Pizza by the slice, and they're huge!!! Went to city slice on a Friday evening to check it out! Staff were very friendly and they had cheese, pepperoni and veggies for options. We ordered 2 pepperoni sliced to go. The slice are huge, very New York style and was delicious! I'll definitely be coming back! read more

See all

Giant sliced, $5 each. They were really good, we got a white, cheese, and pep. Great crunch on each bite. The crust is chewy. And they warm it before. The sauce didn't stand out. Parking is street parking heads up! read more

City Slice - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

City Slice slaps. They are always busy, and for good reason: the pizza is excellent and a great value. The interior is a classic slice shop, with the addition of another room dedicated to arcade games. If you order slices they have at the ready you should be eating in about 10 minutes or less. Most times I go, I really only need one because the slices are the size of your head. The pizza is go good though that even though I only technically NEED one slice, I get two, or I convince my husband to split an extra. Recently, I got an order of garlic knots as well - they were great: soft and pillowy and slathered in garlic. My fair word of warning is that you need to order ahead if you want anything more than a pre-prepared slice. read more

This place is great! The slice is huge, lots of variety of types of slices, salad, drink, cookie for $12 and couldn't finish it all. Cookies for later. We got a margarita slice and a meat lovers slice. Salad, drink, and cookie. Very good. The slice is thin, I like thin. And lots of toppings. Salad decent. I'll have to let you know on the cookie. It looks good. Place is fun. Ice cream parlor and little arcade. Can fit about 25 people. Prices good. Ice cream was closed but the flavors seemed fun and prices were good as well. Oh and staff is super nice and helpful! I'm going to go back! Love it! read more

City Slice - Margarita and meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

I took a small group with me to try this place out. The prices are reasonable, the pizza is really good (New York style and we also ordered the Mega which was huge!), the staff is all super friendly, and it has a small amount of arcade games to keep you busy while you wait for your food. The parking is all free street parking but we went on a Saturday and we're able to find a spot. We had a party of 6 and took up a good section of the seating but we didn't feel cramped or anything. Great place and I would definitely go back again if in the area. read more

City Slice - Eating mega slice! - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

I don't think I will be back because the pizza was too greasy for me. The staff was very nice and the Restaurant is nice but I think I will pass. I have severe heartburn and my boys feel the same way and I only ate a few bites. read more

Not bad a pizza just not great.... Mediocre taste with a large slice portion as a gimmick...

The staff is super friendly and professional! The slices are huge and tasty. The desserts were also huge! I had the ice cream cookie sandwich and couldn't finish it. My nieces and nephews loved the attached game room. Fun environment. read more

See all

Really good New York style thin crust pizza very large portions. I've eaten here twice and really enjoy it. I tried the garlic knots for the first time and I must say they're pretty huge. Also eat them while they're hot. They're much better hot than they are cold. read more

See all

It's the Free Palestine and the 1 slice that feeds 3 for me. Great pizza,nice people & loyal to the community of Cleveland. Local shop w/old school Boogie down Bronx vibes. W/ice cream and a mini arcade. Another favorite. read more

See all

Just tried my first City Slice on recommendation from my neighborhood FB group. Does. Not. Disappoint. You really don't get a feel for how huge the pies and slices are until you're in person. I got 1 slice of pepperoni and it was excellent. Thin but sturdy crust, excellent ratio of cheese to sauce, lots of pep. A little greasy, like it should be. I can't wait to try the cherry pepper pie and an antipasto salad. I was delighted at the decor too. Nice and clean- bright and welcoming. I love the artwork. The ice cream parlor/ arcade/ dining room has ample space and looks like a great place to dine. Service was quick and friendly. City Slice is here to stay. read more

City Slice - HUUUUUGE pies - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

You won't find a better deal on a filling meal than City Slice. A cheese slice bigger (way bigger) than your head currently costs a mere $5. Pepperoni or pepperoni & sausage cost just a bit more. And it's really good pizza! Good crust, good sauce, good cheese, good meat. Good, good, good! Don't expect to be in an out in a minute here, even if you order a slice, because they reheat the slice to roof-of-the-mouth-burning perfection. So don't grab your reheated slice and take a huge bite. Wait a minute and then stuff your face. Our party of five ate in and two of us enjoyed the arcade games. There is an attached ice cream place that appeared not to be open - but we were too full for ice cream so I'm not positive. I had never heard of Malta Goya (a type of pop), so of course I had to try it. It was interesting - tasted like slightly fizzy molasses water. I didn't love it at first, but it grew on me to the point where I'll order it again when we go back. I read that City Slice is thinking of opening a second location in Old Brooklyn, and I hope that's true, because that's where we're located. In the meantime, a 15 minute drive is totally worth it. read more

City Slice - Our family time playing video games while we waited for our slices to be heated. - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

I'm a big fan of a New York style slice of pie, and for us this spot delivered. Came in on a recent weekend afternoon for a quick bite in between shopping trip stops. The crew behind the counter was hard at work making both full pies and slinging individual slices as well. My wife and I ordered two slices...one plain (gotta try the "real deal" to see how legit they are) and a sausage. Pricing is extremely reasonable and the slices are the size of, well, just look at the pictures! They throw our two gargantuan slices in the pizza oven (a pretty standard practice) to heat and crisp them up. As expected, total roof-of-mouth meltage on that first bite. Yowsers! As for the taste...pretty spot on I'd say. Crust was easily foldable, sauce slightly tangy and sweet and that ooey-gooey cheese you'd expect. We're fans and we'll definitely be back. Hauling in one of their jumbo pies to a party would surely be a hit as well...will be doing that sometime in the near future. Keep up the good work, team! read more

See all

Do you like LARGE slices of fresh pie ? How about delicious Submarine sandwiches? Sweet, fast & friendly service ? Can you believe they also serve ice-cream & shakes ..? AND they have a PINBALL arcade ! I can't believe i just discovered this place, it's awesome! Reminds me of old school local pizzeria ( because it IS !! ) ... great ambiance ( i know, they do a lot of take-out orders, but you deserve to come in, sit down & just enjoy this clean, but classic shop, filled with great smells of baking dough & sauce) I recommend this place, of course read more

City Slice - Pepperoni Slice & veggie slice , with lime soda ! - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Gigantic NY style think and crispy slice! Stopped by for lunch. Wasn't too crowded but plenty of seats/tables to have a quick slice and go. Pizza slice was gigantic and thin/crsipy. Will be back when in the area for sure! read more

See all

As someone who loves NY style pizza, Lemme tell you this is the place to come for it. I had a regular cheese slice and the sauce to cheese ratio was on point. The crust had a nothing less than perfect texture to it. And they have beef pepperoni for those who do not eat pork. The staff is always friendly and respectful when I come here and to patronize. They also have ice cream, and video games in addition to the phenomenal pizza A trifecta if you will. read more

Best pizza in town...nice newyork style crust...chewing and crispy and and great price. Can't go wrong. Highly recommended!!!

For the last two years, I have been searching for the best pizza in Cleveland. Well, if you agree that the best slice is NYC style, City Slice has got you covered. We grabbed a pepperoni and plain cheese slice. They're massive portions and on the cheesier side. Crust holds up well. We also ordered the garlic knots, but I suggest passing on those. The texture was off and there wasn't enough garlic. Nice space to hang out. Plenty of seating with an arcade/ice cream shop extension. read more

See all

This is a new place I heard about from coworkers. Apparently it opened in February 2022, so it's brand new. They advertise New York Style. Usually I get disappointed because it's rarely truly authentic. This was a great surprise! Very authentic, and the prices are great. Two mega slices (a 30-inch pie!) and two drinks cost a total of $10.50! It's a small space now but I heard the owner explaining to another customer that they are knocking out a wall and expanding, plus they have a patio going in, so should be quite nice! This place is now on my once-a-week lunch route! read more

City Slice - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

The pizza was top notch. It's a 10 out of 10 for me. Watch out Royals pizza finally some competition on St.Clair

Friendly staff and service was awesome during the lunch rush today. I'm not a huge fan of reheated slices and my timing was a bit off to have a slice fresh from the oven. Will have to stop in again. read more

City Slice - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Got a half veggie/half cheese pizza from here today. They were efficient and cheerful. Clean restaurant, DELICIOUS NY style pie. Crispy crust! Perfect sauce! The only way to improve this place would be to have business hours after the bars close. It could fill in where Steve's Lunch left off. Would be great to get a mega slice of pepperoni after a rager! read more

Horrible pizza and the staff is rude Andy husband found a fake eye lash in his pizza. Gross

The huge slice I had was soooo good, also make sure you try some of the dipping sauces. I think it was a honey jalapeno sauce, it was delicious. Also the new arcade game area is such a cool add on for the family! read more

Since moving from NJ to OH, we've been looking for a pizzeria that has NJ/NY style pies. City Slice comes pretty darn close to what we would find back home. Friendly atmosphere, funny staff, and delicious slices. read more

City Slice - The day's special, a veggie slice. - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Love the mega pizza slice! And you can order a whole pizza! Tough to fit in a car though read more

City Slice - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Read about this place on a blog post calling it authentic New York style pizza, and I'll admit I was a bit skeptical as other places have claimed the same and been far off, since true NY style pizza is so hard to duplicate. City Slice, however, has mastered it. First off, the value is incredible, as the slices are enormous and cut from a 40" pie, and a one topping slice is only $5.50. And, despite the size, the structural integrity of the crust remains intact: almost no flop. The crust itself, is perfectly crisp, and just the right thickness to hold the toppings. The sauce has a lot of flavor, and tastes homemade, yet City Slice does not go overboard with it, uses just the right amount. Also, met the owner while enjoying my slice, very nice guy. Will definitely be returning!! read more

City Slice - Giant pepperoni pie, used for jumbo slices - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Bomb. Everytime it's been great, the staff is always hospitable. Very cool place with an arcade right next door. Highly recommended

They throw it down just like how New York does! This place deserves its flowers. Best pizza and cheesecake ever I never had a place come close to New York style then City Slice!!!! Shout out to the workers there top tier service and food! read more

Giant New York style pizza slices FTW! They only have two sizes if you order a full pie... Large and mega and the large is pretty big!

Pizza was underdone. I'm from NY. That was a long way from NY style. Crust was close. Undercarriage underdone.

Very hard to see from Lorain, No parking, and worst of all, the pizza. Now I am a heavy critic when it comes to the perfect pizza slice, and after numerous people informed me of the opening I said AWESOME some NYC style pizza finallllly!...boy was I wrong. For one it's a pizzeria; there should be two tables max, there's clutter it's crowded and during a pandemic there was no sense of COVID protocol or mask requirements. I guess their edge is super jumbo pizza? But let's be honest in a more health conscious America do we really need that? $4 a slice was actually a steal so I'll give them a star for pricing. They didn't have garlic knots ready, so if I want a slice and knots I have to wait? It's not a grab and go type of place. They take your order and instead of just throwing your slice in the oven they make you wait and so it by like ticket which to me was weird but ok.... It's super crowded in the kitchen area, definitely an accident waiting to happen. They have plain. Aside from my rant about what they can improve on what you really care about is the slice right? Ok. To the pizza. It was HUGE( we established this), it was not even warm they put it in the oven for all of 2 minutes and throw it in a bag. Grease everywhere my cheese wasn't melted and I didn't get the good old fashioned top of my roof burn I had come to crave when eating my pizza. The sauce was bland, and it wasn't fully cooked. Because my cheese wasn't melted it literally came apart from the slice leaving me with a mess, an attitude and a bad taste in my mouth. The crust had no crunch and no flavor. All jokes aside it was probably one of the worst slices I've had in Cleveland... their approach was so genuine and I'm so upset the ball was dropped but then again maybe being a native NYer and a world class pizza eater I set my bar too high...if you smoke a blizzy or come late from the club the slice MIGHT do the trick but I certainly won't be waiting on a long non socially compliant line for subpar pizza again... read more

See all

For me, the biggest draw is that the slice is huge. The end. It was t an amazing piece of pizza, Don't get me wrong, it wasn't bad either. I just didn't find anything amazing about it. read more

I love how large the slices are you'll definitely be getting your money worth it was a 10 out of ten

Another hidden gem, pizza is huge and they have an arcade on the other side of the room definitely fun vibes! Pizza is made in front of you and reminds me of New York and the pizza is crunchy ! read more

I ordered a chicken Parmesan sandwich today, not good. I also ordered pizza, also couldn't eat any because pepperoni was placed in same box as cheese and grease from pepperoni dripped and soaked through the papers that were used to separate them contaminating all of the pizza. I eat no beef or pork. As for the multi-color chicken, nobody should eat this. read more

City Slice - Multi color chicken Parmesan sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

I'm sad to say that I can't recommend this place. I stopped in on a weekday afternoon to buy a few individual slices for coworkers. It's expensive per slice (like $7 out the door with a tip for a large, thin slice). Although the pizza seems to be of good quality, it was not prepared with any attention to detail. One slice was about half dough with no sauce or toppings. On another slice the dough had such large bubbles that a significant portion of the crust was nothing but a burnt shell. There seemed to be a lack of quality control or just indifference to the product. I randomly decided to try them again on a weeknight... only to find the place inexplicably closed at 7pm. Did they already go out of business? Nothing can kill a business quite like not adhering to posted hours. It's really too bad because the people there seemed awesome and were very friendly and outgoing. read more

Very good pizza place! Just like NYC!!!!5***** ****************************************************************** read more

A large, exceptional slice can be had here. This is a very good pizzeria, especially for Cleveland. I'm very happy to have this place within walking distance of my home. read more

City Slice - One large slice of pepperoni pizza. Can for scale. - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Best pizza great people you won't be disappointed best ny style pizza won't be disappointed