Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open 4:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Harley T.
    0
    58
    178

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 817 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Pizza King - The Washburn - which one of my party really adored.

    Pizza King

    (14 reviews)

    Pizza King has been an Indiana institution since the first one popped up in 1958 in Muncie,…read moreIndiana. Over the past 60 years, it has grown to right around 45 locations focused on East-Central Indiana. This includes this spot in Tipton, Indiana catty-corner to the Tipton County Courthouse. Like most pizza joints, Pizza King has those who embrace it with passion and those who wonder "What's the big deal?" As I'm from Indy, I experience Pizza King less as it seems to mostly focus on the smaller communities that surround Indy. Pizza King is passionate about using fresh, not frozen, ingredients along with pizza toppings that go to the edge of the pizza. There's no wasting space here. From the outside, this location looks like it's going to be a run-of-the-mill Pizza King, but it's a lot more fun inside with a sort of retro-vibe in terms of atmosphere and decor. There's a small concrete ramp leading up to the door. However, I will note that they have have a video game that is somewhat of an obstacle to accessing the back rooms. If someone had a larger, motorized chair it probably wouldn't happen. There's a smaller front room that can be used, but you have to get past the video game for the private room and for the larger dining area. This really is a major issue to me as it could easily be a fire hazard and is pretty easily fixed. Thus, the loss of a star here. Beyond the obstacle, this was a really awesome experience. The servers were mostly younger, but our server was friendly, helpful, and top-notch with the service. I gathered with several people due to my fund-raising event and we had multiple varied orders. Everything came out correctly and everything was quite good. I had a pepperoni/sausage pizza and my usual iced tea. I was a bit nervous about eating pizza the night before I needed to go wheeling, but typically when ingredients are fresh things work out. There was no problem here. As a longtime James Dean fan, I enjoyed the decor that had a 50's vibe to it with multiple pieces of James Dean memorabilia. I didn't try the breadsticks as I just didn't trust my body to handle it with my next day's wheeling, but I was really happy with this entire experience. The food was good, the prices fair, the atmosphere warm and fun, the employees friendly and helpful, and the locals were friendly and welcoming. I'd easily return when I'm in the Tipton area. In my somewhat smaller chair, I was able to get by the video game (barely) and I still consider it worth the effort to make it happen. My understanding is they have lunch specials and occasional buffets. Check their website for more info - the same family owns this spot and Alexandria, Indiana's location.

    Stop by here for a early lunch today as it looked fairly decent on yelp. The service was excellent…read moreand the setting was nice. I had a small pizza and a side salad as they didn't have any salad and slice specials. The salad was quickly served very crisp and fresh the pizza came soon after and it had plenty of cheese but I think they could probably use a different type of oven as the crust was kind of soggy. The price was fine for these post Covid price times. I will definitely go here again and maybe try something else

    Bronko’s Pizza And Sandwich Shop - Garlic cheese bread

    Bronko’s Pizza And Sandwich Shop

    (91 reviews)

    What an excellent local pizza place! The breadsticks are absolutely addictive. I'm a breadstick…read moreconnoisseur and here are some of the best I have found anywhere. Pizza is delicious too. The toppings are really piled on, with a generous amount of cheese. No skimpy pizzas here. Service was very friendly. This place does a huge amount of business but they manage to get the pizzas out at the quoted times. Highly recommend stopping by when you are in the area. Actually it is worth a road trip too.

    I had some free time on a Sunday, close to noon, and drove from Westfield to Cicero to check out…read moreBronko's. From the Yelp photos I've seen, this seemed like my kind of place. Service and ambiance were both fantastic. I was one of the first customers of the day, and I dined-in. My server was delightful and attentive. There are a very small number of tables and booths available, but that's perfectly fine for a small-town pizza joint. As much as it pains me to say this, I found the pizza to be underwhelming. I was a bit surprised at the overall lack of bold flavors. The price point is great, and you get a lot of pizza for the dollar, but I was expecting much more of a flavor explosion. I had high hopes, because visually this pizza closely resembles my hometown favorite pizza as a kid (Volcano Pizza in Elkhart), but it just didn't live up to the expectations. I'm sure I'll give this place another try at some point, and maybe experiment with some other pizza combinations on the menu.

    Bad Dad Brewing - Margherita

    Bad Dad Brewing

    (60 reviews)

    $$

    Brewery #281 This…read moreplace understands me, it get's me, I'm partially convinced they tapped my brain or my metaverse and said "Let's make a place that caters to this guy, Da Gabe aka Mike Honcho" Bad Dad has taken dad jokes and made a brewery. Beers named 'Socks and Sandals, Pull My Finger, I'll Turn this Car Around' and many more. Their tin tacker is of a slightly obese dad in an undersized sleeveless shirt, headband and white New Balance sneakers riding a beer can. Perfection. Genius! While their humor got me in the door, their pizza and beer will get me to come back. I got my standard flight with I'll Turn This Car Around (Hazy IPA), Kiss the Cook (DIPA), Snooze Button (Imperial Stout) and a Tapestry of Obscenity (IPA). All were really great but The Snooze Button was my favorite of the bunch. We also got a couple of pizzas. A Detroit style called Motown with thick pepperoni, hot honey, and basil which was very tasty and a Margherita pizza that was solid. My only issue was they were out of stickers for my man cave wall but that's just all the reason to go back next time I visit my parents in Indiana.

    Definitely Destination Dining…read more What a hidden in plain sight gem of a great place for amazing craft beer and out of this world pizza. Kam, our server, took our dining experience to a whole other level. I asked to taste all the beers but the IPAs and was brought a sip of each one, I decided on the "You're Grounded, Mister" Stout. Smooth, with a nice kick of coffee had me order this one twice. Now for the pizza...some of the very best pizza I have ever had. We ordered the "Motown" Detroit style pizza with the Mike's Hot Honey which sent this pizza into orbit and tasted out of the world. The other pizza we ordered was the New Yorker which was a thin crunchy crust pizza and as delicious yet totally different. Plan a trip up to Fairmount sooner than later, this place will not disappoint.

    Pizza Palace California Style - Meat Lovers in our amazing garlic sauce

    Pizza Palace California Style

    (56 reviews)

    I LOVE pizza palace.. but it seems that their management or ownership has changed. The food does…read morenot taste the same, the rations are way smaller, and just no genuine pride in customer service/ satisfaction. I got my pizza today and was shell shocked by the small portions and unappealing look at my food. This was my family's first time trying, and I was so disappointed. There is another pizza place that tastes similar to how this use to taste called pizza pizza on Kessler.. I recommend going there! So disappointed

    Visited Pizza Palace last night for the first time. We ordered 3 large pizzas for pick-up / take…read morehome. Since it was a take home order, I forgot to take a picture of the pizzas. However, I will attach a picture of their menu. The pizza's were good, with fresh ingredients, and remained hot all the way home. We order one hand tossed crust and two crispy thin pizzas. The crispy thin crusts were thin.... but not cracker thin. They were very good none the less. The food is 100% Halal so the sausage is beef rather than pork. We got a sausage and mushroom pizza and enjoyed it. The staff was extremely helpful and friendly. Our bill was correct as was our order. The location has very limited dine-in seating. It appears predominately a carryout location. I believe they make deliveries as well but double check, including the delivery zone. Since it is mainly a carryout / delivery establishment, it is extremely important to me that orders are correct. I was very satisfied with the accuracy... my family can be very particular and makes a lot of menu substitutions! The menu consists mostly of pizza and wings. They have limited appetizer, salad, and sandwich wrap options. Drinks include bottled water and canned soda, among other items. We will return to this restaurant. The wings appear to get good reviews so we will probably order them next time.... along with another pizza!

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...