We have had this pizza place on our list to try for some time, and we were very impressed with our experience. Upon arrival, we were greeted by a very friendly gentleman who was incredibly kind. He took the time to explain the menu and the specific process behind how your pizzas are prepared. Based on his recommendations, we decided on the Fancy Pep pizza. The quality was outstanding. The toppings were generous, and the combination of pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey was truly fabulous. We also appreciated that the honey was served on the side for drizzling. We thoroughly enjoyed the meal and the excellent service. Since there are many other varieties we would like to try, we will definitely be returning soon. Thank you for a great experience. read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

Amazing pizza! I really love that you need to order the phone or in person. The reassurance that my order will be right is great. I ordered a vegan biodome pizza with vegan sausage added to it. The toppings are LOADED!! The crust is sturdy and has a crispy bottom. The sauce is sweet in a very traditional Cleveland style. The vegan cheese was good. Everything about this pizza was 10/10. I'll be back next time i'm in town. read more

See all

Delicious pies!! Excellent crust and sauce. So good every time. never disappointed service is great too read more

Taco pizza was burnt they cant do nothing about it second time there and my last $16 and ate less then half and tasted burnt but never said nothing till got home wifey was pissed so they can't do nothing so dont go to Ohio pie there not doing good business iam new and lost me and people I no like cook the fucking pizza right the first time fuckimg dumb asses just talk all day then burn my pizza fuck them read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Burnt pizza second time there and said fuck me never go back for $16 is high way robbery - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

Finally made it to The Ohio Pie Co and it did not disappoint! The staff are super friendly and helpful, the arcade games are free, and it's a great chill vibe with picnic style tables, paper towels, etc. And the food was great. We had the special which was a vodka sauce with sausage, pepperoni, and ricotta, the sausage and pepper, the BBQ chicken and the veggie. All fabulous! And the hot honey made it even better. Then the cookies were out of this world with all kinds of crazy flavors like pineapple upside down cake, cookie monster, etc. We tried the mint oreo, cookie dough M&M, chocolate chip and dark chocolate expresso and all were delicious. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Best pizza , service great,eat in or take out Very friendly place. The heart of it all deluxe is wonderful!!!! read more

The pizza is fantastic!! Service is great and shop is always clean and welcoming. Would definitely suggest others to try.

Outstanding service, High quality food. Highly recommend this place. The Pies are awesome and the cookies are right there with them!!!

Glad I tried pizza from here while in town. A little thicker than I thought it'd be, almost like grandma pie or Sicilian. Opted for pepperoni and mushroom when I was told their sausage is in sliced form and crumbles. read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

See all

Never had had a bad pizza from here to this point. Please make the Rueben pizza a staple!!

Awesome pizza with it's own unique flare plus a chill eatin enviroment including picnic tables, retro game room and lathe number of cookie flavors to top of meal. read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Nick's Pick with hot honey and ricotta cheese was perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

See all

Excellent pizza! The crust is amazing. Prices are reasonable as well. We need to try other menu items next visit!

I've been vegan for 20 years. I love pizza. But I gave up trying to find anything that even remotely resembles a real pizza. Frozen pizzas of all brands are mostly horrible. Most vegan cheese has more in common with snot than actual mozzarella. And then I drove nine hours from South Carolina to Parma and tried the Ohio Pie Company. I read the reviews and didn't get fancy. Just pepperoni and cheese. Oh my! While it didn't quite reach my pre-vegan favorite pizza (that would be Masseys, also in Ohio), but nonetheless it gave me hope. Crust, sauce, and pepperoni were terrific. Cheese, as close as I've found. No more snot! We also got two no - vegan pies (pepperoni, and bbq chicken) for the family and my in-laws were very pleased. I'll definitely be back. Oh, and try a cookie too. read more

I absolutely loved this place. If it were closer to where I live I'd get their pizza every time! There's no delivery so you can call, come in and order and eat there as well. The place itself is very eclectic, very cool atmosphere. They have old time arcade games you can play for free, so if you come in and place an order you can sit and enjoy a game or two. Cannot wait to go back and try the other types of pizza! read more

Ohio Pie Co. - We got the Burly Boy.Packed with all the meats, literally the whole pizza covered,perfectly great! - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

See all

Ordered for pick up. Pizza was very tasty. I enjoyed the sauce and they had a good amount of toppings. The guy behind the counter seemed friendly. When I got there, no one else was around but the parking lot had been filled. I love that they are open past 10 pm, and probably why not busy . If going here, make sure to get donuts next door too. read more

See all

Great food, great service! Would recommend if you haven't tried it yet! My fav is always the pickle pizza

I consider myself a pizza connoisseur. I can eat pizza every day. This was a recommendation. And it was a great one! I have now eaten here about 10 times. It is super good. This pizza is unique and delicious! You can't go wrong! Toppings are edge to edge and they don't skimp. No matter your taste in toppings know you will get lots in a bite. You can eat in. There are picnic tables to gather. It's not big but enough for some families. With the graffiti on the wall it's got a rock n roll feel. Service is friendly. You order at the counter and wait for your pizza. All the pizzas are good. Even the thanksgiving pizza. It's weird but it's delicious. Very heavy. Can't go wrong with any option. I've had the salad too. Decent. Good to share. I've also had the cookies. Good. But I thought too expensive for what you get. This place is now in regular pizza rotation. Try it and you will be sold. It's really good! read more

Stopped here for a Pizza at dinner time. Very good crowd for just a Tuesday afternoon. Ordered the medium sized plain cheese with 1/2 pepperoni. Requested that they pie cut my pizza instead of squares. I was told "no way". The pizza lacked a lot of flavor and was not as good as a lot of other local pizza shops. When it comes to Ohio, there is a pizza shop on every corner. Not sure why this place has such a high rating. read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

See all

Great friendly service and fabulous pizza. Got the mushroom and one heartburner. Excellent everything from brown bottom- not killed. Sauce was perfect. Toppings all excellent. All 4 of said we would go back! read more

It was very good pizza, cool vibe. Video games were on point. Could use some tv's for Sunday football and beer sales on Sundays.. We will come back, the pizza and cookies were good. read more

I absolutely love this pizza. The employees are always so friendly. The place is decorated so cool and the little arcade in the back is fun too. The pizza is so tasty! I've taken so many people to check this place out and everyone has loved it as much as I do. It's something to look forward to while I'm visiting Cleveland Clinic :) read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Eating our favorite pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

My daughter took me here. I ordered a large burly . I believe that was the name. I was not disappointed. I have to say this was up there with the best pie I've ever ran my cookie duster across. And let's talk about cookies!!!! My god they also have top tier cookies. Being a fat guy I'm a cookie connoisseur. You must carry your a$$ over there and give this a try. You will thank me later. The place was clean. Great atmosphere. Friendly staff. Thanks guys!! read more

Firstly, the pie was pretty good... the sauce was delicious but it was very scarce on the pizza... Needed more! Toppings and the crust were great!! I called in advance to ensure they had a dining room.... It's not quite ready for prime time, as it's very basic. Picnic tables, paper plates, canned soft drinks with no ice available; Headbanger music was blaring the entire time we were there; very bright lighting. The vibe is not for a relaxing meal, that's for sure. Get it to go! read more

Very good pizza and some of it can be a little spice I don't know what else to say customers was very nice

We tried Ohio Pie for the first time and ordered two small pizzas -- the Sausage & Peppers and the Basic B -- and I have to say, the flavors were absolutely fantastic. The ingredients tasted fresh, the seasoning was on point, and the combinations were well-balanced and thoughtful. You can tell there's real care going into the recipes. That said, my only gripe was the texture on pickup. Both pizzas were a bit soggy, and the crust didn't hold up when you picked up a slice -- it flopped right over. It could be from steaming in the box, but I was definitely craving that crisp, structured bite. Next time, if we go the takeout route again, I'd plan to crisp them up in the oven at home for a few minutes. Would I order again? Absolutely -- the flavor alone makes it worth it. Just be ready to tweak the texture a bit if you're not dining in. read more

Pizza is good as always! But today I want to compliment the unique flavors of cookies! The flavors in Brunswick seem to be better. read more

See all

Love this pizza! I highly recommend the fancy pep and a pickle pizza(not on the menu, but available)! If we're in the general area- these are on the menu. read more

Excellent and great tasting pizza. I had the all meat and was tasty, while my sister had pineapple. Weird Ohio law - no beer sales on Sunday - but that is on the state and not Ohio Pie. read more

They were amazing with my daughter's food allergies, and my picky toddler loveddd the white pizza (party bread). Their vegan pizza is some of the best I've ever tried and we have tried a lot with a dairy allergy. They even had vegan cookies that were safe for her. So appreciate them. Family with us that got regular pizza said it was great too. read more

Great experience! I ordered 4 pies and just before I left the guy behind the counter said it looked like I had a lot of mouths to feed and gave me a free cheese pizza that someone didn't pick up. Much appreciated! The family said I had to try the pickle pizza, I didn't see it on the menu but make sure you ask for it!! It has pickle slices and ruffled potato chips, cheese and a white sauce. It was so so good! We also tried 3 others, all delicious! They have a whole case of cookies, and numerous flavors are vegan. They have a large space to be able to eat in too. read more

The pizza is always delicious! We love the Burly Boy and Piggy Bird! The cheesy Party Bread is fantastic!

Well worth an hour drive, Good the last crust!!!!Pepperoni and The Heart of it All, Deluxe read more

Ohio Pie Co. - Good to the last crust...well worth the hour drive - Pizza Near Me - Brunswick, Ohio

Used to think this place was a 5 star. It's lost its luster with us unfortunately. Had a few bad experiences since going often (weekly to every other week). Once the pizza we brought home was just burned. Called them and they offered to replace it because it was hard to eat with the burned flavor. Drove back to the place and you'd think they'd make sure the replacement wasn't burned. Nope. Burned also...and we have eaten here a lot and know what is normal. Also, some of the people working here act like they are doing you a favor by being open or something. The owner is cool and he does cool stuff for his staff...but some of them just act like you are just another number. They ask you if you want cookies or whatever and sit there glaring at you like you know what's in the case and can decide in 5 seconds. Also bought two of the Thanksgiving pizzas last year two different times. Paid $20 for a medium...wanted an extra cranberry sauce because the dang thing is so savory and it should have more cranberry with it...and the dude looked as if he couldn't care less and just said...that'll be $1. For a little tiny plastic cup with cranberry sauce! Pissed me off pretty good. It is not our favorite place to go anymore. Haven't been back in about 5 or 6 months. The punk music adds to the not wanting to go. It's dreadful. When the owner was running the ship it was worth sitting in the loud obnoxious room with the crap music for the pizza. Things have changed. read more

Excellent pie - great service. Solid NEO pizza choice. To get to five: get thin crust option. read more

EAT HERE! They deep dish is unmatched and the toppings are very tasteful and plentiful. The service is quick and quality, and the vibe is what you would want from a pizza place. Beautiful cookies. read more

We stopped on a whim and decided to dine in. The staff was friendly and the dining area was clean. The prices are about average for a decent pizza place. Our pizza was ready faster than they told us it would be which was great. What we loved: the crust was crunchy and the pizza had a lot of toppings on it and the flavor was good. What we didn't love: the pizza is not cut like a traditional pizza it's cut like a sheet pizza would be cut and therefore the pieces in the center have no crust to be picked up by and will either be super messy to eat or require a fork and knife. Also, the sauce was only in the middle of the pizza, outside slices (like 2 to 3 inches away from the crust) had zero sauce and were just cheese on bread which I did not like. Overall, not a bad place and glad we tried it but not likely going to sway us from our regular pizza place. I still gave Ohio Pie 4 stars because of the flavor, staff and facility. read more

Friday lunch date for two Family friendly seating, punk rock music playing, 4 arcade games, cooler full of drinks (non-alcoholic and domestic alcoholic), DELICIOUS pizza! Had no plans for dessert but the cookie case was irresistible. The chocolate chip and lemon raspberry white chocolate were worth the $5. Friendly staff was the cherry on top. Definitely will be back and with with friends! read more

See all

If you're looking for some rich, generously-portioned comfort food then look no further than the Ohio Pie Co! This place serves up hot, tasty pizza pies topped with heaps of quality toppings. The cookies are a wonderful mix of crunchy edge and soft center - not to be missed. The staff were friendly and service was pretty quick. I believe this place is take-out only, just so you know. read more

Whoaaaa This was worth the wait. The pickle pizza was so delicious.. it was just the right amount of pickle and crunch.... and the cream cheese like sauce was amazing. We love hawiian pizza, this one didn't disappoint. They were incredibly efficient and friendly at pick up.... and the cookies were so good... I only was able to snap a pic of the last bite before everyone devoured them up. Don't skip on getting the cookies... they are hands down some of the best ever. We can't wait to go back and try more pies! read more

See all

Really really good vegan pizza. Crust is great, vegan cheese good, lots of faux meat options . Love that they have a whole list of vegan specialty pizzas. They have several vegan cookie options too. The ambiance has a very cool vibe, free video games are a fun touch. I like that all the utensil, plates, napkins, water etc are out for you to grab as you need. Service is fast and the pizza is directly from to the oven so super hot. Love it read more