Cancel

Open app

Search

Catch 24

3.5 (47 reviews)
Open 12:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Order Catch 24 Takeout or Delivery

Catch 24 Photos

Business Info

CATCH 24 ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like Catch 24

Recommended Reviews - Catch 24

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Broccoli with a dead parasite
Roxy A.

Catch count your effin days!! So I ordered two meals via Uber eats. 1 whiting w/ Mac & broccoli since it comes w/ 2 sides. The 2nd order was sweet chilli salmon w/ a side of mash & broccoli. I've never been inside the restaurant, but I heard of this place so I've been meaning to try it out. I saw it on Uber & the prices looked reasonable. When it arrives the food looked & smelled good so no problem there right. I also tried the Mac it seemed like it had lobster chunks in it. Which I didn't kno it came with bc I only asked for regular Mac but didn't mind. So as I proceeded to start eating. I noticed the broccoli looked funny. First & furmost it was brown & didn't appear fresh & green like steamed broccoli should. The mash potatoes also came burnt. Bit I still proceeded to eat. But then as I was about to Pick up another piece of broccoli. I noticed a freaking worm on the broccoli! Yes a worm! I'm Like you have got to be freaking kidding me! I Immediately was disgusted! I literally threw up in my mouth. Both meals had to go in the garbage. How are you serving meals to people with parasites & larva ?! Gross I would not eat from here. If I were you guys smh !

Basa fish with seasoned potatoes and broccoli
Jeff S.

What a great addition to the area. I ordered the 3 piece fish, basa, with two sides. The fish was hot and very good batter. Wasn't salty. For two sides, I ordered broccoli and seasoned potatoes. The broccoli was cooked with just enough crunch with minced garlic and butter. The seasoned potatoes were good. The customer service was excellent. I was updated when there was a delay. My food was brought to me.

Basa fish with the yams and fries. It was bussin
Shad P.

Just about everything I've had so far has been a 5/5 when it comes to flavor and everything tastes very fresh

Crab bag
Nancy L.

Well ,I wanted some crab legs so bad so I ordered this on Uber eats when I tell you if you want a hypertension then buy this it's salty as hell I also ordered a Mac and cheese as well it was okay but I had better and the only thing I really wanted was the banana pudding and I looked in bag no banana pudding in my opinion I wouldn't come here or order from here and lay up on the salt people

Limited menu
Chrissy B.

Wow ! I must say I was utterly impressed when I called and was presented with good customer service. The person responded and had me on a less than two-minute hold but was very pleasant. I called to inquire if it was a black owned restaurant and it is ! I tried to to catch the name of the 4 owners but all I heard was the name Dwayne. After confirming it was black owned, I placed an order on UberEats for pickup since I have a gift card. I ordered the 6 piece shrimp with a side of Mac n cheese, and broccoli. I was feeling extra today so I also ordered the banana pudding and it was AMAZING! It's definitely comparable to Magnolias. The shrimp was a nice hefty size and the Mac n cheese was very flavorful. I'm truly blown away by this business; congrats Dwayne & others ! I'm impressed !

Fried fish with fries and mashed potatoes.
T J.

Very friendly spot. Food was good would recommend. The mashed potatoes was a little fresh needed more salt and pepper. The salmon is great here

Macaroni Salad.(tuna)

Only reason I gave them 4 stars is because their hours never fit mine, but their food is serious. I would DEFINITELY go again

Shrimp Boil Bag, Crab Boil Bag, lobster Mac and Cheese, 10 fried shrimp and Broccoli
Talisah C.

Called Catch 24 to place my order and in 30mins or so my food was ready for pickup. The person who answered the phone was polite and efficient. I had a pretty sizable order. I was obviously craving seafood lol....the lobster Mac n cheese is soooooooo good, oh and the fried shrimp . I really enjoyed everything but those were my favorite. I really loved the extra touch with a sample of their banana pudding. Catch 24 is a must have! Enjoy

6pc Wings w/ Fries ( I forgot to take pic of fries)
Sherelle C.

This was my First time ordering from this restaurant ( via Uber eats) . Honestly I can't complain. The food was packaged well, it was very tasty . Especially the shrimp ( I'm a shrimp lover) . I definitely would recommend this fine establishment . The prices are reasonable I can't name one place where I can get a salmon dinner for $14.99 . I'll be back with more from this restaurant I'm going back lol .

Crab Boil Bag

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Their food is DELICIOUS !!!! Especially their lobster and regular Mac and cheese. You should really eat here :)

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Catch 24

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Seafood 22,213 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Cross Island Fruit

Cross Island Fruit

3.4(81 reviews)
3.3 mi
$$

This is a very old fashioned Italian-American style old NY style of grocery store. They have…read moreproducts and produce here that you won't find anywhere else, except an Italian specialty market. I can always count on them for beautiful broccoli-rabe and escarole. I come here for my hard to find Italian groceries like decaf espresso powder, Anna pasta and Brioshci (I actually get the Galeffi). And of course a box of Torone. In the back is a great little meat market where I get some of the best pork chops and my Bell & Evan's chicken. They also have great sausages, pinwheel steaks and really nice burgers and ground meat. All perfect to add to my Sunday sauce with a nice hunk of braciole or throw on the grill. I was here recently and I was hoping that the deli & bakery would be open, but not yet. I'm hoping they open soon. I miss having a nice loaf of semolina bread and getting my fresh stuffed shells. Prices are good, but you have to pick out your fruits and veggies. Now, if you cook, you should know how to do this. It's why you get such great buys. If you just want to buy it and it's all perfect, go pay 3x the price elsewhere. The fruit section is good. They do have a few seasonal items, like Cardone, or Zucchini blossoms. But the best part is and you can get almost everything here year round. If you're an Italian American who wants their foods, this is the place.

I love this place. I've always gone here for fruits and my vegetables and my sauce and my pasta,…read morebut I love it even more now bc they made the deli department bigger & added the bakery in the deli combined.

Photos
Cross Island Fruit
Cross Island Fruit - $3.81 cheaper at Stop n Shop. Similar expiration date in 2025. I can understand up to a $1 difference, but this is criminal.

$3.81 cheaper at Stop n Shop. Similar expiration date in 2025. I can understand up to a $1 difference, but this is criminal.

Cross Island Fruit

See all

Key Food - Clean isle

Key Food

2.9(18 reviews)
2.6 mi
$$

Let's not be fooled as most of the people giving praises and complimenting the store are employees,…read morefamily and may be some ppl who own the store. Let's be honest ... the customer service is horrible . Beginning with management. Now I don't have much to say about the short one bc he's always helpful n nice but the big one with the ponytail is rude af. The whole store shouldn't know who u fired last week and who u cursed out. He's always pissed with the staff , especially when the customer needs to return something. I guess it's too much for him to take his card off his belt and swipe it through the machine. As for the employees on the floor, none of them speak English so looking for something in the aisle... your own your own. Once u get to the register, the staff always has attitudes. There is one nice big guy on the register that was always smiling and nice but I guess he did the right thing by going back to school this fall bc I don't see him anymore. The food.... The prices are too high! You shouldn't have to pay 5 dollars for a box of noodles. But I guess we are going to blame inflation. Don't get ANY of the meats here !!!! Mold, out of date and thick juices in the chicken, bacon and all those meats. Have you smelled the seafood section! Enough said about that as it screams food poisoning. Go have a sniff yourself . I know this keyfood is convenient for ppl in the neighborhood but the best thing to purchase is the vegetables. Price well as well. Everything else is expensive and I don't trust the food quality. Don't believe me the. Go to the back and purchase a deli sandwich for ten dollars. Your better off making your own. Do better keyfood!!! I don't know who the owners are but you guys need to have a meeting and revamp the whole store . I do not recommend this location. One star bc I had to give a rating and the onions were ok for pick up!i

On Sunday, October 8 my husband did our weekly shopping at this store making purchases totaling…read more$140.00. Part of this purchase included 3 packages of 93/7 ground beef at $9.00 per pack. When we opened a pack on today Tuesday, October 10th we noticed a foul smell, upon looking at the second pack it had a grayish color and the third package was worse. All 3 packages had an expiration date of October 16. When my husband went to return it Management would only exchange 2 packages because we didn't have a receipt and one was opened. All groceries were wiped and refrigerated as soon as my husband got home, so therefore, the quality of this meat was very bad upon purchase. We are community members but we will no longer patronize this location.

Photos
Key Food - Lovely view

Lovely view

Key Food
Key Food

See all

Farmbria Food Center - Spoiled elephant garlic sold to me by Farmbria. I peeled it and it was entirely moldy.

Farmbria Food Center

2.9(53 reviews)
1.0 miCambria Heights
$$

I haven't been to this supermarket in a long time. I used to frequent it a lot when my friend lived…read morein the area. I was in the area and decided to stop by and I believe it was few days before Christmas or New Years and I could've slapped myself. LOL. This place is known to always be crowded so you know it was extra crazy right before a holiday. The parking lot drama was just like I remembered it "hectic." The spots are tight and very busy. Now for the good, LOL. They have tons of Caribbean foods and ingredients you cant find in your typical supermarket. When my cousin visits NY she always want to stop here to pick up some items for her Caribbean dishes. They have a huge fruit and vegetable area that is packed since its the first area you visit when you walk in. I always pick up items I don't find in my neighborhood. I grabbed some cut up chicken to curry and these biscuit like snacks called Shirley that come in a few different flavors that I loove. I also re upped on some of the spices. The lines to check out were loooooonnnnngggg and I remembered looking in my cart seeing if I really wanted my groceries. I sucked it up and waited about 30 minutes. Do NOT go during a holiday, periodt! LOL. The staff are not the friendliest but you have to come in here with a mindset that you gotta do what you have to do and try to finish as quick as you can in this fast paced and always crowded supermarket. This place has Trader Joes beat in terms of crowds and frenzied.

This supermarket is really disgusting! I ordered groceries from there a month ago and ALL OF THE…read moreVEGETABLES WERE ROTTEN OR ON THEIR WAY TO BEING ROTTEN!! I was SO DISGUSTED! They need to be shutdown!

Photos
Farmbria Food Center - Spoiled elephant garlic sold to me by Farmbria. I peeled it and it was entirely moldy.

Spoiled elephant garlic sold to me by Farmbria. I peeled it and it was entirely moldy.

Farmbria Food Center
Farmbria Food Center - Ginger

See all

Ginger

Catch 24 - seafood - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...