I recently visited Youngstown for a family members surprise birthday luncheon. In advance of my visit, I placed an order for a half sheet carrot cake. The cake was amazing and made the birthday and visit very special. Everyone enjoyed the cake and the sweet memories it created. Many thanks, Darrell T read more

Good, quality reasonable bakeries are a dime a dozen to find these days. As part of always honoring, tradition my mom and I had, to check out new local bakeries , had to stop in, in honor of her memory. Aubrey, the young lady that took care of me on my visit, was expectational , friendly, outstanding, customer service and patient. Visiting from out of town after a 5k in Sandy Lake, PA, on my way to Astubula OH and in need of bread , and sweet treats for adopted family visiting. I ended up spending under $12, for assortment of cookies, sliced Italian bread, two turnovers and a peach muffin, and decorative cookie. Defintly, im sure a favorite for locals, and can understand and agree. Conveniently located in a plaza, well worth it, glad I discovered this gem. As always thanks fellow Yelpers. read more

Classic Bakery - Inside case - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

From the special cakes for family birthdays, the burnt almond torte, the pastries, the service.... Always a good experience! read more

Classic Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

If I could get move this zero stars, I would. I purchased a cake for my mom's birthday. We went to cut it and found a hair. Cut another piece and another hair. Called to tell them and they said to bring it back for a refund. Went in for the refund and waited almost 10 minutes for the manager to come over. She never apologized and was just rude the entire time. read more

Classic Bakery - Inside - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

Cookies are hit or miss some are salty with no sugar, some are too sugary with crunchy sugar granules (peanut butter). Oatmeal cookies fell apart fast, the m & m ones were chewy and held together. Flower cookies with frosting ,have a frosty candy crunch to it, with little to no cookie underneath. Very inconsistent cookies across the board; skimping on ingredients, a lot is missing from each cookie, each cookie is lacking something and not that good. The worst part is nothing is even priced in the store, I didn't know they sold coffee , that's not priced, there's no seating, you can't enjoy your coffee and donut. Everything is all different prices so I bought a few small cookies, a big cookie and a donut came out to 9$ which is better than Crumbl but, not putting the price is sus. I wouldn't come back unless my daughter really needed a donut. Just a donut. read more

Food, chefs kiss (muah) the service is definitely not skibidi. Hawk tuah definitely got my gyatt out with these cookies. This place is always crowded and we're always in a line which means that it's good ambiance get these cookies so you can be sigma read more

Classic Bakery - Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

The cookies were made perfectly they were so yummy and the workers who I spoke to while I made my orders were very kind and everything just went well read more

Hands down The BEST bakery between Pitt & CLV The staff has always been patient and friendly, even when they are calling numbers(busy) When you walk in and smell the deliciousness and see the clean white uniforms and shiny display cases you know you're in for an experience. Family run business yep Rose and Pauli are old school professionals A Y-town Classic Jackie read more

Classic Bakery - Mission Beach - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Prices keep going up while product size is going down . Pick one. Plus I am seeing many health violations listed on YELP! This is very disturbing. Used to be the best bakery around. I guess greed and cutting corners got the best of Classic Bakery. read more

NEW NEVER AGAIN! We ordered 5 dozen cutout cookies for a baby shower almost 2 weeks before the shower. Nothing crazy - it was a berry theme, so we asked for strawberries and onesies. They did not have a strawberry cookie cutter, but they said if we found one, they would use it. We just had to have it to them at least 2 days before the order was to be picked up. I found one, and my daughter dropped it off the Thursday before the Sunday pick up, since they are closed Monday - Wednesday. Nothing seemed off; they took the cookie cutter without mentioning any potential issues. On Saturday at 2:50 pm - less than 24 hours before they 9:00 am Sunday pick-up - they called my daughter and left a message that the strawberry cookie cutter wasn't working out. No problem. My daughter called them back and asked if they could do a different shape instead. They changed their story a couple more times and finally said they were unable to fulfill the order at all. My daughter asked if we could just get some of the flower cut out cookies they always have in their display case, but was told that, since it was the holiday weekend (July 4th), they only had red, white and blue icing. We didn't order anything out of the ordinary. 5 dozen iced sugar cookies was not an exotic request. It was extremely ignorant and unprofessional to cancel on us with essentially no notice. To not even offer an alternative was ridiculous! I will not go back and would advise anyone looking to plan for an event to find another vendor. To add insult to injury, a friend stopped in there the morning of the shower and sent me pictures of the cookies in their case. Notice the flowers we requested as an alternative, but were told weren't an option. read more

Classic Bakery - a variety of pastries in a display case - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

We always enjoy our items from there. Sometimes the women can get overwhelmed when really busy but hey it happens.

Classic Bakery is such an appropriate name for this local gem! It's like traveling back in time. Everyone is dressed in all white, the bakery is all white and there are cakes, cookies and bread as far as the eye can see. Of heaven has a smell , this is it! My parents recently celebrated their 50th wedding anniversary and we had their wedding cake too recreated. Classic Bakery did an amazing job and it was beautiful. But the taste?!? This is by far the best white almond cake I've ever eaten! It was absolutely perfect in every way. Will definitely be going back for cookies in the near future and of course, more cake. read more

Classic Bakery - Classic white almond wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Fantastic donuts, cakes, and pastries! In particular the cream sticks are the best in town!!

Love this place sm best bakery in boardman. I always get these like white square things with fondant like frosting its so good.

Their customer service needs a lot of work. Very disappointed. It's so sad that people can be so mean and unpleasant to others. If you can't come to work pleasant and happy please stay home. I hate to say it but no stars for classic. Been going for years, I will not be returning. read more

This review is for their cake only, because that's all I've had from here. It is....awesome! Their delicious Red Velvet comes with delicious cream cheese frosting. Normally the frosting has nuts in it (pecans, I think). I prefer mine w/o nuts though. Their other stuff looks delicious too...it's just soo far away from where I live, so I just get the cake on my b-day. Letter grade: A - read more

Each time I visit the Classic Bakery I leave a happy customer. There are a variety of fresh baked breads, sweet rolls, cakes, pies, and everyone's favorite, cookies, for all to enjoy. Price 5/5 Inexpensive. A slice of my favorite banana cake is only $1.89. Quality 5/5. Consistently good. These baked goods have withstood the test of time. I've eaten here many times over the years. Each time, the taste, portion, and overall quality have not changed. I really like supporting locally owned businesses. It brings money back to the community and keeps the flavors we've grown to love around for all to enjoy. Whether you're in need of Sunday dinner rolls or a sweet treat, this the bakery for you. read more

See all

A Youngstown family tradition for over 50 years! I was traveling to Youngstown for a graduation party and my best friend (who is from Youngstown) recommended that I couldn't go back home without stopping at Classic Bakery first! They offer a variety of delicious baked goods: bread, buns, rolls, pastries, cookies, cakes, donuts, muffins, and pies. All baked goods are made with the highest quality ingredients and skillfully baked. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and made my experience at Classic Bakery a pleasant one! Overall: A solid 5 stars! read more

See all

If you are going to a Bakery in the Boardman area this is the place. They have the best almond torte cake and their carrot cake is also delicious. Save room for some cookies too. They also have a great selection of baked bread and donuts. This is one of my favorite spots even just to stop in and grab a cookie for a sweet treat. If you jus want a bite of something and don't want to go overboard grab one of the smaller cakes they have on hand. read more

came here for the first time since it was Mr. Pauls waaay back when. Gosh the memories from the smell of the pastries to the set up and display cases. Everything we got was amazing including the yummy birthday cake. Keep up the good work Classic read more

See all

Outstanding quality and wide range of bakery items for every taste. Drove from Akron for the nearby butcher shop but the place I will absolutely drive an hour for is this bakery. Very old school vibe. read more

Absolutely love classic bakery my mom got me a banana chocolate cake and it was delicious couldnt stop eating it read more

Classic Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

I had the honor of visiting on Fathers Day which I thought was going to be the ultimate mistake...Although the bakery was pretty busy they were super responsive when we walked in. In fear of not surviving the mob we grabbed our goods and ran. Somehow we did not eat our goodies until two whole days later (who does that!)! Once they hit my mouth I went to a special place of Carbs! This place is AMAZING!!!! read more

A classic in the valley. Staff is very friendly. There are so many delicious options. I dont normally like cream filled pastries but their cream is not too sweet, and fluffy. Great donuts and cream horns! read more

Classic Bakery - donuts! half dozen and a free one on national donut day. - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

No matter what pastry or dessert you're looking for, you can't go wrong with Classic Bakery! Everything I have ever tried from Classic Bakery has been absolutely amazing! A few of my favorites are the iced sugar cookies, any of the decorated custom cakes, carrot cake slices, cupcakes, donuts (especially the maple cream sticks!), and the chocolate log cake. My family and I have been ordering cakes from here for years for various holidays and events and will continue to do so in the future. The store is clean, and service is friendly and quick, even when there's a line out the door sometimes on the weekends. Classic Bakery is one of the best bakeries around and you must try it when in the Youngstown area! read more

I visited Classic Bakery in person while I was in town for a relatives memorial service. I bought some Kolache, which was delicious and ordered some to take home. Everyone was courteous and helpful there compared to my previous experience. The Kolache was excellent both times I got it. Thank you! read more

Love this place. They have the best iced cut out cookies. And their cakes are really yummy too. I haven't tried any bread or pies there yet though but they always look good. Maybe next time. Only downside is when it's busy (like any time during the holidays) the wait can be awhile. They really should get one of those take a number things. People are always trying to cut in front of me in line. Plus then you could walk around and look to see what you want before it's your turn. It felt kinda cut-throat in there with the people in line. Haha read more

Classic Bakery - Holiday 2017 prices - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

The single star is only because the white almond cake here is actually quite good. We used to get one for all our family events & birthdays. However, I cannot & will not give my money to a place with such horrible customer service. I stopped by today on a whim. As soon as I walked in, an abrasive old woman asked what I wanted. I told her I was just looking, for the time being. A minute later, a different woman asked if I had been helped. The first woman answered FOR me, barking "She's just looking!" A few minutes later I decided what I wanted and placed my order with another employee. She went to assemble a box, and the first woman walks over to her and says "I ASKED her if she wanted anything when she walked in, and she said she was JUST LOOKING!" I had NO IDEA bakery etiquette dictates that you MUST know EXACTLY what you want the MOMENT you set foot in the door *eye roll*. I left without purchasing anything. After discussing this with local friends, they agree that it's pretty much standard M.O. for this place. Working in a service-based job for the past twelve years, this kind of thing does not fly with me. If you're in Boardman/Youngstown and you want baked goods but don't enjoy being treated like crap, skip this place and go down the street to Clarancedale Cake. Their stuff is always good, and the people behind the counter are ALWAYS friendly & pleasant. read more

We went here and got Easter bread and bear claws. Smelled delicious!! Beautiful pastries and cookies. read more

See all

First, this is not for the brick and mortar store, its for the cookies they sell through cookies of the month. I am glad I received the three month subscription as a Christmas gift. The thought is what counts even when the gift turns out bad. If I had paid for these cookies I would be furious. Second box came today. Like the first box, every cookie was broken, there are more crumbs than chunks. Sugar cookie is stale and tastes more like flour than butter-sugar. Peanut butter chocolate dipped cookie looked promising. I can't figure out the after taste, is it baking soda or hopelessness. Maybe the store has fresh, tasty cookies and cakes but this box is hitting the trash after four bites. read more

Classic Bakery - Cookie crumb of the month from classic bakery. - Bakeries Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Wife got me a coconut cream pie for birthday gift, since it is my favorite. Was not impress with it due to burnt shell and not much coconut. So now hurt feelings because told her not to purchase me any more from here. Rather drive to Middlefield, Ohio, an get one from Amish Bakery. Sorry just not impress. read more

I had an issue with the service and I called to speak with the owner. I have been waiting 3 days and the owner has not once tried to contact me. Apparantly quality customer service is a thing of the past. No worries, I will not be back and I will not recommend this establishment to anyone. read more

Every time I'm in town from Columbus, classic's is a must. My mother-in-law had my wedding cake made here and their chocolate is to die for. Sugar cookies, cupcakes and cake...uh it's all so amazing. read more

Love love love this bakery! Everyone is so nice and helpful! Favorite spot for donuts and sweets! However, if you want a loaf of italian bread this is also the place to grab one! Delicious! read more

We stopped in for a cake for a birthday and the ladies were all very helpful and took time to explain what each cake was. They even offered a sample tasting. I bought a Banana Split Cake. It was so good! It was full of fresh fruit, two layers of moist cake, and a delicious, light topping. It tasted as good as looked and we will be back! read more

Besides my bfs moms baking, this is one of very few places I actually enjoy buying from (bakery wise) Their cookies and other baked are so good!!!! I hope they always stay in business! read more

Omg! I love all the people that work here. Best tasting desserts in the world. For college graduation, I bought a large order from them and it was perfect and accurate the same people work there so they know exactly what they are doing. Easy to get in and out. read more

I called to order Kolache to get sent to Houston where I now live where my mom lives with me who is ill. My Mom used to make kolache at xmas but is too sick to do that so I wanted to get some for us as a family tradition. Someone named, I believe, Sherry was so rude to me yelling when I asked her a question. She said I couldn't get any. I asked of other places/grocery stores in the area that make them. She said she doesn't know any stores in the area because she lives 20 minutes away!!! She was unbelieveably rude and not helpful. There are no places in Houston that sell Kolache. Wish the owner would realize how she treats customers. Of course, I never got Kolache and never got a return phone call from the owner after leaving my phone number with "Sherry". read more

Agreeing with the 1 star review that many people will come up and ask what you want constantly. They were all polite though. I got a dozen of the cookies to try out and made sure each was a different kind so I could get a good sampling of what they offered. All were quite delicious and fun tasting! I also got a muffin that was to die for and tasted my friend's cannoli. I am so addicted to cannolis and theirs had a great and unique taste. Next to try? The breads and bagels for my carb kick! read more

I have ordered cakes from Classic Bakery for many years. They did a fine job on my wedding cake almost 20 years ago, and I've continued to support them over the years. The almond torte cake or peach chiffon cakes are our family's favorites. It's true that this place is pretty traditional and predictable in its offerings, which might turn off the foodies, but bear in mind that the prices here are much more reasonable than the fancier competition. Sure, the ladies can sometimes be grumpy or short with you, but who cares? Wouldn't you be cranky if you had to deal with slow choosers and were on your feet all day? Seriously, the workers have always treated me with respect, which is all I ask. I don't usually look for BFFs at the cookie counter. read more