Short review: Would go back for the mole, dessert, and cocktails
I was here with one other perhaps a month ago. The place has a nice atmosphere and the service was friendly and the portions were substantial enough for the high prices (72$ for 4 courses.) I would say that some of the courses were definitely worth it for the high price while others were just alright and the drinks were excellent. To drink, I got the the Claro/Oscuro and we both got an agua fresca and I got one of their cocktails.
Claro/Oscuro Milk Punch: Clarified - Don Fulano Tequila Reposado, Mal Bien Mezcal, Amontillado Sherry, Cocchi Americano, Demerara, Lemon, Charred Habanero Oil (16$)
This was a tasty unique cocktail. A bit of smoke from the mezcal along with good tequila with the habanero oil and lemon adding some extra flavor. Would recommend.
Agua frescas: Sesame Matcha Horchata and Pear Poleo (7$ each)
The sesame matcha horchata was more black sesame focused and it was a wonderful take on the usual horchata. Perhaps a bit sweet but horchatas tend to pretty sweet in general. Apparently poleo is a Spanish term for a type of pennywort which is an herb similar to mint and it was sweet and refreshing.
For the food below, I'm listing my chosen course and then theirs.
1st course:
Aguachile: Montauk scallop, satsuma mandarin, blood orange, charred habanero oil, spicy peanut oil. She also said it was going to be fluke along with scallop which I was fine with.
The server warned me that this was going to be very spicy and her warnings were quite warranted. This was probably one of the single spiciest dishes I've had (with the last food this hot probably being in Thailand) but I found the flavors to be excellent. It was served with some totopos (baked corn tortilla) which were crunchy and tasty. Overall I would recommended it though only for spice heads.
Tostada de Remolacha: Beets, guacamole, queso fresco
I tried a tiny bit of this. This was also very tasty and there was a good portion. She enjoyed this.
2nd course:
Memela de Costilla: Heritage pork rib, chile de arbol, queso fresco
This was probably the only disappointing course of what I ordered. The memela was fine but I found the pork rib to not be as flavorful as I expected (even with the chile de arbol) and there wasn't enough queso fresco to drown out some of the meat. This course was just alright and I should probably have done with something else (maybe the venison.) Overall I would pass.
Memela de Maria Sabina- Wild mushrooms, goat cheese crema, pasilla
I tried a tiny bit and this was a lot better. Same memela of course but the mushrooms had a wonderful flavor from the goat cheese and the pasilla pepper. I would recommend this more over the pork and I'm surprised to say that.
3rd course:
Mole Negro: Pekin duck, spring onion, potato
This was absolutely fantastic. The mole negro is of course the highlight being an outstanding version of this very rare type of mole. You just don't find it in many places made this perfectly as it takes hours to prepare even with taking shortcuts and they do a great job here. I loved the texture of the duck having a nice crispy outer shell and a wonderful tender inside. The spring onion and potato worked well to sop up the sauce and if I was any more hungry, I would have probably asked for some tortilla for the sauce (I still had the majority of it with a spoon/ the other person have a good amount with their dish.)
Enmoladas de Calabaza: Spaghetti squash, sheep's milk cheese, toasted pepita crumble.
By comparison to my dish, this was a whole lot worse and easily the weakest dish of the night. As with the name enomoladas, these were enchiladas topped with mole sauce (in this case rojo/red.) The red mole by comparison was just not as well flavored though the cheese and pepitas added some nice textures. Our biggest issue with the dish was the calabaza or spaghetti squash. It was shredded somewhere to a pasta and it was very bland with her having to add my mole to have any semblance of flavor. I think a different vegetable would just work better.
Dessert:
Churros: Cajeta
These were fantastic churros. No real complaints outside of maybe serving the cajeta in a bigger container so it doesn't leak as easily.
Arroz con Leche: rice pudding, kumquats, whipped cream
This was a much lighter dessert. The rice pudding was fine and the fruit was different than listed online (being kumquats) which was actually a preference. Maybe a little bit too much whipped cream but overall quite tasty but definitely worse than the churros.
Overall the food was very good outside of two rather disappointing courses (that being my second and especially her main.) I would normally not reduce a star for two dishes but it's harder to not be picky when the food is this expensive. In terms of a Mexican tasting menu, I think Xixa is a better deal but the mole (very specifically the mole negro) is so good here that I will probably go back and sit at the bar read more