This place is like walking into the past. Bring cash. The owner is a amazing individual. The food is perfect. Try the burgers and chicken salad sandwich. Humble pie is 2 thumbs up. We got a sample of chicken salad it's perfect. Sweat tea and lemonade is perfect. * As a side note: while sitting and enjoying our food we witnessed something which is completely out of the ordinary these days. Several people came in with no cash ( most if us these days) the owner just waved his hand, took the order and said to pay next time. Who does that?!!! These are good folks with great food! read more

Literally everything here is sooo good! My favorite is the smoked chicken salad, and their fries are freshly made a delicious! All of the workers were SO sweet and super friendly. A true southern place! Just a heads up, they only accept cash! read more

Chris (I hope I'm spelling his name right!) the owner, shook my hand and asked me my name when we came up to order and said it was our first visit. The menu is written on the wall behind the counter and appeared...too small. And then Chris introduced the menu to us. All made from scratch...like I do in my own kitchen! (Well, not the burger buns) One of his people came and dropped samples of the home-smoked chicken salad in a practiced flourish the moment he began to describe it. Absolutely delicious! I did, however, opt for the freshly ground, never frozen, burger. My associate had the Philly cheese steak. Everything was excellent. Simple--because the ingredients were real food that didn't need to be complicated. Thank you, Chris. Will be back! read more

Casey's is one of my absolute places in Winder. Chris, the owner, is honestly one of the nicest people I've ever met. The first time I ever went I didn't know they were cash only, and he offered to give me my food for free. I've seen him do it for others too. And the food? Amazing, every single time. My only complaint is that I never get to go because their hours are so limited, but when I have the afternoon off I make an absolute point to go. read more

Home in the wall in downtown Winder, great burgers and fries. I love the atmosphere! It's fun how they play hard to get with limited hours! It's well worth taking the time and try them out. One of my go to places!! read more

Great burgers and fries, historic building. Chris, the owner gave us a thorough introduction to his fresh, homemade, never frozen menu. He and his wife and staff are amazing! My friend had the bourbon bacon bleu cheese burger and I had the pimiento cheese bacon burger. Housemade everything, beef never frozen and cooked on a flat top. We had the fresh housemade fries with complimentary Hell or bbq sauce on the side, housemade fresh lemonade. Chris gave us samples of the fresh smoked chicken salad too - yum. I am going to have to come back and have s different burger every time, next time the Hellburger! Delicious! read more

Casey's - Art outside the building - American Near Me - Winder, Georgia

See all

Decided to stop here after reading reviews on line. Chris gave us samples of their smoked chicken salad. Had to have it!! We also got a Nathan's dog and hamburger. Everything is fantastic! read more

Casey's - American Near Me - Winder, Georgia

They should really change the closing time considering they wont let you in the door after 1:20.

Two dogs, one French fry, $9. This place seems popular, but the prices are a bit high for what you get. Two small dogs, artificial casing, one with some meh chili, and lacklustre buns. Hand cut fries were the star of the show. Hunts brand catsup did not complement the fries well. Must be laughing all the way to the bank. Not worth a revisit. Should have been a bigger natural casing dog for the money. Meh. read more

Fantastic local hole in the wall burger joint I'm always impressed when I find these little hole in the walls that have a small menu but do an amazing job at what they do You may not think that a basic burger from a flat top without any fancy toppings would be that impressive, but you'd be wrong! One of the best burgers in town, and probably the region Did I mention hand cut fries? Now go stuff one of these burgers in your pie hole! Then thank me later read more

It is not often that you go to an establishment and the owner takes time to ask your name and review the menu. This restaurant is all fresh and fantastic. Try the hamburger and fries... best around. On a side note, it is cash only and the owner told me to pay him next time! read more

Just a simple burger done right! What a great find, tucked away in downtown Winder, GA. Two things you have to try are the burgers and the smoked chicken salad. I don't even like chicken salad, but love theirs. Super friendly place with great food! read more

First time here and Ioved it! This hole in the wall has a lot of character and the owners were extremely friendly. Oh boy the food.....awesome homemade burger and fresh cut French fries. They are only open for lunch Monday - Saturday otherwise I would go more often. I can't wait to get back. read more

Simple menu, paired with simple but quality ingredients. Friendly staff, and quick to the table. Bring cash, and be okay with only water, lemonade, or tea. I got the pimento bacon cheeseburger, and homemade fries, but will get the smoked chicken salad next time. Coming back for sure!!! read more

Best American food dive I've ever been to! I got the steak and cheese with peppers and mushrooms and it was real steak hot and melty in the most amazing roll. Being that we went right after the new year (diets....ugh!), I was not planning on eating any fries; but, I made the mistake of trying them. Wow!!!!!! The best fries I've ever had! Hand cut, crispy, perfect pint of salt and a twinge of vinegar...mmmmmm You know it's great when their hours are only M-F 11-2pm Can't wait to go back! read more

Great Local Dive. Owners are awesome and make sure everyone is happy. Food is hot, fresh, authentic and affordable!! Burgers, Dogs, sandwiches and FRESH CUT FRIES :) several dessert choices. You won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Very friendly staff! Possibly the best kept secret in Winder. I love their burgers and the toppings bar. Try the mushroom, Swiss, bacon burger as it's very good. read more

Casey's - Counter - American Near Me - Winder, Georgia

This place made my heart happy. The owner is awesome. Such a great home town feel. The family in front of me didn't know it was cash only but he just said you came in hungry and we are going to feed you - you can pay us later!! And the food was delish. read more

Just ate a great lunch at Casey's. The smoked chicken salad sandwich was just as all the other reviews had commented on. The moisture and smokey flavor were right on. Also the hamburger had a great flavor, it comes plain and there is a toppings bar so you can fix your own. Onion rings taste fresh cut with a ranch sauce to dip them in. Oh and also don't forget to get the lemonade, it is to die for. The last time I remember this kind of lemonade was in Savannah. The owner very friendly knowing everyone that came in. Told him this was my first time here, he was very helpful with menu, let me sample the gumbo. I know that I will be back, just need to remember open 11am-2pm. read more

Bacon & pimento cheese burger was so good! Me and my wife were first timers today and both enjoyed our meals. The owner was nice and offered a sample of smoked chicken salad. We're getting that next time for sure. Prices were good and bring cash! read more

Casey's - Bacon & pimento cheese burger - American Near Me - Winder, Georgia

Great owner!!! He really understands the meaning of small town hospitality. I didn't realize no CC and I was $3 short. I was comped and told to enjoy. Great food and cheap!! read more

Casey's - American Near Me - Winder, Georgia

Smoked chicken salad is mouth watering! So friendly and all the food is absolutely delicious.

Wow! Went there for the first time today. Cheap food, $2 hot dogs. Great service! I bought two dogs, plus one I was able to customize as a Philly cheesesteak hot dog. $8 total, unfortunately they said they only take cash or card but they said (maybe because it was my first time) it was on the house! Awesome place! Hot dogs are excellent, they have other food as well but I needed those to take home and watch our first place Braves play the day game. Thanks Casey's for such an awesome experience and great quality food! read more

This is the only restaurant at which I have tried every single meal on the menu. This shows how much I trust the staff. I know I will get amazing quality food. I also come here for the incredible service. Chris and the staff have great energy and they uplift my mood when I am running low on energy. Great food and amazing folks. read more

Yummmmmmm!!! I was a little hesitant to try Casey's since I work in the area and hadn't heard of them but I'm so glad I gave them a shot! It's a cute little place, very unexpected and simple but delicious! You order your food and then they have a little topping bar. I went there back to back a couple of days ago and I didn't wait more than 5 minutes for my order. The burgers are great and the fries are fresh cut awesomeness! The people are so nice...all in all it's a must try!! read more

Wish this place was open for dinner or on weekends because I just had an amazing lunch and NEED to have the opportunity to eat multiple items on the menu. All hand made, perfectly seasoned and prepared. Wow! read more

The food at Casey's is amazingly good! Everything on the menu is awesome. The service is friendly, the prices are good and the atmosphere is friendly. But, once again, I have to say that the food is amazingly good! I love this place! read more

I was very disappointed in this place. The Hot Dogs were only fair and plane. I love GOOD Hot Dogs.

Food is amazing. People are great. Fast service. Bring cash because they don't take cards. Only open from 11-2.

As always Hell's half pounder was perfect! I'm not familiar with how yelp check in offers work but I was embarrassed by yelp when I showed the owner my check in offer for free sweet tea with meal and he said they didn't offer coupons and didn't know anything about it. How can yelp offer a free product at a business without their permission?! He was good about it and gave me the free tea though. Props to him! read more

It's rare that you find an establishment that achieves perfection but Casey's comes extremely close as it offers everything you could possibly want in a lunch spot. The food is phenomenal, the service is excellent and the prices are fair. They're only open 11-2 but if you work in Winder you're cheating yourself if you're not eating lunch here. I personally recommend the smoked chicken salad sandwich with handcut fries. You'll thank me if you try it. read more

Hands down best pace for lunch in Winder. Owner is top notch and very friendly. He is very enthusiastic and passionate about his food. Hells half pounder is the best burger around. Downside he is only open from 11-2 Monday-Friday. Would love to see Saturday hours! read more

Who would have thought that this tiny hole in the wall joint in Winder, GA would be one of the best dining experiences we've had in a while? The owners are wonderful, down to earth people who truly enjoy serving the community. The menu is small, but what they do serve is just awesome. All fresh, home-cooked, family-owned, friendly, and local. I had the pimiento bacon burger, and it was delicious and perfectly cooked. I have heard that the smoked chicken salad is amazing. Can't wait to try that next time. And the gyros! What more could you ask for? read more

Again, this place never disappoints! Best Philly cheesesteak outside of... well Philly. Great friendly staff and on premise owner is very accommodating and personable. read more

This place was awesome! I went in with my family this past weekend and loved it. I had the Habenero Burger. It had a ton of flavor and just the right amount of heat. I saw 'Habenero' and was nervous that it was one of those TV burgers the host couldn't finish because it was too hot - not in this case. We ordered both deserts and they were great too. The owners were super friendly too. It's as if we were all old friends when we walked in. Definitely stop in here if you're close to Winder or making that drive down 316 between Atlanta and Athens. You'll be glad you did! read more

I wish they were open for dinner and took cards, but it's lunch and cash only here. A little small, but the food is great and the people were friendly. read more

What a great little place! The burgers are great and the service is even better. This was my first visit, and while here I've noticed the owner call at least half of the patrons by name. That says a lot about both the food and the owner! I will definitely be back - with the family next time. read more

Great food and great staff. We were treated like family as we ate our food that was made fresh to order. Hand-cut fries, fresh ground beef, smoked chicken salad just to name a few. They may have limited hours, but it's worth it. New favorite place in town! read more

This place is just amazing!!! I am always happy when I am here! Chris is the best and most humbled person I've ever met!!! He loves joking around with all his customers, and treats them all like his family! Try getting something new every time! You won't be disappointed! read more

Amazing.. ..where do I start...we are new to the area and just happened to walk by this little place. The customer service was the top of the line. The owner home took our order treated us as you would an old friend. Not only was he polite and efficient he took the time to give a sample of some of the food that we didn't order (and I discovered I will be getting the chicken salad next time) and even told us all about the area, things to do with our family, things that were around our neighborhood etc. If that wasn't enough the food was outstanding. I ordered a smoked sausage, which he smokes himself, and it was probably the best smoked sausage I've ever had. My fiancé had a cheeseburger with all kinds of stuff on it and he as well said it was the best burger he has ever had. I can't say enough good things about this place. read more