Cancel

Open app

Search

Classic Bakery

3.9 (47 reviews)
ModerateBakeries
Open • 6:30 am - 6:00 pm

Classic Bakery Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Classic Bakery

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Inside
Ashley O.

If I could get move this zero stars, I would. I purchased a cake for my mom's birthday. We went to cut it and found a hair. Cut another piece and another hair. Called to tell them and they said to bring it back for a refund. Went in for the refund and waited almost 10 minutes for the manager to come over. She never apologized and was just rude the entire time.

Cookies
Giuliana D.

Food, chefs kiss (muah) the service is definitely not skibidi. Hawk tuah definitely got my gyatt out with these cookies. This place is always crowded and we're always in a line which means that it's good ambiance get these cookies so you can be sigma

Mission Beach

Hands down The BEST bakery between Pitt & CLV The staff has always been patient and friendly, even when they are calling numbers(busy) When you walk in and smell the deliciousness and see the clean white uniforms and shiny display cases you know you're in for an experience. Family run business yep Rose and Pauli are old school professionals A Y-town Classic Jackie

a variety of pastries in a display case
Angela D.

NEW NEVER AGAIN! We ordered 5 dozen cutout cookies for a baby shower almost 2 weeks before the shower. Nothing crazy - it was a berry theme, so we asked for strawberries and onesies. They did not have a strawberry cookie cutter, but they said if we found one, they would use it. We just had to have it to them at least 2 days before the order was to be picked up. I found one, and my daughter dropped it off the Thursday before the Sunday pick up, since they are closed Monday - Wednesday. Nothing seemed off; they took the cookie cutter without mentioning any potential issues. On Saturday at 2:50 pm - less than 24 hours before they 9:00 am Sunday pick-up - they called my daughter and left a message that the strawberry cookie cutter wasn't working out. No problem. My daughter called them back and asked if they could do a different shape instead. They changed their story a couple more times and finally said they were unable to fulfill the order at all. My daughter asked if we could just get some of the flower cut out cookies they always have in their display case, but was told that, since it was the holiday weekend (July 4th), they only had red, white and blue icing. We didn't order anything out of the ordinary. 5 dozen iced sugar cookies was not an exotic request. It was extremely ignorant and unprofessional to cancel on us with essentially no notice. To not even offer an alternative was ridiculous! I will not go back and would advise anyone looking to plan for an event to find another vendor. To add insult to injury, a friend stopped in there the morning of the shower and sent me pictures of the cookies in their case. Notice the flowers we requested as an alternative, but were told weren't an option.

Classic white almond wedding cake
Kristen P.

Classic Bakery is such an appropriate name for this local gem! It's like traveling back in time. Everyone is dressed in all white, the bakery is all white and there are cakes, cookies and bread as far as the eye can see. Of heaven has a smell , this is it! My parents recently celebrated their 50th wedding anniversary and we had their wedding cake too recreated. Classic Bakery did an amazing job and it was beautiful. But the taste?!? This is by far the best white almond cake I've ever eaten! It was absolutely perfect in every way. Will definitely be going back for cookies in the near future and of course, more cake.

Goodies on display!
Kate R.

A Youngstown family tradition for over 50 years! I was traveling to Youngstown for a graduation party and my best friend (who is from Youngstown) recommended that I couldn't go back home without stopping at Classic Bakery first! They offer a variety of delicious baked goods: bread, buns, rolls, pastries, cookies, cakes, donuts, muffins, and pies. All baked goods are made with the highest quality ingredients and skillfully baked. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and made my experience at Classic Bakery a pleasant one! Overall: A solid 5 stars!

Shelene L.

Each time I visit the Classic Bakery I leave a happy customer. There are a variety of fresh baked breads, sweet rolls, cakes, pies, and everyone's favorite, cookies, for all to enjoy. Price 5/5 Inexpensive. A slice of my favorite banana cake is only $1.89. Quality 5/5. Consistently good. These baked goods have withstood the test of time. I've eaten here many times over the years. Each time, the taste, portion, and overall quality have not changed. I really like supporting locally owned businesses. It brings money back to the community and keeps the flavors we've grown to love around for all to enjoy. Whether you're in need of Sunday dinner rolls or a sweet treat, this the bakery for you.

Cookies
Lynette C.

came here for the first time since it was Mr. Pauls waaay back when. Gosh the memories from the smell of the pastries to the set up and display cases. Everything we got was amazing including the yummy birthday cake. Keep up the good work Classic

Breann S.

Absolutely love classic bakery my mom got me a banana chocolate cake and it was delicious couldnt stop eating it

donuts! half dozen and a free one on national donut day.

See all

Photo of J W.
0
1
0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Classic Bakery

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 703 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Amish Market - Donut making

The Amish Market

4.5(56 reviews)
0.8 mi
•$$

The Restaurant is absolutely fabulous. They serve Breakfast and Lunch. We tried the Egg and cheese…read moreveggie wrap. We also ordered a cheeseburger as we heard they were absolutely incredible. The wrap was filled with fresh vegetables it was yummy. The cheeseburger comes with fresh hot thin French fries that were so yummy. The burger comes with pickles and mustard and ketchup you can ask for them not to put it on. It was perfectly cooked and the flavor was absolutely on point. The Amish market also has a donut shop that is wonderful. Each donut is 2.00 and they are made all day long. Open Thursday thru Saturday. There are cheese and cold cut vendors. Furniture and custom leather belts and hats. They have a place you can purchase dips for fruit and veggies and they make up beautiful trays daily. Homemade stuffed pretzels with everuthing from breakfast items inside them to just cheese. Fresh cup up fruit and veggies. Every kind of prepped salad you CAN think of. Veggies who veggies sliced. Fruit whole fruit sliced. The best place to find goodies for the weekend. Fresh meats to buy and take home and cook. Ready to eat prepped foods to eat there or take home. A shop for spices and wonderful things to use in the kitchen. This place also has a section where you can buy homemade fresh baked cookies cakes pies, breads. So much here to look at. Candy too. We went back to eat and again I had the Egg veggie wrap. It was fabulous. My friend had the breakfast burger. Crazy good. Burger cooked perfectly on a bun with cheese, sausage gravy, and an egg cooked any way you want she chose scrambled and some sliced home fries. Crazy Combo with a fabulous taste.

Absolute gem of a business. I'm from the West Coast and have never seen anything like this. My only…read moreexposure to the Amish, call me ignorant if you must, was through literature, movies, shows, and word of mouth. This as my first time visiting this area and I can't wait to visit again if inly for The Amish Market! What a lovely place to spend a weekend morning. We had a couple of coffees: delicious. I had a fresh out off of the oven pepperoni Stromboli: magical. I ordered two dozen individual pies from the bakery for Thanksgiving and they were the star of the show. 10 out of 10 would recommend coming here. I halfway joked to my girlfriend that if this was in my neighborhood or if I lived next to one of these that I would be here every weekend, buying fresh eggs, bacon, and coffee. 10/10

Photos
The Amish Market - Outside

Outside

The Amish Market
The Amish Market - 1 (huge) pancake.

See all

1 (huge) pancake.

Classic Bakery - bakeries - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...