hidden gem. read more

Cockeye Bbq - Half Slab Dinner, Macaroni and Cheese, Collard Greens, pickles, Hush Puppies, fried shrimp and grits - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

There is something that just feels right about being greeted with BB King and Blues Brothers music when entering a BBQ spot. I loved the ambiance of said music, warm conversation of adjacent families sharing their meals, and of course, the smell of some good cooking. The variety of sauces was fun, the tea was good, and the sides and BBQ themselves were on point. The service for better or worse is pretty hands-off. Be aware also that they charge a bit more for brisket when eaten as a part of their meat sets, for some reason. Good times here, and I would visit again if I get to visit the Buckeye state. read more

Cockeye Bbq - Two meat meal. - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Food is so darn good!! Exceptional service!! It has that authentic BBQ joint feel! Will visit every time I am back in Warren!!

I got the ribs last time and they were good but the brisket i got this time was pretty mid. Really dry and not a lot of flavor. The sides are where it's at tho espescially the cheesy potatoes!! The corn casserole is not bad as well but ive had better. My faves are definitely the cheesy potatoes and actually the pickles lmao they slap pretty hard read more

Cockeye Bbq - Brisket - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

We drove out of our way to visit Cockeye BBQ after we saw an ad somewhere. Not going to lie, the BBQ / Creamery combo was the biggest draw. Originally walking in with BBQ pork, brisket, etc on the mind, it was actually the southern fried chicken that caught our eye. OK, so I did get a side of brisket too. Note that the fried chicken takes 20-30 minutes to prepare because it is made fresh. I can respect that. The brisket was good but a tad dry and fairly bland. I almost never put BBQ sauce on brisket but this portion needed it. Cockeye has a unique variety of BBQ sauces. The BlackBerry smoke sauce was my favorite. The chicken portions was HUGE and delicious. Onion rings were good. The cheesy potatoes were amazing. Tons of leftovers to bring home. read more

See all

The owner his wife and daughter all working on the Friday we visited. Treated me like a king. Recommended some really good beers. Even shared half of his own beer. Such a good guy. The sauces are varied in flavors and styles. All of them good. The brisket was good. A little dry but the sauce brought it right around. The pulled pork and smoked turkey were really good. The sides were also home made and tasty. I can't wait to visit again and try the ice cream hut this time. read more

Counter service & the holler your name & being you your food in a styrofoam container. The pulled pork without sauce had no real taste. I know I'm one of a few but not sure what the draw was. Their "hot bbq" had no tang to me. I left smelling like I was smoked instead of the pork. read more

The bbq and ice cream are in a class by themselves. 10 iut of 10 I would definitely recommend!

Decent spot in Warren. Tried the burnt ends special, they were ok, not a ton of flavor. Sides were great - green beans & cheesy taters. Will definitely go back to try other things. My customers tried the brisket and pulled pork, both said they enjoyed their meals. read more

Cockeye Bbq - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Great food smoke turkey was excellent . The ice cream is a must have. I go just for the ice cream .

I've never liked BBQ, but this place changed my mind. Food is amazing, service is superb. Highly recommend

definitely greasy spoon cuisine. Very American. Reasonable. Good food, not great. Somewhere you gotta try and make your own decision. One of a kind. read more

Absolutely the best ice cream in town. Flavors are delicious and change frequently. Servers are friendly and helpful. We go there way more often than we should because we can't resist. read more

We've eaten at the restaurant and have had their catering and all I can say is it's average at best, the brisket and pulled pork was dry and flavorless, the sides were good. Doubt we'll be back. read more

Excellent barbecue. The ribs are outstanding as well as the brisket. We had the hush puppies and the beans and they were very good, too. We call ahead and it's always ready when we get there read more

I made the fried corn bread, but ribs and greens courtesy of Cockeye BBQ in Warren. Seriously good! And five stars. People have issues sometimes, but I seem to think when the place runs out of food. So, thinking, rather have them run out, than serve yesterday's food all dried out! read more

Cockeye Bbq - Greens, ribs, my fried corn bread! - American Near Me - Warren, Ohio

Great local bbq place with an ice cream walk up on the other side of the parking lot. Service was friendly and food was amazing!! Two big thumbs up!! read more

Food was excellent! Ribs nice and fall off the bone tender. Service is fast and staff so polite. Restaurant clean! read more