Fish Fry was great! And their salad bar is good. Beer choices, and drinks there are good. Lots of seating. No wait but they are always busy. Good choice for prime rib as well. read more

Prime Rib was so stringy couldn't even cut it with their steak knife, plus couldn't even chew it into small enough pieces to swallow it, it was also very heavily seasoned with garlic , which I can't stand. waitress took $2.00 off the bill , certainly left a bad taste in my mouth. We eat there often, but after this encounter we will be looking for a new favorite place to go out to. read more

After driving past this supper club many times our party of three dined here two nights in a row to give it a fair shake. I am now confident the crowded parking lot is due to limited options nearby and stiff drinks. Our first night was dominated by a party of 12 in their 70s who were so drunk and loud that nobody else in the dining room could hold a conversation. We were five tables away from them and we could not hear each other. I know this is not entirely the restaurant's fault but it appeared that they have another dining room they could have put a large group in so the rest of the customers could enjoy dinner. Option two would be to consider some sound absorbing decor in this large wide open dining area. My wife ordered the ribeye medium rare. It came out cooked less than rare. It had not even been adequately seared to call it rare. It took so long for the waitress to check on us that we just had her box it up to be cooked at home. I had the pepper steak. The pepper topping was not cooked enough to be enjoyable. It was essentially uncooked vegetables piled on a filet. Our daughter's chicken parmesan was OK but nothing special. We decided to go back the next night curious if we had just hit an off night. It appears that they rush everything out of the kitchen. My daughter's blue gill and my fried cod were both undercooked. My wife's clam strips were tasty and cooked well but the fries were undercooked. The salad bar was small but adequate and slightly different the second night which was nice. One of the two soup options changed which we also appreciated. One other strange quirk-- things you see on the website, the menu, and on the TV display in the dining room do not match up. There are no appetizers on the printed menu but they advertise them on a rotating display in the dining room. We had high hopes for this place but came away very disappointed twice. read more

Stopped in to Club 60 on a Saturday night with the family. It's a supper club with one large dinning room. Ambience is nothing special, the menu is large and two of the choices we had were scallop scampi and prime rib and they were good, salad bar and soups so you won't go home hungry! Absolutely no covid stuff going on and that's good for me. Also good stiff old fashioned. I will be back! read more

Club 60 - Small prime! - American Near Me - Columbus, Wisconsin

See all

Never again. How dare you tell us twice that "we have other people that are going to need this table"! The first time the server said this to us was before we even ordered our food. Again, near the end of our dinner. One of the bartenders had an attitude and I gave up trying to get served because she was "too busy right now" to take my drink order. Quite a shame because the fish was really good. read more

First time here. Soup and salad bar was adequate, but missed some staples such as cheese spread and cottage cheese. Prime rib, fries, and smashed potatoes were very good, as were our cocktails. The stuffed shrimp was a miss for us. To much cheese filling, not enough crab. read more

The restaurant was very bright so it wasn't very relaxing. Good salad bar and drinks. Very nice waitress until I told her my ribeye was very bland(looked and tasted like a sirloin). She didn't try to fix or replace my item but snickered as if she was offended. Someone else in our group had the pepper steak and noted there's was bland as well. read more

Everything about this place was just ok. I ordered the shrimp Alfredo - the noodles were a little over cooked. My husband ordered the king prime rib with red potatoes. The prime rib was good but a bit salty and the potatoes were just ok, we make better ones at home. The salad bar and soup were decent. Prices were comparable to other places that are similar. Overall we may be back but I wouldn't go out of my way. read more

See all

Solid supper club. Simple old fashioned with great pour got us feeling good during the short wait for our table. Funky and fun atmosphere reminded me of a cross between a cruise ship and a high school cafeteria. Salad bar was fresh and tasty. My wife enjoyed the fish fry but we both agreed the prime rib was amazing. Great service. read more

First time diners Got drinks at the bar Waited only 10 minutes or two sips of our drinks to be seated Dined on Prime Rib and Ribeye Delicious,we will be back Kim was our cheerful and attentive waitress 7-11-2020 read more

Wife and I went here for dinner after seeing the reviews and the overall experience was mediocre. Staff without masks. We should have left right then. Shows their concern for their customers and staff. My wife had a plain margarita and it tasted off. The bartender said it was the first plain one she had made so it was removed from the bill. My wife also had the prime rib and it was a huge piece of meat. That is where the goodness ended. It was so salty that it was almost inedible. I had the seafood platter. It was meh. On par with a frozen meal. We had high hopes seeing the other reviews but a classic supper club it is not. It is a bar with a dining room slinging below average food. read more

We ran across this gem of a supper club last week when we were visiting the Columbus area on a Friday evening. The place was very busy, the servers and bar staff some of the happiest, kindest and friendliest staff we have had lately! They seemed to be genuinely glad to see you and were very welcoming. The food is prepared just perfectly-- we enjoyed a 3 piece cod dinner, with a terrific twice baked potato and full salad bar with TWO soups to choose from! The drinks were awesome too-- highly recommend one of their signature drinks: Caramel white Russian! We will be back soon! Recommended and even better: they take reservations too! As we left and complimented the owner of our evening, she recommended we call in a reservation next time to avoid a lengthy wait time. But free popcorn at the bar as you wait and other friendly customers who invite you to share their table (if they have extra chairs) was refreshing... and fun! We didn't mind the wait....we felt so welcomed! Good people here! read more

Pros: Food is Reasonably priced and there is a good variety of options. Cons: there is one large room that feels like a cave. There are no windows and tables are close together. The room is loud and makes it difficult to hear anyone sitting with you. This is a popular place and you will be packed in tightly. We had a reservation and were told that there were no open tables and we had to wait an additional 25-30 minutes. With the bar being the host area there was no place to comfortably stand or wait. We were literally shoulder to shoulder with others waiting. Service was marginal. The waitress for our table checked on us once and didn't refill our drinks. The soup/salad bar had no spoons for the soups and there were no spoons with the silverware at the table. We went on a Friday fish fry night and maybe it was busier than normal or they did not have enough staff. We will find a different location for Friday night fish fries. read more

Their drinks were good. Club 60 is the OK-ist supper club I have been to. Nothing was bad, but I can only praise their drinks. Saturday Prime rib was salty tasting. Likely used meat tenderizer as my tongue was numb after. Fair flavor and good portions. Wife's well done filet mignon came medium at best and was slightly dry. Club 50 seems to be a local favorite. Dress code called for camo sweatshirts and jeans. The ambience in the banquet hall was provided by super bright flood lights, wining Club 60 the award for best lit supper club of 2019. Service staff was great, bar tender was awesome. Give it a try it, but don't expect the 5 star food. read more

Great menu! Service was friendly and prompt, and the salad bar offerings were fresh and tasty. We especially liked the fact that the dining area is in another room from the bar. Well worth a return visit whenever we're in Columbus! read more

I have had Prime Rib, salmon, and Broasted Chicken here. Salad soup bar is good too. read more

Club 60 - Good menu - American Near Me - Columbus, Wisconsin

See all

This is an amazing old time supper club that is a must. The food and environment are perfect. Whether it is your first visit or you 50th you will be treated as friends. The food is excellent and the drinks are delish. Staff is out of this world...... From seafood to steaks with many other surprises. You will not be disappointed!!! read more

Club 60 - shrimp and mashed potatoes on a plate - American Near Me - Columbus, Wisconsin

Very consistent, no issues getting in on a Saturday night. Decent service, food good, have been there 3 times since end of May

Great selection of specials. I had prime rib and friends had top sirloin. Food was delicious!! Prices are reasonable and HUGE selection.

This is probably our go to place. The people (owners, employees, and patrons) are always friendly and welcoming. Prices are reasonable. I've finally started trying more than just the amazing prime rib, and haven't found anything I wasn't happy with yet. Fish, ribs, chicken, all excellent. We Have to be careful not to fill up at salad and soup station. If the place looks too busy, still walk in. They generally have a party in the other room. They can still accommodate you. Downside: can be kind of loud in dining room. read more

It's your average run of the mill supper club. Nothing overly special with an average fish fry. Was busy then times we went which is expected for Friday fish. Food was average but priced withing reason. Fish pieces are a little skimpy but again for the price it's OK. read more

This was an awesome place for a Wisconsin supper club experience. Everything about it was great- good food, amazing service and we were treated like royalty. read more

Excellent Mothers Day buffet, good prime rib, reasonably priced. We will be back to check out their normal menu.