Order Pizza 216 Takeout or Delivery
Pizza 216 Photos
Pizza 216 Popular Dishes
PIZZA 216 ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Pizza 216
Recommended Reviews - Pizza 216
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
My go to for takeout pizza. Consistently good every time. Nice amount of sauce, ingredients, and a nice crust. Set up with a bar and high tops. I really like it.
I was recommended Pizza 216 by my mom and brother. I was headed to the Jonas Brothers concert at Rocket just a couple streets over. We were greeted by the hostess upon entry. I asked if there was a separate gluten free menu or if it was on the menu itself, and it is on the menu as is. We were sat very promptly and our waiter came by a couple minutes later. Carlos was his name. Very attentive and quick to get our drink and food orders in quick. The restaurant/bar was pretty full with sports on all of the TVs with music playing. The food came out fairly quickly. I got to eating very fast so we could get to the concert quickly. The food was very warm; the GF crust was thin and held together very well. I had red sauce, sausage and pepperoni. The size of the pizza wasn't too overwhelming, I was able to eat the entire pizza and toppings. Such a fun place. Brick oven pizza. Very fun atmosphere!! Well done 216!!
Called and placed an order for pick up with Kaya. We ordered a large Magherita pizza and confirmed it had 8 slices. My fiance picked up the order and came back with a very thin pizza. The crust was normal size but the area of toppings was as thin as a piece of paper no theatrics needed. I called to see if this was a mistake and the lady on the phone confirmed that she saw my order and that our order as described is their "New York style". From the photos on Yelp, this does not look like the norm. We paid full price for an extremely thin layered pizza. Unacceptable!
After flying all day, having a flight be delayed and dealing with airport food, this was the place to look forward to. The location of this hotspot is absolutely perfect inside the most beautiful Hyatt I've ever seen. Not only does Cleveland rock but Cleveland is beautiful and this pizza place should represent Cleveland because it's the best. The airplane food made my stomach a bit queasy so had to opt for Kevin McAllister's ultimate favorite: cheese pizza just for me. Wow, instant happiness. Since I have to come into town for work, this is the place that I will be going to reward myself after long arduous days.
Came here after a long day at a conference. Located in the arcade which houses the Hyatt, it's quite a charming, in the know location. Had great company of course, and this was the perfect place for a large group to chitchat post conference. The place was accommodating, allowing us to move a table to fit everyone. Our waitress was fabulous. Most people ordered a personal pizza and seem to really enjoy it. I ordered the buffalo salad and it was huge. Very tasty. We'll have to remember it next time I come into town.
UPDATED REVIEW: I returned back to Pizza 216 in early October 2024 and also in mid-October 2024. I'll definitely be back in 2025 to support this local pizza business. I sat outside on October 11, 2024 with a friend in the early evening. It was a warm weather day so I definitely recommend sitting outside when you visit if the weather is nice. ($12.50) MARGHERITA PIZZA (small). 5/5 STARS -- I got it without the red sauce (it comes with an olive oil base already). The menu describes it as "Original red sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and pecorino romano." -- this pizza was very good and especially loved that it is a light pizza with no meat on it - 11 Oct. 2024 ($12.75) SPICY PIE PIZZA (small) - (4/5 STARS) -- I used a $10 off coupon that I was given from a previous visit. I ordered the Spicy Pie pizza to go. The menu describes it as "Local sausage, cheese blend, spicy red, mushrooms, and pepperoncinis." This one was good but not as good, in my opinion, as the margherita pizza which tasted fresher. Still though, I liked the sausage and mushrooms in the spicy pie pizza but I wished it had more flavour because it wasn't spicy at all - 26 Oct. 2024 TIP: Next time I dine-in, I hope to bring a cash tip for the servers because per a Yelp review that I read below, the owner keeps all tips when customers tip using their debit/credit card which is unfortunate, if true.
We ended up coming here twice. The pizza is good but the restaurant needs some work. We came Sunday evening after the baseball, but they were only serving pizza, we tried to order a salad too and couldn't - was kinda weird. The restaurant needed a good sweep, food all over the floor! We noticed a huge nasty liquid dripping on our booth too and moved because of it - they never cleaned it off and when we came back the next day it was still there! Our draft beer looked very flat. Server started her closing duties and was very difficult to get to pay our tab. Came the next day for Happy Hour, sat at the bar, went with bottled beer this time. Pizza was again good but the rest of the place needs work. The pierogi pizza needed some crunch like bacon.
Was very cold and New Year's Eve. Snowing hard and icy out. Came in and thought it was the weekend. It was happy hour got 2 pizzas for $5 each and was a decent size. Got 1 for myself and 1 for my friend. Was so good on a cold day and came out quick. Wood fired pizza and perfect crispy crust. Perfect size for 1 adult. Food was not good at the party we went to later that night so this was perfect to steady our hunger. Server was polite and patient. Really like this place and it is located in the arcade.
I'm a pizza lover, but unfortunately it wasn't worth the hype. The Spicy pizza had great sausage but the banana peppers overpower it and only offer the one dimension of spicy. The Buffalo pizza was limited on topping and overloaded on crust. I get that it's woodfire pizza but I just didn't see the 5 star reviews on every platform. Good barfood pizza if you've had a few but not worth the trip if you're a foody.
Pizza 216 absolutely delivered. We ordered our sausage and pepperoni pizza well done, and it was perfection from the first bite. The pepperoni had that perfect crisp, the sausage was rich and flavorful, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio was spot on. The dough truly stole the show it was airy on the inside, beautifully chewy, and finished with just the right amount of char. Getting it well done took it to another level. What really stood out was that there was zero sloppiness to the pizza. Each slice held up perfectly, wasn't greasy at all, and never felt heavy.That said, the char was so good we definitely left with a few char marks on our mouths after eating... and honestly? It was worth every bite. The garlic knots were just as impressive. Soft, warm, and loaded with garlicky flavor, they were buttery without being oily and paired perfectly with the marinara. The service was great friendly, welcoming, and efficient which made the whole experience even better. They were super quick with getting orders out and always made sure we had everything we needed. We were visiting from Vegas and stumbled across Pizza 216 while walking around and looking for places to eat. Finding such a standout spot tucked inside the arcade made it feel like a true hidden gem. Between the incredible flavor, perfectly well-done crust, no-grease slices, great service, and unique location, Pizza 216 turned a casual stop into a meal we're still thinking about. Would 100% come back already plan your return to before you've even left.
This is a great spot with some patio seating that offers plenty of action. Nice neighborhood makes it safe enough to hang out and enjoy some pizza and cocktails (which we did). Just around the corner from the main entertainment spot in the Gateway District. We had a seasonal special that had peach slices, balsalmic, and basil. It was fantastic! Great selection of wood-fired pies, delivered quickly from the friendly and attentive staff. read more
One of our favorite things about traveling is trying local spots, and Pizza 216 was a great Cleveland find! We were in town for a concert, and it was pretty crowded, but we were able to grab two seats at the bar after just a few minutes. The bartender was friendly, and our food came out really quickly. I also appreciated that they had non-alcoholic drink options. We started with the provolone wedges, which were crispy and delicious. Then we split The King pizza, loaded with pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and sausage. It was packed with toppings and full of flavor. If you get a chance, I highly recommend checking out Pizza 216. read more
10 days ago
Food was amazing, great service, great drink, great music, and our server Carlos was amazing! read more
11 months ago
I was recommended Pizza 216 by my mom and brother. I was headed to the Jonas Brothers concert at Rocket just a couple streets over. We were greeted by the hostess upon entry. I asked if there was a separate gluten free menu or if it was on the menu itself, and it is on the menu as is. We were sat very promptly and our waiter came by a couple minutes later. Carlos was his name. Very attentive and quick to get our drink and food orders in quick. The restaurant/bar was pretty full with sports on all of the TVs with music playing. The food came out fairly quickly. I got to eating very fast so we could get to the concert quickly. The food was very warm; the GF crust was thin and held together very well. I had red sauce, sausage and pepperoni. The size of the pizza wasn't too overwhelming, I was able to eat the entire pizza and toppings. Such a fun place. Brick oven pizza. Very fun atmosphere!! Well done 216!! read more
2 months ago
Called and placed an order for pick up with Kaya. We ordered a large Magherita pizza and confirmed it had 8 slices. My fiance picked up the order and came back with a very thin pizza. The crust was normal size but the area of toppings was as thin as a piece of paper no theatrics needed. I called to see if this was a mistake and the lady on the phone confirmed that she saw my order and that our order as described is their "New York style". From the photos on Yelp, this does not look like the norm. We paid full price for an extremely thin layered pizza. Unacceptable! read more
After flying all day, having a flight be delayed and dealing with airport food, this was the place to look forward to. The location of this hotspot is absolutely perfect inside the most beautiful Hyatt I've ever seen. Not only does Cleveland rock but Cleveland is beautiful and this pizza place should represent Cleveland because it's the best. The airplane food made my stomach a bit queasy so had to opt for Kevin McAllister's ultimate favorite: cheese pizza just for me. Wow, instant happiness. Since I have to come into town for work, this is the place that I will be going to reward myself after long arduous days. read more
Came here after a long day at a conference. Located in the arcade which houses the Hyatt, it's quite a charming, in the know location. Had great company of course, and this was the perfect place for a large group to chitchat post conference. The place was accommodating, allowing us to move a table to fit everyone. Our waitress was fabulous. Most people ordered a personal pizza and seem to really enjoy it. I ordered the buffalo salad and it was huge. Very tasty. We'll have to remember it next time I come into town. read more
13 days ago
UPDATED REVIEW: I returned back to Pizza 216 in early October 2024 and also in mid-October 2024. I'll definitely be back in 2025 to support this local pizza business. I sat outside on October 11, 2024 with a friend in the early evening. It was a warm weather day so I definitely recommend sitting outside when you visit if the weather is nice. ($12.50) MARGHERITA PIZZA (small). 5/5 STARS -- I got it without the red sauce (it comes with an olive oil base already). The menu describes it as "Original red sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil, and pecorino romano." -- this pizza was very good and especially loved that it is a light pizza with no meat on it - 11 Oct. 2024 ($12.75) SPICY PIE PIZZA (small) - (4/5 STARS) -- I used a $10 off coupon that I was given from a previous visit. I ordered the Spicy Pie pizza to go. The menu describes it as "Local sausage, cheese blend, spicy red, mushrooms, and pepperoncinis." This one was good but not as good, in my opinion, as the margherita pizza which tasted fresher. Still though, I liked the sausage and mushrooms in the spicy pie pizza but I wished it had more flavour because it wasn't spicy at all - 26 Oct. 2024 TIP: Next time I dine-in, I hope to bring a cash tip for the servers because per a Yelp review that I read below, the owner keeps all tips when customers tip using their debit/credit card which is unfortunate, if true. read more
We ended up coming here twice. The pizza is good but the restaurant needs some work. We came Sunday evening after the baseball, but they were only serving pizza, we tried to order a salad too and couldn't - was kinda weird. The restaurant needed a good sweep, food all over the floor! We noticed a huge nasty liquid dripping on our booth too and moved because of it - they never cleaned it off and when we came back the next day it was still there! Our draft beer looked very flat. Server started her closing duties and was very difficult to get to pay our tab. Came the next day for Happy Hour, sat at the bar, went with bottled beer this time. Pizza was again good but the rest of the place needs work. The pierogi pizza needed some crunch like bacon. read more
25 days ago
Was very cold and New Year's Eve. Snowing hard and icy out. Came in and thought it was the weekend. It was happy hour got 2 pizzas for $5 each and was a decent size. Got 1 for myself and 1 for my friend. Was so good on a cold day and came out quick. Wood fired pizza and perfect crispy crust. Perfect size for 1 adult. Food was not good at the party we went to later that night so this was perfect to steady our hunger. Server was polite and patient. Really like this place and it is located in the arcade. read more
3 months ago
I ordered a carnivore pizza with mozzarella and I got a burnt pizza with burnt cheese no meat read more
I'm a pizza lover, but unfortunately it wasn't worth the hype. The Spicy pizza had great sausage but the banana peppers overpower it and only offer the one dimension of spicy. The Buffalo pizza was limited on topping and overloaded on crust. I get that it's woodfire pizza but I just didn't see the 5 star reviews on every platform. Good barfood pizza if you've had a few but not worth the trip if you're a foody. read more
Pizza 216 absolutely delivered. We ordered our sausage and pepperoni pizza well done, and it was perfection from the first bite. The pepperoni had that perfect crisp, the sausage was rich and flavorful, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio was spot on. The dough truly stole the show it was airy on the inside, beautifully chewy, and finished with just the right amount of char. Getting it well done took it to another level. What really stood out was that there was zero sloppiness to the pizza. Each slice held up perfectly, wasn't greasy at all, and never felt heavy.That said, the char was so good we definitely left with a few char marks on our mouths after eating... and honestly? It was worth every bite. The garlic knots were just as impressive. Soft, warm, and loaded with garlicky flavor, they were buttery without being oily and paired perfectly with the marinara. The service was great friendly, welcoming, and efficient which made the whole experience even better. They were super quick with getting orders out and always made sure we had everything we needed. We were visiting from Vegas and stumbled across Pizza 216 while walking around and looking for places to eat. Finding such a standout spot tucked inside the arcade made it feel like a true hidden gem. Between the incredible flavor, perfectly well-done crust, no-grease slices, great service, and unique location, Pizza 216 turned a casual stop into a meal we're still thinking about. Would 100% come back already plan your return to before you've even left. read more
2 years ago
Im pretty judgmental on pizza being from Jersey originally. However, this place hit the mark. Its right on euclid so it makes a great before show dinner spot if heading to playhouse square. The pizzas are delicious and they have some unique variations(such as the periogi pizza). The staff is always super friendly and attentive plus the cocktails are well made. Great food, friendly staff, and reasonable prices make this a must visit. read more
4 months ago
9 months ago
11 months ago
11 months ago
I was impressed with the Enzo pizza and garlic knots! Fresh and delicious. Sports fans can enjoy the numerous TVs above bar while you wash down the knock me off my feet pizza flavor that I his makes here! We came here after our conference at the Huntington center for dinner on a Monday night before the football game started so it was not too crowded but I can see other patrons know this place has great chefs! A lot of real estate for groups and easy to find. read more
6 months ago
3 months ago
1 year ago
We came here last night about 40 min before they closed. It wasn't busy since it was towards the end of the night. The girl that helped us was friendly. She let us know they were only serving pizza and garlic knots. That was fine. We didn't want to overeat at a late hour anyway and we understood that they want to get out at a decent time. We only ordered a large "The King". We got our food pretty quickly too! Fast enough that we were able to order and eat it and be out before they closed....and it was really yummy. The large (8 slices) was plenty for the 3 of us. We love the brick oven cooked dough. We're not from the area but if we ever come back, we would definitely come here again! read more
2 years ago
Soooo...it was my first time here, even though I've passed it multiple times. Hubby was with me, so I ordered the carnivore since that man loves a meaty pizza. The place is nice and cozy. The pizza was ready quickly. It was just ok... a little bland. I would, however, consider going back to try an alternate dish. If/when I do, I'll be sure to update my review. read more
3 months ago
Part of the Pierogi Week quest we are on!! Service was friendly, knowledgeable, and spot on. We started with the pierogis of course followed by brick oven pizza. They even had a pierogi style pizza!! Both were truly amazing. They had a gluten free option for the crust. A definite I will come back. Typical bar atmosphere! read more
This place is great! Good food, decent prices, and a nice vibe. And, while one bartender (Josh?) was amazing and going the extra mile to serve everyone, the other one resulted in the losing of a star. I've never seen someone look like they hate me for ordering a bottle of wine and asking for some time to look at the menu. When the wine finally arrived many minutes later, she didn't even bother to open it, just dropped it and two glasses in front of us and walked off. Thankfully Josh was nice enough to get a wine chiller out of their cooler so we weren't stuck with warm white wine. All that being said, I would def come back here when in the area so do stop in. read more
1 year ago
The area is amazing, fun things to do and places to eat. Their air conditioners were broke and we decided to not stay and order the pizza. We got the spicy pizza, i was so looking forward to this pizza. Disappointed . Nothing very good for the price. We also go the buffalo with no blue cheese. It was way better than the other and i would probably eat it again. All and all the area is worth coming to, but doubt id come back to this place read more
Visited Pizza 216 today for lunch. I was contemplating ordering pizza, but I didn't get any St Patty's day food over the weekend. So I decided to request a reuben sammich with fries. My co-worker requested a burger and fries. We chatted with the bartender and had some soft drinks. A few minutes later, the food was delivered. It was hot and looked appetizing. My french fries were excellent. They were cut like flower petals and had a nice taste and texture. The reuben was hot and tasty, but I've had better. We sat at the bar, so we could see directly in the pizza oven. Watching the pizzas being made was entertaining and made me wish I'd requested a pizza. Next time, I'll definitely request a pizza. read more
9 months ago
2 months ago
1 year ago
No frills interior space. They have some outdoor space. Service was good but pizza needs some help. Good crust but that's where it ends. Toppings were awful. I had the margarita pizza and weirdest looking margarita pizza I ever had. Sauce taste like it comes out of a can and cheese was so bland. They have a base with the crust just need to get the rest in order and this could be the place in downtown Cleveland for pizza. read more
7 months ago
2 years ago
Favorite pizza in CLE. Love coming here! The pizza is always good and fresh, and the other food is great too. Definitely a loud vibe since it's right off 4th street. Good place to watch games, or just go out in general. Bartenders are super nice. Always will be back - great happy hour and specials too! read more
Page 1 of 12
More info about Pizza 216
401 Euclid Ave
Cleveland, OH 44114
Gateway District
Directions
Visit Website
http://www.pizza216.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Pizza 216 Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Pizza 216
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
26 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
5 years ago
2 years ago
3 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
4 years ago
9 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
9 years ago
10 years ago
5 years ago
8 years ago
4 years ago
10 years ago
5 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
