I did not go into the restaurant (my wife picked up), so this is strictly based on the food. Pizza is such a personalized dish. What one person loves the next guy hates. So this is a difficult review to write. We grabbed a couple pizzas and the breadsticks flight as we were planning to entertain another couple for the evening. The supreme pizza did not have overwhelming flavor and was very thin crusted but not crispy. The margherita pizza was very tomatoey (if that's a word). Both good but nothing to write home about. The breadsticks were the same but the jalopeno bread should come with a warning...they pack a punch. They are very good but can catch you off guard. All in all, this place is ok but I won't return because it's not my favorite pizza style. read more

This is the first time I'm expressing this opinion because I've been a fan for a while. The Detroit-style pizza was disappointing. Not as generous with the toppings as before. Maybe because it was a Friday night, but they could have shown more interest to detail. read more

Amazing pizza and a friendly and helpful staff! 10/10 I recommend! We had their Detroit style pizza and Greek salad. Both great

The food is ALWAYS delicious and so worth it. I recommend their jalapeño bread sticks with their cheese (to die for). Everything is baked to perfection. Salads are fresh and use the best ingredients. Service is always friendly and helpful. Highly recommend their food and to sit outside on the patio. Oscar's never disappoints unlike most relationships read more

Absolutely phenomenal pizza! You can tell they put a lot of care and attention into their pies! read more

Stopped in Saturday. Ordered a 14" Double Double, the place smelled great. The pizza crust was soft and limp wouldn't hold a slice upright when picking up. Service took longer than expected for as few people were present. Breadsticks (bacon and jalepeno) were great! Will try again before writing off. read more

Solid pizza, nothing special there (I always order pepperoni the first time at a place as a baseline), but I really enjoyed the Jalapeño breadsticks w/ Queso cheese. I was also a big fan of the decor of the building and overall ambiance. I will definitely come back if I'm in the area and try one of their other pizza options. read more

See all

Love the Detroit style pizza! Tons of toppings! Tastes so good! Having a non franchise place that has an amazing product is so good!

The pizza is excellent, best I have had in Kokomo. They do have a habit of over estimating the time it takes to cook. If the say 45 to 55 minutes I would arrive after 40. I'm willing to wait a few minutes to HM get it hot out of the oven. read more

Tried Oscars for the first time and it's easily the best pizza in Kokomo. Great options for pizza toppings and taste was amazing. I ordered take out but the building is super cute with quaint indoor and outdoor seating so I will probably eat there next time. Staff were extremely friendly and seemed really appreciative of my business. read more

Oscar's Pizza - Large with pepperoni, ground beef, and hot gardenia - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Hands down the best pizza in Kokomo! The Detroit style is my favorite and never disappoints.

Okay so I was told this is a hot spot in Kokomo. I didn't know that they stop serving pizza by the slice at 3pm. Of course I come in at 3:15. I saw some people eating slices so I was bummed at that. Hey that's their policy. So I drive 30 mins to try this place out so I was leaving with something. I noticed they had a sign for Wednesday $1 off a Calzone. I bought the sausage Calzone at first it looked good but when I started eating it there was really no flavor. Also their sausage is ground sausage not slices of sausage. They put so much of the ground sausage in it that it took over the calzone. That was different! The calzone was really really greasy and the marinara sauce wasn't that great. I tell you one thing the calzone was huge for $8. They have a nice outdoor area and the inside is really nice and clean on a cobblestone Street. I will try them out one more time for a slice before 3pm. read more

See all

I like the place and service the pizza however maybe needs more cook time. It has flavor but the dough got soggy right away. I will probably go back but maybe I'll ask for it to be cooked more well done ..idk I'm just glad I found a good spot for pizza in Kokomo. read more

Oscar's Pizza - Cute place to get some Zzzzzaaa - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

Absolutely amazing food and service! A great atmosphere that is family friendly or would make a great date night. We will definitely be back when we are visiting Indiana! read more

Oscar's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

Their food is very good! Salads are tasty and pizza is delicious! Their prices are very good and they have daily specials. Service is good. Always friendly and helpful service! Music is upbeat, looks like a fun place to bring friends! read more

Garlic knots are by far sub par no garlic flavor basically dry bread. Pizza lacks on flavor but that is my opinion. But great service in the restaurant an very quick. Very different music on in the restaurant. read more

Oscar's Pizza - Pepperoni & bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

Can say the pizza tastes better than average, but the service is quite poor. Upon one ordering of the pizza, the bottom was charred, it was late so I didn't check it, the staff walked up and told me "hey we burnt the bottom, but is this okay?" well, with a pizza so hot I couldn't eat it at the moment, and just looking at it, fine it was okay, but taking it home it was a completely burnt-tasting pizza. The customer service when bringing it up to them of course, was rude, and of course, they would rather give you a "burnt" pizza instead of actually cooking it right. Clearly they make out by being close to the center of town and having a so-so recipie, but if you like pizza either burnt or so uncooked it falls off your fork, this is the place. Rude staff, to boot. read more

We waited over an hour on a Saturday night, which doesn't sound bad, except there was, at total, maybe 6 groups in the whole restaurant. When we ordered, no one said anything about being backed up. When we got my "Stromboli" it was a complete grease bomb. Also, crust is so thin and greasy you can see through it and it was falling apart. When I picked it up to eat it, it left a pool of grease on my plate. My husbands pizza was okay, but still very greasy as well. read more

Oscar's Pizza - Small Create Your Own Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Stop by here today for lunch. got great service for a quick bite and got a couple slices of vegetable pizza with a side salad, all of which was very good and at a good price read more

I'm from Chicago and love thin crust pizza. Oscars is the closest to my favorite. Although they should add artichoke hearts to their pizza menu! Excellent. read more

Best pizza in Kokomo get a pizza well that is extra crispy and it may as well be New York style

Great pizza. Perfect location and matches well with the brewery next door. Got the meat lovers (not sure what they call it) for dinner and felt I got a good value for the product. Next time I'm around I'll be sure to stop. read more

Great little pizza place with friendly service. The breadsticks were probably the best. Jalapeño and the bacon and cheese were so good. The supreme had great fresh vegetables and the meat lovers was piled high. Good atmosphere and they deliver to the brewery next door. Neat downtown restaurant read more

See all

Good New York style pizza! The atmosphere is fun with great decor and the place is clean, I like all of these things. I'm dinging them a star though because when we walked in we didn't know that you seat yourself and that you have to order your food at the window. All kinds of young folks working there but nobody said hi and and while we stood there looking confused, they just stared back at us. Like dudes, help us out! The whole atmosphere was like the party was for them and we were interfering. read more

Great pizza and calzones. Love the garlic knots and salads also. They have outside seating if you prefer that. Always great service. read more

Oscar's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

They will take care of you. The guys gave me a taster of homemade hot sauce for nothing. The marinara had a great flavor you could tell was made there. I didn't care for the breadsticks and the calzone was just ok but both of the Stromboli's(just like a rolled up hoagie) were excellent. read more

First time visit: We bought a grandma style all meat pizza, garlic butter pepperoni and sausage Stromboli (no pizza sauce) Greek salad, and garlic knots with cheese. We were mixed in our feelings towards the pizza. I felt it was average but the others in my party felt it was very good. My issue is I don't care so much for pizza that has little to no sauce. The knots and salad were good but the Stromboli was awesome. We had them make it special with no sauce and replace it with garlic butter and give us a cup of pizza sauce on the side. Fantastic! Also, would not get the grandma style pizza crust which is just square. Would stick with the traditional round. read more

Hands down the best pizza in the Kokomo area. My favorite is the meatball but I've never disliked anything I've tried from here.

The best pizza in town! If you want real pizzeria pizza This is the place. I recommend ordering the hand tossed. Cheese and sauce were perfect, not overly salty, they are generous with toppings. read more

Had the BBQ chicken pizza delivered to Tin Man. Pizza was quite good. It had a good amount of chicken on it, just enough BBQ sauce, and a few onions. I really liked the thin-ish crust. Pizza was a little pricey, but we'll probably order it again when at Tin Man. Young woman who delivered was very pleasant. read more

Great pizza! I love that I can purchase it by the slice during lunchtime because my husband & I have different pizza tastes! Very affordable as well! Highly recommended! read more

This place is HANDS DOWN the best pizza I've had in a very long time. As someone who grew up on the northeast coast, I'm use to having mom and pop shop pizza. This place has the freshest ingredients and a variety of great foods. I highly suggest eating here. read more

I had lunch today and it was very good, however the soda machine was so disgusting and dirty. It needs to be cleaned and looks like a health hazard. read more

Kokomo has so many chain restaurants and not nearly enough original places. This is a locally owned business, using local produce, AND boosting the local economy?? TAKE ALL MY MONEY!!! I've eaten at Oscar's pizza more times than I can count, almost always on two dollar slice Tuesday, and every single time it has been amazing. However, I would like to say nothing beats a fresh out of the oven Oscar's pizza, which first knocked me off me feet over the holidays at Tin Man. Pizza Hut, Papa John's, and Dominos wish that their frozen, processed "pizza's" tasted so good. I've lived abroad for a few years now, lacking decent pizza options, and I always make it a point to visit Oscar's at LEAST once every time I visit home. In fact, for fathers day, I called Oscar's pizza and ordered my parents a large pizza as a gift since I'm not there and now they also love Oscar's pizza. 11/10 would eat again. I also recommend the Garlic knots read more

Good pizza . Service was good . Ordered take out - Large Pep around 10 pm . They were getting ready to close soon but they were still friendly read more

Oscar's Pizza - Large Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

I had this delivered to tin man brewing that is right across the street. They will bring the pizza over for free. The pizza is above average but a box expensive. It's good for the area but the ingredients are about average. If I went to tin man brewing I would get the pizza again. But I wouldn't order it on its own. read more

its it like a lot of doughy stuff with a lot of toppings but not very sloppy you know i like a nice amount of slop on my plate so its it was ok could be greasier and more slop but very cool place maybe will take my niece there one day she is 16 read more

While at a soccer tournament in the Kokomo area kids wanted pizza. After reading some reviews decided to give it a try. Not disappointed AT ALL!!! Great pizza - great service - quirky atmosphere that was fun. Oh - and the jalapeño breadsticks are a must!!! read more

Fun atmosphere with unique decor. Had 3 different types of pizza: veggie pesto, margherita, and supreme. My personal favorite was the veggie pesto! Great flavor! read more

Coming from Nashville, Tennessee, I've been spoiled with good food and good pizza. My family and I have tried several pizza places here in Kokomo, but Oscar's is officially our favorite. As soon as we walked in, based on the decor, we knew we were about to have delicious pizza. And we were right! We ordered a caprese salad, jalapeño breadsticks, meatball pizza, and pesto pizza. So. Good! Everything was made fresh. Anytime we want pizza, we will be ordering from here. Can't wait to go back! read more