I usually get great pizzas here but got a bad one today. We go hear all the time and this time not so good. Called them to say my order wasn't correct and they offered me to bring back the pizza but we live out in the country and asked for a credit and was refuse. So sad that service has went this way. read more

Bursting with flavor. The sauce is flavorful and the toppings are fresh. The crust holds up just enough for straight-in or New York style fold up. Staff is friendly even at their busiest. Nice little pick up place although a couple of tables are in place if you care to sit and stay. read more

Decided to try Gabe's again after around 10 years. I'll probably wait another 10 years for another try. I just don't get it. If you like you meat in purée form like a nursing home, you'd like their sausage. If you only have the sausage in your mouth, it would have the texture of a paste. The pizza sauce has virtually no taste. The mushrooms seem to be from a place like GFS foods or something. I guess you gotta get them somewhere. I wish they would have put cheese on the pizza. Most places do that without asking. There may have been a tiny bit under the sausage purée, but I'm not totally sure. The crust seemed to be from a frozen box. Probably from GFS too. I might try again in 2033 if they are still open. read more

Gabe's is open later than other local pizza joints. Pizza is crisp and cooked perfect with a good pizza sauce that's not too salty or too sweet. Warning, If you get sausage, they pile it on. But it is gooooood! read more

Pizza wasn't to my liking, not gonna say it was bad but I ordered over the phone and even gave them an extra 5 min but when I walked in they hadn't even started on my pizza. So I had to go sit back in my truck for another 20 min. read more

The pros, seems like a LOT of toppings on the pizza, more than I was expecting The cons: Frozen formed crust - really lacking all flavor Red sauce - only flavor I could pick out, tomato paste Lack of cheese- I am originally from Minnesota, and the style I grew up with - pizza is a cheese delivery service All things considered, it is the sauce that will keep me away in the future read more

My pizza looks colorful and the flavors are the same. I enjoyed my pizza. It was cut i to cute small squares. The lady who took my order was pleasant and patient as this was my first time there. I purchased the 10" veggie pizza minus onions and olives. I added jalapeños. I'd check out this cute little pizza shop if you have time. read more

Gabe's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Had heard good things about this spot. I knew I should be worried when I saw a stack of frozen cardboard crusts being set out. Lackluster toppings with very little flavor. read more

Awesome pizza, awesome service, highly recommended, can't believe I have lived in kokomo for 20 yrs and just now trying this pizza. Best pizza in town read more

Good service, good pizza (but I grew up on their pies). Only thin crust I eat. They even have indoor dining.

My husband and I are lifelong fans, best pizza in Kokomo hands down at either location!

GDTBA-Great Day To Be Alive. They're known for their sausage, which is fantastic. We always get pepperoni sausage pizza. Breadsticks are good too. A classic place to get pizza in Kokomo, Indiana and my family's favorite. read more

See all

Excellent pizza! Friendly and prompt staff. Sandwiches are great! Always consistent and quality food! Love Gabes! (You with too) read more

Ordered last night got home had a crappy sandwich with ham and cheese and like 4 pepperonis what I ordered was a Stromboli supreme with green peppers and extra pepperoni sandwich tried to call them last night couldn't get through so called this morning to talk to them and there is nothing they could do Will be the last time ordering from there read more

Great pizza, large seating area, TV and good customer service. I'm traveling from out of town and was going to try pizza king but they take no credit cards or debit, how do businesses survive in 2015 and not take those?? read more

Gabe's Pizza - Large seating area - Pizza Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

I just wanted to give a quick review of a place I recently found, Gabe's Pizza. I have ordered twice from this place after seeing their reviews on YELP. Being a low carb eater I need options when I want pizza and it's hard to eat just the toppings bc the crust is tempting. I found this place and they offer a cauliflower crust, load it up with meats, veggies and cheese and go light on sauce and it's amazing. read more

I love it how they have so many low carb items and meals for eating healthy,their cauliflower crust is amazing

food sucks, their onion are dried onions crusts taste like cardboard, hardly any sauce, mushrooms are way to big,! i would not recommends this pizza at all!! worst pizza i have ever had!! read more

To my knowledge, I may have never eaten the pizza from Gabe's Pizza - I've heard it's great. As a kid growing up in Indiana, my family went to Gabe's for one thing: the strombolis. I recently made a trip back, and I am happy to report that they taste exactly as amazing as I remember. Technically, their strombolis aren't strombolis at all - they're grinders. But I don't care what they call them as long as they don't stop making them. It's a 10 or 12 inch hoagie-type roll filled with pizza sauce, crumbly sausage, and lots of melted cheese. There's something about the sweetness of the pizza sauce and the spiciness of the sausage that creates a magical land of tasty goodness and wonder in your mouth where the streets are made of cheese and trees are made of hoagie rolls. I cannot adequately express my love for this sandwich, but if you're in the area and want a hefty meal that will fill you up with awesome and not drain your wallet, stop in at Gabe's and get a stromboli. And I always get mine with extra sauce! read more

For BFI, this is great pizza! The 7 inch meater lover was loaded! Their fine ground sausage is outstanding.

Our first pizza in our new home and soooo glad we chose Gabe. The pizzas tasted fresh and crust was the right amount (not too thin or not too thick). Service presented was friendly and helpful. Definitely will have this be our go to pizza place. read more

The pizza was OK. It was upsetting to see all the good reviews and walk in to see them using already cooked, preformed crust and mushy canned mushrooms. We did like the fact that banana peppers were a normal topping that already came on the deluxe. The pizza was mediocre. I have definately had better. Nachos were OK too. The salad was excellent. There was so much for toppings that dressing wasn't even needed. Customer service was great. They were friendly and timely. read more

We love gabes pizza . There ground sausage on the pizza is so good. There peperoni and sausage is good. And we love there strombolis

We love to get Gabe's Pizza! Always fresh ingredients and some new varieties and combinations! Don't miss out--get Gabe's Pizza Today!

Last time I was at gabe's pizza ( over a year ago) it was nothing like I remembered growing up, the cheese, and meat were off and the atmosphere Tony had created was gone. I reluctantly went in today more for the memory than pizza and was blown away. The owner was there and friendly, the building was inviting, and clean. When I got our pizza home it was as good as the old gabe's if not better! Tons of toppings, perfect crust, and the storm was perfect! I'm not sure what made this amazing change happen but thank you to the new owner for saving Gabe's pizza! I may have to grab a pizza for the road trip back to texas! read more

Gabe's Pizza has become my favorite!!! I LOVE THE MEAT LOVERS PIZZA! We need to branch out and try different food items, but we can't get enough of the Pizza! read more

Disgusting pizza is terribly dry wish I could rate this zero stars and get my $12 back.

So-So pizza. Taste-wise, I've had better (Pizza Hut was better IMO). Don't care much for the ground sausage- it was more like crumbs of bland hamburger- not pieces of Italian sausage. When you picked up a piece of pizza, the burger fell off of each slice (messy). Having requested thin crust, I'd estimate they don't have a true "thin" crust. And you only have 2 options for size: 10 and 14". Other items on their menu may be OK (per reviews I've seen), but I won't buy another pizza from Gabe's. read more

Excellent pizza & strombolies! Every time we're here from Fort Wayne we stop & get storms for tomorrow and have a supreme minus mushrooms and NO banana peppers!! Yum!!! read more

The pizza is amazing and the stromboli is even better. Hands down, best pizza in Kokomo! Only two locations and they haven't changed the way they make it since I've been alive, which is 31 years. Excellent. read more

They have the Pizza and Stromboli! I have been eating here for at least 30 years! Would recommend Gabe's to everyone!