Do not pass by this hole in the wall! Ordering was kind of a nightmare because I have anxiety issues, but that's not on them. It was totally worth it, though, because it was literally the best pizza I've ever had in my life! It is kind of hard to actually eat in the restaurant because, as adorable as the place is, there is no space. They have a cute little counter and a couple of tables, but they are tough to eat at because the entire restaurant is the size of a hallway. read more

Each plate demonstrates thoughtful preparation. After becoming a local resident, finding this restaurant was wonderful. The food quality exceeds what the prices suggest. Workers were efficient while maintaining friendliness. Check out this place and you'll enjoy your visit. read more

Great breakfast wrap fresh to order with my substitutions. Orange juice was really fresh and refreshing also!

I usually always search on Yelp when I'm hungry and don't know where to eat but I had a promo code for Seamless last night so was on there instead. Ordered a greek salad (and a bagel with cream cheese for the morning to hit their delivery minimum). Why I'm giving 4 stars-- they have the BEST salad dressings ever! They make sure to reinforce on the menu that the dressings are made on premises and you can totally tell. I chose the "Broken Lemon Vinaigrette" for my greek salad and it was incredible. There's nothing worse than ordering a greek salad and getting asked "balsamic or ranch?" -- bleh. But not here! Also must note their high quality ingredients. They didn't deliver me old soggy 'on their last day' greens-- their lettuce was BRIGHT green and crunchy. Feta was nice and creamy (not like what you usually get elsewhere like cheap pre-crumbled feta that's dried out). Everything tasted so high quality & these things matter to me a great deal. Also PROPS to Certe for calling me to tell me they were out of olives for my salad. They added extra vegetables to make up for the lack of an ingredient. Very good customer service! I feel like other restaurants would just leave the olives out, hide and not say anything. A little confused why Certe is just listed as Caterers on Yelp though. You can certainly order 1 meal for delivery just like I did! Because of this- I've never considered ordering from them before because I was never looking for a caterer so had no clue they even existed. Awesome food here, hope they fix the Yelp page and I'm already trying to figure out what to get from them next! YUM!!! read more

See all

I've read about cette since the early 2000's on a website called Midtown Lunch (which seems to sadly be dormant now). It was always ranked as one of the best spots in Midtown to grab a sandwich. Now, I'd been to their spin-off Pizza By Certe many times - and it was fantastic - so I figured Certe would be great as well. But somehow I never made it until now. Incidentally, due to COVID they closed Pizza By Certe and they now have all the Pizza items in this Certe. I got the cheesesteak. I mean, I'm a huge Philly cheesesteak fan but I knew this would be its own unique creation when j read they use a gooey cheese blend (3 cheese? 5? I forget but it was definitely more than one!). Anyway, it's a beautiful greasy mess of deliciousness. Get a bit of their homemade habanero sauce on the side if you like extreme heat like I do. Go easy with it... or don't! But give this place a try for lunch. read more

certé - Certe Cheesesteak Sandwich - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

I have never posted a review to date but truly felt the need to do so today in defense of a previous post. Certe is truly a rare establishment! The food is carefully purveyed and crafted with full attention to providing high quality ingredients at the best price point possible. Seasonal menus and standard favorites keep the clients coming back for more. Daily meals, special events and lifetime celebrations are all part of what they do, and they do it well. What separates them from other food establishments is the love and care that they put into their service, menu planning, food and basically everything that they do. Quality control and health standards are always at the forefront!!!! I have been fortunate to be eating Certe's delicious food for the last 27 years and I can't think of anywhere else that I would rather order from. As for the owner, there are no words to convey his dedication to his team, his clients and the success of his business. I would challenge any negative comments previously posted. If you haven't had the opportunity to order from Certe, I would highly recommend doing so. read more

Super tiny spot, SUPERB Foods!! Wanted a real NYC pizza slice, got SO much more!! A HUGE variety of pies after the fist slice we ordered MORE and it was so worth the wait, you won't be disappointed...stop by before or after the MOMA...just a few steps away! I highly recommend the Traditional Pepperoni slice and the assorted mushroom (no pic) but it was topped in a creamy mushroom Bernaise sauce piled with sautéed assorted mushrooms, was SO good!!! Also, pics of the place, menu and our Pepperoni slices! Check it out, they also cater!! read more

See all

Very mediocre, the crust was not very crispy. I felt like it was a bit underwhelming. I wish the tomato sauce was a a little more sweet and refreshing read more

If you're looking for a small personal pie for a lighter meal at a good price, this is it! I have to give 5 stars for their service. I ordered their 7 in Uncanny Tomato Pie from Certe a couple of days ago, and received a call from their manager today asking for feedback. After I shared my honest review, she offered a 7in Cheese Pizza for me to try (which I liked a lot better than my first order) Will definitely be trying their other pizzas! read more

certé - Create Your Own Individual Pizza (7 inch) cheese pizza - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Let's face it, bar mitzvahs are stressful, but one thing you won't have to worry about is catering with Certe. I'm a repeat customer and have found them consistently helpful and flexible. Yummy food and courteous, unobtrusive staff. read more

certé - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

We stopped by Certé and grabbed a few pizzas, they were personal pizzas for $5 which is a great deal! Not only was it a very affordable lunch it was delicious and will definitely be coming back! I got a pepperoni and bacon pizza and my fiancé got a pepperoni with peppers! read more

certé - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The 10 inch was just perfect for two people. The New Yawker looks so simple, but the cheese and sauce are so delicious and flavorful. Everything tasted homemade. There is hardly any seating inside, but the staff is able to set up another table outside if you request it. The person working at Certe was so friendly to us and wrote this message on our pizza box. He also threw in some complimentary cookies and wished us a good day. I highly recommend you give Certe a try for the excellent service and tasty pizza! read more

certé - 10 inch New Yawker Pizza - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

One of the best pizza spots in New York. Service is great, ingredients are fresh and the food is so good. I had the garlic knots and the 4 cheese pizza and the fried spaghetti. Everything was so delicious: read more

See all

I've always come to Certé for their breakfast sandwiches, but this review is focused on their pizza to go. I was looking to switch up my lunch spots and saw good things about the pizza here and I was not disappointed. I ordered the 7" Italian Wedding Pizza for $6.75 and it was so worth it. It was nice and warm still by time I got back to my desk. The pizza had a nice thinner crust, hearty portions of the broken house ground meatballs, spinach, and cheese and red pepper flakes that gave a nice kick. The size was just right for a tasty but not food coma inducing work lunch. Looking forward to coming back again for lunch. Although they're usually pretty busy with catering and online orders, the workers here are all hard at work getting everyone's food prepared. It may take a little longer than usual close by sandwich or pizza spot, but worth it for the quality and price. read more

certé - Italian Wedding Pizza 7" - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

We extend a big thank you to Certe for a wonderful Shabbat dinner--following our pre-wedding blessing--at Central Synagogue on 4/5/24. All of our guests commented on the delicious food, abundance of choices, appealing presentation and professional and courteous service. A great time was had by all! The entire team was great to work with from start to finish and we'll absolutely keep Certe in mind for future catering needs. Many thanks again for helping make the kick-off to our wedding weekend so memorable. With gratitude & appreciation, Larry and Christopher read more

I have ordered many times from Certe for group office lunches and also gone in person to pick up lunch for 1. The vegans and vegetarians in my office enjoy the food as well. It seems to be a winner for casual food but quality ingredients, no matter how many people I am ordering for! The salad dressings are made in house and taste great. Many things here are from scratch that wouldn't be for a casual lunch place elsewhere in Midtown. They seem to really care about what goes into their food. Give them a try for delivery or pickup. This is the only place like it in the area! read more

We ordered from seamless and the food was very mediocre. Most of it was tasteless and bland ex. the acai bowl (which came in a tiny cup), asparagus and leek soup and egg sandwich. Worst of all, the 7 grain bread which I requested for the egg sandwich was completely burnt (see attached pics) but they chose to invert the slices thinking I wouldn't notice?! Besides the burnt bread I also expected more from this sandwich since it was one of the popular items listed on seamless. The "freshly" sliced turkey I requested was completely dry and flavorless. Will not be ordering from here again. read more

certé - Egg Sandwich - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Our favorite restaurant in all of New York. Something for everyone! My daughters loved the spaghetti, pizza, and lasagna. My (born and raised New-Orleans) husband returned for the hot sauce with a punch that you can put on the sandwiches. They even had great gluten free options (hello, zucchini pasta!). Joel offered wonderful service in addition to great recommendations of what do in New York. Such a lovely treat of a place to get food from. Thank you Certe! read more

You cannot go wrong with the food here no matter what you're in the mood for. These guys are awesome~ It is a small shop serving freshly-made, to-go food ranging from breakfast to sandwiches to pizzas to yummy pastries. There's always samples of different foods for you to try, and the daily specials are ever-changing and delicious. Service is fast, and the food comes out warm. I'd definitely recommend you give it a try - you'll be laughing at the guys waiting in line at Dig Inn next door as you walk away with your incrementally better food. read more

certé - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

Absolutely the best Italian take in the Midtown area. Food is above average. The breakfast is great too. Always fresh ingredients. Wonderful staff ! read more

Updated Review: Restaurant called just two days after my last order, apologized and sent me a new vegetarian socca and a bonus dessert (last photo). The order was on time! Vegetarian Socca: very good this time, there's a kick on both flavor and texture, most likely from the sauce/cheese and mushroom. Bonus Dessert: I'm a sucker for fall spices, and this one just check all boxes lol moist, right sweetness, and right amount of spice, spice is not overpowering at all. I'll come back to support a local business which cares about customer satisfaction. read more

See all

The customer service and value at Certe is unbeatable. Dylan provided me with proposed menus for many different budgets and gave excellent recommendations. When a dish was accidentally left behind after we picked them up, they promptly delivered it to us in time for our event. Everyone was lovely to work with, the variety of food options were fantastic, and we absolutely got the best bang for our buck. read more

Lovely experience! The pizza was amazing, the workers were friendly, welcoming, and diligent. Can't wait to come back to try the breakfast pizza one of these days. read more

I am blown away by this place. When given the task of hosting a holiday party for my medium sized start up on a minimal budget I found this place. I was somewhat skeptical because it was cheap, very cheap. Since it was one of the only options I had I decided to go for it. I ordered via seamless and could not have been more pleased. Not only was the food delicious but also beautifully presented. They provided plates, napkins and utensils. They also provided trays, stands and heating oil for our hot entrees. Everyone at my holiday party was impressed, we had leftovers and I spent less than $700 for catering for 56 people! read more

See all

Overall: 4/5 TLDR: Typical good NYC pizza joint, with above average crust Quality: 4/5 Price: 4.5/5 Service: 4/5 I was walking around the theater district looking for a lowkey pizza joint to take my friend who was visiting NYC, and we came across Pizza by Certe. Small place and easy to miss, but we decided to check it out. The worker was super friendly and helpful, and he even recommended a place for us to pick up some beer nearby. The deal was any 2 slices for $6, so we each got a couple. I got a caramelized onion slice and a spinach slice, and made conversation with the worker while our food was being heated up. It was a new york style thin crust, but I really liked how the dough felt like real pizza crust and not like a cheap quality 99 cent crust. The flavor of the pizza was pretty typical for a NYC slice, but the quality of the crust made it a 4/5. I was particularly a fan of the caramelized onion slice. Seating was pretty limited, but we were some of the only customers there, so it wasn't an issue. Overall, I would recommend this place if you're in the area and craving a slice that's superior than your dollar slice, but don't go traveling to check this place out. read more

August Sandwich of the Month - 4.5 Stars A - MAZ - ING!! Inspired to go to get this sandwich from Midtown Lunch. http://midtownlunch.com/2011/08/02/cer-te-now-serving-its-august-sandwich/ Montauk Hangover Sandwich - fried duck egg - creamed corn with pancetta - spicy lobster sauce - crispy leeks - all on a grilled potato roll The duck egg was runny, which was a nice surprise. I love runny eggs. Creamed corn made the sandwich sweet. Good spice from the lobster sauce. Little bit of salt from the pancetta. There you have it... little bit of salt.. little bit of sweet... little bit of spice... with some good runny egg yolk. CONCLUSION: Head over and get it before August is up. - Julia B just told me that this promotion ends August 12th!! P.S. I usually get take out here... dine in is in the back with full service, but food usually cost about a buck or two more. read more

Amazing pizza and super quick service! Small place but amazing a quick bite. Staff is super friendly and the place is clean :) read more

So disappointing. I ordered delicious food a few times a week from this place when they were on the east side, so close to my apartment. Always so good. When they moved many of the recipes changed, nothing seemed as fresh or tasty. Finally I gave up on them as so many years of being a raving fan. Tonight after a long hiatus I was craving their chicken Milanese, my long time favorite so I decided to give them another chance. They are not on most delivery apps so I ordered through their website. I know they received the order because they called me to say they needed to make a substitution which I agreed to. Well they have now been closed for over an hour so I can't contact them but my food is not here and I also cannot track it through their website like a normal delivery app. I'm 100% done. No more chances. I guess I need to order from somewhere else at 9pm!!! read more

Complete Redemption. After writing up a disappointing customer experience the first time out to Certe (with Groupon in hand), I was promptly contacted by PJ, the manager. She was shocked at my account, apologized for any ill-treatment, advised me that they had made some recent personnel changes, and invited me back in to further discuss and address the situation. Despite being near closing when I arrived, PJ had no problem waiting for me to show up (hit some traffic/rush hour commuters). She was super nice, explained Certe's business and their utmost commitment to customer service (as evidenced by the prompt response to my review and everything that followed). I also met Carlos, the counter manager, who was also really nice and helpful. Together, we debated what I should get this time around - tough choices with so many great options (again, the issue last time was not the food - the Chubby Chinese Girl sandwich was actually really good!). This time I settled on the Torta, the Valrhona Brownie, and the Tiramisu: The Torta - Grass-Fed Sirloin * Queso Fresca * Avocado * Black Bean Puree' * Tomato * Jalapeño * soft Roll - SO GOOD. Just tons of flavor, and the sirloin was super tender and well-seasoned/marinated. Thank goodness I took Carlos' advice and stuck with the Portuguese roll, it held up perfectly to the hefty sandwich ingredients! Valrhona Brownie with nuts - Certe uses specialty imported chocolate for this treat, and man does it make a difference! Super dense-fudgey goodness! Wow. Just really delightful. Tiramisu - the tiramisu is made at Certe's nearby pizza shop (Pizza by Certe). It's light, moist, and has a really nice, strong coffee punch. Diet Raspberry Snapple - just tasty and satisfying as the day Wendy the Snapple Lady graced our TV screens. After an unfortunate first experience, PJ/Carlos/Certe has won my patronage back and then some. It's inspiring to see a business that cares when things don't go exactly right and takes prompt action to make it right. In my case, they did far more than just make it right. Thank You Certe! read more

See all

Small almost miss it if you're not looking but very good pizza. Pastries also good. Crust is good and so is the sauce.

As disappointed as I was not getting my hands on my twin, the Chubby Chinese Girl, I happily settled for the Grilled Chicken Pesto Sandwich. I was sold on the "melted mozzarella" like love at first sight. W 55th is where Midtown's best-kept secrets are for lunch, so you know Cer-te HAD to be good. The sandwich was $8 and I also got a banana-walnut loaf, which was like eating a whole bag of sugar. The people that work here were so kind and of all the places I've had lunch, they have got to have the best packaging; the sandwich was placed in a plastic container and in a nice, small shopping bag--not like the other places where they shove your food in a paper bag and it falls out from the steam! I actually really liked the sandwich because it was cheesy and fresh but the chicken was a bit dry and there actually wasn't any lettuce as pictured on their site. They overput the pesto sauce, which doesn't really have a taste. I think it would've been a lot better if the sandwich was eaten cold because the steam made it almost inedible. They seem to make the most creative sandwiches here and I definitely recommend giving this place a try. If you get the Chubby Chinese Girl, remember to share half! read more

certé - Pesto Chicken Mozzarella - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

I love this place! their old location on 56th and Lexington isn't open anymore but now they're on 55th and 5th which isn't far away. Their pizza is super delicious. Their combinations of all their pizzas are creative and yummy. I personally love their shroom and Italian wedding ones. I always get their spaghetti and rice balls as appetizers and they're always good. Their pasta dishes are also great quality and fresh. I love love this place and got afraid when I thought they closed down. Thank goodness they just moved. read more

certé - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

The local pizza spot popping up by Central Park was this place so I walked down to check it out. Excellent pizza slices! Had the Italian Wedding and Grandma pie slices and both were great, especially with a dab of their habanero sauce and some ranch. The cashier gave me a happy hour price of 2 slices for $6 so you can't beat that!! I'll definitely earmark Certé next time I'm down by Central Park. read more

certé - Grandmas Pie and Italian Wedding Detroit Style slices - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped in for a quick slice of pie. Very good Margharita Pizza. Crispy out of the oven. Just what you expected of a NYC pizza place. Lots of other options but I was just in and out. read more

So wonderful! Best pizza I have ever had... seriously, crispy, fresh. It was just fantastic! read more

certé - Wow! The New Yorker and the Bianco... amazing! - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

Good pizza. The reason I gave 5 stars is because the staff is very polite, and the customer service was great! read more

certé - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

Best eggplant parmigiana I ever had. Great quality pizza, fresh pasta made on premises. High quality service and high quality take out also. Reasonable prices , good portions for high quality Italian food. It's the place to go if you want high end Italian f read more

Secret gem this spot. Some of the best Pizza in NYC. Fresh ingredients and pizza with a very delicious crispy crust. I highly recommend! read more

certé - Uncanny Tomato Pie with half Pepperoni and Onions. Fantastic. - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

Corporate Catering? Look no further because I absolutely love this place. My office uses this place on a regular basis and the overall quality is simply top notch from customer service, delivery, presentation and food. I believe cold food orders can be average from many places even this place depending on what you order, however if you order their hot catered meals then you will be surprised how well the stuff is made. Everything is delivered in a manner that allows easy setup from cold plates and hot plates alike. My office does a lot of catering and I've personally used several places in the area and Certe has become my favorite. A little more pricey than others but also better than others hence, "you get what you pay for." read more

certé - Caterers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm glad my coworkers suggested coming here for a quick bite! There are tons of places you can go to for an $11ish lunch, but that's too expensive for me. Fortunately Certe's buffalo chicken stromboli was only $6.95 so I'll likely come by and get one again in the future! It was suuuuuper good, especially because I was craving something greasy. If you're into the health stuff, don't get this. Seriously, very greasy. But if you're okay with a little oil and you're in the mood for buffalo chicken, do it! Huge chunks of chicken, tons of cheese, very decent level of heat (without going overboard at all). Bonus: check in on Yelp and get a free brownie! I ended up not finishing it because it's very dark and bitter and also quite greasy, but to each their own. read more